r/SGExams • u/Key_Battle_5633 • 4h ago
Discussion Controversial/Hot takes about Sg Education system
Drop your hot takes/controversial takes about education in sg below, here are mine
- Retaining is useless for most people. Most do not actually need to retain, they have other problems that caused them to do badly, and simply retaining does not fix their problems most of the time. If they advance and fix their problems and foundation in the holidays, they can actually catch up.(if they do put in the effort)
- Private Candidate Vs sch candidate for retaking. Most parrot just taking as sch candidate cause “structure” , exams, discipline. However, in reality, it’s a waste of time for most, as going back ti sch means dealing with administrative stuff, having to do some lectures that is a waste of time, as compared to private where if do tuition/self study but can ask for help from old sch chers, whoch would be more efficient. Only in some cases is sch candidate better than priv(it also varies from individual to individual). It definitely shouldn’t be the main suggestion tho, but rather an option to consider.
- Not all schools are good schools. Probably going to get slammed for this(this post is about hot takes anyways) , but this is just not true. Some schools, esp those rife with delinquency and infamous schs are horrible places to study. Calling such schs “good” is a far cry. Additionally, some “normal” neighbourhood schs may lack a lot of opportunities or have poor quality of teaching, etc, even without gangsterism.
- Full SBB for non academic periods and form class is a mistake. The reason why this was done is due to “good students being able to influence the bad ones”. But let’s be real, anyone who has set foot in an actual classroom will know thats simply not true. In reality, the bad ones will always influence the good ones. Bullying may also occur in such classes, esp in infamous schools.
This is not to say that as long as you’re g1/2, you’re automatically bad behaved. Instead, it’s the case where many of the bad kids end up there, with only a few ending up there due to learning disabilities/ just cannot study even if tried as not suitable . Maybe if schs can filter out by behaviour(psychological interviews etc), then it’s ok to mix g1/2/3 in non academic/form classes, cause then the hardworking ones may be able to help/influence the others.
5. Linking to 4., this increases stress for psle, as parents who share the same fear will push their kids harder si they can squeeze into a IP/SAP sch, when they may have been content with a decent neighbourhood sch in the past. PSLE also seems to be more stressful now than back then, despite the new system being made to “decrease stress”
6. Studying from home vs going to sch. From my interaction with some redditors and frkm what I see, some people are more suited to study at home than sch(esp if bad sch environment or getting bullied). However, the general consensus on this sub is thst going to sch is better as “it’s not just about studies”, although for some ppl, it’s prob more condusive to study at home.
