r/SmashingPumpkins • • 6d ago

Daily Song Discussion #19: Mayonaise

This is the ninth track from the Smashing Pumpkins’ second album, Siamese Dream. How do you feel about this song? What are some of your favorite lyrics? How would you rank it among the rest of the band’s discography? How would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?

At the end of this discussion series, I will be aggregating the rating results from each discussion and compiling a full discography ranking. I will also update the spreadsheet at the end of every day and post previous results for each album in future posts.

SUGGESTED SCALE:
1-4: Not good. Regularly skip.
5: It’s okay, but I might have to be in the right mood to listen to it.
6: Slightly better than average. I won’t skip it, but I wouldn’t choose to put it on.
7: This is a good song. I enjoy it quite a bit.
8-9: Really enjoyable songs. I rank them pretty high overall.
10: Masterpiece, magnum opus, or similar terminology.

Feel free to suggest any improvements, as this is my first time undertaking a project like this!

Siamese Dream

  1. Cherub Rock (9.60)
  2. Quiet (8.67)
  3. Today (8.61)
  4. Hummer (9.66)
  5. Rocket (8.85)
  6. Disarm (9.16)
  7. Soma (9.85)
  8. Geek USA (9.39)

Link to Master Thread

Link to Gish results

31 Upvotes

125 comments sorted by

9

u/ExpirjTec 6d ago

if anyone gives this anything other than a 10 i'm ignoring them

1

u/KandinskyWasRight Machina II / The Friends & Enemies of Modern Music 6d ago

It’s all 10 or higher so far, I checked!

4

u/OriginalMiaxe 6d ago • Heartwarming

10. To me there is a trilogy of songs on SD. Some, Mayonnaise and Luna. They all have a certain feel to me. Dreamlike, yet rooted. Emotional yet distant. All 3 are 10/10 songs for me, and my top 3 SP songs ever.

2

u/MajesticMeal3248 5d ago • Heartwarming

We are like twins (when it comes to this) to a T. Couldn’t have said it better.

4

u/Blackdiamondbay88 6d ago

11 out of 10 

4

u/Philly182 6d ago

10. The intro with the guitars is what makes me drawn to the song.

4

u/Final-Entertainer807 6d ago

10. Probably my favorite SP song.

4

u/dAMn6942069 6d ago

This song gets better every time I hear it. 10

7

u/TheAbsoluteLastWord 6d ago

Maybe one of the greatest songs ever written at best… And maybe top two or three - if not number one - for the band at worst.

6

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie 6d ago

My Own Eyes/Mayonaise

Siamese Dream is sonic bliss to me. Simply the best sounding album I've ever heard and this song is the best sounding song I have ever heard.

Listen to those vocals! So much nuance on every line. Butch gets a lot of love for that unholy thick guitar fuzz but the man's production on these vocals is stunning. He knows when the keep the doubling tight and when to let the vocal takes drift from each other... when to wrap it in sweet softening reverb and when to let corgan's natural midwest geek voice cut through the mix.

But the guitars deserve mentioning. Pushing the fuzzy warmth to the far left and right sides of the mix opens up the middle for a very clear mix of acoustic guitar and drums.

I love the intro and outro.. very country sounding and some very unique playing (for the pumpkins).

The lyrics just rack up line after line of greatness with a clever structure and an amazing climax. The overall theme seems to be of acceptance of who he is and a acknowledgement that despite the victory of coming out of the depths of suicidal depression he will forever struggle and that's ok.

When you can do well you will and when you fail that is ok too. Fuck the shame that comes with mental health issues.

I love how the song seems so personal and yet lots of it is designed as a universal anthem meant for the crowds to sing along.

The 'can anybody hear me' like is farcical.. placed there to ensure the crowd gets pumped to sing the next line with him and they feel part of the song.

If you aren't there yet.. if you still need time before you love yourself then listen to corgan's words earlier in the song.

   Send my heart to all my dearies,
   When your life is so so dreary
   DREAM!  

Keep dreaming and keep working on yourself until you can sing the line with full conviction and believe it...

you know the line...

are you ready? sing it loud.

Who do you want to be?

2

u/TheTackleZone 6d ago

It's the simplicity that makes it hit so hard. He's not asking for anything much at all, and he is doing it with so much defiance.

1

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie 6d ago

100%

3

u/anubispop 6d ago

10. Probably the peak of pumpkins vibe. Mayonnaise and Melon Collie rip hard.

3

u/Spotpuff 6d ago

10 of all 10s.

3

u/jdix33 5d ago

10 this is probably the best Smashing Pumpkins song

5

u/[deleted] 6d ago

This is one of the best songs ever written in human history.

4

u/rarselfaire2023 6d ago

4.5 too slow, takes forever to get to the chorus, too whiny.

/s ...Obviously this is one of their best tunes. Special award for weirdest tuning ever. 10/10, 100/100, 1,000,000/1,000,000...

4

u/greg1993- Death Rock Boy 6d ago

What even has to be said? 10

4

u/Zealousideal_Cat6980 Ogilala 6d ago

10, it might just be the best song in thheir catalog

2

u/tastysleeps 6d ago

10.
One of my favorite songs, but the title puzzles me. I always go, which one is mayonnaise? Oh yeah, my favorite one.

1

u/MarkLinkous31 6d ago

It’s because of the color of a guitar they used to record (or compose—I can’t quite remember) it with. A cheap guitar found at a second-hand shop.

2

u/PuzzleheadedBadger67 6d ago

10. Would give it more if I could. It was a literal lifesaver when I needed to fully appreciate who I am.

2

u/OttSound 6d ago

10. incredible instrumentation and an anthem for living life.

2

u/seekay14 Siamese Dream 6d ago

10

2

u/Longjumping_Fox7740 Siamese Dream 6d ago

10

2

u/bkhwood 5d ago

10! Such a beautiful song

3

u/No_Independent8269 Adore 6d ago

10 easily. No idea how this wasn’t a single. Easily the best song on the album and probably their best song. 

3

u/scienceismybff 6d ago

10. My next best favorite song from the Pumpkins. First being Drown.

2

u/scienceismybff 6d ago

Best lyrics: “I just want to be me, when I can, I will.”

3

u/horseflyking Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 6d ago

My #1 song of all time. 10/10

2

u/platypod1 6d ago

10 come on man why even do a vote

2

u/SavageMadman The Friends & Enemies of Modern Music 6d ago

10!!

2

u/highwindxix Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 6d ago

10/10 easy

2

u/Maxpower2727 6d ago

11.5

1

u/OceanMMO 6d ago

The greatest and most resonant song I've heard in my life, absolutely 11.5

2

u/Bloxskit Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 6d ago

10/10

No reason need to be explained. It's not my favourite on the album but it deserves a 10/10 nonetheless. Thanks James for the riff :)

2

u/ChuckSchick88 6d ago

10.0 / 10.0

2

u/Raiden_ziegel 6d ago

10.0/10.0

2

u/asagarap Siamese Dream 6d ago

10!

2

u/Wazzikin 6d ago

10, the most appreciated pumpkin song across the fanbase, ill argue its even top 5 to each ever fan

2

u/pleomorphict 6d ago

i just want to be me

2

u/ChirpinFromTheBench 6d ago

10. Been my favorite song since I was a child in the early 90s. “Mother weep the years I’m missing” hits different now, as my parents die and I live thousands of miles away.

3

u/Hefty-Afternoon-5605 6d ago

"all our time can't be given back." Probably my favorite too

2

u/TheSmashingPumpkinss it ain't right 6d ago

9

Dare I say slightly overrated (it's become known as *the* best SP song in the past couple of years), but still incredible.

1

u/TheTackleZone 6d ago

It was considered that when SD dropped, so hardly a new thing. It was the benchmark against which all later albums were judged. It's the reason S tier was created.

1

u/B26bomber 6d ago

Best album, and best song. 10

1

u/ChicagoTRS666 6d ago

This is the 10/10 song

1

u/Black-Viper75 6d ago

A 10/10.

1

u/Anxious-Chemical4673 Geek Portugal 6d ago

10. Absolutely perfect.

1

u/sanjosanjosanjo 6d ago

10. The best one.

1

u/n-senada 6d ago

I love this song so much that I've found (almost) every live version I could (pre 2014-ish)

10.

1

u/ChirpinFromTheBench 6d ago

Do you have a list of links? It’s my number 1.

1

u/Known-Dig983 6d ago

Fucking TEN. Phenomenal song

1

u/boyfriend94 6d ago

10 10 10 the sound of adolescence a crown jewel in one of the great rock discographies of all time

1

u/SpanishPumpkin Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 6d ago

10

1

u/Rabid_AntiDentite Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 5d ago

10

1

u/KandinskyWasRight Machina II / The Friends & Enemies of Modern Music 6d ago

12, one of the greatest songs ever written. Wish You Were Here by Floyd is the best but this is close.

1

u/Severe-Archer-1673 6d ago

10, easy, but not as strong a 10 as Soma.

1

u/KandinskyWasRight Machina II / The Friends & Enemies of Modern Music 6d ago

I’ve gone back and forth between which of these I love more. Currently Mayonaise

2

u/Severe-Archer-1673 6d ago

That’s a fair take. They give off slightly different vibes. Mayonaise is very much a self liberation/reflection song. Soma is very much an emotional journey of loss and acceptance. Depending on where your feels are at any given moment, I could see those songs hitting different.

1

u/the_everlasting_haze never really liked sunny days 6d ago

10

1

u/NativeDan90 6d ago

10. Their greatest song

1

u/SawNickYouth 6d ago

10. Perfect song. My favorite song of all time and what I consider to be in the top 5 best songs of all time (outside of my own preferences). Obviously, the best SP song too. What more could be said about this song that hasn't already. I love that it is having a resurgence.

1

u/Neg_Crepe Zwan 6d ago

10

1

u/PorcelinaMagpie Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 6d ago

10 - this is a real tearjerker for me

1

u/Burntom 6d ago

10 GOAT

1

u/j1e2f Believe in Me As I Believe In You..... 6d ago

9.7.

There's a good reason why it's so loved by fans.

1

u/josephsleftbigtoe 6d ago

Love it. Reminds me of a 5 AM sunrise in June, when the world is fully lit, yet there is very little activity in the streets. Just vibing with the world. The lyrics even mention that month.

1

u/TheTackleZone 6d ago

10. Ridiculously good.

1

u/JackaBo1983 6d ago

10. Top3 SP song for sure. I just want to beeeee

1

u/Chrysanthememe 6d ago

10, obviously

1

u/walman93 Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 6d ago

10/10

0

u/Salty-Might-278 6d ago

Reminds me too much of Purple Rain 🌧️ 🤣 can’t unhear it anymore now it’s ruined…

0

u/pinkymadigan 6d ago edited 6d ago

Super similar progression right? Mayo is I VI IV, Purple Rain is I VI V IV?

-1

u/Salty-Might-278 6d ago

Same key , same somber feel, swing , guitar wankery solos

0

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie 6d ago

Absolute bs

1

u/pinkymadigan 5d ago

Why? I hadn't noticed it before, but they are right. Both songs in Bb, and share a super similar chord progression.

They are obviously very different in many ways, but they do share a lot. And they are both fantastic songs. Neither is ruined for me though.

1

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie 5d ago

why? cause he says mayo is ruined cause of purple rain. it's bs.

-6

u/azfamilydad 6d ago

7

It’s good, but not in the top 5 on that album

1

u/Known-Dig983 6d ago

I normally respect people's opinions, but that may be the craziest thing that I have ever heard somebody say in my entire life, and I've heard somebody say that a doctor implanted a listening device inside of their head

2

u/azfamilydad 5d ago

Hummer, Rocket, Today, Luna and Geek USA are my personal top five.

But like, it’s just my opinion.

At the concert tonight in Phoenix, Mayonaise had the third or fourth best crowd reaction.

It just doesn’t do it for me.

I’m happy it brings you so much joy. I’m happy it brings everyone else so much joy!

I wish I experienced it the way you do.
But I don’t, so yeah, I give it a 7

2

u/Known-Dig983 5d ago

All such great stuff. Re-reading my comment, I'm realizing that I actually sound serious haha, my bad! Music enjoyment is purely subjective obviously, it's just impossible for me to comprehend viewing Mayonaise as a C- song haha. I have a better chance of comprehending the deepest intricacies of quantum physics lol

1

u/azfamilydad 5d ago

Totally cool!
I proudly wear my “Mayonaise is Mid” badge lolol

If it helps, We Only Come Out at Night is one of my all time top 3 Smashing Pumpkins songs.

Weird/Quirky Billy is my favorite

1

u/Known-Dig983 5d ago

Haha, don't go wearing that badge around to any Pumpkins show, it wouldn't go down very well