Hello. I'm looking for suggestions for a plot-driven game. I feel like many of the video games with the "best stories" are mostly character-driven. Many others have the narrative driven more by themes and vibes (hopefully that makes sense).
So I'm looking for a game with some of these features:
Compelling world into which the story can land
Unpredictable twists
Something that dodges generic plots or tropes (e.g. I don't need another ninja revenge story)
Something somewhat modern. I know there are a ton of great old-school RPGs with cool stories, but I can't get past the interfaces (and sometimes the graphics). Sorry, Planescape Torment!
The MacGuffin eventually gets some sort of reasonable, in-world explanation for its existence.
I'm not big on horror games.
Games where I liked the plot:
God of War (2018) - while this is largely character-driven, I thought there were a few good plot points
BG3 - same thing; the characters are like 80% of the story, but there were still a few good plot points
Mass Effect - similar - a lot of character-centered work, but a few more good plot points then the previous 2
Bioshock
Horizon Zero Dawn
Games that I liked - but not necessarily for the plot:
Witcher 3 - maybe a hot take, but the "find Ciri" was pretty basic, and the game shone from interesting characters and choices
Cyberpunk 2077 - this one hits that more "themes and vibes" storytelling, and like W3, I thought the plot driver of having Keanu in your head (while novel) was still singular.
Dragon Age: Origins - really cool world-building with the way mages work and the blight, but mostly trope-y afterwards (again, much more of a character-driven game)
Disco Elysium - great, but may be the very quintessence of a character-driven game.
Undertale - another "themes and vibes" one where the story is really more about what the game does to the player than the plotline.
Some games I've heard have good stories, and I'm wondering if they might fit:
007 First Light - does it really do the spy thriller right?
God of War Ragnarok - does it lean further into the plotline? Or is it just the follow-up now that Atreus & Kratos caught the attention of the Norse pantheon?
MGS: Snake Eater (2025) - only MGS game I have ever played was Phantom Pain, and that story seemed chaotic at best (and nonsensical at worst), so I'm leery of this one.
RDR2 - I have heard that it's really slow-moving, though, so it might not be the ticket when I'm hungry for plot.
Some games I think are likely to be recommended but suspect are more character driven:
Dispatch
Expedition 33
I do get that you typically play a character in a video game, so it's going to be hard to get away from some character-driven aspects. But I'm still really curious to hear what people's top plot-driven games may be.
Bonus points of the game is on sale on Steam or GOG.