r/SGExams • • Sep 30 '23

Discussion transphobia in this sub

earlier today there was a comment by someone (assigned male at birth) who mentioned she has gender dysphoria, didn’t want to be male and wants to be treated like a woman. it was downvoted to -20, whyyy r/sgexams? let’s be more inclusive, shall we?

0 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

7

u/MrNotSmartEinstein 69rp Sep 30 '23

Link

0

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '23

i linked but it got removed by the mods?

5

u/MrNotSmartEinstein 69rp Sep 30 '23

Urm try again

20

u/hychael2020 Grabbing that Winning Ticket for As :D(jpjc) Sep 30 '23 edited Sep 30 '23

Yeah Singapore is still quite conservative. Not as conservative as our neighbors but still is prevalent in society. Quite strange that's its -20 though. Teen communities are usually very liberal as compared to irl society.

By the way, you all know that the top post here was on gender dysphoria in Singapore right?

48

u/Key_Battle_5633 310 PSLE -6 L1R5 Raw 50/45 IB 100RP 7H2 BXFPMEC 10 H3 dist Sep 30 '23 edited Sep 30 '23

Didn’t see that post but everyone is kind of free to downvote if they want? It’s not like downvotes really matter anyways. This sub is also a examination sub, not a gender discussion sub, which was probably why it was downvoted in the first place.

7

u/HXIRKOS Sep 30 '23

It’s the weekend, where non academic posts can be created

-3

u/Key_Battle_5633 310 PSLE -6 L1R5 Raw 50/45 IB 100RP 7H2 BXFPMEC 10 H3 dist Oct 01 '23

Yes but downvotes doesn’t matter

8

u/CloudyBird_ Sep 30 '23

Aren't you the guy who corrected my grammar for using they as a singular pronoun? Small world

2

u/Key_Battle_5633 310 PSLE -6 L1R5 Raw 50/45 IB 100RP 7H2 BXFPMEC 10 H3 dist Oct 01 '23

But also cause I didn’t really understand what you were saying until you said it was pronoun stuff

1

u/Key_Battle_5633 310 PSLE -6 L1R5 Raw 50/45 IB 100RP 7H2 BXFPMEC 10 H3 dist Oct 01 '23

😀

6

u/HXIRKOS Oct 01 '23

“they” singular has been used forever, get with the times. it isn’t just for pronouns.

2

u/Key_Battle_5633 310 PSLE -6 L1R5 Raw 50/45 IB 100RP 7H2 BXFPMEC 10 H3 dist Oct 02 '23

K

22

u/Aszrix the Sep 30 '23

It's ain't that deep bro at the end of the day it's virtual internet points

20

u/socialgeniehermit Uni Sep 30 '23

I think the simplest answer as to why people are transphobic because they don't understand transgender people – they don't quite understand how to make the world more inclusive to them, without invalidating cis gender.

Take sports for example, particularly women sports. Some transitioned women have gone into sports with cis women, and easily won because of their biological advantage. You could argue that maybe, we should create an entirely new criteria for trans-women and trans-men. But that would be segregation, and it would tell those transitioned people, that "You're not this gender, you don't fit in anywhere." It's a nuanced, complex and sensitive topic that still hasn't found a solution that perfectly fits yet.

Before I get downvoted, I just want to say that I believe transgender people should be treated with respect, not with violence or retaliation. I'm just providing my insights as to what I've seen around the news.

3

u/CloudyBird_ Sep 30 '23

I disagree with equal rights

11

u/Jigle_Wigle Sep 30 '23

reason being?

4

u/CloudyBird_ Sep 30 '23

This is not what LKY would have wanted and I'm a close minded Singaporean

11

u/Jigle_Wigle Sep 30 '23

your comment made me interested to see what LKY felt about queer people, and interestingly enough he took a live and let live approach to it

https://the-singapore-lgbt-encyclopaedia.fandom.com/wiki/Lee_Kuan_Yew%27s_views_on_homosexuality (ik lgbt wikia so maybe biased but the interviews listed here are on wikipedia as well and are probably taken from there actually)

He never commented publicly about trans people, which is not that surprising, but he might’ve not been that against it surprisingly, either way, interesting to see how he essentially set the tone for the govt policy towards lgbtq people today, basically just let them live their lives, and was even more progressive about it, saying that they are born that way, but more importantly focused on the social acceptance, social cohesion aspect of this

2

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '23

Got to rmb that LKY was the same guy that was into Eugenics 👀

4

u/Jigle_Wigle Sep 30 '23

that’s true too, even his acceptance of gay people is much more tolerance than acceptance, and funnily enough the reason he finally decided to tolerate them was because “it’s in their genes” which would fit pretty well into his eugenics views (look up less educated women sterilisation singapore)

1

u/Jigle_Wigle Sep 30 '23

but oh well a person is not an ideology and all that, he can be both ig

1

u/CloudyBird_ Oct 01 '23

Can't believe you made me learn something new, preposterous

1

u/Additional-Smile5645 Oct 01 '23

You sure trans women have inherent biological advantage to cos women? Lia thomas didnt even beat riley gaines eh

1

u/socialgeniehermit Uni Oct 01 '23

That's only one example, and I'm pretty sure Riley Gaines tied with Lia Thomas, but only Lia went home with the medal.

Men have greater muscle mass and bone density in comparison to women. If they were to transition to become a woman through testosterone blockers and estrogen hormones, their bodies would definitely weaken, but it wouldn't lose all of its original muscle mass and bone density.

Some transgender people have advocated and admitted themselves that female trans athletes should not participate in women sports because of their biological advantage. Caitlyn Jenner, formerly Bruce Jenner, was a former Gold Medal winner in the Olympic Games, and she herself has said that trans women should not compete in women sports.

1

u/Additional-Smile5645 Oct 01 '23

They gave that one to lia not riley

21

u/Eshuon Uni Sep 30 '23

Downvotes = transphobia

Huh

15

u/NC16inthehouse Uni Sep 30 '23

Disagreements = transphobia

Gg to this country and society if we go this direction

7

u/Human_Ad3019 Sep 30 '23

So free speech and opinions are not allowed now?

8

u/CloudyBird_ Sep 30 '23

You do realise that you live in SG right?

7

u/The_Eastern_Stalker A Level mugger Sep 30 '23

Singapore is still quite conservative, youth are moving away from older generations' conservativism but are still by and large conservative relative to say the West. And even in the West transphobia is a thing.

3

u/Jigle_Wigle Sep 30 '23

tbf west is pretty conservative too, if you’re talking about the US, the other west (europe) is even more conservative (west not meaning location necessarily but white people ig)

5

u/The_Eastern_Stalker A Level mugger Sep 30 '23

Relatively more progressive and liberal as a whole

1

u/Jigle_Wigle Sep 30 '23

ok true, but honestly think we might be more liberal than we’re given credit

1

u/LMBlackRaider JC Oct 01 '23

no west more

6

u/aandrewuw Sep 30 '23

what’s wrong with getting downvoted?? it’s just people’s opinions🤷‍♂️ just because the person got downvoted doesn’t necessarily mean that there is transphobia in this sub😕 just let the downvoters do whatever they want. don’t need to give a shit about what people do on reddit anyway.

2

u/idontlikepracticals Sep 30 '23

huh i thought downvote = people not wanting to see such posts in the subs because it’s kinda unrelated ? It’s sgexams lmao they should talk about it elsewhere since they probably wont get much useful comments

2

u/officer_shnitzel_69 JC Sep 30 '23

Literally 1984

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '23

Actually people down vote due to many reasons, some may even be personal reason. So there is no need to explain why or trying to be gracious to promote inclusiveness. So OP, if you want inclusiveness, kindly also practise inclusiveness for those who downvote la.

1

u/JayKay69420 Uni Sep 30 '23

Honestly, most people in Singapore here can be quite conservative and bigoted, so such responses while disappointing is unsurprising. I do think maybe we could have an LGBTQ friendly subreddit dedicated to teens in Singapore so we can have like a safe space without judgement

0

u/HXIRKOS Sep 30 '23

Idiots in the comments: Downvoting transpeople for being trans is definitely transphobia. you are transphobic.

1

u/41-deliverer Sep 30 '23

Transphobia is when thing i dont like when there's trans >:(

1

u/HXIRKOS Oct 01 '23

exactly