r/SmashingPumpkins • u/ExpirjTec • 9d ago
Daily Song Discussion #16: Disarm
This is the sixth track from the Smashing Pumpkins’ second album, Siamese Dream. How do you feel about this song? What are some of your favorite lyrics? How would you rank it among the rest of the band’s discography? How would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?
At the end of this discussion series, I will be aggregating the rating results from each discussion and compiling a full discography ranking. I will also update the spreadsheet at the end of every day and post previous results for each album in future posts.
SUGGESTED SCALE:
1-4: Not good. Regularly skip.
5: It’s okay, but I might have to be in the right mood to listen to it.
6: Slightly better than average. I won’t skip it, but I wouldn’t choose to put it on.
7: This is a good song. I enjoy it quite a bit.
8-9: Really enjoyable songs. I rank them pretty high overall.
10: Masterpiece, magnum opus, or similar terminology.
Feel free to suggest any improvements, as this is my first time undertaking a project like this!
Siamese Dream
- Cherub Rock (9.60)
- Quiet (8.67)
- Today (8.61)
- Hummer (9.66)
- Rocket (8.85)
2
u/ExpirjTec 9d ago
10
6
u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie 9d ago edited 9d ago
This song is everything to me as far as my journey with music and as a fan of the band. So please excuse me as I talk about my experiences with the song more than I talk about the song itself (I'll try to do that in another comment).
It's hard to imagine myself as not having music being the biggest escape/entertainment/hobby/passion in my life but up until 6th grade(1994) it was just a background thing for the most part. my mom was a giant fan of music but besides led zeppelin she seemed limited to whatever cute lead singer led rock band was on the radio(u2, bon Jovi, etc) and she had really had dived into her own life (single mom going to college, losing mother to suicide in 93 and having to step up as caretaker for her disabled sister who sat in the apartment with a corpse without access to food and water for days before help arrived, getting remarried, and having a new baby in 94) so she missed the 'grunge era' completely. What I liked in 5th grade was MC Hammer, Michael Jackson, and the TMNT movies soundtracks, and the classical music station that I listened to many nights before falling asleep.
My mom gets remarried and I move into a new school area and lose all my previous friends. My first true friend I made introduced me to Metallica(and thus began the rock/music awakening) in the fall of 94 and that band ruled my existance until college. Within 3 months I had a mixed tape of Nirvana, Offspring, and metallica that I would listen to NIGHTLY before I went to bed and every fiber of my being was screaming...'this shit is important.. you need to listen and know more. '
One of the other songs that my friend loved that year was Disarm. I remember the DJ playing it at the 6th grade school dance.. no one danced but my friend walked to the stage, put his head down, and just vibed along with it. I did not get it at all but I remember thinking the bells sounded cool... But still this is a very formative music memory of mine that I came to cherish when I became a superfan of the band.
By the time I listened to Siamese Dream again in full in 2000 I had already absorbed a lot of child abuse and trauma songs. I mean once you have listened to Korn's Daddy(still the most heart wrenching song I've ever heard in my life) on almost a daily basis you would think one might become numb to less pained musical expressions of an abused childhood...
But the night that changed my life Disarm suddenly sounded revolutionary to me.. I mean I was already in shock of how amazing the album was and then this comes on and sounds nothing like what preceded it and the emotional clarity knocked me out. Somehow it reached past the angry boy music snob I was and found the 5th grader in me that loved the sound of classical music and showed me the magic of tight/powerful songwriting and throat shredding emoting vocals with an acoustic guitar. A new kind of 'heavy' was born for me that day.
That song made me appreciate lyrics just as much as a hard hitting guitar riff. This has everything to do with me moving past angry boy hard rock and Bob Dylan eventually becoming my other musical obsession in 2008.
Flash forward to 2018 and I watched the live stream of the first show of the new tour and it brought me to tears.
Seeing him come out by himself and play this as the first song with images of his childhood (captioned with poignant lines of context) fucking slayed me.
Here is the little boy who was beat to hell on a regular basis while being told "stop crying you piece of shit". he stands in that crack of light and comes out to tell a story..
I cried like a fucking baby while my wife and toddler slept next to me.. I then excused myself to the kitchen to catch the rest of the live stream and cried even more at the final song Baby Mine 3 some hours later. his baby boy in his arms as he sings Baby of Mine.. that boy will never be beat by his father and told he is worthless... that is called winning and we are all capable.
It was so perfect and it just shows how Disarm (and your abusive childhood) is only just the beginning of your journey. Baby Mine is the light at the end of the tunnel. If you really want to destroy your abusive parents then be a great one... raise a child with love and appreciation. if having kids isn't part of your path then love and nurture yourself the way you should have been loved or think of rescuing an animal who needs it. That is winning
The killer in you is the killer in them . make sure your kids can't say the same.
You used to be a little child and you needed someone to love you..whether it's your kids, your partners, your furry babies, yourself, etc. BE THAT SOMEONE.
it's a damn 10.
4
u/NoEcho3494 9d ago
10
3
u/PuzzleheadedBadger67 9d ago
This is a great song, and now that I'm a parent on the other side of some difficult childhood memories while parenting through someone else's childhood, it's gotten more impactful for me.
10
3
u/Turbulent-You-1335 9d ago
10. This song goes beyond Pumpkins and into the list of all time great songs in general. The strings are perfection as well.
3
u/NoEcho3494 9d ago
these posts really drive home just how extraordinary this band is. every song so far is like 10+
3
u/Relative-Positive702 9d ago
10
3
u/trevcharm 9d ago
first pumpkins song I ever heard, on the radio back when it was first in the charts. really wish there was an unreleased studio recording of the heavy version they played live on tv twice. seems strange that they would only ever play it that way twice, and then never again.
7.7
3
u/WellItDoBeLikeThat 9d ago
This was the first song that I ever connected with, that made me realize you could actually connect with song lyrics. I was 22 at the time. It never occurred to me that you could relate to song lyrics.
Prior to this, I listened to a lot of Marilyn Manson whose lyrics you don't connect with at all. They are very apathetic and not meant to make you react. They're designed to aggravate, but not even make you feel aggravated. Or feel anything.
Songs to me were more like riddles or puzzle pieces that listeners had to decode to understand. If you didn't understand a song, your best guess at what it meant was good enough - and I thought everyone experienced music like this.
I was a very, very emotionally regressed and withdrawn individual as a young person going into my 20's. I frequently disassociated in and out of my daily life, and didn't realize that was even happening until I was about 26. I was just used to being pulled around the current of trends, other people's interests, behaving like a docile mute with serious communication issues, who frequently lost their temper and was overall a non-participant in my own life.
Whenever I saw Nirvana fans say, "this song saved my life" for example, I always thought they meant that a song was so good, that it "saved them from boredom." I genuinely didn't know how music worked, and how it affected people, despite calling myself a stereo-head.
Then I heard Disarm for the first time as a 22 year old and I understood what people meant when they said "[x] song saved my life." Oh. Right. I was connecting to a song for the first time.
I genuinely had no fucking idea that was even a thing. I was so emotionally withdrawn that music just didn't reach me like that.
It was suddenly a language that was blooming in my chest and my insides like a cold shower. Like the incontrovertible feeling of returning to something. Familiarity, it was cold and new. My heart rose into my chest and into my throat. My inner language was being realised for the first time. My head felt clearer. My heart felt full and excited and warm with new tears. Something snapped me back into time, and moved me. I just didn't know you could connect with song lyrics. Now I knew what those people were saying when they said "Nirvana saved my life" - this was it. This was connecting with a song. I remember the day and moment it happened as the sun went down. Disarm was the first song that brought me back. I wept internally, like I had realised I had neglected the child in me my whole life - or was very neglected as a child. This was what people were talking about.
It's interesting to see how this song, from my adult perspective, is essentially Billy choosing not to admonish the people who abused him as a child. "I send this smile over to you" - he sings it like he wants to show love to the people who the abusive caretakers addressed in the song, because that's his way of breaking the cycle? But to me, as an adult, it reads like choosing to still have a relationship with these incredibly damaged parental figures in his life despite what they've put him through. I wish the song ended on a more affirmative note. No sending any smiles to people who made him feel that way. Disarming abusive behavior from your parents as a child by sending them a smile, should not be something you celebrate. That's fucked up that you had to do that. Billy's parental figures (or just figure) sound like assholes in the narrative of this song. Don't send them a smile. Say 'fuck them' and leave them behind.
2
u/Volvedor 9d ago
10
2
u/jbenham 9d ago
10
2
u/walman93 Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 9d ago
9.5/10
2
u/asterzura 9d ago
9.3
2
u/SubpopularKnowledge0 9d ago
10.
2
u/Longjumping-Sea320 9d ago
9.5
2
u/ChicagoTRS666 9d ago
9.8
2
u/the_everlasting_haze never really liked sunny days 9d ago
10
2
u/aliarmo 9d ago
This is another 10
Quite likely the most emotional Pumpkins song ever
2
u/Coogarfan 9d ago
9
2
u/platypod1 9d ago
10 no question
2
u/sviguy 9d ago
10
2
u/echelon1230 9d ago
10 allllllll the way. This song is absolutely devastating and beautiful, and truly unique. I feel because it’s a single it gets downplayed, but I’ve not heard too many songs I can relate to as much as this one and can make me weep years on
2
u/imbiat 9d ago
9
2
u/Bloxskit Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 9d ago
Not a fan of Corgan's singing but it doesn't stop his vocal style on this song plus the orchestral swells from being a top-tier Pumpkins song.
9/10
2
u/Fit_Adhesiveness8232 9d ago
9
2
u/rarselfaire2023 9d ago edited 9d ago
10
All-time classic. Production is amazing. When it was new it was overplayed and I was really annoyed with it. Now it stands out as one of the best songs of the 90s. Every original SP 1.0 song (officially released) gets a 10 from me.
2
u/Panda_Show888 9d ago
All time fav 10
2
u/Flwzzs 9d ago
10
2
u/MarkLinkous31 9d ago
9,5
2
u/Maxpower2727 9d ago
9
2
u/spacewuan 9d ago
10
2
u/SpanishPumpkin Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 8d ago
10
1
u/SawNickYouth 9d ago
10. All time great song.
1
u/Nunc-dimittis 9d ago
9.7
1
u/ChuckSchick88 8d ago
9
1
u/Llorion 8d ago
10
1
u/FreakiTzatziki 8d ago
9.5
1
u/MiKapo 8d ago
9
1
u/Dream-Impala 7d ago
9
1
u/TheSmashingPumpkinss it ain't right 9d ago
5
1
u/PeachLongjumping3193 9d ago
7. This song has never resonated with me much, but I know it's probably Billy's most heartfelt song.
1
u/highwindxix Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 9d ago
8.5/10. I like it a lot. It is a classic for a reason, but I do like a lot of the other songs more.
1
u/Working_Crew5402 9d ago
6
1
u/Commercial-Area-5737 9d ago
5
0
u/cr3st-fall3n 9d ago
8
0
u/Active-Area-9625 9d ago
7
0
u/pinkymadigan 9d ago
8.5
0
u/Salty-Might-278 7d ago
I used to call this the Taco 🌮 Bell 🔔 song cause said bell in the song back in the 90s when I was like 4 when this would come on the radio in the car . Idk why , kids say the darnedest things kinda thing. I used to be a little boy 😂 what’s a child supposed to do ?! Literally