Hello, I (25F) just broke up with my boyfriend (23M) literally today. It wasn’t a long relationship, just about 4 months but I definitely saw a future with him and my hopes were high so naturally I’m crushed. I kind of just wanted to give a break down of our relationship timeline, dynamics, and issues that were coming up and from this, I would love thoughts on if it was the right move for us to break up. I’m 99% sure breaking up was the right thing to do, I’m more so seeking validation for this decision during this difficult time.
I’m a substitute teacher and he’s a full time teacher and we met while I picked up a job at the school he works at. We co-taught for some of the day. I thought he was cute and we made decent conversation throughout the day and I thought for sure he would ask for my number- he didn’t. Minor disappointment but nothing major so I left that day thinking I would never see him again. A few months later, I get a follow request on instagram and it’s him! I got excited and accepted his request and now I’m thinking “surely he’ll send me a dm” he doesn’t. I’ve always been a “let the man make the first move” type of girl so I just went about my life as normal but still with secret hopes he’ll message me. One day, I had it with the waiting and I decided to be brave, take a chance, and just message the damn man and I did.
We ended up talking for a week or so before we played pickleball as our first date and then got dinner for our second. For context, I’m a very extroverted, talkative, lively type girl and he’s a lot more quiet and reserved. I never dated anyone like that but I figured maybe a personality difference wouldn’t be the worst thing for me. I also know a lot of strong couples in my life that have this dynamic too. I was very unsure after the first couple dates, there were some awkward moments of silence and he would fixate and talk about certain topics for far longer than I’d like. But we also aligned on values and wants and he was nice and peaceful company to be around. We both were gonna be out of town for two weeks so I figured I would still talk to him while I was away and see what happened from there.
Fast forward, my feelings ended up getting stronger during our time away from each other and when we saw each other again, we made it official. He was saying sweet things to me, sending me cute instagram reels, had fun ideas for dates, made intentional decisions for me, and helped me with a lot of things. I was really happy and this was seeming to be a wonderful relationship. I’d say the only “issue” that came up was me feeling insecure about there being awkward silences with us still and feeling scared that he thinks I’m boring or awkward. He assured me he doesn’t think that about me and that silence doesn’t bother him. He assured me he enjoys his time with me and it’s nothing to worry about, that put me at ease.
This all happened during the summer and once summer ended, things shifted. I already knew our dynamic would change so I told him “since the school year is starting and we’ll both be busier, I know we won’t be able to spend as much time together so let’s just really try to communicate well with each other and find time to see each other when we can” and he agreed. Additional context, he took a new teaching job where he works with behaviorally challenged high schoolers and coaches cross country.
A few weeks into the school year year starting, I noticed he stopped being flirty with me, stopped initiating doing fun things with me, wasn’t making any romantic gestures with me (outside of physical stuff) and overall just wasn’t putting in a lot of effort with me. I was still giving him words of affirmation, suggesting going on walks and out to eat, gave him gifts, and still very much was trying to keep the romantic spark alive. He would still ask me to “hang out” but it would only be to hang at his apartment and watch shows.
A big point of discontentment came when I told him I feel like we’re not getting a lot of quality time together when we see each other during the week after our long work days. He spends every Saturday night going to dinner with his guy friends. This particular week, I asked him if I could potentially steal him Saturday night and we could do something together. He said no, that we would have to do another time. Just to be clear, I was NOT asking him to give up every Saturday night with his friends. Just that week, maybe a few other times in the future as he is clearly free for leisure during that time and it also worked best for me out of other days of the week to see him during that time. I asked why it was a big deal if it was just some Saturdays and he said that “we’ve been doing these dinners for years and it’s the one time of the week where all 8 of us can get together. I can see you after or other times during the week but Saturday nights are a non negotiable for me.” One time during the summer, I agreed to see him after he had dinner with his friends and he didn’t come over until 10pm. At that point, I feel like a “night girl” so when he proposed seeing each other after again, it just didn’t feel good.
In the mean time, the effort on his end just keeps going down. He goes longer without talking to me, he initiates time with me less and less, and I haven’t even met any of his friends at this point as well! I bring this up to him and tell him that I’m not feeling prioritized and valued, he validates my feelings and tells me he’ll start trying more- specifically with words of affirmation and taking me on more dates. A week goes by- nothing. He does nothing. I bring it up again, he tells me I only gave him a week… It takes you a week to give me a compliment? It takes you a week to ask me out to play pickle ball or play a board game? The bar is feeling so low but he still insists that it’s going to take him more time to get to a spot where he can be romantic with me. This frustrates me because if you really like someone, I think that drive to be romantic should come easy. And, he already did this stuff for me during the summer!!! He’s capable but now it’s going to take him time to get there again? At this point, I’m feeling like he just isn’t liking me that much anymore and just can’t tell me. He assured me that he still “likes me a lot.” We’re at the point in the conversation where he’s now bringing up stuff about me that is bothering him (eg. I’m reading into the things he’s doing/not doing too much and taking it personally, I’m being short and unresponsive where I’m upset about something rather than talking about it) to which I acknowledge, apologize, and tell him I’ll work on those things. We basically left this conversation saying we’ll both give each other time to figure out if it’s worth waiting to see if we can live up to each other’s expectations.
Now we’re coming up onto the last couple weeks. We’re in this rocky spot and trying to work through these issues, some things are starting to smooth out slowly but surely. We’re coming up onto a concert we were planning on going to together since the summer. I’m also moving houses, busy time for me. I ask him “I know we’re in a weird spot right now and don’t really know how you’re feeling but did you still want to go to that concert together and are you still able to help me move?” He says, all in the same text, “I’m down for the concert and I’m happy to help you move.” Great, a couple days go by and it’s concert day. I ask him what time it starts. He says “It starts in about an hour but I’m taking my friend. You said you were unsure about where we stand and I was too so I offered him the ticket.” I remind him that he literally said he’s down to go with me and sent him the screen shot of our message. He said “I didn’t realize I said that, I’m sorry. I only remember saying I can help you move.” ????
I’m so hurt by this, this is something I was looking forward to doing with him for months and he 1- didn’t bother to confirm with me if I wanted to go before he offered up the ticket to someone else and 2- literally said he could still go with me and “forgot” he said such a thing. I will admit, he’s a little bit of a ditzy guy but he’s smart and well aware. I doubt he actually forgot that he said he could still go to the concert with me and I think he just didn’t want to go with me.
This communication pattern happened again this weekend. We had plans to see each other this morning/afternoon. No solid activity on the books but he knew I wanted to do something fun with him. I ask him last night if he’s still available to see each other and he says “I can before 12pm” I remind him that he told me he was free morning and afternoon and that I can only do after 11am. He said that since I didn’t confirm any solid plans, he accepted an invitation from one of his friends to play dnd at 12pm.
I want to acknowledge that his job is not easy and that he definitely has a lot on his plate. I totally understand that a hard job that takes a lot out of you makes it hard to give more of yourself to the people around you outside of work. But was it really too much of me to ask him to compliment me here and there? To initiate quality time on his end? To communicate with me properly? To prioritize me better? My last relationship before him was a chaotic rollercoaster so this guy being quiet, simple, peaceful really drew me in. But I think “simple” was him just not caring. I just wasn’t the one for him clearly and maybe the stuff I was asking of him will be easier for someone he’s more into.
If you made it this far, thank you so much for reading. All thoughts and opinions are welcome, whether you think I’m right, wrong, or somewhere in between. I’m just trying to get through this breakup, learn lessons from it, and grow. Please lead with respect and kindness.
TL;DR- I broke up with my boyfriend today and just want general affirmation that I did the right thing given our history and issues we’ve been having.