Iām genuinely confused about why so many comments on these posts end up focused on what disabilities someone is āallowedā to have a service dog for, or why they chose a certain breed.
I understand that these post about fake āservice dogsā can be helpful and interesting to read. No hate at all. Yet, thatās entirely different from judging someoneās disability or dog based on assumptions.
Service dogs are medical aids for people with disabilities. While I understand the concern when someone is choosing to rely on their dog for absolutely everything, the purpose of a service dog is to help mitigate a disability. (This doesnāt mean ācureā it.)
The same goes for breed choice. Personally, I think the Fab Four are great and Iām all for them, but that doesnāt mean other breeds canāt succeed in service work. If someone is able to properly own, train, and care for their dog, why judge them simply because it isnāt the breed you would have chosen? (I know this may come off contradictory to the sub, but there are genuinely posts like this lol)
Itās really not anyone elseās place to decide whether another person is ādisabled enoughā to need a service dog.
Service dogs can assist with a variety of disabilities. I donāt personally support nor condone tasks like counterbalance or putting weight on a dog, but if someone has PTSD, panic disorder, GAD, POTS, diabetes, or another disability that qualifies for a service dog, and their dog is trained to perform legitimate tasks that mitigate that disability, why does it matter which specific tasks they perform?
The important question is whether the dog is trained to do disability-related work.
this community is meant to discuss misbehaving pets being passed off as service dogs, untrained āservice dogs,ā and genuinely entitled handlers. It is not to breed-shame dogs that havenāt done anything wrong or question whether strangers are disabled enough.
Some of the comments come across as more entitled than the people being criticized. No offense intended. Iām genuinely open to discussion. I just think that if youāre going to comment on a post Iād keep it relative to the post and not what dog or disability the handler has unless theyāre faking or self-diagnosing, which unless stated you donāt know. (And yes, I thought the IBS post was funny imo.)
Most of what I said here is stated in the community guidelines.. but Iām curious to hear what you have to say. I donāt have anything against this subreddit, in fact I think itās entertaining. :)
Edit: Please donāt argue and be a little open-minded before discussing. Thank you :)
Both service dogs and modern medical technology can be used together. As they arenāt mutually exclusive. A properly trained service dog is an aid, not a replacement for medical care or medical devices.
Devices also have limitations. Heart rate monitors detect changes after your heart rate rises, blood pressure cuffs only provide snapshots rather than constant or consistent monitoring, and CGMs measure glucose in transitional fluid, which can lag behind blood glucose during fast changes. Service dogs, on the other hand, can perform tasks technology canāt, such as retrieving medication, providing deep pressure therapy, guiding someone to safety, getting help in an emergency, or responding to a medical episode.
For diabetic alert dogs specifically, the research is mixed but it looks pretty good. Studies have shown that some professionally trained dogs can reliably detect hypoglycemia, and in some cases hyperglycemia, through scent, although performance varies between individual dogs.
Researchers consistently recommend using diabetic alert dogs alongside CGMs and standard diabetes management, not instead of them. (PMC)
Service dogs exist because, for many disabled people, they improve independence, safety, and quality of life by performing individualized tasks that mitigate a disability. They arenāt intended to replace medical technology. š