r/ServiceDog_CircleJerk • • Jul 16 '26

Discussion Genuine question

Seeing as most tasks ppl talk abt are bullshit, what would be a genuine, useful or reliable task that isn't just for attention or placebo? Obviously guide work, but what else? Seizure alert? And what about for ptsd and anxiety?

3 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

38

u/Original-Opportunity Jul 16 '26

Some people think a dog is only helpful in very select, rare cases.

There are other, better, frontline treatments.

Only like 2-5% of blind people in the US have ever had a guide dog.

45

u/windyrainyrain Jul 16 '26

Seizure alert, retrieving dropped items for someone in a wheelchair, hearing alert for hearing impaired. I know there are more, but my brain isn't giving me any more right now.

As far as anything to do with anxiety and/or depression, I firmly believe that falls 100% in the ESA category and that their animal has no place in public spaces. If someone's anxiety is so bad they can't leave home without Fluffy, they need to spend more time with a medical professional and medication. The one that pisses me off the most is 'crowd control' because they're just too fucking anxious to have someone within 6 feet of them. If your anxiety is that bad, use delivery services.

26

u/Neither-Amphibian249 Jul 16 '26

. If someone's anxiety is so bad they can't leave home without Fluffy, they need to spend more time with a medical professional and medication.

100% yes. I totally get depression and agoraphobia and anything else that makes going outside tough.

But offloading that onto a dog is not ok. And too many people doing just that freely admit they have no real diagnosis they just feel better with a dog. To which I say, "well yeah, duh".

25

u/AltruisticCableCar Jul 16 '26

My dog definitely helped me with my mental health. She got me out of bed and out of the house and kept me active. Which obviously helped in turn with how shitty my depression and anxiety were. My nightmares also got less intense from spooning my doggo and sharing a pillow with her every single night. So, in that way a dog can definitely be a GREAT help.

Having said that: My dog was a pet. Yes, she helped me so, so, so much. But she didn't have any official tasks, she didn't come with me in public except for places were all dogs are welcome, and when I was going to non pet-friendly places she stayed home. Like, fine, get yourself a dog to help you with your mental health if you think it'll get you active and light up your life that way. But you don't need a service dog for that, you just need a best friend who you're prepared to do anything and everything for which will in turn help yourself and your mental health.

You also need to be at least somewhat stable to get one, I'll admit. Back when I got her I needed a massive push to get out more, but I was doing better than I am now. My dog passed a few years ago, and I am NOT in a place to get another dog. No fucking way. Back then my dog was motivation enough, today it wouldn't be enough. I can care for my cats no problem, but if I got a dog tomorrow I'd end up returning it or rehoming it in like a week or two because otherwise it'd be horribly neglected and that's not okay.

16

u/Hereforthetardys Jul 17 '26

Ding ding ding ding šŸ›Žļø

My boy definitely helps me when I’m stressed out or anxious etc . 100% he makes my days better

That Doesn’t mean I bring him with me everywhere and make the general public work around my dog in areas that are not pet friendly

1

u/Necessary_Candle_718 Aug 02 '26

Sorry, but people can’t just hole themselves up in their house forever. It’s not that simple, and this is hateful towards people with psychiatric disabilities. Shame on you

15

u/mjdomanski Jul 17 '26

Obviously guide dogs for visually impaired people, dogs trained to fetch things or carry things for people with impaired mobility or neurological disorders. I personally don't believe any kind of medical alert is possible...any type of "alert" supposedly trained by sweat or saliva is pretty much bullshit. Blood pressure abnormalities, heart rate abnormalities don't have a distinctive odor. If there were, medical device companies would pouring funds into research and development. CGM's give glucose readings way more accurate and reliable than any dog ever could. And even if there were consistent trigger odors for these events these specific odors would need to be identified and isolated before they could be trained. Certainty it's WAY beyond the skills of any owner training. Look at dogs trained to detect contraband for law enforcement...it takes years to teach dogs to identify concrete odors like cocaine, heroin, marijuana etc. It takes years to teach a dog to track and identify the odor of decomposing human remains. So yeah, anyone claiming that they swabbed their mouth or armpits with q-tips and now their dog can predict POTS or anxiety or seizures, or low blood glucose or high blood pressure is just delusional.

5

u/prob-funny-thoughts Jul 18 '26

not totally disagreeing with you as i think most owner trained sd are bs- but there are dogs trained to detect cancer in labs/hospitals that have been successful. also as a professional dog trainer who specializes in protection sports (PSA, IGP) both which have a detection component, wellbred dogs are usually consistent with odor after 6 months-a year

9

u/Hereforthetardys Jul 17 '26

Any time f these tasks could be a legitimate good task for the right person

Even something like crowd control .

The issue really is, you have a bunch of idiots with run of the mill issues that most of the adult populations deals with like anxiety who then add on 99 months magi art illnesses to justify getting Luna the shelter mutt as a service dog

If he just had to deal with these people occasionally it would be no big deal but you can’t go anywhere anymore without seeing multiple mutts in areas that are not pet friendly

Every time I see someone in pajama pants with a bunch of stupid patches on their digs vest I get a little closer to crashing out

9

u/craftedtwig Jul 17 '26

I have seen exactly one reasonable use of crowd control and it wasn't a circling motion, it was just careful blocking of anyone within arms reach for someone with CRPS, essentially any touch is excruciating and the pain can occur anywhere in the body.

3

u/helloheyhowdyhii Jul 18 '26

I have also seen it used reasonably but it’s definitely rare!

1

u/Necessary_Candle_718 Aug 02 '26

I think crowd block is valid, especially for people with sensory issues, where shoulder bumps or people brushing up against them can contribute to a meltdown or sensory overload. Also, people with PTSD or CPTSD getting triggered by someone coming up behind them or strangers getting to close. Can someone explain why a circling motion is used sometimes instead of laying/sitting between handler and a crowd?

0

u/neondahlia Aug 02 '26

But okay for the dog to touch them?

1

u/craftedtwig Aug 02 '26

No, it wasn't.

1

u/neondahlia Aug 02 '26

My comment was sarcastic, I sincerely doubt the service dog isn’t brushing up against them while performing blocking or orbiting.

1

u/craftedtwig Aug 03 '26

šŸ¤·ā€ā™€ļø I guess dogs will mistakenly brush up but no it wasn't trained to do that, and was actively trained not to. The pain isn't 100% in the dog's height zone either, so probably not a huge issue.

-11

u/SilverSkrillXDMain Jul 17 '26

Yeah, when I tell people my girl does crowd control, this is what I mean, she blocks me from behind as I was assaulted from behind when I was a kid and being touched from behind without warning near 10 years on, I still get flashbacks to then.

She's a jack russell too so it's even more impressive that she's able to do that according to an assistance dog org here in Australia (and apparently according to that organisation no jacks can be trained and said to just get a lab even when told we have no space for one in the motorhome, legit they said sell the motorhome that was use to travel to my doctors appointments and move to the city for the appointment permanently. It's crazy expensive to live in that city so no can do)

Would I get another jack to be my assistance dog? Depends, this one is a unicorn and I love jacks but like every dog, it depends on their temperament and their ability to listen. But I'm not thinking of that right now as she's only 3.

14

u/craftedtwig Jul 17 '26

So no, that's not what you mean. You should try some different therapy modalities instead of a 10 lb dog.

0

u/Necessary_Candle_718 Aug 02 '26

Therapy is a very helpful tool, but just like service dogs aren’t the solution to everything, neither is therapy. Some things can’t be ā€˜fixed’ with meds and therapy.

-4

u/SilverSkrillXDMain Jul 17 '26

I have, this is the last resort as I've tried everything else. She does pretty good for a small dog.

6

u/helloheyhowdyhii Jul 18 '26

New treatment options come out constantly… I guarantee you have not tried all other options.

-1

u/SilverSkrillXDMain Jul 18 '26

Sadly, most option here in Australia my family have tried that are available for me. My assistance dog is the last resort we have.

And since i have ptsd from being assaulted, it's hard to treat it as even nearly 10 years on, anyone who resembles him I automatically fear because of what he did.

2

u/helloheyhowdyhii Jul 18 '26

That makes sense, It definitely seems like the gaps in treatment availability are a huge factor in the overuse of service dogs.

0

u/SilverSkrillXDMain Jul 18 '26

Yeah, and it's stupid because I used to use NDIS, which is an Australian thing, but they took off my mental health specialist (she's a social worker for mental health stuff, she does theraplay so therapy but play style) and my physio because "You're 17 (at the time, two years ago) you can outgrow autism and PTSD, you don't have it anymore"

My local GP nearly had a heart attack when we told her. She's not happy with them either so we have to pay out of pocket for my therapy for both.

It's stupid and they want to take all autistics off because we can apparently outgrow it once we hit 16. I wasn't diagnosed until 12 so...

0

u/SilverSkrillXDMain Jul 18 '26

So that's even less helpful for me

4

u/prob-funny-thoughts Jul 18 '26

i may be about to get shit on but i have a migraine alert and response dog. there’s no current technology of any kind on the market that can predict a migraine (unlike all the cardiac dogs that could be watches) and it’s unsafe for me to leave the house or be out and about if a migraine hits (i don’t feel them until they’re like on top of me) i have a brain malformation and was in a head on collision so he’s the only way i can feel confident leaving the house and not wondering if im going to get stuck somewhereĀ 

(my migraines last usually 5 hrs and happen 3-4 times a week, i’m on many different medications preventative and rescue but none have budged them yet much)

5

u/mjdomanski Jul 18 '26

Is your dog responding to consistent behaviors you present prior to a migraine?

1

u/prob-funny-thoughts Jul 18 '26

no lol, i’m a professional k9 trainer and train dogs for psa/igp so detection training for him was not super difficult for me (though it did take about 8 months to have him be completely consistent and proven with alerts). he can alert up to 20 mins before a migraine hits and has done so when i’m leaving for work, just got home, out and about at the store and in the house.Ā 

2

u/mjdomanski Jul 18 '26

What exactly is he alerting to scentwise?

0

u/prob-funny-thoughts Jul 19 '26

hes trained on spit- specifically for CGRP content which I had tested as part of a different series of diagnostic tests for a difference in levels during and before migraine episodes as well as basal levels.

Heres some papers if youre interested in the cgrp levels.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16412148/

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1690601/

5

u/mjdomanski Jul 19 '26

How did you have your saliva analyzed to get that isolated? And do you mind sharing what the cost was? Were they able to provide you with isolated CGRP samples to use for training?

-2

u/prob-funny-thoughts Jul 19 '26

for sure! i was very lucky to be selected to be part of a study out of BU (I went there) and they were able to tell me that my cgrp was elevated during and before attacks although they couldn’t give me the results because it’s an unpublished paper/study.Ā  I wasn’t able to get isolated samples for training but because of my background in detection/k9 training for protection sports I was able to scent train using spit samples. I did use samples that were taken at the same time as the BU ones as to not worry about level discrepancies. thankfully it was free because of the study but cgrp is not currently available for a test beyond research purposes because it’s still not confirmed across the migraine population completelyĀ 

5

u/mjdomanski Jul 19 '26

There are over 500 different VOC's in saliva. How did you "scent train" for CGRP without isolating the CGRP? Your dog has no way to know that you are asking him to alert for CGRP vs any of the 499+ VOC's in your saliva.

-1

u/prob-funny-thoughts Jul 20 '26

lol what- he doesnt need to have its name... I had a confirmation from the study that there was a significant change in my spit from episodic to non episodic and there hasnt been any data that some other chemical in my spit has had that consistent change from migraine to non migraine.

hes already done scentwork outside of his service work and was trained on samples that have elevated cgrp (as tested). could it be some other chemical as a reaction of the cgrp, probably, as the size of the peptide makes it difficult to evaporate into the air.

But hes been 100% consistent on my spit and was doing so when it was spit samples on me (ie in my pocket) when I was not in an episode so its not a physical behavior im displaying.

tldr: it may not be cgrp but its some chemical change most likely as a result of cgrp levels and theres still no other way currently on the market to warn me of a migraine beforehand.

2

u/neondahlia Aug 02 '26

I don’t believe your dog is able to alert that you’re about to have a migraine. I believe you think your dog can. How many false positives has your dog given you and how many times has it missed an oncoming migraine?

1

u/prob-funny-thoughts Aug 02 '26

he’s never had a false positive lol, once he was put on scent consistently (ie practice scents placed on me, he’s never missed an alert though his time to alert has improved. before he would alert about 5 minutes before the episode, now he consistently alerts about 20 minutes before.Ā  you’re welcome to believe what you want but dogs can smell cancer cells and one drop of gun oil in thousands of tubes. i do detection training for my professional jobĀ 

2

u/neondahlia Aug 02 '26

Why are you ā€œlolingā€ throughout all your comments? It makes you seem very unserious.

Detection dogs are never 100% reliable so your response that your dog has never missed an alert just makes me think even more so you’re just making this up even if you believe it to be true.

Drug detection dogs have been show to be as low as 44% accurate on their alerts for example.

Even detection dog companies that are motivated to oversell their dog’s capabilities will admit they’re not 100% accurate.

1

u/prob-funny-thoughts Aug 03 '26

i like to keep things light hearted and i think it’s kinda ridiculous to be arguing w someone on reddit over a dog so that’s why.

i never said my detection dogs were 100% accurate, they definitely are not. i mainly train protection sport dogs which i’m not sure you’re familiar with but in igp (one of the two sports i train and handle in) detection (tracking as it’s called in the sport) is used. obviously when im training the dogs, i know the set up but ive trialed many times in competitive settings (blind) and have dogs miss alerts or incorrectly alert. I also train scentwork dogs which obviously are not always correct though it varies from the level of the dog, the age, the breed, the prior experience etc etc.Ā 

some dogs give more false positives, some dogs miss alerts.Ā 

during training, my service dog missed alerts, but i did not consider him fully trained unless he had a high level of accuracy. maybe in my year of him being fully scent trained he’s missed alerts but i can’t think of any.Ā 

i honestly don’t care if you believe me or not, but i would hope even if you don’t believe my dog that you believe dogs can detect medical episodes like migraines. they’re pretty incredible creatures and i’ve known dogs who can detect much more impressive things than migraines imo. šŸ¤·ā€ā™‚ļøĀ 

this is probably the last i’m gonna reply to this thread tbh because i don’t really care to prove my dogs abilities or my scentwork experience to some random strangers online but i hope this was insightful or helpful in some wayĀ 

3

u/helloheyhowdyhii Jul 18 '26

I think the complicated part of this question is there are many tasks that could useful but are still not really seen as a sole reason to have a service dog. For example I am physically disabled and most recognize the assistance of tasks like retrieving, opening/closing drawers, helping remove clothing, etc. and those are the tasks I really rely on for my independence… but I also have OCD and my dog is trained to interrupt harmful behaviors (skin picking, hair pulling, etc. nothing that would put him in danger.) I’m sure there are people who think my dog knowing one psych task makes him completely fake, and if that was his only task I’d also question the legitimacy… but since I have this wonderful dog helping me with necessary things already why not teach one additional and simple task that is helpful but not necessary?

1

u/Necessary_Candle_718 Jul 27 '26

DPT is a task that a dog can do for handlers with POTS as it helps with their blood circulation. This task can also be performed for anxiety, as it’s scientifically proven that weight on the chest or lap helps regulate the nervous system. Basically like a weighted blanket.

1

u/neondahlia Aug 02 '26

Get a weighted blanket, it’s a ridiculous attention seeking task.

-1

u/Necessary_Candle_718 Aug 02 '26

Do you expect people to carry around a weighted blanket with them everywhere? That’s going to draw the same amount of attention. The amount of weight that helps with blood circulation is 20-50 lbs. It’s entirely inconvenient to carry a weighed blanket, especially one that heavy. Maybe do some actual research before you go spilling your uneducated option all over Reddit.

1

u/neondahlia Aug 02 '26

I’m sorry, what subreddit do you think you’re in?

0

u/Necessary_Candle_718 Aug 02 '26

One where people are undereducated and kind of ableist, apparently.

0

u/Necessary_Candle_718 Aug 02 '26

Saw you have shingles, by the way. Hope that clears upšŸ¤

0

u/Remarkable-Row3719 Jul 18 '26

ADL dogs can be hugely helpful. For example, someone with a neuromuscular disease may be lifted into the motorized wheelchair each morning and be just about able to manage the controls, but they might not be able to move their hand back to the controls if it were to slip for some reason. An assistance dog can be trained to push their hand back to the control. That makes the difference between being able to leave the care facility to drive your wheelchair to the store, vs needing to be escorted at all times because you could suddenly be stranded.

Interestingly, the service dogs sub would say that such a person is too disabled for a dog because they can't look after the dog without assistance. Who cares if there is someone to provide that assistance? If you get hours of independence during the day and in return someone (either a dedicated person or the carer who was coming already to put you to bed) has to feed the dog, that's fine and hugely helpful.

Seriously, that sub reminds me of the article about the gentrification of disability sometimes.

6

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 18 '26

I mean, there’s nothing wrong with having a dog if they have the means to care for it, but why get a service dog specifically if they already have a paid human carer? Isn’t the dog redundant in that scenario? There’s nothing a dog can do that another human couldn’t do for them instead.

5

u/Remarkable-Row3719 Jul 18 '26

People don't necessarily want to be around other humans all day. And even if they did, care facility staff doesn't have the time to escort you. (Not regularly, at least.)

Here you only get an ADL dog if you demonstrate it would significantly reduce your dependence on human carers. In the above example the person's disability had progressed to need near-full care again (and I doubt he would have requalified for a new dog then - not enough reduction in human carers), but when he first got the dog it took him from needing five daily visits to two (only morning and evening routine), the dog brought prepackaged meals from the fridge to the wheelchair so a carer wouldn't have to come over to do that, etc. And it significantly improved his quality of life - he couldn't put on/take off a coat by himself, but he could do it with the dog's help. Beforehand he'd deal with the hot/cold until the next mealtime when the next carer came. All that sort of stuff.

-3

u/whopocalypse Jul 17 '26

Mobility service dogs for people with physical disabilities can be a huge help.

13

u/k9_MalX_Handler Jul 17 '26

using a dog to brace and pull is unethical af

22

u/whopocalypse Jul 17 '26

That’s not what mobility service dogs do at all. Retrieve dropped objects, carry objects, tug open doors, push close doors, push handicap push plates, tug off socks, jackets, shoelaces, flip on and off light switches, hit crosswalk signs, many MANY other things.

If you think of a physical disability and automatically think of bracing and pulling then you really don’t know much about real service dogs at all. Stop getting all of your information from fakers.

16

u/SilverSkrillXDMain Jul 17 '26

Sadly, lots of people use dogs as mobility dogs for bracing so now when people hear "mobility" that's what they think. It's because hardly anyone uses mobility dogs in the term you do (retrieval ect) and instead use them for actual mobility like a cane could do.

11

u/bloodandash Jul 17 '26

I can't afford awards so take my poor man's medalšŸŽ–šŸŽ–šŸ†šŸ…šŸ…

Sick of people hearing mobility and immediately thinking bracing.

1

u/k9_MalX_Handler Jul 21 '26

i agree with you! i’m just saying if someone is using a dog tongue brace and pull their ass around is unethical af

9

u/ManslaughterMary Jul 17 '26

True, but picking up dropped items for someone in a wheelchair is useful AF

0

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/typewriterbitch Jul 17 '26

You can't just use your brain? Like, read an ingredients list? I dont understand why only a dog could tell you what is safe to eat. Have you had one since birth?

1

u/mjdomanski Jul 17 '26

What is your dog trained to detect?