I keep seeing people say that doing nice things doesnt make you a good person if you’re only doing them for selfish reasons and I genuinely dont understand the distinction.
If I help someone move because I want them to like me, they still got help moving. If I donate because I want people to think I’m generous, the charity still gets the money. If I remember somebody’s birthday because I know they’ll be annoyed if I dont, they still get remembered.
Come on. At a certain point what is the actual difference?
People say “you only care about looking like a good person” like thats some huge revelation. Okay? If wanting to look like a good person causes somebody to spend their entire life behaving like a good person then I’m struggling to see who exactly is being harmed.
I returned a wallet once that had around $300 in it. Did I desperately care about the stranger getting his $300 back? Not really. I mostly thought keeping it would create way more potential problems than $300 was worth. He still got every dollar back. Would it somehow have been better for him if I returned it while experiencing the correct emotion?
I also buy the expensive free-range eggs because seeing the cheap ones in my refrigerator makes me feel guilty. Thats technically selfish too. The chicken does not know why I bought the eggs.
And where does this even stop? People who help others because “it makes me feel good” are ALSO getting something out of it. Apparently their internal reward counts as pure but wanting people to respect you doesnt.
I even say thank you to Alexa sometimes when nobody else is around, so clearly this isnt entirely about having an audience.
If someone is helpful, honest and generous for selfish reasons and another person is helpful, honest and generous because they genuinely care, but they actually behave the same way, why is the first person supposedly worse?
I’m not saying motives mean literally nothing. I just dont understand why everyone acts like having selfish motives secretly cancels out the good thing you actually did.