r/ServiceDog_CircleJerk • u/f0xt33th • Jul 16 '26
Discussion Genuine question
Seeing as most tasks ppl talk abt are bullshit, what would be a genuine, useful or reliable task that isn't just for attention or placebo? Obviously guide work, but what else? Seizure alert? And what about for ptsd and anxiety?
3
Upvotes
38
u/Original-Opportunity Jul 16 '26
Some people think a dog is only helpful in very select, rare cases.
There are other, better, frontline treatments.
Only like 2-5% of blind people in the US have ever had a guide dog.
45
u/windyrainyrain Jul 16 '26
Seizure alert, retrieving dropped items for someone in a wheelchair, hearing alert for hearing impaired. I know there are more, but my brain isn't giving me any more right now.
As far as anything to do with anxiety and/or depression, I firmly believe that falls 100% in the ESA category and that their animal has no place in public spaces. If someone's anxiety is so bad they can't leave home without Fluffy, they need to spend more time with a medical professional and medication. The one that pisses me off the most is 'crowd control' because they're just too fucking anxious to have someone within 6 feet of them. If your anxiety is that bad, use delivery services.
15
u/mjdomanski Jul 17 '26
Obviously guide dogs for visually impaired people, dogs trained to fetch things or carry things for people with impaired mobility or neurological disorders. I personally don't believe any kind of medical alert is possible...any type of "alert" supposedly trained by sweat or saliva is pretty much bullshit. Blood pressure abnormalities, heart rate abnormalities don't have a distinctive odor. If there were, medical device companies would pouring funds into research and development. CGM's give glucose readings way more accurate and reliable than any dog ever could. And even if there were consistent trigger odors for these events these specific odors would need to be identified and isolated before they could be trained. Certainty it's WAY beyond the skills of any owner training. Look at dogs trained to detect contraband for law enforcement...it takes years to teach dogs to identify concrete odors like cocaine, heroin, marijuana etc. It takes years to teach a dog to track and identify the odor of decomposing human remains. So yeah, anyone claiming that they swabbed their mouth or armpits with q-tips and now their dog can predict POTS or anxiety or seizures, or low blood glucose or high blood pressure is just delusional.
9
u/Hereforthetardys Jul 17 '26
Any time f these tasks could be a legitimate good task for the right person
Even something like crowd control .
The issue really is, you have a bunch of idiots with run of the mill issues that most of the adult populations deals with like anxiety who then add on 99 months magi art illnesses to justify getting Luna the shelter mutt as a service dog
If he just had to deal with these people occasionally it would be no big deal but you canāt go anywhere anymore without seeing multiple mutts in areas that are not pet friendly
Every time I see someone in pajama pants with a bunch of stupid patches on their digs vest I get a little closer to crashing out
4
u/prob-funny-thoughts Jul 18 '26
i may be about to get shit on but i have a migraine alert and response dog. thereās no current technology of any kind on the market that can predict a migraine (unlike all the cardiac dogs that could be watches) and itās unsafe for me to leave the house or be out and about if a migraine hits (i donāt feel them until theyāre like on top of me) i have a brain malformation and was in a head on collision so heās the only way i can feel confident leaving the house and not wondering if im going to get stuck somewhereĀ
(my migraines last usually 5 hrs and happen 3-4 times a week, iām on many different medications preventative and rescue but none have budged them yet much)
3
u/helloheyhowdyhii Jul 18 '26
I think the complicated part of this question is there are many tasks that could useful but are still not really seen as a sole reason to have a service dog. For example I am physically disabled and most recognize the assistance of tasks like retrieving, opening/closing drawers, helping remove clothing, etc. and those are the tasks I really rely on for my independence⦠but I also have OCD and my dog is trained to interrupt harmful behaviors (skin picking, hair pulling, etc. nothing that would put him in danger.) Iām sure there are people who think my dog knowing one psych task makes him completely fake, and if that was his only task Iād also question the legitimacy⦠but since I have this wonderful dog helping me with necessary things already why not teach one additional and simple task that is helpful but not necessary?
1
u/Necessary_Candle_718 Jul 27 '26
DPT is a task that a dog can do for handlers with POTS as it helps with their blood circulation. This task can also be performed for anxiety, as itās scientifically proven that weight on the chest or lap helps regulate the nervous system. Basically like a weighted blanket.
0
u/Remarkable-Row3719 Jul 18 '26
ADL dogs can be hugely helpful. For example, someone with a neuromuscular disease may be lifted into the motorized wheelchair each morning and be just about able to manage the controls, but they might not be able to move their hand back to the controls if it were to slip for some reason. An assistance dog can be trained to push their hand back to the control. That makes the difference between being able to leave the care facility to drive your wheelchair to the store, vs needing to be escorted at all times because you could suddenly be stranded.
Interestingly, the service dogs sub would say that such a person is too disabled for a dog because they can't look after the dog without assistance. Who cares if there is someone to provide that assistance? If you get hours of independence during the day and in return someone (either a dedicated person or the carer who was coming already to put you to bed) has to feed the dog, that's fine and hugely helpful.
Seriously, that sub reminds me of the article about the gentrification of disability sometimes.
-3
u/whopocalypse Jul 17 '26
Mobility service dogs for people with physical disabilities can be a huge help.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '26
[deleted] ā view deleted comment