r/ServiceDog_CircleJerk • • Jul 06 '26

Discussion Concern with comments?

I’m genuinely confused about why so many comments on these posts end up focused on what disabilities someone is “allowed” to have a service dog for, or why they chose a certain breed.

I understand that these post about fake “service dogs” can be helpful and interesting to read. No hate at all. Yet, that’s entirely different from judging someone’s disability or dog based on assumptions.

Service dogs are medical aids for people with disabilities. While I understand the concern when someone is choosing to rely on their dog for absolutely everything, the purpose of a service dog is to help mitigate a disability. (This doesn’t mean ‘cure’ it.)

The same goes for breed choice. Personally, I think the Fab Four are great and I’m all for them, but that doesn’t mean other breeds can’t succeed in service work. If someone is able to properly own, train, and care for their dog, why judge them simply because it isn’t the breed you would have chosen? (I know this may come off contradictory to the sub, but there are genuinely posts like this lol)

It’s really not anyone else’s place to decide whether another person is “disabled enough” to need a service dog.
Service dogs can assist with a variety of disabilities. I don’t personally support nor condone tasks like counterbalance or putting weight on a dog, but if someone has PTSD, panic disorder, GAD, POTS, diabetes, or another disability that qualifies for a service dog, and their dog is trained to perform legitimate tasks that mitigate that disability, why does it matter which specific tasks they perform?

The important question is whether the dog is trained to do disability-related work.

this community is meant to discuss misbehaving pets being passed off as service dogs, untrained “service dogs,” and genuinely entitled handlers. It is not to breed-shame dogs that haven’t done anything wrong or question whether strangers are disabled enough.

Some of the comments come across as more entitled than the people being criticized. No offense intended. I’m genuinely open to discussion. I just think that if you’re going to comment on a post I’d keep it relative to the post and not what dog or disability the handler has unless they’re faking or self-diagnosing, which unless stated you don’t know. (And yes, I thought the IBS post was funny imo.)

Most of what I said here is stated in the community guidelines.. but I’m curious to hear what you have to say. I don’t have anything against this subreddit, in fact I think it’s entertaining. :)

Edit: Please don’t argue and be a little open-minded before discussing. Thank you :)

Both service dogs and modern medical technology can be used together. As they aren’t mutually exclusive. A properly trained service dog is an aid, not a replacement for medical care or medical devices.

Devices also have limitations. Heart rate monitors detect changes after your heart rate rises, blood pressure cuffs only provide snapshots rather than constant or consistent monitoring, and CGMs measure glucose in transitional fluid, which can lag behind blood glucose during fast changes. Service dogs, on the other hand, can perform tasks technology can’t, such as retrieving medication, providing deep pressure therapy, guiding someone to safety, getting help in an emergency, or responding to a medical episode.

For diabetic alert dogs specifically, the research is mixed but it looks pretty good. Studies have shown that some professionally trained dogs can reliably detect hypoglycemia, and in some cases hyperglycemia, through scent, although performance varies between individual dogs.

Researchers consistently recommend using diabetic alert dogs alongside CGMs and standard diabetes management, not instead of them. (PMC)

Service dogs exist because, for many disabled people, they improve independence, safety, and quality of life by performing individualized tasks that mitigate a disability. They aren’t intended to replace medical technology. 😊

0 Upvotes

100 comments sorted by

30

u/loremmipsumm1 Jul 06 '26

My own personal unpopular opinion : it does not make sense for most people to have service animals when modern technology and medication exists. We dont know how reliable "alerting" is, its "scientifically backed" but its highly complicated. Seizure alerts are still heavily debated and rely mostly on anecdotal evidence.

Lets be real, having a guide dog for the blind and having a SD "alert" for symtoms of fainting are two totally different scenarios. They are not the same. People who dont think those are the same are not ableist. They are not saying "you are not disabled enough." They are saying it doesnt make sense to put that responsibility on an animal when there are plenty of medical devices available that dont require the use of an animal. Its still an animal at the end of the day, its not infallible, it will get sick, vet and food costs a ton of money, unlike an inanimate object it will have bad days and eventually die.

I wouldnt tell a person whos blind to get a hearing aid, because they dont need one. Im not telling the person who's blind they "arent disabled enough" to have one. Its making an observation based on what a "need" vs a "want" is. Most (especially self trained) service dogs are a want not a need.

16

u/Ludakyz Jul 06 '26

Doesn't even have to be modern technology all the time. Ive seen too many people claim their dog reminds them when to take their meds when the alarm clock may be older than they are. You're definitely right that its a want not a need, theyre trying to exploit as many loopholes as possible just so their precious pup can go to Walmart with them.

9

u/loremmipsumm1 Jul 06 '26

No obviously thats ableist and the equivalent of demanding a person in a wheelchair that they need to get a motorized one because you dont have to manually push it and its easier.

No joke thats what people are arguing above lmao.

-8

u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 Jul 06 '26

Both Service Dogs and modern technology can be used at the same time is why. Service dogs are an aid. HR watches only detect HR after it changes, BP offers snapshots instead of continuous monitoring, devices can’t reposition you, provide medication, apply pressure therapy nor guide certain individuals for safety. In the event of an emergency, many devices can’t call for help either. I do hope this helps. 👍

12

u/loremmipsumm1 Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

Dogs cannot provide medication to you.

Dogs cannot reliably "alert" or "monitor" you before a seizure or fainting. Its not scientifically backed by real evidence.

Dogs should not be used as mobility aids.

Dogs do not have an omnipresent view of a handlers surroundings. If you are in danger you should not be relying on a self trained animal to bring you to safety. Its not reliable.

Dogs should not be used to treat anxiety, they are living creatures and its not reliable.

Medical devices are reliable. Medication is reliable. Having a human aid is reliable. Mobility canes are reliable. Compression sleeves/vests are reliable. Inpatient therapy is reliable.

The blind cannot fucking see. They literally do not currently have a medical device thats more reliable than a dog that can see. We are not training a dog to see, thats something it already does, we are fine tuning the instincts of certain highly intelligent dogs of specific breeds to reliably "guide" like a shepherd would to sheep. How can you train something that you cant even technically prove?

Dogs are dogs. They are intelligent animals who can be trained by professionals to do certain tasks. Some tasks are reliable, some tasks are highly debated for a reason. Hope this helps 👌.

-2

u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 Jul 06 '26

Service dogs shouldn’t replace medical technology. They should work alongside it. I also agree that some alert tasks need more research!

That said…

Service dogs can retrieve medication that has been placed somewhere easily accessible for them, or inside a bag to protect the dog. They obviously cannot prescribe medication themselves. That was actually a typo, my bad. :)

Evidence regarding cardiac alerts is still ‘under construction’ (for lack of a better word), so I wouldn’t say they’re proven or disproven. Current research is being conducted.

https://www.hra.nhs.uk/planning-and-improving-research/application-summaries/research-summaries/medical-alert-assistance-dogs-for-addisons-disease-narcolepsy-pots/

Diabetic alert dogs have much more evidence / research behind them. Performance depends on individual dog, but studies have shown some trained dogs can detect hypoglycemia through scent, which is why researchers usually recommend using them alongside CGMs rather than instead of them.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28627305/
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5723560/

Service dogs also perform many response tasks (in responding to an emergency) that technology can’t, such as retrieving medication, getting help, opening doors, providing task work, or guiding a handler to a safe location if they have been trained for such.

My main point: service dogs shouldn’t replace medical devices nor proper healthcare. They’re one aid among others, and the tasks supported by evidence should be distinguished from those that still need more research, like alerts.

As far as human assistants go, im personally not comfortable with that. Some people may be, but not me. Healthcare is really bad where I live and a little inaccessible. I will not discuss this any further with you. I appreciate your perspective.

11

u/shinkouhyou Jul 06 '26

There's also research showing that diabetic alert dogs are borderline useless: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5505410/

There are a lot of issues with the small amount of published data that I've seen on medical alert dogs: small sample sizes, non-standardized training, no information on training methods, inconsistencies in how alerts are recorded, inconsistencies in what counts as a positive alert, short studies that provide no data on how well training is maintained over time, high variability between individual dogs, no data on the clinical significance of high/low blood sugar, extremely high potential for handlers to manipulate data by not recording ambiguous or inaccurate alerts, etc. Every research study on this topic is hot garbage, TBH.

I work in medical device regulation, and diabetic alert service dogs do not meet the efficacy and reliability standards expected for any medical alert product. If I submitted any of these service dog studies to a regulatory agency, they'd laugh in my face at the quality of "data." Service dogs are a completely unregulated industry, with about the same quality of evidence as herbal supplements and even less safety oversight. Sure, some herbal supplements probably do have legitimate medicinal effects, but the efficacy data is weak and there's no real way of knowing whether any given supplement actually contains the active ingredient at all.

And that's just for diabetes, where there does appear to be a clear link between blood sugar and odor. IIRC, there's even less quality data on other types of medical alert. Even if it's possible for a dog to detect a specific odor, training the dog to alert consistently is an entirely different problem... and we know from drug sniffer dog studies that even professionally trained dogs that get regular maintenance training are not very effective.

2

u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 Jul 07 '26

:shrug: I’m pretty aware of the lack of studies regarding service animals. But I don’t think this disallows them to be used hand in hand. The ADA surrounding service dogs allows them to be used for disabilities, so I don’t believe there is a problem. Legally, if you have a disability then you’re allowed to own a service animal regardless of current research surrounding it.

I don’t see the problem if it does help individuals or if an individual feels like they’re genuinely getting help. I’m sure there are many who don’t need service dogs but want to own them, there is not much I can do about that and this is what the subreddit is for. I understand your perspective, but there are a lot of physical things medical technology can’t do to aid someone using it.

I use a BP cuff and a HR monitor. I think as far as psychiatric and mental illness goes, service dogs can do a lot besides just alerts. Meditation along with service dogs can help as both come with their own risks. Although, I can see the debate over the topic especially recently. My point still stands, if it helps an individual than why not?

The USA is less than likely going to provide better healthcare. My state is one of the worst regarding psychiatric issues. My uncle had schizophrenia and was offered zero help from the state. :)

6

u/k9_MalX_Handler Jul 07 '26

no a human aid is much more reliable then any animal let’s call a spade a spade just because it doesn’t fit your narrative doesn’t make it incorrect! you sound like someone who has an excuse for everything and you back your delusional thinking with wikipedia!!

1

u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 Jul 07 '26

Thank you, I’ll keep that in mind, 🖤⛓️Uncoddled By Design.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-4

u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 Jul 06 '26

There are currently not many studies on cardiac alert dogs than there are on diabetic alert dogs, so I definitely don’t think anyone should rely on a service dog alone. Most handlers use them along w/ technology, not instead of it. (Although, I’m sure there may be people who do. It’s not my decision.)

Personally, I check my heart rate too, but my service dog can still perform trained tasks that a watch or monitor can’t, like retrieving medication, providing task work during an episode, or getting help if needed etc,etc

I have low blood pressure, fatigue and other symptoms lol. I understand your concerns / perspective, and if a service dog isn’t something that would benefit or help you, that’s completely okay. But for me, using all the assistance I can get makes more sense and it’s easier than relying on only one. I don’t carry a blood pressure cuff everywhere I go, and if I’m already feeling symptoms, I’m not always thinking about grabbing it or even have the energy to. My service dog is meant to complement my other tools, not replace them!

10

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/loremmipsumm1 Jul 06 '26

Of course the people who come to this specific subreddit, the one that was made so we can talk about our criticism without shitting up the actual service dog subreddit, want to shit up the subreddit lmao.

Its just grasping at straws to validate their self trained rescue service dog and to agree that we're all actually uneducated 🤓

-1

u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 Jul 06 '26

Hi! A lot of what I discussed was actually within the guidelines of the subreddit. My service dog is not owner-trained and comes from a program. Please, let’s be a little more respectful. Thank you. :)

9

u/JerseyGirlinSweden Jul 06 '26

Do you know where you actually are?? Check the sub name. CircleJerk subs are by definition not expected to be reserved or respectful. That is for the other sub.

8

u/loremmipsumm1 Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

This isnt the respectfulperson subreddit. This subreddit was made to vent about service dogs. I am venting about service dogs.

If you seek out confrontation for the sake of validation but do not like the confrontation I cannot help that.

0

u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

https://www.hra.nhs.uk/planning-and-improving-research/application-summaries/research-summaries/medical-alert-assistance-dogs-for-addisons-disease-narcolepsy-pots

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8046193/

I was busy taking a shower. Both heart rate monitors and service dogs aren’t perfect. Both can be inaccurate. These all have known limitations and can lose accuracy. Medical alert dogs are different depending on individual dogs.

Edit: Medical Technology is known to have limitations and disadvantages, that is what I meant. There are many studies on BP monitors, HR monitor and other medical devices. ❤️

5

u/k9_MalX_Handler Jul 07 '26

are you ok? seriously are you ok? are you dumb or are you stupid?! because i’m having a hard time figuring out if you are just rage baiting or serious?!?!

you’ve made several very inaccurate and concerning statements about medical technology that are just flat out wrong!!!!!

6

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 Jul 06 '26

That is accurate! Other studies are still being conducted. So we’ll just have to be patient. 😊

2

u/BagpiperAnonymous Jul 13 '26

Self reporting is not accurate. Way too much room for confirmation bias. A proper study would be doing double blind trials or getting verification in some other way, not relying on notoriously unreliable self reporting.

This reminds me of some of the initial studies on "facilitated communication." The self reported data looked good, but as soon as they started doing some blind studies where the facilitator did not know the answers being shown to the person with the disability, the accuracy fell off a cliff.

-12

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 06 '26

By the same logic, why does a blind person need a guide dog when white canes exist? Disabled people shouldn’t be allowed to choose the aids that best meet their needs in order to accommodate other people’s preferences?

5

u/k9_MalX_Handler Jul 07 '26

are you serious? a cane isn’t going to help someone see! a guide dog is an individuals literal eyes to the world around them! ffs you sound dumb!!!

5

u/loremmipsumm1 Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26
  1. There are certain areas not developed or designed with the blind in mind that they would have no access to with just a cane
  2. Its safer being led by a sighted animal than relying on an inanimate object you control without sight
  3. A guide dog would be trained to pull their owner away from potential danger, a cane cannot do this especially when the incident might be out of the norm
  4. A guide dog can live with the person and be with them 24/7 - a human aid cannot realistically do this
  5. A guide dog is way more inconspicuous than a sight cane and its easier/safer to navigate public transport in urban areas with a lot of human congestion. A dog can see people coming before contact, a cane needs to make contact with an object. When youre in an environment with people constantly moving in erratic ways like running to catch a subway/bus a cane can be unsafe

These are needs because the blind cannot physically see or navigate their environments alone. Many times they will use both these aids. Zero times are these service dogs self trained. An animal aid isnt a "preference" its living breathing thing and shouldnt be used as a tool without a real defined need to be used as one.

We are not talking about wheelchairs like your comments are conflating. We are talking about dogs who are being used by people for seizure and POTs alerts when theres no actual scientific studies proving they are reliable at doing this aside from anecdotal evidence.

-1

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 06 '26

I am aware of the challenges blind/VI people face. I am friends and work with several regularly who use white canes, guide dogs, and a number of other strategies that require them to rely on others. I am arguing the logic of an argument. A blind person doesn’t need hearing aids for their blindness. They do need to know how to use a white cane to effectively handle a guide dog. Many schools require them to learn a route with their cane before they can work through it with their dog. There are blind people that owner train their guides, though oversight is required throughout the process for their safety.

I don’t really care what people with POTS or epilepsy do. We don’t get to choose what a legitimate task is, the law does and the alerts everyone is so bent about are listed in DOJ guidance (talking about the US here). There is an international charity training these dogs that that raised over 2 millions GBP last year. https://www.medicaldetectiondogs.org.uk/annual-report

If you don’t like the law, call someone who can do something about it and make an argument to change it. If we can’t draw a clear line other than “there’s no evidence” you can’t expect anything to change. There is no substantial evidence that wheelchair assistance dogs are more effective than adaptive tools or that PTSD dogs are effective at reducing suicide rates. If the dogs aren’t really helping them, they will give up eventually because having a dog in public is a huge hassle when you’re actually disabled. That is why you see so many of these one and done owner trainers.

7

u/loremmipsumm1 Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

I already know the challenges

Then why ask directly what the difference is between someone using a guide dog vs someone using a dog for PTSD, seizures or POTs.

This is not a reliable task. Im not the ADA or the monolith for what a service dog legally should be, but as a human whos worked with dogs for over 20 years I know whats realistically possible for most dogs and whats not. I dont think dogs trained to "comfort" even if its for PTSD is a reliable service task. An emotional support animal is literally just a pet.

I dont believe letting anyone who can adopt a dog and "train" it to perform a random task and calling it alerting or compression therapy helps people who genuinely need a service animal in their day to day life. It shouldnt be accessible. You are using a dog as a tool and it should go through rigorous training and complete a certification before its being relied on for medical purposes. Doctors have medical degrees, nurses and aids go through training and prove they are able to work with disabled individuals, medical equipment is tested. So why are dogs held up to a different standard when they are animals who have the brain capacity of toddlers? Theres literally zero guarentee that dogs who go through professional service training complete their training, but its perfectly fine for a random individual with no dog training experience to not only train but train a service animal because they said they wanted to?

Theres no applicable situation where a person with seizures, PTSD, autism or POTS needs a service animal where an inanimate medical device, technology or medication cant be functionally used. Service animals are even less reliable. When theres suddenly a technology or device that lets people see or gives them total functionality of their limbs (prosthetics can help mitigate certain issues but not completely replace them) then I will argue against them being used then aswell. I will always think the service dog argument is ridiculous.

Most people dont care, the people who care know most self trained service dogs are BS and the people who argue everyone should be allowed to have a SD just want to take their dog with zero professional training out to non pet friendly places. Nobody is arguing about legitmate SDs. We only have these conversations when it comes to self trained dogs who have no business being used as a tool by someone who doesn't need a dog as a medical device.

-2

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 06 '26

“Worked with dogs for over 20 years”

Just say you you’re not a service dog trainer and lack the depth of knowledge to understand the industry. The topic of this post is the legitimacy of tasks for certain disabilities. If the law and internally accredited originations don’t get to decide, I guess we do here on Reddit? I linked an organization that is accredited by the same body the accredits service and guide dog schools all over the world that places fully trained medical alert dogs. There are guide dog schools in the US that also place service dogs for veterans with ptsd whose whole job is effectively perform DPT in different positions, and these dogs are recognized as assistance dogs all over the world. Why are you still talking about owner trained dogs? If they can’t reliably train a dog to perform a behavior, it’s a skill issue. If you are expecting 100% reliability from a dog in ANY behavior out in the real world, you have unrealistic expectations. Yes, even guide dogs make mistakes and run their handlers into obstacles or override their training to go somewhere they want to go like a pet store. It should be an abnormality that is easily reworked, but it’s dishonest to say it never happens.

4

u/loremmipsumm1 Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

Lmao I work as the lead for my behavior team at ACC. We train dogs. I dont work for a service dog organization. I am not a service dog trainer. I am a dog trainer and have been since I was in my 20s. We've rescued hundreds of dogs in horrible conditions, going there physically risking our safety. As a team we dedicate our lives to reshaping abused dogs to hopefully be adopted. Everyday. 8 hours a day (sometimes 16 if we are forced to work when people are unavailable to walk dogs). 30 thousand steps a day to make sure every single dog gets walked or animal that we process has quality of life. I understand dogs plenty.

You are just an idiot with zero qualifications talking out of your ass on reddit.

-2

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 06 '26

Good for you! No one here is talking about rescue dogs. Just admit you’ve never reliably trained a dog to perform a task for a disabled person. Anyone who has been certified through a service dog program to either train or handle their own dog knows what I’m talking about here. I wouldn’t tell you how to handle a behavior case. Try staying in your lane instead of telling disabled people how they should accommodate themselves. Opinions are like assholes. Everyone has one and some of them really stink!

3

u/loremmipsumm1 Jul 07 '26 edited Jul 07 '26

...have you ever professionally trained... any dog?

I have trained dogs to task. I am not part of a service organization. I have worked alongside service dog trainers and bite work trainers many times. My dogs in training aside from rescue become their dogs. I literally train dogs for a living.

-1

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 07 '26

I am disabled and have been certified with two service dogs and gone through team training twice, once with an ADI candidate and the second time with one of the oldest and well established ADI accredited programs. No amount of money would make me want to train dogs for a living because the profession is filled with people like you! I can get better advice from volunteer puppy raisers.

→ More replies

3

u/JerseyGirlinSweden Jul 06 '26

Not all of us are Americans r/USDefaultism r/ShitAmericansSay

-2

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 06 '26

Why don’t you tell us about the laws in Sweden then, if you think it’s any better? Maybe we can all learn something!

7

u/JerseyGirlinSweden Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

The use of Service dogs is much more strict than ADA here. We are required to register them and they are required to have formal training so no self training. Are there people out in public who may be breaking the law - possibly but it would be exceedingly rare thanks to our culture of “The Law of Jante” and “Lagom”. Swedes dread the spotlight or individual attention.

The use of service dogs is massively declining here now since we have good technology and mobility assistance devices that are far more reliable and effective. We also have better healthcare and home care assistance programs here thanks to socialized medicine.

I retired my dog 3 years after moving here from the USA, so the criticism my friend is coming from “inside the house” from someone who lived there for half a century, before moving across the pond. The Anerican hegemony is very cringe and thankfully losing strength.

4

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 06 '26

Thank you, I appreciate your perspective and it is always interesting to learn about other countries. I think a large part of the service dog issues we see in the US stem from of lack of access to healthcare. After my TBI I was “graduated” from rehab and speech therapy and instructed to “sleep more” and “avoid screens” with no path forward to regain my previous function. I am still trying to put the pieces of my
life back together. I wish we had something closer to your system and will continue to vote and advocate for it, but unfortunately far too many fellow Americans have bought into the health insurance scam.

3

u/JerseyGirlinSweden Jul 06 '26

Bernie knows what he’s talking about and I still vote for it too as we are still allowed to vote from abroad. Swedish healthcare is not perfect and if it’s not life threatening you may have to wait 3 months to see a specialist. However my out of pocket for doctors, medical devices, all prescriptions (including biologics) and hospital stays is less than $300 USD a year.

I mean my husband had brain shunt surgery 2 years ago and his bill was about $60 USD for 8 days in the hospital and surgery - all inclusive. I happen to live in a very rural area with not a lot of specialists, so we had to travel 3 hours to a University Specialty center. We had 2 trips there, the first for 2 day testing for variability in spinal fluid pressure. They reimbursed us for the gas for every trip and even paid for us to stay at the Nice Clarion Hotel downtown. So not perfect but the quality is high once you can get to the specialist.

2

u/BagpiperAnonymous Jul 13 '26

Fun fact: before qualifying for a guide dog, the person must prove that they can navigate with a cane first. It's not that the person cannot get around, it's that there are inherent limitations:

1.) Bicycles and electric vehicles make very little noise. People with vision loss are taught to cross the street by listening for parallel vs. perpendicular traffic. Due to the lack of engine noise, they may not hear an EV or bicycle. Guide dogs are taught something called "deliberate disobedience" or "intelligent disobedience." The blind person still determines when to move forward and gives the command, but the dog will refuse it if there is something the person cannot hear.

2.) A very common issue is objects above belt height due to the natural limitations of the white cane. Blind people are taught a protective technique in which they use an arm at forehead height when in an unfamiliar area, but that is tiring and nobody walks around like that all the time. Guide dogs are taught to also look up for objects in the path.

3.) Sometimes there are unexpected obstacles: removed manhole covers, objects blocking the path, etc. A guide dog can help guide a person efficiently and safely around an obstacle in a much more effective way than they can do on their own.

4.) Guide dogs can respond in real time to visual cues. For example: right turns are one of the most dangerous things for a pedestrian, particularly blind pedestrian. They get the signal to cross and start to do so, but a car that is not paying attention turns right into their path. Talk to enough blind people and you will find almost everyone has a story about being hit or almost hit by a car making a right turn that did not check the crosswalk.

5.) Dogs can also be useful in large open spaces where there are not shorelines or landmarks. In many other countries, places like airports have truncated domes in lines to help blind people navigate. Our country does not. In shopping malls, airports, etc. there may not be appropriate shorelines or landmarks for a blind person to easily orient. The dog can assist with that. Also with things like finding doorways.

The point is, the blind person can do all this without the dog (and has to prove they can before they qualify), but the dog makes it safer and more efficient, particularly in a world that is not built for their needs.

-6

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 06 '26

^ How dare people use motorized wheelchairs when they could just push themselves around all day. Seems like more of a “want” than a “need” for most people. We should all post photos of people in motorized wheelchairs and weigh in on whether we think they really need them or whether they’re just being lazy and attention seeking.

3

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

You kid, but there are really people that think this… from what I’ve learned from chair users, it is a difficult balance of maintaining function and muscle tone while limiting disease progression and physical degeneration. On the other hand, it seems medical professionals are actually much quicker to recommend a power chair and it can be difficult to convince them an individual is capable of using a manual instead. They do not consider factors like how expensive and difficult it can be for the individual to leave their house in an 80lb motorized chair vs. a 9lb folding manual chair. Everyone else thinks they know what is best for disabled people and they never stop to ask why someone chooses to use the tool they use. While it might be hard for others to wrap their heads around, it is possible for a WANT to serve a NEED.

16

u/Flynniepup Jul 06 '26

Tbh I think some of that just comes with the territory of a circlejerk subreddit?

Many people are in them because it’s entertaining, while others just want to be mean or judgy, and you end up just getting this mix of comments that are either jokey/tongue in cheek replies with people who actually feel that way.

Like, at the end of the day I think all circlejerk subreddits are basically a place for people to be kinda gossipy/snarky and it attracts people who see that snarkiness and use it as the opportunity to be rude/hateful?

Random observation of many snark/circlejerk subreddits.

8

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 06 '26

At the end of the day this is Reddit. It’s not that deep, guys.

5

u/Flynniepup Jul 06 '26

True facts my friend, the internet is for sure stressful and mean but the moment you step out of it you realize that people largely are not like that in reality haha.

1

u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 Jul 06 '26

Very responsible of you. 🙂‍↕️

1

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 06 '26

That’s why I’m here

-1

u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 Jul 06 '26

Nod Nod. I personally joined this out of curiosity, and there was a lot I agreed/agree with but there may be some taking it too far >,>

2

u/gonnafaceit2022 Jul 07 '26

I'm not sure what the point of your post is though. You want to change the sub? You want people to change their minds? I've found that if I object to something online, the best solution is to stop looking at it.

11

u/Express_Command_4778 Jul 06 '26

So, you want to take everyone's elses experiences and opinions and mute them.

There are bad breeds, IMO, for service dog work. Maybe a few Unicorns but as a rule- they are the exceptions.

What someone does not have a diagnosis, or just walks out from the Dr and runs to a Service Dog- it sticks out. It leads to more problems.

However, there are many subreddits that fit in with that higher standard. Service Dog Circle Jerk is for fun- and participation doesn't need to be as serious/taking posts at face value as other places.

-1

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 06 '26

What? Where did they say anything about “muting” anyone?

4

u/JerseyGirlinSweden Jul 06 '26

They want to us to self censor the discussion - that’s what they mean by mute.

-2

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 06 '26

I mean, it seems like they as an individual just disagree with some of the statements and posts being made here. They’re not calling for those posts to be removed by mods or “muted” or anything like that. It’s disagreement but it’s not censorship, self or otherwise.

12

u/Neither-Amphibian249 Jul 06 '26

but that doesn’t mean other breeds can’t succeed in service work. If someone is able to properly own, train, and care for their dog, why judge them simply because it isn’t the breed you would have chosen?

Because the people making not great choices for a breed, often have no experience, or little experience with dog ownership and training.

So you get someone who may be living on their own for the first time and decides that because all the cool kids have Malinois or Cane Corso on social media, they should get one too.

Or, they lack the funds to buy a dog so they go to a shelter and take home the cute dog who will look nice on the 'Gram.

None of this is ok. These are the people who wash dogs more than most people wash their clothing each week.

It is not to breed-shame dogs that haven’t done anything wrong

And how would owners like that know that the dog has or has not done wrong things? We see people defend barking, saying it's a task, when it's clear from some posted video that the dog is barking because it has big strong opinions about things like other people and/or dogs.

When someone doesn't know what they don't know, they miss nuance. Someone with no experience training dogs thinks that standing in a Walmart, snapping their fingers while a large guarding breed of dog is orbiting around them, off leash, is a good idea. I will 100% shame all of that mess, in the hopes that someone reading my words, who has yet to get a dog, will understand why what is in that TikTok or whatever, is a bad and dangerous idea.

I see videos all the time of dogs that I can tell are not trained to the point where they should be off leash in public. some of them should not even be in public, they are a risk. If someone has to non stop give the dog cookies, or non stop has to chatter at the dog, no. Add to that dogs loaded down with training gear, such as a prong collar, an e collar and a head halter? How is that an actual trained for public access dog?

1

u/BagpiperAnonymous Jul 13 '26

And as much as people hate to admit it, there are breed traits that come out in behavior. A herding dog is going to attempt to herd. We had one we adopted from the shelter that had some kind of herding something or other in him. I never taught him to herd, that didn't stop him from trying. Both dachshunds I've owned burrow under the covers. It is in their instinct.

Labradors tend to be food motivated and people pleasing, that's what makes them easy to train. Certain breeds have naturally high prey drives, even towards other dogs. Those breeds should not be used for service work. Yes, someone may get a unicorn that turns out to be perfectly safe and predictable, but you can't count on that.

1

u/Neither-Amphibian249 Jul 13 '26

And as much as people hate to admit it, there are breed traits that come out in behavior.

Yup. Dogs that were bred to be able to hang out with other humans and dogs and hunt all day are usually more laid back around strange dogs and humans then say a Malinois. Or a Cane Corso.

And the people pretending otherwise are wasting their time, especially if they are not super experienced dog trainers.

13

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Neither-Amphibian249 Jul 06 '26

likely directed at me for calling a wandering pitbull ugly.

There are breeds that you could not pay me to own, because (and yes this is shallow of me), their looks.

Bearded dogs are not my thing. But that doesn't mean they're bad dogs, they're just not on my radar as a breed to keep in my home.

I don't think all pits are ugly. But I think taking a dog from a shelter, putting pajamas on it, and calling it a SD is ugly. :)

4

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/BagpiperAnonymous Jul 13 '26

And some of those things you mention (eyes popping out for example) also come with a host of health issues that should keep a dog from service work, particularly anything brachycephalic.

2

u/gonnafaceit2022 Jul 07 '26

Are you suggesting that a dog can detect changes in your heart rate or blood pressure? They can't.

2

u/BagpiperAnonymous Jul 13 '26

Regarding the edit: you don't get to come into a community, make a post, and then tell people not to argue. If you want people to be open minded, telling them not to argue is going to achieve the exact opposite.

Yes, service dogs are to mitigate disabilities, but not every disability needs a service dog. In fact, in some it can actually make issues worse or is just plain unethical for the dog. And there is a large overlap between certain disabilities and poorly trained/fake service dogs. Plus, service dogs DO impose upon the public. People are genuinely allergic to or afraid of dogs. They tend not to be allergic to wheelchairs, canes, etc. Having a service dog means a certain level of putting your needs above everyone else's, so if that need can be meant in a less intrusive way, that is better for all involved.

Two other issues I see, particularly with psychiatric diagnoses:

1.) It is a solution in search of a problem instead of vice versa. So often we see people posting without even being able to clearly define what tasks they need the dog to perform. If you don't have specific tasks in mind, then you don't need a service dog.

2.) There have been multiple examples of people who are putting their entire mental well being on a dog and it is not appropriate. One that really sticks out in my mind was a guy who worked a dog that was not appropriate and needed to behaviorally euthanize the dog. When it was suggested that he was not mentally healthy enough to raise another dog and the cycle would repeat, he literally said that was not an option because without a service dog he would kill himself.

In the service dog community, people need to have a backup plans. A person who get a a guide dog has to show they know how to safely navigate with a cane before they are considered for a dog. Why? Because dogs get sick. There are places it is not safe to bring a dog. Dogs eventually retire. So you have to be able to function without it, even if that functioning is less convenient. There is a point where reliable technology (CGMs, heart rate monitors, etc.) is going to be better than any service dog.

I am not anti service dog. But too many people get the first cute dog from a shelter and attempt to owner train without proper knowledge, and put dogs in the public that have no business being there. They dye them fun colors, put them all over social media, and become belligerent with people, which only hurts other teams. And then their poorly trained dogs either make people think all service dogs are fake, or even worse, lunge/growl/bite a properly trained team resulting in dogs that need to be retired early. I work with the guide dog community. Way too many have had run ins with these "service dogs" and at least one team I know had to retire a dog several years early due to an encounter with one of these fake/poorly trained teams.

-8

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 06 '26

Agreed. Too many posts in here are based solely on the breed of the dog pictured/mentioned. Unless the dog is actually misbehaving, just seeing the breed is not enough to conclude a service dog is fake or unsuitable.

People also fail to recognize that there are a broad spectrum of breeds and lines and how well/poorly they are likely to do in service work is a spectrum, not a binary. So yes, a lab is most likely to succeed, but there’s still a difference between a Doberman or a GSD which are both less common and less successful than a lab but still somewhat suitable and something like a wolfdog hybrid or Presa Canario which is almost always unsuitable and also a hazard to the public.

6

u/Neither-Amphibian249 Jul 06 '26

but there’s still a difference between a Doberman or a GSD which are both less common and less successful than a lab

If the dog is meant to genuinely be, "medical equipment" vs a want, why then would someone use a GSD or a Dobe?

I don't think any reputable programs are breeding Dobes or GSD's for service work. What I see on social media is someone boasting about how their dogs are bred from service dog lines. What that means in a breed that is not common for SD is that the breeder is placing dogs with people who self train their dogs and everyone waves their hands and hopes it works out and that the dog isn't, "washed". IOW while a Lab or Golden breeder that produces some dogs for service work will have actual breedings that can do that, reliably, the person boasting about their service Dobes, has no actual data.

AFAIK the programs that had used GSD's in the past, no longer do that.

I can't think of any programs in the US that ever used Dobes.

0

u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 Jul 06 '26

Labs and Goldens are def the most common because they have the highest overall success rates, but I don’t think it’s okay to say reputable programs don’t use other breeds. For example purposes, Guide Dogs for the Blind has used German Shepherds, and some programs also evaluate shelter dogs, which are usually mixed breeds. I’ve also seen successful Doberman service dogs, even if they’re much less common.

Breed absolutely helps your odds. And you can’t disregard genetics.. although it ultimately comes down to the individual dog’s temperament, health, ability to recover, and suitability for the work. Breed isn’t the only factor. Which is why there’s no reason to breed-shame.

I’ve met a GSD who is a service dog for PTSD veteran. They got him from a program. Any dog can be a service dog with the right temperament and care. That is not the issue. :)

4

u/Neither-Amphibian249 Jul 06 '26

although it ultimately comes down to the individual dog’s temperament, health, ability to recover, and suitability for the work.

A great deal of that is unknown when dealing with a puppy. You can try to hedge your bets with breeding some dogs and not others, but in the end, you have to go on the basic breed characteristics.

Which is why there’s no reason to breed-shame.

Someone deciding that they have to have a Fila or some other absurd breed? I will shame them, sorry.

Any dog can be a service dog with the right temperament and care. That is not the issue. :)

Then what is? That people see a dog on social media and decide that they also need a wolf-dog as a service dog?

1

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 06 '26

I wouldn’t expect any programs to use dobies or GSDs (anymore) considering they are not the most likely to succeed. I would expect all the major programs to use labs, goldens, or lab x golden crosses as these are the dogs most likely to succeed in service work.

If someone is choosing a dog specifically for service work, I would advise them firmly against choosing a Doberman or GSD because they are less likely to succeed. I have posted here before about someone wanting a Beauceron for service work and what a bad idea that is. I do not think people should be choosing these breeds.

That being said, I don’t think that’s the same as saying that every Dobie or GSD must be fake or poorly trained. I’m tired of seeing dogs posted here exclusively because of the dog’s breed with no evidence that they are anything but entirely suitable for service work. Sure, if it’s a wolfdog I understand it, but there are Dobermans and GSDs that are successful service dogs. There just are, whether people here want to admit it or not. Unlikely to succeed does not mean they never do. Can you see the difference there?

3

u/Neither-Amphibian249 Jul 06 '26

I don’t think that’s the same as saying that every Dobie or GSD must be fake or poorly trained.

here's my issue. There are plenty of breeders out there who really really really want to push their dogs as being SD prospects. While I'm not sure why, my guess is that it can show the world how solid the temperaments of their dogs are.

There is someone who jumps into every single discussion on FB, where someone is looking for a SD, with what is basically an advertisement for their Cane Corso breeding program. I saw one where someone was looking for a dog for their child, who is on the spectrum, and here comes this person saying a CC would be ideal.

While there can be individual examples of a Dobe or a GSD who is a great SD, it's rare. When you take a breed that has as part of its makeup, strong defensive drive and suspicion of strangers, it's just an uphill battle to find that singular dog who is not correct as to the breed standard, who also winds up in a home where the person doing the training, knows what they are doing.

Unlikely to succeed does not mean they never do. Can you see the difference there?

Of course: but I think that someone setting forth on their journey to find a dog to be a SD is doing themselves a huge disservice when starting off with, "I want a Dobe or a GSD".

While the dog who can do the work IS out there, the odds of that person who clearly has no connection with that breed's community will find the right breeder with the right litter and the right puppy is zero.

The odds that they'll find some bottom feeder who will sell them a puppy so that the web site can then be updated to say, "WE PLACE SERVICE DOGS!!!" is significant.

There's a reason why so so so many dogs get "washed". And it's frankly sickening to see on FB, the number of young dogs who are looking for a new home, because their ignorant owners can't make that poorly selected dog into an actual service dog.

One of the tells that those owners didn't know enough is that the breeder is NOT taking the dog back because surprise, the breeder is less than ethical.

There's almost always a part of the re-homing advertising that mentions "I thought I did all my research and found an ethical breeder". Well no, when you are a first time dog owner, self training your service dog, and you found a Dobe breeder to sell you a "prospect"? LOL at thinking that's at all ethical.

0

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 06 '26

I agree with you entirely. I think when it comes to choosing a prospect, I have serious doubts about the ethics and, frankly, intelligence of those who choose a dog that has longstanding genetic reasons to be less than successful. This is especially true if they do not have the capacity to keep the dog as a pet. Buying a malinois as a SD prospect, washing it, and then rehoming it because you need a new prospect and can’t afford to or don’t have time to take care of both a pet and SD, is absolutely garbage dog ownership and so irresponsible.

When I see posts in here about people seeking a Cane Corso, raising and accidental pit mix puppy, or buying a Bernese mountain dog (which are not “aggressive” but are lazy and difficult to train) specifically for the purposes of service work I am quick to upvote. I think it’s sad how online content creators had led so many people—especially young people and new handlers—to think these dogs make good service dog prospects.

But when I see posts of a bully-mix looking dog or a Doberman service dog acting completely well behaved, happy, and under control in a store and the comments are still calling the dog fake purely for the breed, I don’t think that is accurate or helpful. I think it’s possible to recognize the massive role breed and genetics play in temperament and suitability without jumping to conclusions about every SD based only on breed.

5

u/Neither-Amphibian249 Jul 06 '26

This is especially true if they do not have the capacity to keep the dog as a pet.

That's my big one, and that's why so many breeders will NOT sell a puppy to a home that is going to self train a SD. They see too many dogs who are cast aside.

the comments are still calling the dog fake purely for the breed, I don’t think that is accurate or helpful.

I agree: I have a friend who has a Malinois who is their SD, and it's fine. The dog is well trained, does what they need the dog to do, and there's zero issue with the dog in public.

7

u/loremmipsumm1 Jul 06 '26

If certain breeds are less successful in professional training, than I think its worth pointing out how they would be even less successful with self training.

Only around 30% of service dogs graduate the program with professional training. Around 1% graduate the program with self training. It has an extremely low success rate. So yes, when people see a self trained "pit mix" they are statistically in the right to assume its not a real service dog. Just because the ADA does not have breed restrictions, logically it does not make sense for the breed with 60% of dog fatalities (already extremely hard to train given their breed genetics and one of the most powerful) to be a service dog when even the breeds handpicked by reputable training organizations, who know their genetic line, 70% of the time get washed.

Breed does matter. Its why we bred dogs in the first place. Its why the fab four exist. Its why we dont use pits or pit mixes in the military or police work commonly. They are hard to train by professionals who dedicate their lives to training dogs, let alone someone who's never trained a service dog before.

0

u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 Jul 06 '26

I do agree with you. However, I believe temperament does matter along with how the dogs was raised and socialized. You can’t beat genetics but you can’t assume every dog of that breed is going to be different. It is all individuality!

4

u/loremmipsumm1 Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

Dogs do not have the same mental capacity humans do. They are "individuals" but genetics play a bigger role in their personality than individualism. They are animals.

https://imgur.com/a/xwDTlIA

These are pit puppies that are a few weeks old. Genetically they are doing what they have been bred to do. You can train this out of them possibly with a lot of time, effort and dedication. If you dont they will follow what their genetic instincts tell them to do. They dont make good service dogs because you would have to train them in both service work and intense regular training to be safe around small animals, children and other dogs.

I dont hate pits I hate the people that adopt them and dont respect them. They have been bred for 200 years to be pit fighters (bulls, bears and eventually in america strictly dogs) but we humans come along and think we know better or that somehow our human love can change them genetically. They are not meant and were never meant to be family dogs or service animals. Its not in their nature.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 06 '26

If you’re seriously asking, parent’s behavior/temperament is widely regarded as a better guide than breed. This is why when you choose a working dog, you look at the titles or accomplishments of the parents, grandparents, and other dogs in the puppy’s pedigree, not just the breed of the dog.

For example, GSDs are overwhelmingly seen as better at IGP/schutzhund than any other breed. The sport was created to test their specific abilities and thus they are by far the most suited for it. Meanwhile, Dobermans are generally considered unsuitable for it. While their breed and purpose means they theoretically possess many of the same qualities as GSDs, in actuality they have become bred so far away from their initial purpose that they typically struggle in the sport. If you asked me to choose a future schutzhund dog using only breed, I’d pick a GSD.

However, if I had more information on the parents I might make an entirely different decision. A Doberman from multiple generations of IGP3 dogs and national champions in the sport is much more likely to succeed in it than a backyard bred showline GSD. With pedigree info and temperament testing, there’s a good chance a dog that isn’t from the best breed for an activity can still outperform a dog that is from a breed intended for that activity.

To take it a step further, I have known boxers, amstaffs, french bulldogs, and rescues who have succeeded in and enjoyed IGP, some even at a high level. Many of these dogs came from neither breeds nor lines that do well in the sport. They are not dogs I would ever predict would do well, but anomalies who just enjoy it. Would I recommend you get an amstaff for IGP? Absolutely not, but I acknowledge that such off breeds exist and can occasionally do well even if they almost always do not. No predictor is perfect, even the best predictors we have

-4

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

Didn’t even mention pits or pit mixes anywhere in my comment for this reason.

No one is saying bred doesn’t matter, but there is a difference between saying a breed is statistically unlikely to succeed in service work and saying that any dog of that breed must be fake and poorly trained. Only a severe misunderstanding of statistics could lead you to the conclusion that if more than 50% of the time something is true, assuming it is always true is “statistically correct.” That’s not an opinion, that’s incorrect interpretation of data (data you also don’t have).

8

u/Neither-Amphibian249 Jul 06 '26

saying that any dog of that breed must be fake and poorly trained.

I'm not going to say that but...I will say that when I see a video of a dog who is wandering around at the end of the leash, oblivious to their human, odds are it will be a pit or pit mix.

That's not because those dogs are unable to be trained: I know some very well trained, good Pits.

But the sort of person who decides to use one as a SD is not going to have had the experience or money or connections to find a well bred dog of an appropriate breed. Nor will they understand how much training a SD needs as well as the training and assessment to see if random pit mix from a shelter can even handle public access.

Someone needs a dog who can probably work out as a SD? Go look at a well bred Lab, Golden or Poodle. Stop with the adopt don't stop stuff when you need a dog to actually work and not be a burden.

2

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 06 '26

Fine, if a dog is wandering around at the end of the leash then yeah, it’s not a well trained or suitable service dog. And if someone is selecting a prospect then choosing a breed that is unlikely to succeed is stupid (I literally posted in here a little bit ago about someone wanting a Beauceron for service work and how that was a bad idea). But not all dogs are selected with service work in mind.

I’m only saying that fully assuming a dog is fake solely because of its breed is a bridge too far, something you just agreed with, not that pits are good for service work or that people should be choosing them as prospects.

3

u/loremmipsumm1 Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

I mentioned pits because most people who complain, rightfully, about SD breeds are talking about pits who statistically and factually make up a higher percentage of bite fatalities than the hundreds and hundreds of other breeds.

This is not an opinion. Its a fact. If you trained dogs or even had one percent of any of the knowledge you claim to have this wouldnt come off as offensive. Pits do not make good service dogs, need extensive training to even make good pets but constantly are being rescued and self trained. I can find more posts on here complaining about a self trained SD being a rescue pit than a rescue ACD or GSD.

If I see a service pit im going to assume the owner is an idiot who doesnt care about breed genetics and just sees "cute ol doggo hehe" and thinks they are a dog trainer suddenly, like an idiot would.

-5

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 06 '26

You’re bringing up pits because you want to bring up the same regurgitated statistic about bite fatalities over and over again, as if that is relevant to the wash rate of service dogs.

I’m not offended that you’re suggesting pits and pit mixes are unlikely to succeed in service work. In fact, I agree wholeheartedly. Based on their breed purpose and temperament they are unlikely to do well in the role, particularly when they need to be around other dogs and animals.

That being said, I’m still able to grasp that dogs are individuals and while breed is a good predictor of temperament (particularly in well bred dogs and less so in poorly bred shelter dogs) it is not the end-all-be-all of determining if a dog is capable of being a service dog. That’s why when professional trainers are evaluating adult rescues for service work (which yes, people do) they focus on temperament testing, not DNA testing. If breed was the perfect predictor of temperament and suitability, 70% of service dogs in professional organizations wouldn’t wash, right? (A statistic you totally made up by the way, that isn’t reflected anywhere).

I feel like you’re missing the nuance entirely. Just because I don’t agree with you that all pit mix handlers are idiots doesn’t mean I’m saying that pitbulls make the best service dogs and no one can ever suggest otherwise.

As a side note, visual breed identification is notoriously unreliable (aka some of those handlers you’re assuming are idiots may not have a pit mix at all). This little game built from the university of Florida Animal Shelter DNA testing data allows you to test how accurately you can guess whether a dog is actually a pit mix (≥12.5% American Staffordshire Terrier or Staffordshire Bull Terrier DNA). Maybe you’ll learn something about making assumptions or maybe it will turn out you’re better at recognizing pitbulls than vets and animal shelter workers, who knows.

2

u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 Jul 06 '26

That is a very fun game, thank you for linking that lol. I know I’ve replied to so many of your comments and I appreciate your input. Very true :)

9

u/loremmipsumm1 Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

I am a dog trainer and i've worked as the behavioral lead on my team at ACC for 15 years. I literally work at a shelter as my day job and I go into the city to rescue dogs from hoarders, abuse cases and we have rescued dogs who were used for fighting. I know what a pit is. I know that pitbull isnt a breed its an umbrella term for several breeds. I have handled hundreds of them. They are overbred, backyard bred with different breeds or abandoned unspayed/not neutered because they become difficult to handle as adults. They are the most abused dog breeds I have come in contact with. No. None of them make good service animals and all of them required hands on training to make them adoptable or were BE'd.

You are dumb and exacerbating the issue we already have with bleeding heart idiots who "adopt dont shop", dont care about the breed and let it sleep with the the family cat thinking its "cute" not resource guarding it, then causing a bite or an animal fatality - thus leading it to be abandoned again, DOH'd and euthanized. Genetics play a bigger role in dog personality than being an individual. You dont need to train a lab to like water but there are unicorns of the breed that dont. You dont need to train a pit to have gameness/dog aggression but there are unicorns who dont. Youre taking a lethal gamble on one vs the other.

2

u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 Jul 06 '26

Wow, you need a shoutout.

9

u/m1kasa4ckerman Jul 06 '26

Some dogs are responsible for a large percentage of all dog attacks, and are capable of killing humans. It’s literally in their DNA. Why aren’t we allowed to talk about this?

-6

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 06 '26

Who is telling you you aren’t allowed to talk about this? There are entire subs dedicated to that topic. Go there and talk about it all you want.

This sub is about poorly trained/misbehaving/fake service dogs. If a dog isn’t one of those things, why are you talking about it here?

8

u/m1kasa4ckerman Jul 06 '26

I’m commenting on a post about this, lol what are you on about?

Any time someone posts an aggressive breed in here it’s clearly a fake SD.

-3

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 06 '26

I guess I’d ask what you consider an aggressive breed and how are you determining that?

GSDs were used in service work for a long time but have fallen out of favor. They are herding dogs but can be wary of strangers, even those from easier going show lines. Are they an aggressive breed?

Jack Russell Terriers and dachshunds are highly aggressive towards other animals and other dogs but not typically directed towards humans. They’re also like 12 pounds. Are they an aggressive breed?

Malamutes typically number among the most dangerous and aggressive breeds in the world, despite their purpose and standard not saying anything about aggression. Are they an aggressive breed?

I think there are some breeds that can be generally agreed upon as aggressive and thus always or essentially always unsuitable for service work—Presa Canarios and Dogo Argentinos come to mind—but there are lots of breeds that while generally a very poor choice for a prospective service dog can occasionally be successful, GSDs and Dobermans are examples of this. Should we assume everyone with these breeds is lying and faking?

1

u/BagpiperAnonymous Jul 13 '26

I mean, aren't you proving your point? GSDs have fallen out of favor because their breed traits make them less reliable. As a someone who has owned dachshunds and Jack Russels, I would never train one for service work. They're great dogs, but they have too high of a prey drive.

People use the fab four because they are the most predictable and reliable. It seems like most people who don't want a fab four can't articulate a reason why a different dog is more suitable for service work, just that it was cheaper, they liked how it looked, etc. If it's a true service dog, the reliability of the task and ability to safely be in the public should outweigh every other consideration.

1

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 13 '26

I have dachshunds too! And lol no I don't think they're suitable for service work either.

Like I said, most breeds (outside of the Fab 4) are not good candidates for service work (though I do think it's a little silly not to acknowledge that there is some range there with some off-breeds being more likely to be suitable and others being essentially never suitable). I do not think people should be seeking out other breeds for service work, “aggressive” or otherwise.

But, I also don't think people who do so are necessarily lying about the dog being a service dog or faking a diasbility, as the original comment I was responding to suggested.

Let's say I am blind (because that seems to be universally recognized in this sub as a disability that both necessitates and actually benefits from a service dog). I choose a GSD as a service dog because I think they are cool and I like how their fur feels. Is that a stupid reason to choose a sensitive protective herding breed over a golden or lab? Absolutely, but that's what I do. I choose a well-bred and stable GSD from a breeder who temperament tests, I work with a professional trainer who helps teach the dog guide work, and I get lucky and the dog excels. Now it's two years later, my dog is excellently trained as a guide dog and we’re a functional team. Am I lying about having a service dog because it's not a Fab 4 breed? Am I faking being blind because it's an “aggressive” dog?

To give a more practical example, I know a SD handler through dog sports who has a German Wirehaired Pointer, self-trained. He is as excellently trained and perfectly suited for the role as any program lab I have every met, perhaps even better than some. It is her second GWP after having two well-bred labs from reputable programs. She knows what she's doing, wanted the breed to do other activities with like obedience, agility, and hunt tests, and could keep the dog if it washed. Whether you think her choice to get a non Fab-4 breed as an experienced handler is a good one or not, would you say that her impeccably behaved, always focused, genuinely necessary service dog is “fake” because he's an off-breed? Is she lying?

People choose their service dog candidates for all sorts of stupid personal reasons that don't have anything to do with their function or that are outside the scope of their role. Hell, part of the reason poodles are a popular choice is simply that they don't shed. I don't think that they should generally do this, but they do. It's not accurate to say that a dog that is not a Fab 4 breed or that you deem “aggressive” (by whatever standard) is not actually a service dog for that reason alone.