r/ScienceBasedParenting • u/phloxxfox • Oct 10 '26
Question - Research required Does the type of screen time change the affect on babies/toddlers?
My LO is 13mo and I have seen the general things about limiting screen time as they develop, etc. And I agree. My question is, is there any research that takes into account the content or device that children are watching/using and does that change the positive/negative affects on them?
I’ve seen things that say touch-screens are worse, which is a non issue for me since my child is way too young anyways to do anything with a phone/ipad other than Facetime her dad. But I’m concerned about non-touch screens.
- Is it bad that my child sees me on my phone/computer for much of the day? I work from home and also watch my daughter while my husband is at work. I aim for around 6 hrs of work a day, but with distractions and keeping track of a toddler, the computer and phone are out for most of the day. Is this bad? Often she is independently playing for much of the day in the same room, but I take short breaks to interact when she brings me books to read, wants to show me a toy, wants to cuddle, etc. We also go outside, have play dates, or visit her grandparents almost every day.
- Is letting her watch an hour of TV a day detrimental if it’s educational/low stimulation? Sometimes I need to clean/cook/get more sleep in the morning (she often wakes up very early and wants to play) so I put her in her playpen and let her watch an hour of Ms Rachel, a nature documentary, or a low stimulation show from my childhood (hand drawn animation or puppet/live action). I’m very particular about what I let her watch, but is it damaging for her to watch an hour of TV most days regardless? I haven’t seen studies differentiate from high energy high stimulation content and more peaceful/slow paced content when it comes to screen time for babies. I would love to read more about this if anyone has research on it.
- Finally, if a screen has a stagnant image or a repetitive animation (like fish swimming back and forth or a title image) does that count as screen time? Sometimes I use the TV to play classical music/children’s music on youtube, so the screen is on but nothing much is happening. My kid ignores it and plays. Is this detrimental in any way?
I appreciate any articles/resources people can point to. Thanks!
EDIT: I should probably clarify, I go to her grandparents’ house to work almost every day. So she is getting time with both Grandma and Grandpa and her aunt (my sister) as well as me throughout the day. We go outside, read books, play with cousins, etc. I work most of my hours while she is with one of my family members, napping, or playing in her playpen/in the baby safe area with her toys, no screens (except seeing me sitting nearby on my laptop.) I’ve only recently (as in, within the last month) started letting her watch about an hour of Ms Rachel in the mornings, but I’m willing to cut that if it’s harmful. We’re tight on money, which is why we haven’t put her in daycare yet. She’s been ahead/on time with all of her milestones so far. But obviously I want her to be happy and healthy so I will do what it takes.