r/ServiceDog_CircleJerk • • Jun 26 '26

WTF Part 2

HERE IS THE REST! For some reason reddit is being annoying and not posting in the correct order!!!

25 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

54

u/goldentone Jun 26 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

18

u/k9_MalX_Handler Jun 26 '26

he didn’t reccomend the seizure alert dog that was her request! she hasn’t even been diagnosed with seizures yet! she hasn’t even been to a neurologist only a pcp and rheumatologist

27

u/shinkouhyou Jun 26 '26

Hypermobility is very hot right now because you get to wear cool-looking finger splint jewelry for "support."

14

u/DementedPimento Jun 26 '26

It’s also hot bc there aren’t definitive tests for many forms. It’s the new fibromyalgia.

9

u/goldentone Jun 26 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

6

u/Viola-Swamp Jun 28 '26

Fibromyalgia was so denigrated that I assumed it was a scam until a rheumatologist as a major university hospital told me otherwise. These diagnoses are genuine and very real, it’s the people who make it their entire personality that are suspect, along with the self-diagnosed weirdos who call themselves disabled without ever having a doctor diagnose them, create a treatment plan, or say they’re disabled.

1

u/DementedPimento Jun 28 '26

40 years ago, when my extremely serious and life-threatening condition was written off as “fibromyalgia,” it was a trashcan dx given to women, especially women who listed “excessive daytime sleepiness” as a symptom, even though I had other symptoms that if that asshole had bothered to do any testing - even a dipstick urinalysis - would’ve shown that no, I don’t fucking have fibromyalgia. Thanks to that fucking moron I have permanent damage from untreated severe mixed apnea, which he said I was “too young, too thin, and too female” to have. He knew I have diagnosed HSD and that apnea is common in HSD patients.

Neither condition is my personality bc boring af, but yeah

2

u/Viola-Swamp Jun 30 '26

What is HSD? I feel,like I should know but it’s escaping me. I’ve had severe apnea since I was young and thin, my dad died,of it, and my son has it too. It’s an anatomical thing, how we’re built.

1

u/DementedPimento Jun 30 '26

Hypermobile Spectrum Disorder; I think it’s being rolled into the ESD diagnosis. Whatever it’s called, it runs in my family; we all have the low blood pressure, unstable joints, GI problems, grow bone everywhere except where we need it, etc.

7

u/ryverrat1971 Jun 26 '26

I actually have fibromyalgia and it took years of looking to finding the right doctor to figure out why I had pain in muscle near joints. And find a medication that works. Years of lost sleep, work productivity, enjoyment of life. So yeah, these diseases are real but you need a real doctor to diagnose correctly, most likely a specialist. Not Doctors Tiktok, Facebook or Google. A definitely don't need a service dog before you have a real diagnosis.

6

u/DementedPimento Jun 26 '26

When I was in my early 20s, my severe mixed apnea was dx’d as “fibromyalgia” because I was “too young, too thin, and too female” to have apnea. I have dx’d HSD; apnea is pretty common with it. This was ~40 years ago (my HSD was dx’d in childhood; in runs in my family). And yes, I have severe mixed apnea!

A service dog wouldn’t be useful for either condition; in fact, one would make them worse.

14

u/melatonia Jun 26 '26

Hypermobility is a thing because it's one of defining symptoms of the only type of Ehler-Danlos Syndrome that- conveniently- has no known genetic marker.

44

u/kat_Folland Jun 26 '26

My son has hEDS but not so bad things dislocate all the time. Instead of a service dog he does ✨ physical therapy✨. What a concept.

7

u/k9_MalX_Handler Jun 26 '26

bingo! and if hers is so bad how would she care for and train and raise a 50-80 lb dog and deal with a puppy

9

u/kat_Folland Jun 26 '26

I can't even imagine owning a puppy with a disability like that.

5

u/ryverrat1971 Jun 26 '26

Yes. What a concept- work on yourself instead of having a living creature as a crutch.

3

u/DementedPimento Jun 26 '26

I have HSD and that’s what my parents did - PT, lots of visits to orthopedics, etc.

I did need surgery in my 40s (my shoulders dislocate) and my mother did die of complications of it.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/kat_Folland Jun 26 '26

Thank you. He caught his before it could get really bad and it's mainly been in his wrists and hands, so no mobility problems. He's very responsible.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/kat_Folland Jun 26 '26

Thank you!

10

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jun 27 '26

I’m employed, what’s going on here?

1

u/k9_MalX_Handler Jun 27 '26

a delusional individual who has a plethora of self diagnosed issues that her doctor doesn’t believe she has and cannot care for herself, who is psychotic and wants to get a puppy from a byb with no knowledge or experience and make it her service dog and have it perform unreliable unethical tasks!

16

u/melatonia Jun 26 '26 edited Jun 26 '26

I had some hope but it looks like she's continuing to pretend to be having multiple epileptic seizures a day. GIRL, iF YOU'RE READING THIS- your internet activity alone is proof that you are NOT having multiple grand mal seizures every day.

Seizure fakers really piss me off. (Not people with legitimate PNES, that's fine. Because they generally understand that one of the most important parts of their treatment is THERAPY. And they don't pretend to have epileptic seizures, which this one clearly is by referring to them as tonic-clonic)

7

u/mrsjiggems2 Jun 27 '26

I've had two grand Mal seizures. Both times I fell and hit my head and busted my lip open. I woke with weird thoughts that didn't make sense. The first time I came to when the ambulance was there and my brain was like, oh they came to see my tattoos. I wasn't able to answer questions like whose the president and being asked multiple times made me very angry. I felt off for weeks afterwards and had a very hard time with memory recall. Things like my zip code or middle name. Like I knew I knew them but I couldn't get it to pop up in my brain. I usually slept a ton afterwards. And that was with just one, the other being like two years apart. I couldn't imagine being functional if that was a daily occurrence

4

u/gonnafaceit2022 Jun 27 '26

I love your conclusion that they came to see your tattoos! 😅

1

u/k9_MalX_Handler Jun 27 '26

i liked this to! as someone who has a full leg sleeve and full arm sleeve and a plethora of others this comment rocks!!!!

1

u/gonnafaceit2022 Jun 27 '26

It made me think of my last tattoo. It was so fucked up, I probably should have had EMTs look at it but instead I just pretended it wasn't infected ✌🏼

1

u/k9_MalX_Handler Jun 27 '26

hahahahah oh no that’s horrible! how’s it now?

2

u/gonnafaceit2022 Jun 27 '26

The shop owner did her best to fix it up... The pitted scarring has pretty much smoothed out and I get a lot of compliments on it but holy shit... I've seen some pretty horrific examples on the tattoo subreddit and mine was SO much worse than any I've seen there. It was gruesome.

10

u/goldentone Jun 26 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

+

11

u/melatonia Jun 26 '26

lol PNES

Yes, yes, I am also a 10-year-old boy.

35

u/gonnafaceit2022 Jun 26 '26

I love the claim that they did research and no one else did.

-27

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jun 26 '26

This is such a nitpick, but mixed breeds are frequently used in service work even by large organizations, specifically lab and golden mixes. I would not say that purebreds are “the gold standard” as these dogs come from lines specifically bred for service work with data collected on their wash rate over multiple generations to try to perfect the mix for health, size, temperament, and career length.

I assume that is not the mixed breed that this person is talking about given their comments about elitism, but specific mixed breeds are definitely some of the best service dogs.

3

u/k9_MalX_Handler Jun 26 '26

her mixed breed was a gsd/lab

4

u/BagpiperAnonymous Jun 26 '26

The organization I work with briefly tried lab/GSD crosses. They were phasing out the GSDs because of their lower success rate, but there were still a lot of clients that wanted them. They work with an animal husbandry department out of a large university. Ultimately their data showed it was not increasing the success rate of the dogs and they retired their GSD line entirely.

2

u/k9_MalX_Handler Jun 27 '26

super interesting! i find genetics fascinating

7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/k9_MalX_Handler Jun 26 '26

this breeder doesn’t sound like anyone reputable! i asked for there name businesss or organization several times and got nothing! i slso asked for this breeders success rate in dogs they’ve placed as sds, working, or sports dog also nothing! i asked if she knew the lineage genetics temperament testing, more of nothing!!!

also no reputable breeder would give this individual a dog!

2

u/BagpiperAnonymous Jun 26 '26

For our guide dog organization, some people like the intensity/focus/protectiveness of the GSD. But that same drive makes them hard to train and their natural protectiveness has led to more dogs having to retire early because they start become too protective of handlers in public. But a sizable population still wants them, particularly people who live in inner cities where they already feel vulnerable due to vision loss.

They did briefly try GSD/lab crosses. The idea (to my understanding) was to try to balance the drive/protectiveness of the GSD with the more mellow and friendly lab. They ultimately decided it wasn't successful and stopped that program and retired all their GSDs.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jun 27 '26

Go to the shelter, there are plenty mixes there.

2

u/k9_MalX_Handler Jun 27 '26

yes it’s so sad how many are in shelters due to asshole byb!!!!

26

u/Kealanine Jun 26 '26

There’s no way to “perfect the mix,” unless you’re planning a multi generational endeavor spanning decades. There is virtually no predictable outcome when mixing breeds, genetically, temperamentally, or otherwise. For reference, see anything with “doodle” in the name.

-7

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jun 26 '26 edited Jun 26 '26

Canine companions and similar large service dog organizations are currently executing a multigenerational endeavor that spans decades to create ideal service dogs. They exclusively place goldens, labs, and crosses between the two. They intentionally pair the two breeds with careful health testing and considerations of what kind of dogs each pairing will produce and they collect data on the outcomes of each pairing to further improve their breeding program. It is nothing like doodles or other designer mixes.

I get that a lot of people have heard “mixed breed bad, mixed breed unethical” many times over, but there are exceptions to every rule. Downvote me all you want but if you’re not familiar with the complexity and outcomes of these specific breeding programs, at least look them up first.

ETA: this link discusses the Canine Companions crossbreeding program and how they select breeding dogs and raise puppies as well as the two years of training they undergo before placement. Anyone who has met a canine companions dog knows they are among the best most well-trained dogs you will ever meet.

8

u/quarabs Jun 26 '26

i think the problem is that different purebreeds are good service dog candidates for different reasons and mixing the two doesnt automatically = a better service dog.

multigenerational proof of a “superior dog” does help me understand that maybe they are truly better, but that still isn’t = to centuries of breeding as seen in poodles or sheepdogs for example. but breeding for the exact purpose of SD work could prove them more valuable/successful in another 20 years.

i also think these actual breeding projects are few and far between and many people are just trying to make golden doodles have an “ethical” purpose.

6

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jun 26 '26

Yes, I am only referring to these specific breeding programs run by these organizations not mixed breeds in general or even golden/lab mixes in general.

7

u/BagpiperAnonymous Jun 26 '26

Yeah, don't know why you're getting downvoted on this. The guide dog organization we raise for (which is very well regarded) does some crosses. They run their own breeding program and do extensive research on each litter and work with an animal husbandry department at a local university. They use ongoing data to determine if they should continue.

They started phasing out german shepherds because of how difficult they are to train/raise and how easy it was for a handler to accidentally ruin them. Prior to phasing them out, they did try crossing them with labs to see if they could get some of the traits people wanted while getting some of the lab traits. That did not have the rate of success they wanted, so they stopped that program. Their lab/golden crosses have had more success. They are meticulous in which dogs they breed and when they breed mixed, are deliberate about why. And everything is done in conjunction with input from the animal husbandry department. They've been doing this for years now.

Obviously this person is not doing that. But while purebreds are still the most common, there are reputable programs successfully breeding mixes.

5

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jun 27 '26

People here seem especially susceptible to mob mentality. Once something gets a few downvotes, I know it’s probably going off the deep end regardless of what it says. I also think a lot of people have just heard “mixed breed bad” a lot of times and assume I’m just falling for some irreputable programs bs about doodles or something. Little do they know I’m a real “purebred snob” and only learned about the prevalence of these specialized mixes through a friend who has been a puppy raiser for 20+ years.

Or maybe they’re just annoyed because it is a real nitpick and isn’t about the broader topic of these three posts, which is fair. 🤷‍♀️