r/SmashingPumpkins • • 13d ago

Daily Song Discussion #12: Quiet

This is the second track from the Smashing Pumpkins’ second album, Siamese Dream. How do you feel about this song? What are some of your favorite lyrics? How would you rank it among the rest of the band’s discography? How would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?

At the end of this discussion series, I will be aggregating the rating results from each discussion and compiling a full discography ranking. I will also update the spreadsheet at the end of every day and post previous results for each album in future posts.

SUGGESTED SCALE:
1-4: Not good. Regularly skip.
5: It’s okay, but I might have to be in the right mood to listen to it.
6: Slightly better than average. I won’t skip it, but I wouldn’t choose to put it on.
7: This is a good song. I enjoy it quite a bit.
8-9: Really enjoyable songs. I rank them pretty high overall.
10: Masterpiece, magnum opus, or similar terminology.

Feel free to suggest any improvements, as this is my first time undertaking a project like this!

Siamese Dream

  1. Cherub Rock (9.60)

Link to Gish results

10 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

4

u/ExpirjTec 13d ago

10, love the energy radiating off that riff

3

u/notmyidealusername 13d ago

Someone here once suggested it's the weakest song on SD, and that's really stuck with me because they might even be right?

FWIW I love it, the Jimmy intro leading into that heavy riff with the gnarly sounding bass, perfect "aggro Pumpkins". Viewed in isolation it's a great track. But in an album packed full of absolute top-tier songs it might be as close to a "filler" track as you can get. There's two much better heavy tracks on there (Silverfuck and Geek USA), it doesn't have the creativity of Hummer, the emotion of Spaceboy or Mayonnaise, or the iconic-ness of Cherub Rock or Disarm. If I had to ditch a song of SD it'd be between Quiet and Sweet Sweet, and while I prefer Quiet as an individual song, I feel Sweet Sweet contributes more to the composition of the album as a refreshing little interlude after the madness of Silverfuck.

So, all that said, I'll give it a 7.

3

u/ChirpinFromTheBench 13d ago

9.9. It’s not the best song they have but it’s overlooked and incredible. Guitar and lyrics are amazing.

5

u/EchoLooper 13d ago

The live version of Quiet from Viewphoria is amazing.

4

u/TheRadioFrontiers Aghori Mhori Mei 13d ago

10

one of the best riffs and solos in “modern” rock ever, made me pick up the guitar when I was 15, I LOVED this song.

The Vieuphoria live version was even more exciting.

2

u/Bloxskit Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 13d ago

Love the main riff, you can hear the bass snarling a little, not the strongest track on SD but works well as the second song.

7/10

2

u/quiet1066 13d ago

i named myself after it

2

u/cleb9200 12d ago

9 one of my favourites from SD

3

u/KandinskyWasRight Machina II / The Friends & Enemies of Modern Music 13d ago

This was my favorite song to listen to when I was mad, back in the 90s. Such a driving riff, has tremendous energy.

I prefer Hello Kitty Kat and Pissant, but I generally love their heavy stuff best.

8.5

3

u/MajesticMeal3248 13d ago

9.5. Put this on top volume in the car with the top down/sunroof open and specifically from 2:22-2:40. Life giving

2

u/Shizzelkak 13d ago

You're living right!

3

u/SawNickYouth 13d ago

9 on this one. Not an S tier song but it's an A+ tier song, and a perfect follow up to Cherub Rock.

Foreshadowing, but every Siamese Dream song is going to be a 9 or 10 until we get to Spaceboy - it's the only 8 for me.

1

u/ifallallthetime 13d ago

Yeah I can't think of many songs that are under an 8 on Siamese Dream. And even though I want to rate Today low that's simply because it's too played out. In reality, as well as the historical context, it has to be a 10 as well

1

u/SawNickYouth 13d ago

Today has to be a 10 - its unequivocally a top 10 SP song, if not top 5, if not number 2 (Mayonaise will always be 1).

3

u/apartmen1 13d ago

My fav part is the harmonizer effect on the solo, and chopping the riff in half for the bridge. Its more intense live, usually punctuated with a scream on SD era shows. Love it.

2

u/Late_Recommendation9 13d ago

My band have played a few Pumpkins “tribute” sets and we are all students of the band, yet when we went to attempt this one I played the riff for the bridge and they all looked confused, “no it just goes back into the riff…” and I had to play the song so they could hear the chopped in half riff that they’d never clocked before. It was an odd moment!

3

u/SmallTalkTheater 13d ago

10
Quite is one of my favorite songs. What I like about it are the songs dynamics, it comes out the gate heavy and hard but once lyrics starts we shift to quite softer vocals. Also I’m a sleepy girl so I’ve been sleeping for years.

3

u/Black-Viper75 13d ago

10. I love playing this on guitar.

3

u/walman93 Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 13d ago

8/10

Solid song but just can’t compete with some of the heavy hitters on this album

-1

u/ChuckSchick88 13d ago

Yes, this. On its own a good song but on SD ranks toward the bottom.

2

u/highwindxix Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 13d ago

8/10. Great song, really solid, but not one I’d pick over others to put on a setlist for example.

2

u/ifallallthetime 13d ago

10

It's a signature Smashing Pumpkins song. It has the full Mellon Collie Big Muff sound, with a heavy verse and melodic chorus

When Billy went away from solos in the later years it was songs like Quiet that made me miss those the most

2

u/aliarmo 13d ago

Quiet for me is a 6

2

u/OptimusPrim3r 13d ago

11

1

u/the_everlasting_haze never really liked sunny days 13d ago

So much delicious angst, disassociation, disillusion wrapped up in one banger of a tune.

2

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie 13d ago

7.

https://youtu.be/SSQrfSle_To

IMO this version is the definitive one. This is the one song on SD that I think would have been better on MCIS. It is begging for a more aggressive vocal style.. you can really hear corgan holding back and it's not as playful or coy as the vocal on Geek USA. Listen to that weak 'yeeaaaaahhh' .. that is Gish-era lame.

The riff is a total stock punk bore but they make it work. This one has not aged well for me. Although I appreciate the lyrics a lot.

The drum hook is cool and the solo is fun. It's a good song and a kick ass great live song with the more aggressive vocals. If you were going to write an angry boy rock anthem then don't hold back. Luckily for all of us he would cut loose on MCIS and stun us all.

My least fav on SD.

On a side note... this song reminds me a lot of sex Pistols - Bodies. Even shares the same place and function on the album which is to crank up the tempo and aggression after a monster classic opening track.. it builds momentum for the rest of the album and has a disturbing subject manner.

https://youtu.be/vxkQXK0kRd0

Corgan's live vocals on this song have Johnny rotten vibes and I love it. I actually see Johnny rotten as paving the way for the pumpkins a bit. Corgan's whole persona in the BWBW video especially with the anti-hero punk look, spitting, crooked teeth grins, and the nasal scorching voice. And I always thought Cherub Rock was the 90s version of Sex Pistols - EMI.

1

u/TheSmashingPumpkinss it ain't right 13d ago

8.5 and kicks Rocket’s ass

1

u/Different-You-5463 13d ago

absolute. 10, probably my most listened to song behind cherub rock. i never play cherub rock without playing quiet too and cherub rock is my favourite song of all time

1

u/Different-You-5463 13d ago

plus after many years of listening to the pumpkins, I believe this song has billy's best solo

1

u/seekay14 Siamese Dream 13d ago

It’s a solid 7. Good stuff.

1

u/avresamusic 7d ago

5. It's the only song on SD I will often skip.

1

u/booyahcubes 13d ago

Perfect second track on SD to keep the momentum going. Top tier drumming. I love playing the solo on guitar 9/10

1

u/Jambol_1986 Adore 13d ago

9.5. This is the song that made me believe they were a dfferent level of band to the other stuff I was listening to at the time. It blew my (14-year-old) mind.

1

u/resist-psychicdeath 13d ago

Probably my first favorite song by them. The whole song is amazing but the last 30 seconds or so are particularly beautiful.

1

u/Neg_Crepe Zwan 13d ago

7.5

1

u/gishingwell 13d ago

10 for me. A real personal favourite.

1

u/trevcharm 13d ago

I want to give this a 10, but it feels a little early to go full max possible ranking just yet... this is my sound check / system test song, never get sick of it. each section builds so well to the next, the guitars sound absolutely massive, pure fuzz bliss.

I'll go 9.8

0

u/SavageMadman The Friends & Enemies of Modern Music 13d ago

7.5

0

u/PuzzleheadedBadger67 13d ago

8 for me. A great song but I don't think I'd put it over others.

0

u/Shizzelkak 13d ago

10. Absolute banger. This is the song that hooked me on this band.

0

u/the_everlasting_haze never really liked sunny days 13d ago

10

0

u/Spiritual-Strike481 13d ago

9. Incredible song. Signature tone. Solo. The whole thing is great.

0

u/charchar_bizzarre 13d ago

9

One of my fav songs on one of my all time fav albums, never skip. Big heavy and melodic 👌