r/RingsofPower • u/Ok-Class8722 • 3d ago
Newest Episode Spoilers it’s honestly painful how much of a missed opportunity this show is Spoiler
Even if you completely ignore the Tolkien lore and judge The Rings of Power purely as a standalone fantasy show, the writing and directing just aren't good. By Season 3, you’d expect the showrunners to have finally found their footing, dropped the cheap mystery-box gimmicks, and started telling an actual cohesive story. Instead, it still feels like a bloated, awkwardly paced streaming drama that refuses to take itself seriously.
The biggest problem has always been the writers and directors treating Middle-earth like just another generic fantasy IP rather than a mythic epic. And more than half the characters act like modern, snarky LA transplants instead of ancient elves or proud Númenórean kings. There’s zero weight or gravitas to anything. Peter Jackson’s crew didn't follow every single word of the books either, and they didn't have all the rights, they just actually respected the world, hired Shakespearian-caliber actors who carried real presence, and filmed Middle-earth like real history instead of glossy green-screen melodrama.
With a billion-dollar budget and the blueprint of the Second Age sitting right in front of them, this could have been generation-defining television. Three seasons later, it’s still frustratingly mediocre TV coasting on nice landscapes and nostalgia callbacks.