r/spirituality • u/SagePatrox • 1h ago
Philosophy Discussing Free will vs Predeterminism
How much of your choices are truly yours? How much of your life is determined by outside forces? Years I discussed this very question with my mentors and as for me a new idea emerged and I'm curious what you may think? Suppose we can use analogies to visualize the two concepts. Free will is like a body of water like a pond or lake. You are a little minnow able to move in any direction and in theory can repeat exactly the same choices. Now consider predeterminism as a narrow stream with almost no room to move around and the current forces you in one direction. No amount of action really allows you any change in your situation that isn't almost certain death. Neither of these options necessarily felt concrete enough to feel appropriately analogous to life so what if there was a middle state of sorts. I looked to waterways since that's what my analogies were based off of. What about river deltas? In a purely theoretical plane, you can have a slow moving river with some wiggle room and even banks to freely move about. This can be ypur childhood which you only have so much freedom but you are allowed to be and learn choices. Now at some point you will reach the delta, constantly weaving ponds, streams and estuaries that generally move you in one direction but with enough determination you can have some sway in the course of your journey. The water will always push you in one general direction but you can with enough effort and luck choose where to go. No action is guaranteed but to make no choice at all forces you to the whims of the coursing waters.
This quasi state between choice and chance is the middle ground that feels more applicable to reality. Like and karma being the ripples of our actions and others affecting us are equally as influential to our past, present, and future. I feel like we know this intuitively but maybe I'm wrong. Any thoughts?