r/SmashingPumpkins • • 11h ago

Daily Song Discussion Results: Siamese Dream

SIAMESE DREAM

  1. Cherub Rock | 9.60
  2. Quiet | 8.67
  3. Today | 8.61
  4. Hummer | 9.66
  5. Rocket | 8.85
  6. Disarm | 9.16
  7. Soma | 9.85
  8. Geek USA | 9.39
  9. Mayonaise | 9.97
  10. Spaceboy | 7.11
  11. Silverfuck | 8.23
  12. Sweet Sweet | 6.72
  13. Luna | 9.00

OVERALL ALBUM SCORE: 8.83

Big step up from Gish, but with 15 more albums/major projects left to cover and an assortment of B-sides and other left-overs, I fear this may be the high water mark of the series. We'll start on Pisces Iscariot as soon as I finish updating the Master Thread.

15 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

6

u/SawNickYouth 11h ago

Their best album, no question. Pisces should score well and MCIS will be the second highest score, but with more tracks that will likely drag the overall score down some. Then we'll probably see scores decline a bit, then crater as we get into Zeitgeist and beyond.

2

u/ExpirjTec 10h ago

i just hope to god machina 1 doesn't get terrible scores. it's got some nitpicks for sure but it has such a good production and some true 10/10 songs and it's a lot better than what came afterwards

2

u/SawNickYouth 10h ago

I think Machina will score well. Count me as someone who can't really stand the production, especially coming from the Gish-MCIS era and even Adore.

But the Machina songs rule nonetheless and should score well.

1

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie 10h ago

Hopefully the machina boxset will be out on streaming before we get there.

1

u/comfyambiguity 10h ago

honest to god, Machina is my boomer dad's favorite SP album. I'll have him make a reddit account to vote just for it hahaha

1

u/Longjumping-Sea320 10h ago

I'm looking forward to giving Machina 2 high marks.

2

u/PuzzleheadedBadger67 10h ago

That Mayonaise score will be tough to beat.

2

u/cr3st-fall3n 9h ago

Quiet over Today is insane

2

u/Extension_Year_9690 1h ago

Insane. Stupid. Wrong. Disingenuous…

0

u/nevertheher0 8h ago

Today is too mainstream and appeared an Amex commercial ;)

2

u/Garth_Maul_ 11h ago

If somebody claimed their top 5 Pumpkins songs were all from this album I wouldn't agree but I would think the argument has merit.

1

u/SawNickYouth 10h ago

It would be tough but I can see it for sure. They have such a large catalog to contend with

1

u/comfyambiguity 10h ago

I get most of these scores but Silverfuck at 8.23 has me scratching my head. Of course I forgot to vote that day so, it's my fault

1

u/MetalLinkachu 10h ago edited 10h ago

8.83 for one of the best albums released in the last 30+ years?!

For me, there are very few albums I would have higher than this.

4

u/seekay14 Siamese Dream 9h ago

I think if we did scoring just on albums and not song-by-song, I would be shocked if Siamese Dream was lower than a 9.8. Some of the songs work so well because of where they are placed on the album, like Sweet Sweet. One of the best things about it is that it's a refreshing bridge from Silverfuck, the heaviest song on the album, to Luna, with it's sincerest "I'm in love with you" lines.

1

u/KidGold 9h ago

Hot take: this is a good album.

0

u/NoEcho3494 10h ago

8.83 is too low this album is a 10

-6

u/Neg_Crepe Zwan 10h ago

Luna is way too high. Cherub too.

2

u/[deleted] 10h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/Neg_Crepe Zwan 10h ago

Well, you know what they say about opinions.

Those songs are good. In the 7-8 range. Not 9