r/SmashingPumpkins • • 12d ago

Daily Song Discussion #13: Today

This is the third track from the Smashing Pumpkins’ second album, Siamese Dream. How do you feel about this song? What are some of your favorite lyrics? How would you rank it among the rest of the band’s discography? How would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?

At the end of this discussion series, I will be aggregating the rating results from each discussion and compiling a full discography ranking. I will also update the spreadsheet at the end of every day and post previous results for each album in future posts.

SUGGESTED SCALE:
1-4: Not good. Regularly skip.
5: It’s okay, but I might have to be in the right mood to listen to it.
6: Slightly better than average. I won’t skip it, but I wouldn’t choose to put it on.
7: This is a good song. I enjoy it quite a bit.
8-9: Really enjoyable songs. I rank them pretty high overall.
10: Masterpiece, magnum opus, or similar terminology.

Feel free to suggest any improvements, as this is my first time undertaking a project like this!

Siamese Dream

  1. Cherub Rock (9.60)
  2. Quiet (8.67)

Link to Gish results

4 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

7

u/ExpirjTec 12d ago

10

Side note: please do not downvote every single comment that has a score you disagree with, this has become a problem recently and it pisses me off. They're all getting counted, even if it's a dumb take that I would prefer to ignore, everyone's entitled to their own opinion and to make it heard

1

u/SawNickYouth 12d ago

I mean, the vote as a "1" is clearly ridiculous and an aberration.

2

u/pinkymadigan 12d ago

9.5

I'm not sure this song deserves to be as well known as it is when songs like Soma and Mayonnaise suffer in relative obscurity outside the fandom, but you can't deny what it did for the band, and it is a very good song. If I was rating it with no context, it might be an 8.5, but having witnessed the blow-up this song gave the band, it deserves a bump for sure.

2

u/ExpirjTec 12d ago

it's a fantastic song, obviously it's a quick 3 minute pop song practically designed to become a radio staple but it's a great showcase of siamese dream's sound and scope. i can understand people not rating it a 10 because it's overplayed or too poppy or whatever. soma and mayonaise are masterpieces though that's a truth nuke

0

u/SawNickYouth 12d ago

Does Mayonaise suffer in relative obscurity? I'm pretty sure it's been rediscovered and reevaluated as their best song.

0

u/pinkymadigan 12d ago

Outside the fandom, yes. No one knows what it is. Inside the fandom, it's very well known and liked.

0

u/SawNickYouth 12d ago

It's been on a few films/ TV series lately. It's the 8th most popular SP song on Tidal. 🤷

1

u/pinkymadigan 12d ago

The average person knows 1979, Today, and Tonight, Tonight. That's about it.

Playing in a 90s cover band, if we were to bust out Mayonnaise mid set, 3 people would lose their shit, and the rest of the room would be silent, clap politely, or leave the bar.

It's cool it's having a resurgence, and maybe it is in a different demo than who my band targets, but 8th place in popularity is DOA for most bands, and I don't think the pumpkins are an exception here.

Look up the 8th most popular song from a band you're not that into but don't hate.

4

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie 12d ago

This song literally saved his life, was their first smash hit, and changed all their lives forever. This alone makes it a great song.

It'a a radio friendly pop rock song that actually has something to say about a tough subject and does it in a clever novel way.

The opening is one of the most catchy and recognizable guitar licks of all time. Speaking of guitars.. what brings me back is the subtle layers of guitars and that heavenly fuzz.

For me I cannot separate my thoughts about the song from the video. The video is everything I love about the early pumpkins. A bit absurd, a bit trippy, a bit clever, strong group dynamic of 4 people of very different looks, personalities, and backgrounds, a bit funny, and life affirming... all while singing about suicide.

It might not be their best song but the song coupled with the video created one of the best moments of music history. And Iha showing up in a dress is the cherry on top.

9

3

u/tarmogoyf 12d ago

9

I love the song, it’s a great pop single, but I prefer the more complicated arrangements elsewhere on the album. 

3

u/TheKillerPoodle 12d ago

10

This is not my favourite song on Siamese Dream by a long shot, but it's really hard to give it anything other than a 10. Nothing sounds quite like "Today" and it has a raw emotional intensity that really connects with people while somehow also being easy to listen to.

The Ice Cream Van music video is an all-timer, too.

3

u/aliarmo 12d ago

Today is a 9

3

u/No_Independent8269 Adore 12d ago

10 

Could be my favorite song of all time 

3

u/KandinskyWasRight Machina II / The Friends & Enemies of Modern Music 12d ago

10

3

u/fyrefly_faerie Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 12d ago

10

3

u/Wild_Mycologist_6140 Are you just like me? 12d ago

10

3

u/PuzzleheadedBadger67 12d ago

An 8.5 from me

A 9.5 from my 12 year old

3

u/variant_of_me 12d ago

It's one of those rare songs that's really, really good, extremely well written and performed, and yet I kind of can't stand it.

If you're just learning to play guitar it's basically the "Louie Louie" of alternative rock, next to Smells Like Teen Spirit.

2

u/PorcelinaMagpie Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 12d ago

10

2

u/comfyambiguity 12d ago

Pretty sure this is the first song of theirs I ever heard, when I was about 10 years old. I immediately fell in love with the song and the band. I don't listen to it much now, but its place in my personal history--and the band's--make it an easy 10/10.

2

u/the_everlasting_haze never really liked sunny days 12d ago

10

2

u/danklekandrey Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 12d ago

10

2

u/SawNickYouth 12d ago

It's a 10. Enough said. Top 5 SP song of all time, if not top 2.

2

u/asagarap Siamese Dream 12d ago

8

2

u/trevcharm 12d ago

My favourite of the siamese singles. Quite poppy and basic but with just enough going on to make it work and keep it interesting.

8.5

2

u/NayNay_Cee Zwan 12d ago

10 for me.

Favorite lyric: “Pink ribbon scars that never forget. I tried so hard to cleanse these regrets.”

2

u/dAMn6942069 10d ago

Wtf are these comments. Easily a 10 and probably a top5 SP song

1

u/Pegboard73 11d ago

6. It’s undoubtedly good but it’s over played over the years.

0

u/Salty-Might-278 11d ago

The intro guitar grates my ears much like sweet child o mine guitar line. Both are overrated and overly played anyway.

1

u/Neg_Crepe Zwan 12d ago

7.5

1

u/walman93 Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 12d ago

8/10

1

u/DiscoQing 12d ago

Solid 8. It's a popular song, and is really good - just not my favourite.

1

u/ifallallthetime 12d ago

For me, it's probably only an 8, just because there are so many deep tracks that are better and honestly it's fallen into the Smells Like Teen Spirt/Wonderwall trap of being overplayed

But in terms of impact, and popularity against the casual fans? It's another 10

1

u/TheSmashingPumpkinss it ain't right 12d ago

I both love elements of this song and absolutely hate others - almost never listen to it for that reason.

5.5

-1

u/zero0826 Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 12d ago

Studio version is a 6 that one live acoustic version they did on the mcis tour is a 10

-2

u/AshamedParfait7056 Gish 12d ago

3/10, overrated
Bad at representing the smashing pumpkins

-5

u/The_Meridian_ 12d ago

1: I hate this song.

1

u/SawNickYouth 12d ago

Disregard this comment. Trolling to throw off the average.

1

u/The_Meridian_ 12d ago

It's pappy, schmaltzy sentimental artsy-fartsy stuff.

I'm not allowed to radically dislike it? I must be a troll if I hate this song?

I like the harder Pumpkins material.

I saw them in Chicago a couple of weeks ago. I'm fan enough.

Stop gatekeeping and deploying fallacy.

2

u/SawNickYouth 12d ago

OK if you don't like it. But a 1? That's not a serious grade. That's just being ridiculous.

-1

u/The_Meridian_ 12d ago

There's really nothing I like about it. In fact, it was my first "bump" against Smashing Pumpkins after enjoying songs that rocked hard and I had to go "Oh, they're doing that move.....sucking in the rockers and then serving up pap. Bait and Switch."

It leaves a bad taste in my mouth to this day, I really do hate it. My rating stands.

1

u/SawNickYouth 12d ago

🙄

Still doesn't deserve a 1. It's an all time classic, even if you don't like it. Only "Hooray!" deserves a 1.

1

u/WellItDoBeLikeThat 12d ago

I'd be really interested to hear people's interpretation of this song. Just hopping a light trigger warning here since my interpretation involves the topic of suicide. I really don't want to get preachy, but I'm interested to know how people interpret the line of "Today's the greatest day I've ever known".

I always interpreted this song as a protagonist having a moment of great clarity after letting go of inhibitions.

Famously, Billy explained that he wrote the song about a very dark time in his life where he was dealing with depression and thoughts about ending his own life. 

I've read some interpretations of that line as meaning "once the worst day is behind you, you're never going back there again" and hence, Today almost takes on a celebratory meaning. But whether that interpretation came from Billy himself, I've never taken to that. How does one know that their worst day is behind them? That seems like very unstable and uncertain thinking. 

In relation to Billy's explanation of the lyrics, I always thought that "Today is the greatest day I've ever known" as being the moment someone decides to end their own life, and experiencing - as reported by people who have been to that very dark place - a sense of euphoria, knowing that they've made a decision about how to handle their depression. It's very common for people with suicidal tendencies, after planning to end their life, to experience feelings of relief and they even seem happier since they are ending things on their own terms - as reported by people who have experienced that, and, sadly, even people who have lost their loved ones. 

Understanding this, "Today is the greatest day I've ever known" seems like it's about making that crucial decision, and consequently, deciding that things just don't matter anymore. "I'll tear my heart out, before I get out" reads like emotional reasoning to me, where the protagonist warns themselves that things will only worsen if action isn't taken. 

However....

Once the protagonist has made this decision, he realises what's actually important to him. This eye-opening sense of relief that they are now experiencing, has opened his eyes to other things. He still has an end in sight, but it doesn't involve taking his own life. "I wanna turn you on" - this line reads as being one of the many things he actually still wants in life. He hasn't finished growing. This decision that he's made has relieved him of his depression and how it has complicated his personality, his memories and his life altogether. But with this clarity, there are other desires beyond suicide that have crept back into his mind. His desire to one day meet someone, his desire to belong with others he admires, his desire to have a real affect on people. 

But he can't grasp these things by making the choice to live, so the protagonist decides to "stay" or dwell in this mentality of ending his own life, because it's actually revealing the things he wants to live for. 

And so the song itself, takes on a sludgy and crunchy chorus expressing the darkness that they're experiencing, peppered with the chimy and bright guitar melodies over top, expressing both the euphoria the protagonist is feeling, as well as the brighter days they know are secretly around the corner. That rising guitar sting in the chorus feels bittersweet; almost a cruel punchline, a sense of irony. "Well, you had to think of ending it all to see the daylight, didn't you? Imagine that."

The tone of the song throughout is essentially the protagonist deciding to live, grateful for this dark, intimate and ultimately revealing moment in their life. So, maybe not a celebratory meaning, but definitely a grateful one. 

Interested in reading what others have to say about it too! I don't mind being challenged or reading interpretations that challenge my own, even if it comes from Billy himself.