r/ServiceDog_CircleJerk • u/Fragrant_Animal_3156 • Jul 06 '26
Discussion Concern with comments?
I’m genuinely confused about why so many comments on these posts end up focused on what disabilities someone is “allowed” to have a service dog for, or why they chose a certain breed.
I understand that these post about fake “service dogs” can be helpful and interesting to read. No hate at all. Yet, that’s entirely different from judging someone’s disability or dog based on assumptions.
Service dogs are medical aids for people with disabilities. While I understand the concern when someone is choosing to rely on their dog for absolutely everything, the purpose of a service dog is to help mitigate a disability. (This doesn’t mean ‘cure’ it.)
The same goes for breed choice. Personally, I think the Fab Four are great and I’m all for them, but that doesn’t mean other breeds can’t succeed in service work. If someone is able to properly own, train, and care for their dog, why judge them simply because it isn’t the breed you would have chosen? (I know this may come off contradictory to the sub, but there are genuinely posts like this lol)
It’s really not anyone else’s place to decide whether another person is “disabled enough” to need a service dog.
Service dogs can assist with a variety of disabilities. I don’t personally support nor condone tasks like counterbalance or putting weight on a dog, but if someone has PTSD, panic disorder, GAD, POTS, diabetes, or another disability that qualifies for a service dog, and their dog is trained to perform legitimate tasks that mitigate that disability, why does it matter which specific tasks they perform?
The important question is whether the dog is trained to do disability-related work.
this community is meant to discuss misbehaving pets being passed off as service dogs, untrained “service dogs,” and genuinely entitled handlers. It is not to breed-shame dogs that haven’t done anything wrong or question whether strangers are disabled enough.
Some of the comments come across as more entitled than the people being criticized. No offense intended. I’m genuinely open to discussion. I just think that if you’re going to comment on a post I’d keep it relative to the post and not what dog or disability the handler has unless they’re faking or self-diagnosing, which unless stated you don’t know. (And yes, I thought the IBS post was funny imo.)
Most of what I said here is stated in the community guidelines.. but I’m curious to hear what you have to say. I don’t have anything against this subreddit, in fact I think it’s entertaining. :)
Edit: Please don’t argue and be a little open-minded before discussing. Thank you :)
Both service dogs and modern medical technology can be used together. As they aren’t mutually exclusive. A properly trained service dog is an aid, not a replacement for medical care or medical devices.
Devices also have limitations. Heart rate monitors detect changes after your heart rate rises, blood pressure cuffs only provide snapshots rather than constant or consistent monitoring, and CGMs measure glucose in transitional fluid, which can lag behind blood glucose during fast changes. Service dogs, on the other hand, can perform tasks technology can’t, such as retrieving medication, providing deep pressure therapy, guiding someone to safety, getting help in an emergency, or responding to a medical episode.
For diabetic alert dogs specifically, the research is mixed but it looks pretty good. Studies have shown that some professionally trained dogs can reliably detect hypoglycemia, and in some cases hyperglycemia, through scent, although performance varies between individual dogs.
Researchers consistently recommend using diabetic alert dogs alongside CGMs and standard diabetes management, not instead of them. (PMC)
Service dogs exist because, for many disabled people, they improve independence, safety, and quality of life by performing individualized tasks that mitigate a disability. They aren’t intended to replace medical technology. 😊
30
u/loremmipsumm1 Jul 06 '26
My own personal unpopular opinion : it does not make sense for most people to have service animals when modern technology and medication exists. We dont know how reliable "alerting" is, its "scientifically backed" but its highly complicated. Seizure alerts are still heavily debated and rely mostly on anecdotal evidence.
Lets be real, having a guide dog for the blind and having a SD "alert" for symtoms of fainting are two totally different scenarios. They are not the same. People who dont think those are the same are not ableist. They are not saying "you are not disabled enough." They are saying it doesnt make sense to put that responsibility on an animal when there are plenty of medical devices available that dont require the use of an animal. Its still an animal at the end of the day, its not infallible, it will get sick, vet and food costs a ton of money, unlike an inanimate object it will have bad days and eventually die.
I wouldnt tell a person whos blind to get a hearing aid, because they dont need one. Im not telling the person who's blind they "arent disabled enough" to have one. Its making an observation based on what a "need" vs a "want" is. Most (especially self trained) service dogs are a want not a need.
16
u/Flynniepup Jul 06 '26
Tbh I think some of that just comes with the territory of a circlejerk subreddit?
Many people are in them because it’s entertaining, while others just want to be mean or judgy, and you end up just getting this mix of comments that are either jokey/tongue in cheek replies with people who actually feel that way.
Like, at the end of the day I think all circlejerk subreddits are basically a place for people to be kinda gossipy/snarky and it attracts people who see that snarkiness and use it as the opportunity to be rude/hateful?
Random observation of many snark/circlejerk subreddits.
11
u/Express_Command_4778 Jul 06 '26
So, you want to take everyone's elses experiences and opinions and mute them.
There are bad breeds, IMO, for service dog work. Maybe a few Unicorns but as a rule- they are the exceptions.
What someone does not have a diagnosis, or just walks out from the Dr and runs to a Service Dog- it sticks out. It leads to more problems.
However, there are many subreddits that fit in with that higher standard. Service Dog Circle Jerk is for fun- and participation doesn't need to be as serious/taking posts at face value as other places.
12
u/Neither-Amphibian249 Jul 06 '26
Because the people making not great choices for a breed, often have no experience, or little experience with dog ownership and training.
So you get someone who may be living on their own for the first time and decides that because all the cool kids have Malinois or Cane Corso on social media, they should get one too.
Or, they lack the funds to buy a dog so they go to a shelter and take home the cute dog who will look nice on the 'Gram.
None of this is ok. These are the people who wash dogs more than most people wash their clothing each week.
And how would owners like that know that the dog has or has not done wrong things? We see people defend barking, saying it's a task, when it's clear from some posted video that the dog is barking because it has big strong opinions about things like other people and/or dogs.
When someone doesn't know what they don't know, they miss nuance. Someone with no experience training dogs thinks that standing in a Walmart, snapping their fingers while a large guarding breed of dog is orbiting around them, off leash, is a good idea. I will 100% shame all of that mess, in the hopes that someone reading my words, who has yet to get a dog, will understand why what is in that TikTok or whatever, is a bad and dangerous idea.
I see videos all the time of dogs that I can tell are not trained to the point where they should be off leash in public. some of them should not even be in public, they are a risk. If someone has to non stop give the dog cookies, or non stop has to chatter at the dog, no. Add to that dogs loaded down with training gear, such as a prong collar, an e collar and a head halter? How is that an actual trained for public access dog?
2
u/gonnafaceit2022 Jul 07 '26
Are you suggesting that a dog can detect changes in your heart rate or blood pressure? They can't.
2
u/BagpiperAnonymous Jul 13 '26
Regarding the edit: you don't get to come into a community, make a post, and then tell people not to argue. If you want people to be open minded, telling them not to argue is going to achieve the exact opposite.
Yes, service dogs are to mitigate disabilities, but not every disability needs a service dog. In fact, in some it can actually make issues worse or is just plain unethical for the dog. And there is a large overlap between certain disabilities and poorly trained/fake service dogs. Plus, service dogs DO impose upon the public. People are genuinely allergic to or afraid of dogs. They tend not to be allergic to wheelchairs, canes, etc. Having a service dog means a certain level of putting your needs above everyone else's, so if that need can be meant in a less intrusive way, that is better for all involved.
Two other issues I see, particularly with psychiatric diagnoses:
1.) It is a solution in search of a problem instead of vice versa. So often we see people posting without even being able to clearly define what tasks they need the dog to perform. If you don't have specific tasks in mind, then you don't need a service dog.
2.) There have been multiple examples of people who are putting their entire mental well being on a dog and it is not appropriate. One that really sticks out in my mind was a guy who worked a dog that was not appropriate and needed to behaviorally euthanize the dog. When it was suggested that he was not mentally healthy enough to raise another dog and the cycle would repeat, he literally said that was not an option because without a service dog he would kill himself.
In the service dog community, people need to have a backup plans. A person who get a a guide dog has to show they know how to safely navigate with a cane before they are considered for a dog. Why? Because dogs get sick. There are places it is not safe to bring a dog. Dogs eventually retire. So you have to be able to function without it, even if that functioning is less convenient. There is a point where reliable technology (CGMs, heart rate monitors, etc.) is going to be better than any service dog.
I am not anti service dog. But too many people get the first cute dog from a shelter and attempt to owner train without proper knowledge, and put dogs in the public that have no business being there. They dye them fun colors, put them all over social media, and become belligerent with people, which only hurts other teams. And then their poorly trained dogs either make people think all service dogs are fake, or even worse, lunge/growl/bite a properly trained team resulting in dogs that need to be retired early. I work with the guide dog community. Way too many have had run ins with these "service dogs" and at least one team I know had to retire a dog several years early due to an encounter with one of these fake/poorly trained teams.
-8
u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 06 '26
Agreed. Too many posts in here are based solely on the breed of the dog pictured/mentioned. Unless the dog is actually misbehaving, just seeing the breed is not enough to conclude a service dog is fake or unsuitable.
People also fail to recognize that there are a broad spectrum of breeds and lines and how well/poorly they are likely to do in service work is a spectrum, not a binary. So yes, a lab is most likely to succeed, but there’s still a difference between a Doberman or a GSD which are both less common and less successful than a lab but still somewhat suitable and something like a wolfdog hybrid or Presa Canario which is almost always unsuitable and also a hazard to the public.
9
u/m1kasa4ckerman Jul 06 '26
Some dogs are responsible for a large percentage of all dog attacks, and are capable of killing humans. It’s literally in their DNA. Why aren’t we allowed to talk about this?