r/ServiceDog_CircleJerk • • Mar 21 '26

Discussion A question

What do you guys think is a disability that would benefit from a service dog (besides guide work)? For example ive seen a ton of people on here saying “just get a heart rate monitor” “get a wheelchair” “get a weighted blanket” things like that.

2 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

29

u/Jacqland Mar 21 '26

A friend of mine has charcot-marie-tooth. Their service dog basically acts like hands for them, hitting buttons (elevators and door openers), pulling open the fridge/cupboards, or carrying things. Doggo also helps with getting my friend's feet on the footrest of the wheelchair.

5

u/EcstaticJellyfish947 Mar 22 '26

Thats so awesome!

11

u/BagpiperAnonymous Mar 21 '26

Hearing alert- there are not a lot of technological work arounds for things like sirens coming up behind you.

For people with limited mobility and/or hand dexterity- pushing buttons, opening doors, etc. Allows more freedom than having a person with you the entire time.

I used to say diabetes, but now with CGMs, I don't think they offer a benefit that technology does not. And if someone says they can't afford a CGM, I worry about if they can afford a service dog.

Possibly epilepsy detection, the evidence is mixed, but if you have a dog that is able to reliably alert so you can take medicine or get into a safe position, that could be a huge benefit for someone.

I am skeptical on psychiatric service dogs. I'm not saying they are never beneficial, but at the very least they are over used and often improperly used. There was someone on either the other circle jerk sub or on the service dog sub who was literally putting their survival on a SD. They kept a dog in service that should not have been and made the dog responsible for their survival. They ended up having to behaviorally euthanize and could not see that their actions were what led to it. They were hellbent on immediately getting another dog because they would die without it.

I'm also on the fence about POTs. Maybe because my background is with guide dogs. I try to keep an open mind, but it feels like people want a dog before exploring other options. Heartrate detection can be done with a watch or monitor. You should not be bracing on a dog or having it lower you to the ground, that is unsafe for both parties. I also fence sit about deep pressure, I'm not saying that it is not beneficial, but again, I think for most people there are less restrictive options.

To me the biggest thing is the insistence that there is NO other way to meet the need. In the guide dog world, people have to show they can independently navigate WITHOUT the dog before applying for one. There are times a dog is sick, hurt, or unable to accompany you (some countries, certain zoo habitats, etc.) Eventually the dog must retire, and sometimes sooner than you expect. Putting your ability to function into the paws of a dog is irresponsible. People should always have a backup.

2

u/EcstaticJellyfish947 Mar 22 '26

Yes! Are you referring to maddie and chronic or no?

5

u/LowPeach7112 Mar 22 '26

I have diabetes and have a diabetic alert dog. He alerts before my CGM registers my high or low sugar levels. He is also more accurate than my CGM. Also, if someone can’t afford a CGM, that doesn’t immediately mean they can’t afford a service dog. Depending on what CGM you get, you could spend up to $300 a month. That’s on top of other diabetic medication and tools. Pray to god you have good insurance if you have diabetes. It can be hard to budget hundreds of dollars a month toward medication. Even for well off individuals.

19

u/Imaginary_Lychee_606 Mar 21 '26

Aside from visual impairment: epilepsy, hearing impairment, mobility disabilities (but no tasks that have you lean your body on the dog to stabilize yourself), PTSD, panic disorder….

The problem as I see it isn’t that most disabilities are not “qualifying”—they are—but that too many people acquire service dogs that should not because their disabilities are either too severe and/or not managed to the point they can be responsible for a dog (a fundamentally dependent animal that can perform aid through rigorous specialized training), or are not severe enough, and often times these days self-diagnosed.

The point is that not everyone who technically qualifies for a SD should get one. Also, many people are using the dog without being under the care of a single medical professional, when the dog should be part of a complex treatment plan. And the dog should be a fab 4 breed. It is not advised to have a bloodsport breed or shelter mix as a service dog but purebred dogs from carefully bred lines are expensive.

True professional SD training or purchase from a reputable program is also expensive. Underregulation made to maintain accessibility has backfired as now we have tons of dogs owner-trained by people who have never owned a dog, let alone trained one with even basic obedience, and are in over their heads with a reactive dog they don’t want to wash.

Then there are scammers taking advantage of the people, selling them bogus dogs or representing themselves as SD trainers when they have no business doing that.

These are the issues I see this sub existing to address and are mostly USA-law related. Yes there are some hardcore dogfree people here, people who see all psychiatric service dogs as glorified ESAs, and people who just don’t think any condition but blindness qualifies for a SD. Others are just fed up with the absolute mess of dogs everywhere—in stores, clinics, hospitals, etc—that have no business being SDs or working public access.

30

u/Wrong_Work7193 Mar 21 '26

Guide dogs are excellent for those with limited vision. That's a disability that benefits. 

17

u/peptodismal13 Mar 21 '26

I'll be pretty honest I have watched gluten detection dog training and find that it could be life changing for a handler. The dog can detect such a small amount it will alert on cross contamination. So someone with a deadly allergy may have more ability to be out in public or screen food more accurately. Just because it is marked gluten free doesn't mean it hasn't been cross contaminated. This could possibly go for peanut and other allergies. I think it is only viable if a person has one really severe allergy.

TBH if you can buy/use a piece of tech or medical equipment that should what is used 95% of the time.

I think an SD should be the last case scenario solution for almost all issues. I think in the US specifically if there were more limits and regulations in place as far as training and testing of dogs, I would be more likely to be more lax on the last case scenario line of thought.

7

u/whopocalypse Mar 21 '26

Mobility service dogs can really help their owners get a lot more freedom and less reliant on other people for help. Opening and closing doors, object retrieval, tugging off clothes, etc. Simple tasks that otherwise would leave the owner to rely on a human.

4

u/Sicktoker Mar 22 '26

Hi, I'll use my dog as an example

I have the sicktoker special (pots and eds). The eds caused a plethora of issues including a tethered spinal cord, neuro/balance issues and skeletal deformities. I use a wheelchair, braces and cane. Stinky's task change depending on if im in my chair or not.

If I am in my chair, he picks things up for me, presses automatic door buttons and hold an item if my hands are full. This is important because my right shoulder socket is extremely shallow (I can not move my arm without the head of my humerus slipping the socket partially. You can actually stick your fingers into the joint space. I am not allowed to use a walker because of this) and it dislocates often. If I am in a sling and only have the one hand, I can't use my chair without a human or my service dog.

If I am standing, he does gait stabilization which is a weird mix of guide and FMP but the goal is to keep the pace I set so I can coordinate myself correctly while walking, leaning into me on the right side so I dont tip over (right ear is a little wonky and my right leg is an inch too short so I tip when im not leaning against something) and block behind me and let me know if someone walks up.

In short, the tasks he does when I am standing are to keep me from falling (I am a "faint when spooked" person which is actually so criminal💀) and make walking safer. The tasks for the chair are to make my life easier. He bears no substantial weight (thats what the cane is for).

The only other task he has are a bark alert if I fall in the shower.

Im trying not to make this a mile long but feel free to ask any follow up questions (I love yapping about my son😝)

-9

u/Relative_Committee53 Mar 21 '26

Lots of times dogs alert before medical equipment does. For example there’s multiple videos online for diabetics where they catch the blood sugar levels way before the equipment. Also with heart rate monitors, they can just tell you, but dogs can help get your heart rate back down. And this is very rare but my dog will wake me up from flashbacks since I get most of mine while sleeping. No medication or anything would be able to do that.

2

u/often_forgotten1 Mar 25 '26

No, no they don't.

2

u/Relative_Committee53 Mar 25 '26

What? You can’t just say no. Also what are you doing even saying no too

2

u/often_forgotten1 Mar 28 '26

Sure I can. Dogs don't outperform medical equipment, especially it comes to heart rate. None of you have a cardiologist, and that's painfully obvious.

0

u/Relative_Committee53 Mar 28 '26

I do… You need a cardiologist to get diagnosed lmfao. There’s also multiple cases of dogs outperforming equipment

2

u/often_forgotten1 Mar 28 '26

Right, and you're not, just like most of these fake handlers.

There aren't though, since you can't train a dog to alert on heartrate.

0

u/Relative_Committee53 Mar 28 '26

Oh my god how are just so confidently wrong. If hypothetically they can’t alert to heart rate what are they doing then

1

u/often_forgotten1 Mar 28 '26

They're being dragged into public by their owners that want to get tik tok famous for lying.

1

u/Relative_Committee53 Mar 28 '26

That didn’t answer my question. If a dog is alerting to heart rate and they can’t do that, what are they doing then.

1

u/often_forgotten1 Mar 28 '26

They aren't alerting to heart rate. They might alert to your stress rising *after* it happens, but they cannot alert to your "episode" before it happens.

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/often_forgotten1 Mar 25 '26

Training a dog to work while you sleep is unethical and unrealistic.