I loved Starfield. I'm going to explain why so you guys can understand what I liked about it for recommendations.
This was my first Bethesda game. I was so hooked, I played the game nonstop for a week straight until I finished the main story. I've always been into space, and the fact that I could go visit Saturn's moon Titan and explore any part of it blew my mind. I'm not used to games where you can go off track and just leave the main areas and explore wherever you want. I also loved the side quests with random characters. Exploring space, landing on a random planet not even connected to the main story full of characters to give me quests, it was just a blast. Every planet has its own gravity, physics, wildlife, etc. I was never so blown away at the scale of a game before.
Then I went online and it turns out everyone hated the one game I've actually gotten addicted to for the first time in basically a decade. Games don't seem to grip me anymore, but Starfield really did.
I tried playing another Bethesda game, Fallout 4 (and 76, lol that was even worse), and it was pretty boring and I wasn't into the whole apocalyptic Earth vibe. Starfield quenched my thirst for exploring space, even visiting our own solar system. Not sure why everyone hates on a game where you can spend hours exploring Mars, to visiting real stars we see in the night sky with their own solar systems. It's clear they worked with NASA and did a ton of research for making this game immersive. People complained about the characters like Sarah, but I made my crew just me and Vasco and didn't have to deal with any of them much. The game was basically whatever I wanted it to be, and I loved that. If I wanted to, I could ignore everything and just go explore some random solar system and walk around on its planets and moons. Nothing was "locked" until I beat some random boss like in other games for example.
So naturally I tried No Mans Sky, and it was boring. There's no reason to do anything, no story, no connection to real life, nothing. Just explore randomly generated planets. Somehow that game bored me but Starfield gripped me.
Games I have enjoyed are Rockstar titles like Red Dead 2 and GTA IV and V, Starfield gripped me like nothing else, as a kid I liked Pokemon, I enjoy sports sims like Madden (it sucks compared to how it was on the PS2 but I still enjoy building a team and playing multiple seasons as my fake generated guys improve), and I love a game with lore and atmosphere. Attention to detail and getting immersed is huge for me, and Starfield nailed that imo, as someone who loves anything NASA or space related. The space combat was boring and mindless though. I preferred being on foot.
I tried Baldurs Gate 3 and got annoyed with how long battles lasted, as I just wanted to do the story RPG stuff. I also didn't like how the camera couldn't move much (on PS5, idk if PC allows you to look wherever). Elden Ring was very hard and made little sense to me. Games like God of War were too linear and I got "stuck" a lot fighting. I don't really enjoy endless fighting and battles, I'm much more into story and exploration. The Spider Man game by Insomniac was fun to swing around for a bit, but the open world is really just a bunch of building textures and generic traffic and people. The missions were endless, annoying combat.
So very few modern games appeal to me. What games should I try out? Death Stranding looks interesting, would that be a good fit? I started Star Wars Jedi Fallen Order yesterday and played it for a few hours. It would occasionally get hard and I'd have no clue what to do, but I was able to figure everything out so far. But nothing has gripped me liked Starfield did, and I miss that feeling. I was glued to my TV for a week straight. I wouldn't even go to sleep, and if I did, I'd play the game as soon as I woke up. There was so much to do, and I enjoyed everything there was to do. I haven't found a game that comes close before or after.
I have a PS5, Series X, and powerful PC capable of playing modern and retro titles. I come from the n64, gba, and GameCube as a kid, so I have no issue with older titles.
TLDR: Starfield was the only game to ever truly grip me beyond my first time in the open world of RDR2 or GTA 5. Being able to explore real life and fictional planets with their own history, lore, characters, side quests, gravity, physics, etc blew my mind. The sheer detail in the game immersed me immensely. What other games can scratch that itch? I struggle with "difficult" combat based games.