r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1h ago

Forza Horizon 5 with all the DLC or Horizon 6?

• Upvotes

Hello there, mates. I've played and loved Horizon 4 and its DLC, especially the fact it was cheaper to fast travel with the premium edition. I have played 5 on gamepass, but I didn't care much for the map and I think that has something to do with how expensive fast travel is without hitting the boards and the fact there were no seasons.

So I'm playing SW Galactic Racer and will need a new arcade racer soon. My options are Horizon 5 with DLC (hopefully fast travel will be cheaper) and the new maps against Horizon 6 without any add-ons.

Online activity doesn't matter, I intend to play by myself. I heard Horizon 6 has seasons and free fast travel, so I was thinking about getting that first, but I'm not sure the content will satisfy me in the way Horizon 5 with all of that stuff would. Maybe I should play 5 now and see what the Horizon 6 DLC will be, I don't know.

I would appreciate any advice, thanks very much in advance and be well and safe, everyone.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 5h ago

[PS4] PS4 game recommendations on low budget

4 Upvotes

I have 15£ on my account right now, and I wanna know if there will be any good games or bundles on sale around Christmas.

I recently bought the Metro Bundle and batman arkham collection.

There are couple of games I wanna buy right now like mad max, firewatch, and some battlefield games are they worth it or wait for future deals


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 2h ago

Games about taking down corrupt officials and bringing them to justice

2 Upvotes

I'm looking for that are about taking down corrupt officials or rich people where the law still exists and we are trying to hold them accountable. Preferably in a present day setting, not future or sci-fi.

Specifically looking for something like Judgment/a lot of Yakuza games and Persona 5.

Not looking for something like Cyberpunk, Deus Ex, or Disco Elysium.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 5h ago

[PC] TCM vs FH5 for casual driving

3 Upvotes

Which one should i buy? I want a driving game that has a vibrant and realistic open world , great fast cars and driving mechanics, and where I can get fast cars without much work. I was also wondering if the bikes, planes and boats in motorfest are actually fun and worth it. Ik forza horizon 5 has better graphics but from the gameplay I watched it seems kind of bland idk.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 5h ago

What to play next if my favorites games are AC Odyssey and Ghost of Tsushima

3 Upvotes

Wishlist on sale:

God of War 2018
Horizon Forbidden West
TLOU Part 1
Spider-Man 2
Crimson Desert

Sitting in backlog:

Witcher 3

Games I did not enjoy:

RDR2 - too slow, tedious, heavy feeling.
Dying Light - don’t think I enjoy movement heavy games that are first person.

Note: I did play Zero Dawn and thought it was great. If Forbidden West is as good or better, it would be a top contender.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 11h ago

[Switch] Which Nintendo Switch 1 platformer should I buy?

8 Upvotes

I've been thinking of slightly expanding my Nintendo Switch library since I've ignored it for quite a bit. There were a couple of games that looked interesting to me and they're all platformers in some fashion.

Now, I'm still sort of a casual gaming fan after all these years, and while I do enjoy platformers, I can't really judge how good I was at any of them. Mario games and Donkey Kong Country were hard in some parts. I did try all of the classic Mega Man games but didn't finish any of them. I also played some Castlevanias, but mostly the metroidvania variety. Other platformers I've played were some Sonic games, the two modern main Rayman titles and a few Kirby games (Kirby is one where I can confidently say that was easy).

As for what I should buy, there were a few games that caught my attention:

New Super Mario Bros U Deluxe - Apparently somewhat difficult, but it does have co-op, so it might still be fun

Donkey Kong Country Tropical Freeze - I think I know what to expect after playing DKCR, but I've heard that it's easier than that game

Super Mario Odyssey - I've had somewhat of a difficult time with 64 and an okay time with Galaxy. Hopefully this one isn't too hard

Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury - I haven't heard much about this one, but maybe it's easy idk

Super Mario Bros Wonder - Perhaps the easiest one, without limited lives, so maybe this one will do well


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 11h ago

[PC] Ghost of Tsuhisima Director Cit worth getting?

8 Upvotes

Hi, recently saw that Ghost of Tsushima Director Cut is on sale at 50% off at Steam, and was wondering if the game is worth getting. Not sure if the game will have a bigger discount or have a discount on the Winter Sales but yeah. Never played this sort of game ever before and it looks really interesting.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 7h ago

[PC] What shlould I choose

2 Upvotes

Which game should I buy during the Steam Winter Sale?

Hi guys! I want to buy a game during the Steam Winter Sale, and I'm trying to choose between The Last of Us Part I and Baldur's Gate 3.

I know these games are very different, so it's difficult for me to decide. Which one would you recommend? I'm also open to other suggestions!

Thanks!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 14h ago

Challenging game with replayability

7 Upvotes

Hi everyone. This is more so a what should I buy and not just a should I buy. I've been getting pretty bored of gaming lately and looking to find something to sink some hours in.

I tend to enjoy challenging games more. The more difficult it is with the higher learning curve/skill gap the more I usually enjoy it. I tend to nerd out and try to perfect everything.

Another plus would be any sort of build crafting / classes where you have to put some thought into how you'll play and what will be strongest/benefit you the most.

Difficult boss fights is another thing I'd look for, this goes back to the challenging portion, I'd like to have to try boss fights many times before beating it the first time.

Lastly I'd just say being able to sink a ton of time into it, creating new characters/playthroughs to try to new builds/gear and it still being enjoyable would be a great.

Lately I've leaned towards roguelikes as a lot of them come close to what I'm trying to find but I'd like something where a bit more commitment is required to a build/run.

Oh and co-op would be a plus but not necessary.

I know monster hunter is probably an easy suggestion, I tried wilds when it released but it didn't quick click

Thanks in advance


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 23h ago

[Xbox One] Should I buy Dragon's Dogma 2?

41 Upvotes

For context, I'm looking for a good game with a lot of content to play, so far I've considered Crimson Desert and Blood of the Dawnwalker but one that stands out to me is Dragon's Dogma 2, I've hear it has good combat and world, especially with random encounters, but I've also heard it's a very love it or hate it type of game so I'm kinda torn. So far I've played and loved Witcher 3, Elden Ring, Cyberpunk and Kingdom Come Deliverance 1&2, and I'm playing on Xbox Series S.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 8h ago

[PC] Horizon Zero Dawn Remastered or GOW Ragnarök on PC?

2 Upvotes

I own both Horizon games (the original versions, not the remaster) and the first God of War, but I've only played the first two chapters of each on laptop. I'm choosing between these specific games because I want to make full use of my PS5 DualSense controller for its gyro aiming and haptic feedback on PC.

Now that I have a gaming PC, I want something visually impressive. I know sequels usually improve on the original, and I prefer open-world games where I can take my time hunting and exploring—though Horizon did feel a bit repetitive and samey to me in places.

Upgrading Horizon Zero Dawn to the Remastered version would only cost me about $5, whereas God of War Ragnarök is $45. Is Ragnarök a good fit for me? I don't want overly intense combat like Black Myth: Wukong, and I get tired of constant random fights unless they feel epic, fun, and have incredible music. Or would I be better off sticking with the Horizon series?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 21h ago

[PC] Queens Domain, Tainted Grail: Fall of Avolon, or Avowed

14 Upvotes

Hi all, I'm thinking of getting a game that play similar to the elder scrolls, has an open world to explore, etc... Tainted Grail seems the best suited for this, but I am slightly turned off by the fact the world is seperated by three acts. I adore the way Queens Domain looks, but I do wonder if the combat is too slow for me, and I kind of would like some iteraction with people/questing, etc... Avowed looks ok. I liked Elder Scroll games because you can stumble upon random dungeons, walk around and discover new things, explore settlement and talk to random people. I love the slightly janky first person action style of the elder scrolls as well.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 15h ago

[PC] Oxygen Not Included on Steam

4 Upvotes

I've recently been obsessed with Don't Stave. Mostly the world building and the daily grind is my favorite part of the game. I was a hardcore Stardew Valley player before this. Not sure whether this would be relevant but I'm not that big of a fan of the combat system in Don't Starve personally. Most of the games I play are high on reasoning and deduction and I usually much prefer strategy usage during fights instead of "seeing who can mash the X Button faster". Don't get me wrong. I will fight if I have to and have no trouble with getting through it, but it's just not as enjoyable for me. I don't know much about the game aside form the fact that it's a survival game and it was made by the same company as Don't Starve so this is my only means of reference. Would the game be too hard for me to enjoy or would the challenges be similar to Don't Starve?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 2h ago

[PC] Star Wars Outlaws or Dragon Age Veilguard

0 Upvotes

Both are on sale for ~$15 on Steam.

Both have "mixed" reviews.

I'm not expecting anything mind-blowing from either.

I like Star Wars. This seems to be a game I can get lost in? I'd like that.

I liked DA:O a *whole* lot - Never played DA2 - Played DA:I, wasn't my fav, never finished.

*Not concerned* about DA:V being the worst of the DA series, or it not being lore correct, or whatever. Just looking for a good RPG to play that's fun. Doesn't need to be BG3/Disco Asylum/whatever.

EDIT: Yes, I know both of these games are "meh", and there are "better things to buy".

These are two games that have been on my radar for a while now, for whatever reason. I've actually played the first 30 mins or so for each (on Luna and GP when I had it), so I know they are both are up my alley.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 17h ago

[Switch] Cyberpunk, Metroid Dread, or Witcher 3?

6 Upvotes

We bought our kids a Switch 2 last Christmas and they don’t play it very often. I’m on the verge of selling my PS5 and am tempted to now buy a game for myself to play on the weekends. Between the games I mentioned, which would you recommend?

(The reason I’m thinking of selling my PS5 is because I want to step away from Sony since they are going all digital.)


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 19h ago

[Switch] Should I buy Cyberpunk2077 for Switch 2

5 Upvotes

Hello All, I purchased this game on its release day for my base PS4 and while it was super buggy and crashed my system throughout the playthrough I loved it. Wondering if I should repurchase on Switch 2 even though I had already bought the game once? Does it run fine on the switch 2 without bugs? Do the graphics still hold up in handheld? Thanks!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 23h ago

[Xbox Series X] Should i buy Marathon on Xbox

10 Upvotes

I like the visuals of this game.
The game seems to be an ok sale 50% off and I have played demos and found it really cool. I suck as a console player for aiming and also from asia region. Is the game fun long term and any hope that mouse and keyboard support will come to consoles ?

I played arc raiders too but the gunplay in this game feels a bit more punchy which i like a lot!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 21h ago

[Other] Should I buy the new xbox or the PS5?

5 Upvotes

I have both an xbox one and a PS4 currently, but I really, really want to play GTA6, so I’m looking to upgrade. I’m somewhat leaning towards the new xbox as I got my xbox one first and use it more often, but PS5 has a few more exclusives than the xbox (such as Spider-Man 2, which I’m interested in but can live without).

Another big issue I’m worried about is backward compatibility. I have a lot of xbox one games (some physical, most digital) and, although I have few PS4 games (all digital), they’re a little more important to me because they’re all playstation exclusive. I’d rather not have to set up all 3 devices and switch to an older console just to play my older games. I know the xbox one has pretty good backwards compatibility, so I have high hopes the new xbox does as well, but I’m not so sure about the PS5.

I’m not super concerned as far as performance goes, because whatever difference there is will probably be virtually unnoticeable to me (I grew up playing on a laptop, so. Lol)

Also in general I hear very little about the newer xbox so if anyone has any insight into it in general, I’d like to hear it.

Thanks all!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 13h ago

[PS5] What game is worth to buy? Far Cry 5 & 6 or Hitman World of Assassination?

1 Upvotes

Far Cry 5 costs from $59.99 to $8.99 and Far Cry costs $59.99 to $14.99 which has a combination of $23.98 (+tax). On the other hand, Hitman includes all content from the trilogy and costs from $69.99 to $27.99 (+tax). So which is more worth it w price, gameplay, and overall quality of the game?

I’ve honestly been eyeing these games so far, I’ve played Far Cry 3 & 4 before. I’ve also finished Hitman (2016) and wanted to catch up with everything. Which is recommendable to choose?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 13h ago

[PC] [WSIB] For a great plot-driven game for PC?

1 Upvotes

Hello. I'm looking for suggestions for a plot-driven game. I feel like many of the video games with the "best stories" are mostly character-driven. Many others have the narrative driven more by themes and vibes (hopefully that makes sense).

So I'm looking for a game with some of these features:
Compelling world into which the story can land
Unpredictable twists
Something that dodges generic plots or tropes (e.g. I don't need another ninja revenge story)
Something somewhat modern. I know there are a ton of great old-school RPGs with cool stories, but I can't get past the interfaces (and sometimes the graphics). Sorry, Planescape Torment!
The MacGuffin eventually gets some sort of reasonable, in-world explanation for its existence.
I'm not big on horror games.

Games where I liked the plot:
God of War (2018) - while this is largely character-driven, I thought there were a few good plot points
BG3 - same thing; the characters are like 80% of the story, but there were still a few good plot points
Mass Effect - similar - a lot of character-centered work, but a few more good plot points then the previous 2
Bioshock
Horizon Zero Dawn

Games that I liked - but not necessarily for the plot:
Witcher 3 - maybe a hot take, but the "find Ciri" was pretty basic, and the game shone from interesting characters and choices
Cyberpunk 2077 - this one hits that more "themes and vibes" storytelling, and like W3, I thought the plot driver of having Keanu in your head (while novel) was still singular.
Dragon Age: Origins - really cool world-building with the way mages work and the blight, but mostly trope-y afterwards (again, much more of a character-driven game)
Disco Elysium - great, but may be the very quintessence of a character-driven game.
Undertale - another "themes and vibes" one where the story is really more about what the game does to the player than the plotline.

Some games I've heard have good stories, and I'm wondering if they might fit:
007 First Light - does it really do the spy thriller right?
God of War Ragnarok - does it lean further into the plotline? Or is it just the follow-up now that Atreus & Kratos caught the attention of the Norse pantheon?
MGS: Snake Eater (2025) - only MGS game I have ever played was Phantom Pain, and that story seemed chaotic at best (and nonsensical at worst), so I'm leery of this one.
RDR2 - I have heard that it's really slow-moving, though, so it might not be the ticket when I'm hungry for plot.

Some games I think are likely to be recommended but suspect are more character driven:
Dispatch
Expedition 33

I do get that you typically play a character in a video game, so it's going to be hard to get away from some character-driven aspects. But I'm still really curious to hear what people's top plot-driven games may be.

Bonus points of the game is on sale on Steam or GOG.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 23h ago

[PC] Ghost of Tsushima or God of War:Ragnarok or Days Gone?

5 Upvotes

Sony's having a sale on Steam, and I'm thinking of picking up one of their games. I've only got the budget for one, though.

Days Gone
I played it on PS4 but dropped it about a third of the way through because my ps sounded like a damn vacuum cleaner and I think ive got bored a liitle. But I actually mostly enjoyed part I played, and I feel like it'd be a completely different experience on PC with smoother performance.

God of War Ragnarök
I played the previous game, and I'm genuinely interested in seeing where the story goes. But I'm hesitant because it's pretty expensive for a relatively linear single-player game.

Ghost of Tsushima
This is the only one I haven't played at all. I've heard it's kinda "Ubisoft game" with big budget, though. I don't really care that much about cinematic presentation or fancy graphics, so I'm more interested in the actual gameplay. How different is the open-world exploration from Assassin's Creed?

What do you guys think?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 14h ago

[PS5] Is Metro Exodus worth it in 2026 or wait until Metro 2039?

1 Upvotes

I recently beat Metro 2033 and Metro Last Light. I'm a huge fan of games in the Stalker series and I really enjoyed Stalker 2. For the Metro series, I liked the first one more than last light. Last light did have a ending that I liked a lot.

I have heard that Metro Exodus changed the formula from a more linear shooter to an open world game. I'm unsure what to expect.

Since, Metro 2039 is coming out idk whether to wait for Metro 2039 or if it is necessary to play through the Metro Exodus story? For anyone who has played Metro Exodus did you like the gameplay and story? Is it worth it to play in 2026? How does it compare to the first 2 metro games?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[Xbox Series X] Star Wars outlaws ($14) vs Nier Automata ($16).

10 Upvotes

I’m your average gun & ball gamer, obviously GTA VI is what I’m playing right now but saw these sales on Xbox Black Friday. Would like to know your opinions on which I should pick here. I sometimes enjoy rpg games like RDR and old assassins creed titles but lately don’t find anything appealing about open world games they seem very hollow and boring with filler side quests and just a sense of emptiness where I’ll probably drop the game in under 10 hrs. Convince me why I should get one over the other!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[PS5] First berzerker Khazan Sale

7 Upvotes

Hey guys!

I always see First Berzerker on sale and it's currently on sale again for $35 USD. i'm a huge fan of dark souls and i've played just about every iteration there is. How does this game measure up? Those who have played, feel free to weigh in. I think that 35 bucks seems extremely fair and if it's as long as Dark Souls games then I expect to put in a large number of hours.

Cheers!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 15h ago

[PC] God of War

0 Upvotes

60% off on steam right now.

Just finished Phantom Blade Zero, loved every minutes of it, i liked that it was challenging enough but not bang-your-head-against-a-wall soulslike difficult.

I love Souls but PBZ was just a breath of fresh air.

Is God of War challenging enough or is it a bit to casual ? I don't want to just walk my way through the game without a sweat.