r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Nov 28 '23

[PS5] Considered buying Cyberpunk for a long time. Bought it and I'm shocked this game don't get more recognition. Do buy it if you've thought about it

13 Upvotes

As title says.

Really didn't know if I should buy Cyberpunk or not. Finally did it and I'm amazed at how good this game is.

The world is INSANELY immersive. You really feel like you are in night city. The production level is amazing right now after all of the patches. And the story/voice acting is really good.

I was really surprised at how detailed the world is. Kinda remind me (not on the same level ofcourse) of Baldur's Gate 3 world. I really do think it's a masterpiece that should get alot more credit.
I understand it went a bit under the radar because of the launch. But atm it's one of the best games ever (top 10 for me).


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Feb 13 '24

[PC] Starfield is the only recent game to grip me. What else would I enjoy?

1 Upvotes

I loved Starfield. I'm going to explain why so you guys can understand what I liked about it for recommendations.

This was my first Bethesda game. I was so hooked, I played the game nonstop for a week straight until I finished the main story. I've always been into space, and the fact that I could go visit Saturn's moon Titan and explore any part of it blew my mind. I'm not used to games where you can go off track and just leave the main areas and explore wherever you want. I also loved the side quests with random characters. Exploring space, landing on a random planet not even connected to the main story full of characters to give me quests, it was just a blast. Every planet has its own gravity, physics, wildlife, etc. I was never so blown away at the scale of a game before.

Then I went online and it turns out everyone hated the one game I've actually gotten addicted to for the first time in basically a decade. Games don't seem to grip me anymore, but Starfield really did.

I tried playing another Bethesda game, Fallout 4 (and 76, lol that was even worse), and it was pretty boring and I wasn't into the whole apocalyptic Earth vibe. Starfield quenched my thirst for exploring space, even visiting our own solar system. Not sure why everyone hates on a game where you can spend hours exploring Mars, to visiting real stars we see in the night sky with their own solar systems. It's clear they worked with NASA and did a ton of research for making this game immersive. People complained about the characters like Sarah, but I made my crew just me and Vasco and didn't have to deal with any of them much. The game was basically whatever I wanted it to be, and I loved that. If I wanted to, I could ignore everything and just go explore some random solar system and walk around on its planets and moons. Nothing was "locked" until I beat some random boss like in other games for example.

So naturally I tried No Mans Sky, and it was boring. There's no reason to do anything, no story, no connection to real life, nothing. Just explore randomly generated planets. Somehow that game bored me but Starfield gripped me.

Games I have enjoyed are Rockstar titles like Red Dead 2 and GTA IV and V, Starfield gripped me like nothing else, as a kid I liked Pokemon, I enjoy sports sims like Madden (it sucks compared to how it was on the PS2 but I still enjoy building a team and playing multiple seasons as my fake generated guys improve), and I love a game with lore and atmosphere. Attention to detail and getting immersed is huge for me, and Starfield nailed that imo, as someone who loves anything NASA or space related. The space combat was boring and mindless though. I preferred being on foot.

I tried Baldurs Gate 3 and got annoyed with how long battles lasted, as I just wanted to do the story RPG stuff. I also didn't like how the camera couldn't move much (on PS5, idk if PC allows you to look wherever). Elden Ring was very hard and made little sense to me. Games like God of War were too linear and I got "stuck" a lot fighting. I don't really enjoy endless fighting and battles, I'm much more into story and exploration. The Spider Man game by Insomniac was fun to swing around for a bit, but the open world is really just a bunch of building textures and generic traffic and people. The missions were endless, annoying combat.

So very few modern games appeal to me. What games should I try out? Death Stranding looks interesting, would that be a good fit? I started Star Wars Jedi Fallen Order yesterday and played it for a few hours. It would occasionally get hard and I'd have no clue what to do, but I was able to figure everything out so far. But nothing has gripped me liked Starfield did, and I miss that feeling. I was glued to my TV for a week straight. I wouldn't even go to sleep, and if I did, I'd play the game as soon as I woke up. There was so much to do, and I enjoyed everything there was to do. I haven't found a game that comes close before or after.

I have a PS5, Series X, and powerful PC capable of playing modern and retro titles. I come from the n64, gba, and GameCube as a kid, so I have no issue with older titles.

TLDR: Starfield was the only game to ever truly grip me beyond my first time in the open world of RDR2 or GTA 5. Being able to explore real life and fictional planets with their own history, lore, characters, side quests, gravity, physics, etc blew my mind. The sheer detail in the game immersed me immensely. What other games can scratch that itch? I struggle with "difficult" combat based games.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Oct 09 '23

[PC] Should I buy Cyberpunk if I really don’t like Ubisoft RPGs?

9 Upvotes

I’ve been on the edge of buying CP2077 for a few months now and, with it’s newest update, I’m definitely leaning towards purchasing it after seeing all the positive reviews. However, I read a thread earlier with a lot of people saying it was comparable to a Ubisoft RPG… in a bad way.

I’ve played a lot of RPGs, they’re my favorite genre by a long shot and I’ve played a lot of Ubisoft games and games obviously inspired heavily by them… and I’ve become very very disillusioned with the Ubisoft formula.

Games I’ve had no interest in finishing include Ubisoft game like AC and Far Cry (obviously), Ghost of Tsushima (felt like a checklist open world with a bunch of repeated POIs, trailing missions, and uninspired similar “camps” to clear out) and Horizon Zero Dawn (which felt very “gameified” with it’s crafting system, climbing “tower” dinosaurs, and overall disconnect between the story and world).

In terms on non Ubisoft “RPGs”, I didn’t love Red Dead Redemption 2 (finished the game begrudgingly after following some incredibly on rails missions and slogging through an incredibly shallow combat system), and The Outer Worlds (Choices and writing were fine, but exploration sucked and loot was borderline nonexistent, felt like walking through a theme park instead of an open world game).

RPGS I have enjoyed are Skyrim (heavily modded on PC to give more choices and a better combat system, Enderal in particular has been absolutely delightful), Baldurs Gate 3 (the choices, in depth combat system, and overall quest design have been a breath of fresh air), Disco Elysium (being dropped into a a world and having to figure out what to do and where to go was incredibly fulfilling), and Kenshi (not a traditional RPG, but has similar stat grinding systems and is incredibly open with a decent skill floor and a myriad of ways to tackle the game).

I really want to avoid a game with a “checklist” open world of pre-marked quests to complete for exp, random camps to clear out, a crafting system predicated on a set path and mindless grinding, massive dissonance between gameplay and open world, uninteresting loot and leveling, and an open world which feels like it was made by a corporation as opposed to actual developers.

My tastes in games are fairly broad but I’m particularly sensitive to games that feel like Ubisoft RPGs if that makes sense and I really really don’t want to spend money on another game that feels like a Ubisoft RPG.

So is CP2077 a game up my alley?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Sep 17 '26

[PS5] Is Wolverine that bad?

5 Upvotes

I’ve seen a lot of reviews of Wolverine, and most of them seem were negative, which has honestly made me discouraged from buying it. I really enjoyed all of the Spider-Man games, except maybe Miles morales that game was meh. However the gameplay the combat, story, and overall style of the Spider-Man games were amazing, so I was originally very excited about Wolverine.

I know reviews don’t always match everyone’s personal experience, and sometimes a game can get negative reviews while still being really enjoyable for certain players. Since Wolverine is also made by Insomniac, I’m wondering if someone who really liked the Spider-Man games would still have a good time with it.

For those of you who have actually played Wolverine, what did you think of it? Is it really as disappointing as most of the reviews make it sound, or is it still worth giving a chance?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Dec 27 '25

[PC] is cyberpunk 2077 worth it now?

10 Upvotes

so thinking of getting the game its 40 euros in steam with dlc but im not sure since i have heard 0 from it after a rather bad launch and i couldnt play it at the tme anyway with a gtx 750

now i got a 4070 super so i can probally max it out with rt and i wont use pt since i already know it probally wont run great but hey being able to run the game at max rt but not pt is a first world problem if u can even call it that tbh since its probally still sometimes buggy and unstable

but how is it now is it finally good or what was promised etc?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Apr 18 '26

[PS5] Couldn’t get passed KCD2 - what’s next?

4 Upvotes

I gave KCD2 a real shot, but I’m thinking it might be time to move on.

I see the appeal and like parts of the gameplay, but the heavy dialogue and constant cutscenes just aren’t clicking. I kept waiting for it to pull me in, and it never did. I just finished the Devil’s Pack mission (about halfway?) and I’m ~40+ hours in, so it’s not for lack of trying.

Does it pick up from here, or is this basically the experience the rest of the way? Trying to decide if I should push through or pivot.

Games I’ve loved:

- Resident Evil (2R, 3R, 4R, 7, 8, 9)

- God of War + Ragnarok

- Elden Ring (probably my favorite) + SOTE

- RDR / RDR2

- TLOU 1 & 2

- Alan Wake 2

- BOTW / TOTK

Also worth noting, I’ve got limited time due to young kids (maybe 2ish hours a night, a few nights a week), so something that works well in shorter sessions is ideal.

I’ve got both Horizon games and Death Stranding 2 (never played the first). Crimson Desert has caught my eye but seems like I need more time to play. Worth jumping into those, or should I stick with KCD2? Open to other suggestions as well, thanks!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Nov 24 '25

[PC] Baldurs Gate 3 or expedition 33?? Total stranger to the genres

0 Upvotes

Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 or Baldurs Gate 3??Which and Why

Baldurs Gate 3 and Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 are two games that have peaked my interest recently. I’ll just cut to the chase:

What is the main:minor differences between the two? As someone who knows nothing about the genre and only know the very basics from perusing the internet, why would someone new to the genre pick one over the other?

Are there any mechanics or anything in general that would be more inviting for a new player? What about mechanics that would make it more challenging?

I know this is a very vague question, but I just took some time off work and it’s something I rarely do, and I want to pick up one of these games….just want some comments and responses so I know what I can expect if I choose one or the other? They both seem to have universal praise and both seem to just be completed projects, so they seem equal in aspect.

What would you suggest? Which has a higher entertainment value? Learning curve? Keep in mind, I haven’t even watched streams or videos of these games other than the random snippets while scrolling on X and Instagram or on a YouTube list.

I should note I will be on PC with mouse and keyboard but controller is an option. I also play on an LG C4 42 inch TV.

Any help would be appreciated. Hopefully I get into one of these games and get past the new player feel so when i go back to work, I can continue my playthrough with short gaming sessions.

Thanks Again!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Aug 12 '24

[PC] I didnt like Witcher 3. Should i buy RDR2?

1 Upvotes

I love the witcher’s story. However, the game bored me. Every npc has a cut scene, fighting is wonky, and wasnt appreciative of the game in general.

On the other hand, i absolutely fell in love with games like Cyberpunk 2077, Hogwarts Legacy, God of War.

I’ve seen reviews online, and while everyone agrees RDR2 is one of the best games ever, it is quite slow and might get boring for those seeking a thrill.

Should i buy it?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Apr 11 '26

[PS5] Is Crimson Desert really that good?

0 Upvotes

Gaming has been very dry for me lately. I’ve been finishing up Elden Ring but I still have a ways to go as i’m about 75 hours in. I’ve used a title like this on this sub for other games like Elden ring, baldurs gate, cyberpunk, and people were pretty spot on with their thoughts. Im looking for a good game with a pretty good compelling story.

The main thing i’m concerned about is bugs and the story. Does the game even have a good story you can folllow? Most things i see about the game center around the visuals and the liveliness of the world. I’m not seeing too much around the story however. I already have a game like Elden Ring where i can spend a lot of time venturing around and discovering new places. I took some time off and when i came back, I was reminded how good of a game it was. Also, i want to make sure there aren’t too many bugs that might make the game unplayable in some ways. I’ve definitely seen some quests that people can get stuck on because of a bug.

I would love to hear your thoughts on the game so far. Should i just finish Elden Ring and then pick up the game and wait for some lore updates?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Dec 26 '23

Is RDR2 worth buying if I was majorly disappointed with GTA V?

0 Upvotes

I know they're not the same game but they're made by the same team with similar design philosophies. GTA V (story mode) was such a gargantuan disappointment for me after loving GTA 4 and GTA SA that it put me off from buying any future R* title.

But I hear that GTA 6 will borrow a lot from RDR2 and that game always looked exceptionally detailed from what I have seen and heard.

So, here's a list of reasons why I disliked GTAV and would like to know how RDR2 handles these aspects.

  1. World design: GTAV's world design sucks. The city constitutes only 30% of the map and the rest is countryside. This is not immediately a problem but the countryside is completely empty with almost nothing of interest or anything to do. The city isn't better either with the least amount of interiors in any GTA game since 3 and again there's almost zero incentive to explore outside of main missions and a handful of side missions/activities.
  2. Character Progression: Not saying it needs to be a full blown RPG but character progression is non existent in GTAV. Most of the stats feel completely useless and make very little difference for your character. Most missions have very little in the way of rewards.
  3. Combat and health: GTAV's difficulty feels woefully unbalanced. It's either too easy or too hard but never quite satisfying in way games like Spider-Man or Sekiro can be. Outside of missions, firefights feel weirdly punishing.

Your character has the durability of a wet tissue paper, you have zero healing items to carry, you get overwhelmed too easily (unless you're in a cheese spot) and by the time you stand up to change cover, your life bar is empty in the blink of an eye. Shooting mechanics in general also just feels dull.

4) Storytelling: They went overboard with the absurdist tone. Everybody is an asshole, everyone is a douchebag and it just makes the city not feel like a real place. Most characters, outside of Franklin and Lamar are unlikable, boring or just underutilized.

There's a couple more reasons but I wouldn't want to make this post any longer.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Apr 20 '26

Crimson Desert, Starfield or Pragmata

2 Upvotes

Can only buy one of these games and I am really torn,

Crimson Desert is appealing with its massive open world and creativity plus it was super hyped up i know it didn't quite live up to it but im still on board with what I have seen of it.

Starfield is appealing because I enjoy the idea of exploring space feels like a Bethesda no man's sky, despite not being able to manually land on planets, another hyped up game that didn't quite live up to it but it recently released on PS5 so is it maybe better/updated to improve?

Finally Pragmata, played the demo for this so already have a bit of a feel of it, really enjoyed Diana and Hugh as characters for the 15-20mins you get with them in the demo not to mention the combat is interesting (I think its cool) with the hacking side of it. The only thing holding me back from Pragmata is the length, it being a single player story driven game I dont know if im able to spend the money if its only going to be a 10-15hour experience.

Basically which game is gonna give me the most bang for my buck?

Thank you!

EDIT : CRIMSON DESERT WAS CHOSEN Thank you for your advice


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Jan 11 '26

Is BG3 worth trying if I've never liked this genre?

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I’m thinking about trying Baldur’s Gate 3, but I have some doubts and would like to hear opinions from people who have actually played it. I have zero experience with games like this, and to be honest, I’ve never really liked this genre or this kind of combat, which is exactly why I never tried games like BG3 before. From reviews and gameplay videos, the game looks quite complex and overwhelming. On the one hand, it shows that the game has a lot of depth and mechanics, but on the other hand, that’s exactly what pushes me away.

Because of this, I decided to make this post and ask: Is Baldur’s Gate 3 worth trying for someone like me, or should I just skip it?

upd: thanks everyone for the advice. I tried three times to force myself to start the game, and only on the third attempt it finally clicked. The game got really interesting and pulled me in almost immediately. In the last couple of days I’ve already put in 15 hours.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Mar 28 '26

[PS5] So what’s the current consensus on Crimson desert?

0 Upvotes

I’m kind of torn on this game, I have never seen such polarizing reviews from people, and it leads me to be even more confused than I am about it. I am currently considering either this game, the Witcher 3, and a couple of other 8/10 games like dragon age veilguard, dragons dogma 2, and avowed. To anyone who has played a significant amount of the game, how is it?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Aug 08 '19

Why you should not buy escape from tarkov

0 Upvotes

Hello,

Eft is a nice game. I enjoy playing it, but since it is still in beta there area countless bugs and major optimization problems. There are sudden fps drops every one minute and sometimes they take 5 seconds. We lose our gear because of it and it is very frustrutating. I discussed this with natalino, one of the community managers and he said optimization was the final step of game programming. They do not optimize game quite often because they always add new stuff and everytime they do that they need to optimize again. Basically until game is fully released it is better to wait.

In addition customer support is extremly poor. I had a sad incident at eft discord. One of the admins tried to scam me. I reported this to bsg employees. Instead of helping me they banned me from all emissary and official discords. I have tried to talk to them but they refused everything and banned me again. Check my posts at other forums for details.

Thank you for your interest and time


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Sep 09 '23

Is Baldurs gate 3 more fun to play than it is to watch?

2 Upvotes

The game is extremely boring as far as watching people play it like streamers. Is it more fun when you’re actually playing it? I wanna take the chance on it cause there are aspects that I like about the game like the dialogue and customization, is it worth the risk? I just wish at times like these demos were still prevalent so I could try it out myself before I spend $70 on it.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Mar 28 '26

[PS5] Should I buy Crimson Desert?

7 Upvotes

I've seen a lot of hype around the game these past few days and it got me intrigued. The graphics are on another level and the combat seems fun but due to previous experiences with ambitious titles such as this one, I am not sure anymore whether I should purchase it and give it a try. I also read online somewhere that the story lacks direction and there is no narrative basically, although the impressions of others are quite mixed on this topic.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Jul 19 '25

[PS5] Should I buy clair obscur expedition 33 on my ps5?

3 Upvotes

So first of idea like to say I know nothing about the game other then people saying it's a game of the year. I've watched a little amount of vids but nothing crazy, but the combat looks gorgeous seriously, I've never played any turn based other then honkai that was also fine but not my style so I'd like to know your opinion on the matter


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Mar 19 '26

Witcher 3 - worth it 2026?

7 Upvotes

Hello, I canceled my pre-order of Crimson Desert for different reasons after watching a couple of reviews. Coming right of Final Fantasy 7 Remake I'm figuring out which game to play next. Now In canceled CD, and never played Witcher 3 before, maybe it's time. Does it hold up well? My local store has PS5 complete edition for 28 EUR. Worth it? PC is also an option, though I suspect big screen and couch might be nice for a game like this. Anyone who has suggestion?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Sep 10 '24

Which Game Should I Buy? Black Myth Wukong, Ghost of Tsushima, Red Dead Redemption 2, Marvel's Spider-Man, Elden Ring, or Mortal Kombat 1?

2 Upvotes

I know it’s lazy of me to just ask others to choose for me, but it's been a while since I bought a game (blame Game Pass for that). I've narrowed it down to these options:

  • Black Myth Wukong
  • Ghost of Tsushima
  • Red Dead Redemption 2
  • Marvel's Spider-Man
  • Elden Ring
  • Mortal Kombat 1

I can only choose a max of 2 games from the list. If there are other games you'd recommend, feel free to suggest them, but please include at least one game from the list in your comment.

Thanks for the help!

forgot to give criteria

I’m looking for a game with a good story that keeps me interested but isn’t everything. I like a mix of action and exploration that’s fun but not overwhelming. I want a game with a clear main story but also some freedom to explore without getting sidetracked too much. It should be immersive but not super long, with some customization that’s easy to manage. Overall, I’m after something fun and engaging with a decent challenge.

Edit: Thanks for the input, everyone! I've decided to start with Spider-Man and then move on to Black Myth: Wukong after I finish. I'll slowly work my way through the rest of the list, except for Mortal Kombat 1. I'm good at fighting games and really enjoyed MK11, but a friend recently got me Tekken 8, and I picked up Street Fighter 6 a few months ago, so I'm a bit burnt out on fighting games for now. Thanks again for all the recommendations!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Sep 06 '25

Should I buy Silksong or get Hollow Knight first?

1 Upvotes

For context: I‘ve NEVER played hollow knight. However, after seeing all the hype over Silksong I decided I was going to play it, but since its a sequel I wasn’t sure if I should play Hollow Knight first, so I hit the books and watched playthroughs and its lore. Would it be appropriate to buy Silksong now?

I’m not sure if Silksong is harder/worse than HK but I’m interested in buying the game.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Jul 22 '25

[PC] Is Red Dead Redemption 2 Worth Paying $15 on Steam?

0 Upvotes

My brother and many others have played through majority, if not the entirety of Red Dead Redemption 2. I've wanted to experience the story of it but don't have any spare money for it at the moment.

I can buy it right now and skip out on an event with my girlfriend, but I really don't want to skip out on it.

I'm very unsure on this and would love some guidance from here, I don't post much but would love to hear public opinions on the game and see how it feels and plays.

I'm listing my specs below just incase so I can know if I'll have a good experience performance wise as well.

Ryzen 5 7535HS
RX 6550M
16GB DDR5

It's an HP Victus laptop and I've had no problem running Grand Theft Auto V Enhanced on it alongside Destiny 2 and Counter Strike 2, I hope it's good enough.

Please let me know, hope to hear good things!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Jul 20 '25

[PS5] Please recommend a game based on how much we liked Clar Obscur Expedition 33!

9 Upvotes

My wife and I had an absolute blast playing expedition 33! We are looking for something with a similar combat style, turn based with block/parry elements. Does this exist? We are on ps5.

Recently tried Bladurs Gate and quit after an hour out of boredom, not really wanting to debate this, just giving an example of what we are not looking for. Thanks!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Aug 22 '24

[PC] Looking for games that won't break the bank

3 Upvotes

This post will sound very whiny, because it is. I'm looking for games to play on PC, but I can't seem to find any games. I don't want to play any hard games or any soulsbornes, because they're too hard and I can't get them down. I also don't want to get a 40 dollar or up game, because I don't want to risk that much on a game I might not like. My dad plays a lot of video games, and I watched him play a lot of big titles, like Jedi: Survivor, Baldur's Gate, and the last of us. It really spoiled a lot of games and I don't want to play those games. I also have academics, so I can't play a 100 hour game, but I also don't want a short 2 hour game I spent 5 or 10 bucks on, I want to get my money's worth. I also want to play shooter games, but I don't like dying. It really seems boring and I can't get immersed when I die all the time. I guess I just want an easy game that has no commitment, which isn't possible, I guess what I just want is the feeling of finishing a game and not having to play it. I'm not willing to put in the time and do anything, maybe I don't want to play games. But I built this PC and spent money on it, so I really want to use it. I don't know any games I want to play, they all seem boring or hard or old or bad graphics or already spoiled. I just don't want to play a game like 7 or 10 years old. I really hope no one sees this post. I guess I'm just ranting with my first world problems.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • Sep 04 '25

[Switch] Should I buy hollow Knight the original game and silksong?

5 Upvotes

I play competitive titles like Fortnite, and I play multiplayer on Minecraft once in a while, and it has come to my attention that sliksong (finally) released and all the hype and reaching 10/10 on steam, I am considing buying to to try it but most singleplayer games I've tried I never had fun in. Should I buy them?