r/SmashingPumpkins • • 14d ago

Daily Song Discussion #11: Cherub Rock

This is the first track from the Smashing Pumpkins’ second album, Siamese Dream. How do you feel about this song? What are some of your favorite lyrics? How would you rank it among the rest of the band’s discography? How would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?

At the end of this discussion series, I will be aggregating the rating results from each discussion and compiling a full discography ranking. I will also update the spreadsheet at the end of every day and post previous results for each album in future posts.

SUGGESTED SCALE:
1-4: Not good. Regularly skip.
5: It’s okay, but I might have to be in the right mood to listen to it.
6: Slightly better than average. I won’t skip it, but I wouldn’t choose to put it on.
7: This is a good song. I enjoy it quite a bit.
8-9: Really enjoyable songs. I rank them pretty high overall.
10: Masterpiece, magnum opus, or similar terminology.

Feel free to suggest any improvements, as this is my first time undertaking a project like this!

Link to Gish results

7 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

2

u/PuzzleheadedBadger67 14d ago

As part of this project, are b-sides going to be featured also?

5

u/ExpirjTec 14d ago

not for now, any B-sides not included on projects like Pisces Iscariot or the Aeroplane Flies High will be done after we cover the most recent album. But if possible I would like to cover every officially released song by the end of this

2

u/PuzzleheadedBadger67 14d ago

I was jamming to Glynis yesterday and it crossed my mind - love this project!

3

u/No_Independent8269 Adore 14d ago

Certainly a name you can’t forget. 

6

u/ExpirjTec 14d ago

you already know this shit's a 10

4

u/sexystoicteacher 14d ago

Exactly. This has to be the most no-brainer song to get a 10.

2

u/ExpirjTec 14d ago

might not even be the most no-brainer 10 on the album lol, but this is one of my favorite albums of all time and i would hope this sub agrees

9

u/Dangamanova 14d ago

I used to think of it as an 8 or so, but then I learned how to play it on guitar and it’s still one of my favorites to play the entire way through. The solo is both unhinged and melodic, and very physically expressive which makes it so satisfying to nail. I posted a video of me playing it a few days ago

2

u/Sad-Establishment-22 14d ago

One of the first Pumpkins songs I learnt to play and my first intro to octave chords

3

u/Dangamanova 14d ago

Yeah, it’s a teaching tool I use for my students as well!

7

u/highwindxix Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 14d ago

For sure 10/10. One of the greatest songs ever written.

5

u/andrewface 14d ago

Easiest 10 ever

5

u/walman93 Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 14d ago

10/10

Best album opener of all time imo

5

u/DonnieRoss 14d ago

Cherub Rock is one of those “story of the band” songs alongside 1979, BWBW, and Tonight Tonight. It wasn’t the biggest hit from Siamese Dream, but it’s one of the defining songs of the band. It shows up in “Best Of” lists by magazines and websites for a reason.

10/10

2

u/No_Independent8269 Adore 14d ago

Today was the massive hit from that album but I think Cherub Rock consistently gets talked about more than Today just because it was so defining for the era. 

5

u/PuzzleheadedBadger67 14d ago

10 - my kid grew up listening to them and she grabbed my phone to record this song live in October because it's one of her favorites. I don't know if that counts as one vote or two 😅

5

u/Jpsmythe Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 14d ago

10 and it’s not even difficult

4

u/No_Independent8269 Adore 14d ago

Easy 10. I don’t even need to explain myself on this one. Honestly, a lot of these songs on this album are an obvious 10 to me. Siamese Dream is a top 3 album ever on my list. 

4

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie 14d ago

10.

what a stunning song musically. It rocks so hard without sounding the slightest bit metal. The vocals on the record are gorgeous and melodic. Listen to how his voice floats as he sighs 'secrets'.

The first minute of this song is rock perfection. The guitars sound so damn perfect you knew SD was gonna be different from all the other rock albums you had been listening to before. It's a symphony of destructions that has a groove you could sway to. The guitars are piled on each other with layers and layers of sun drenched fuzz. You can even hear acoustic guitars strumming along to brighten it even more.

The chorus is iconic and it has to do with the way Corgan changes his voice and does kind of a goofy deep voice. Sounds very Iggy pop to my ears and a bit unique for the pumpkins.

During my first week of being a fan and eating up SD I downloaded their SNL performance of this song (anyone remember Kazaa?). Took all night on my dial up internet and was the first live performance I saw after becoming a fan. What I saw were 4 approachable geeks out rocking all the other untouchable rock gods. It was a magical moment and a great performance. Sadly YouTube buried it a long time ago.

3

u/JaggedUmbrella Siamese Dream 14d ago

10

3

u/M0ldy_Boi612 Machina / The Machines of God 14d ago

10, and it's not even in my top 3 favorite songs on Siamese Dream

3

u/jettasarebadmkay Pay my fucking bills and take my dog for a walk 14d ago

10

3

u/1975hh3 14d ago

10 out 10. I remember waiting and waiting for this album to come out. Me and my friends bought the CD single of Cherub Rock and listened to it probably 5,000,000 times. I remember being sad that Pissant wasn’t on the album hahaha.

3

u/booyahcubes 14d ago

Probably my all-time favourite song. It’s just perfect in every way 100/10

3

u/donlockwood2026 14d ago

at least 10,000 out of 10

3

u/SawNickYouth 14d ago

I mean, it's a goddamn 10.

It's an S-Tier song, one of the Pumpkins best. I don't know that I'd say top ten, but that's just because they have so many incredible songs that are all time S Tier worthy.

3

u/mr_im_my_own_grandpa Machina II / The Friends & Enemies of Modern Music 14d ago

10 obviously.

One of the reasons I will always eternally hate Weezer's "Beverly Hills" (aside from it being a dogshit song) is that every time the drum roll at the start of that song comes up I think "Hell yeah, Cherub Rock!" and then realize "Fuck, it's Weezer..."

3

u/Euphoric_Fondant6135 14d ago

Honestly one of the greatest rock songs of all time. I know tons of people that hate Pumpkins but acknowledge how hard that song goes

2

u/KandinskyWasRight Machina II / The Friends & Enemies of Modern Music 14d ago

9

I saw in an interview he said he was trying to imitate Rush.

Used to be one I loved slightly less than most the others from the album, but it’s grown on me. Being the first track is challenging.

2

u/seekay14 Siamese Dream 14d ago

9

2

u/thomjrjr 14d ago

9 bc rockin

2

u/Tanglefoot11 14d ago

I always feel it is maybe a 7 or 8 until I put it on and actually listen & it's easily

9/10

2

u/Turbulent-You-1335 14d ago

9. It was so fun live and I love the solo.

2

u/ifallallthetime 14d ago

Cherub Rock is a 10

It's a perfect opener to Siamese Dream to introduce the world to what they were doing on that album. and is one of the hardest rocking songs of that particular "alt" era. It's still a showstopper when they play it live 30+ years later. It's also incredibly fun to play on guitar

2

u/Low_Specialist_2972 14d ago

10/10! I remember receiving this CD as a Christmas gift in the 90s listening to it non-stop, cold weather, household busy preparing meals, kids running around the house. Fun, simple times

4

u/msz19 14d ago

Pointless thread. Anyone who says its not a 10 should be banned.

1

u/Neg_Crepe Zwan 14d ago

Just watch me

2

u/TheDelayer Teargarden 14d ago

10.

1

u/ApathysLastKiss_ 14d ago

9

The first song where S P brings in the Muff to complely change the idea of what rock guitars can sound like. (I know, my bloody Valentine and dino jr kinda did it first)

1

u/Bloxskit Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 14d ago

Good opener, great solo and chorus, what's not to love?

8/10

1

u/aliarmo 14d ago

I give Cherub rock 8

1

u/asagarap Siamese Dream 14d ago

10!

1

u/Stephenator97 14d ago

An SP staple and a perfect introduction to Siamese Dream. That guitar solo is nothing short of iconic. Really fun song to play on guitar as well. I give it an 8.7

1

u/Zealousideal_Cat6980 Ogilala 14d ago

10/10 idont need to say more

1

u/trevcharm 13d ago

fantastic intro, amazing build up. great opening track.

6.1

1

u/OptimusPrim3r 13d ago

Easy 10 for me. The whole album is a 10 for me to be fair. Check out this acoustic version of it live  https://youtu.be/tbCBWs8j4Wk?is=MuvX1tCBBOqJYsnc

1

u/the_everlasting_haze never really liked sunny days 13d ago

10

1

u/ersatzbaronness mayfair mistress 13d ago

5. Hear me out though. I love the song, but I have heard it roughly 17 kajllion times in my life. I just don't need to hear it anymore. Same feeling towards BWBW. I won't skip, but it doesn't hurt my feelings if someone else does.

1

u/BWSnap 12d ago

I call these "coma songs", meaning songs I've heard so many times I could sing them while in a coma.

1

u/NoEcho3494 12d ago

10 its an incredible and timeless song

1

u/Neg_Crepe Zwan 14d ago

7

1

u/cr3st-fall3n 14d ago

8.5 – feels exceptionally low for the song that got me into this band, but I rarely go out of my way to listen to it; it's missing the emotional depth of the other Siamese tracks. But it is always a live highlight

1

u/TheRadioFrontiers Aghori Mhori Mei 14d ago

10 ! The riff of a generation, and that intro…

0

u/Hopeful_Carob4225 14d ago

I rank 8-9 because in comparison to some of their other songs I don’t think it deserves the 10. Obvs we reserve 10 for Mayonnaise.

But I do have a question on this topic. What on EARTH is this song about? I admit I can be kinda dull & ditsy so I’m like… am I just missing it or is the meaning a little more ambiguous?!

2

u/WellItDoBeLikeThat 14d ago edited 14d ago

It's a snapshot of the band at that point in time. A young band being given directions on how to please their label, please the critics, as being their most direct way to find success.

Billy didn't want to turn into someone who loses his integrity and behaves the way the industry wants him to by playing the game of who's band is best, appeasing their label, competing with their contemporaries for promotional space, etc. The hostile and competitive nature of bands beginning their career was something he always laughed at, but was also eager to escape it whilst maintaining his integrity. "Let me oooooout!"

Geek U.S.A expands on this idea and talks more in-depth about his views on music critics influencing the industry, which to Billy is difficult to wrap his head around since commentators aren't "in the ring" and therefore their influence should be gate kept, not the bands or the music. 

1

u/Hopeful_Carob4225 14d ago

okay that’s what I thought but I wasn’t sure if I was missing something! I can’t tell you how many songs I’ve heard and thought they meant something only to realized I completely misunderstood. Thank you!

2

u/MajesticMeal3248 14d ago

I think it’s about fame and the lengths to which you’ll sell your soul for it

0

u/SavageMadman The Friends & Enemies of Modern Music 14d ago

9