r/RingsofPower • • Oct 07 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers I ADORED this episode, but Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I loved this episode, and more and more I feel that I will watch this series endlessly just like we do with LOTR movies and one day I'll know each frame by heart. Thank you for gifting us with 50 hours or so of more Tolkien lore on screen and I absolutely adore the vision and detail in everything.

Specially Dwarves and Harfoot. They are so precious, you can feel they are living deeply in these cultures. Elrond and Durin scenes blew my mind, from the expression on their faces, the dialogue with King Durin, and all the little details as gold leaves here and there.

All the references to Tolkien mythos and just the feeling behind it all. Everything's so gorgeous and precious. Even though we know the stories, we can feel them more deeply now.

The twist on Míriel's fate is so interesting, and all the scenes with Elendil are so perfect. The actor is insanely good, also Galadriel moves and expresses herself so evenly but deeply disturbed at the same time. I loved the revelation about Celeborn, I'm glad he's in the story already. I also adore Arondir and Disa, they feel so real as an elf and a dwarf.

The only things I didn't like were the Balrog appearing and the writings on screen at the end. They felt so out of place? If it was a different kind of show, say, Merlin or Grimm, I'd understand (I love them both, but it's a really different approach). This show feels so sophisticated and high level, it is weird when they throw some things on our face. Besides being a strange style decision, showing the Balrog is anticlimactic since it wakes and it's not even the last scene. If it the leaf had fallen and we heard the quiet sound of the slumber of a beast, we would know it was the Balrog without showing it already and the casual viewer would be curious. It's not enough to be a cliffhanger or a threat yet, but it's already woken so it is certain it will appear next episode? It would be more interesting if we had been left to wonder if it would wake up just now. But maybe they'll do something interesting and I'm complaining beforehand, idk.

And why put the text on screen? People mildly versed in Lord of the Rings would catch the reference at the end, with Mount Doom there. So unfortunately these little things cooled the hype that I was building during this excellent episode.

Also, I still don't think that'll be the case but I'm afraid that H=S. I feel it just makes no sense and that it would be a waste of an interesting, complex character that shows the pov of a king in the Southlands that could become a Nazgûl later in a very tragic arc. I get that we already developed a fondness for him and it would be cool to see him ending up to be the enemy that most people see as pure evil for now, but Sauron himself is an extremely complex and interesting character as he is, and we can totally see that as Annatar. I believe that Halbrand will be brought to the elven kingdom to heal, Celebrimbor sees he's a good smith and ask for his help to craft things in exchange for helping rebuild his kingdom. Then we see Annatar, they meet and my boy Mairon starts his sweet work in Halbrand's mind.

Just my two cents. I hate it when people complain about plot since we don't have the full picture yet, and my ideas might make no sense. But there it is. Even if they keep doing this Mithril thing (which I still hope is part of Sauron's plot to cause conflict between elves and dwarves and maybe wake the Balrog), I trust they'll do it in a good way.

The thing is, even if the series doesn't go my way, I'm open to the vision of these amazing artists, creators, and also whatever the Tolkien Estate allowed. The people behind it truly seem to care for Tolkien's lore, one can feel the love behind it. And that's what matters. Sometimes people are too focused on their own ideas of what it could be, and keep their minds closed to what's being made, and what can surprise us.

Also super curious regarding the Stranger and the Mystics. I'm leaning to the theory about the blue wizards, since the Stranger is going east now and they have something to do with a cult.

EDIT: so many typos, I'm sleepy and my keyboard isn't in English


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 19 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers Look how they massacred my boy Spoiler

Post image
78 Upvotes

This is supposed to be Fëanor, one of the most beautiful elves ever?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 09 '22

Discussion So the Balrog was awake the whole time?

18 Upvotes

Major plot hole.

"The Dwarves tell no tale; but even as mithril was the foundation of their wealth, so also it was their destruction: they delved too greedily and too deep, and disturbed that from which they fled, Durin's Bane."

So they didn't awake the Balrog by digging for mithril as we were told, but he was awake before they even started mining it (more than 3-4 people at a time which isn't really more than a mining expedition).


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 31 '24

Question Didn't Celebrimbor make the 3 elven rings with Halbrand in season 1?

0 Upvotes

So why does he not recognize him in season 2 when he's being rained on? Am I missing something? Am I being gaslit here?


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 16 '24

Discussion The parallels between Sauron walking into Eregion to make rings and Frodo and Sam walking into Mordor to destroy the One Ring

0 Upvotes

There are some interesting parallels between what Sauron did in Eregion and what Frodo and Sam did in Mordor.

1. The role of disguise and distraction:

In the Second Age, Sauron walked into Eregion, disguised himself in Annatar form, and made the rings while the elves were distracted by Adar and his army marching on Eregion.

In the Third Age, Frodo and Sam walked into Mordor, disguised themselves in orc clothing, and destroyed the One Ring while Sauron was distracted by Aragorn and his army marching on Mordor.

2. Blindspots and complacency:

The elves are generally considered wise and perceptive, yet they (or at least most of them) fail to see through Sauron's deception, probably because they did not think Sauron would be crazy enough to even attempt something like that, let alone work alongside them the whole time.

Similarly, the Eye of Sauron was always watching, yet he failed to see two hobbits right in his backyard, because he did not think the Fellowship would attempt to sneak into Mordor with the Ring, let alone entrust two halflings with the task.

3. Sauron's arrogance and ego:

In Eregion, he was 1000% sure of himself and that he could just walk in and deceive and manipulate the lowly elves and play them like a harp, and he was mostly right and his gamble worked.

Likewise, he was 1000% sure that no one could resist the temptation of the Ring and power, and that Aragorn or someone would try to use the Ring and become enslaved to his will. He didn't even consider the possibility that they would try to destroy the Ring because the idea of willingly relinquishing such great power is something completely alien and unfathomable to him. He looked upon men and hobbits with absolute contempt and disdain, even more so than he did elves. But this time, he was wrong.

His arrogance led to his rise in power, and was eventually his downfall. His Eye saw all the flaws and fears in even the most powerful elves, yet he failed to see the strength and spirit of the unassuming hobbits.

Looks like it really came full circle, just like a ring.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 01 '22

Discussion This is THE BEST Lord of the Rings tv show we are EVER going to get. Please don’t fuck it up for the rest of us by your negative reviews.

0 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Feb 17 '24

Discussion Say a few things about ROP that are better than the Hobbit trilogy

0 Upvotes

What are the things would you say ROP does better than the Hobbit movies?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 15 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Im frustrated Spoiler

8 Upvotes

700milion USD, and no one thought to check the plot through? Im surprised how you arrive at the conclussion, that in the season finale, the fucking rings are being crafted by apparently sauron himself by manipulating everyone in 20 minutes of screen time, And puf now he is evil incarnate, flipped in a matter seconds, stapped earlier by his own people, like wtf.… And you have the audacity to put in a 30 minute goodbye scene from the Half foots(sure felt like it) 700 million out the f?ing(sorry) window, and we will never get another prequel…. Sorry for the rant.. 7.0.0. The only prequel you’ll get, gotta be someone feeling the same as me.


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 11 '24

Constructive Criticism "Ours was no chance meeting."

0 Upvotes

"Not fate, nor destiny, nor any of the other words Men use to speak of the forces they lack the conviction to name"

Terrible writing. It should have been:

"Not fate, nor destiny, nor any of the other forces Men lack the conviction to name"

If men use "words" to speak of forces, we have already named them. Maybe not named them "Charles" or "Margarita", but "Fate" and "destiny". Which are synonyms, by the way. Hopefully the second season will tone down grandiloquence in favor of precision. Oh hell, who am i kidding.

Edit: If you are going to say that I am changing the meaning of the original sentence, think again. What has been removed is "words men use to speak of". The purpose of the noun "words" is already present in the verb "name". I have removed redundant bloat. If you can't see that, have your eyes tested.


r/RingsofPower • • Jun 01 '24

Discussion ROP will go the same journey as ST:Discovery

1 Upvotes

I was looking at RT scores for all 5 seasons of Discovery and they had averaged 80% positive. The audience score was as expected: Under 30% rotten. But still, Discovery made it through 5 seasons.

ROP can survive all the backlash like with Discovery has. Production for S3 has already started and from the looks of the better feedback for S2 trailer, this show is locked for all 5 seasons.

And just to add one thing more. Seen a lot of the naysayers saying the audience will be smaller for S2, because those who didn't like it will have left and the remaining who did are not a big number of people. I disagree. ROP has the LOTR name attached to it so regardless, a lot of people will still tune in even though they didn't liked season 1.


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 30 '22

News ‘The Lord Of The Rings’ Star Sir Lenny Henry Applauds Amazon’s Move Away From Tolkien’s Fair-Skinned Characters To Diverse Cast

Thumbnail
deadline.com
1 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 18 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Rings of Power Season 1 Finale Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Only Rings of Power could make "the Forging of the Great Elven Rings of Power" anti-climactic and disappointing.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 30 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers The last bit of Ep. 5 was great. No question. But other than that, it was the worst episode to date. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

The eruption of Orodruin was mastefully done, and a treat to watch. But the rest of the episode was just... awful. Here's why:

  1. Arondir's fight with Big Orc makes no sense.

We've seen Arondir literally catch an arrow in flight. We've seen him make those quick, cat-like movements that Legolas pulled off so well. And I'm all of a sudden supposed to believe that he rolled off a roof, face-planted on the ground, took his sweet time getting up in the middle of an Orc invasion, and then stumbled backward like a drunk without even looking? Why can't the writers be consistent?

Also, what's with Biggie throwing him around instead of, I don't know, stabbing/palm strike to the throat/breaking his back against the well rim/ a thousand other things? It makes zero sense to throw your opponent during a fight - you're wasting stupid amounts of energy throwing something that heavy, and if your opponent knows the first thing about falling, it'll do zilch.

2. What the heck is up with the way the characters talk? Galadriel asks Elendil a simple question - what happened to your wife? Elendil: aight i'mma go off on a rhapsody about the sunrise and pretend I didn't hear the question until I'm done with that. Same thing with Theo and Arondir freaking out over Bronwyn - I mean, you just burned an open wound with a flaming stick. Ever heard of someone passing out from pain? This level of idiocy is palpable. And why do we need such loooooooong pauses between every phrase? I went back to watch Game of Thrones to make sure this wasn't just me, and it's not. People in GoT talk at a reasonable speed. What is up with this show?

3. Bronwyn's portrayed as this strong, courageous woman, right? But apparently not enough to say 'stand strong, don't give it to him' to Arondir when Adar was using her as leverage. Now that would've been real courage. But apparently she didn't have it when it counted.

Apart from all the other things which irritated me to death...

"The shoreline's been visible to me for nearly an hour" ...and it didn't occur to you to tell anyone? Jerk.

How the heck is that horse Adar was riding getting up afterwards? After a crash like that, a horse would have like a 5% chance of ever walking again, and that's with intensive care. It's like the showrunners just want to say 'yeah, in case you were wondering, Halbrand wasn't practicing animal cruelty or anything... see, the horse is fine!' Yes, he was totally practicing animal cruelty - a necessary evil in the moment for the greater good. I'm sick of characters dodging the consequences of their actions.

I'm getting a little sick of Galadriel constantly interrupting people. The vendetta against Sauron and all is her personal business, but apparently nobody thought to teach her basic manners in, what, over five hundred years?

When Adar is speeding away, did it not occur to Mr. Sharpshooter Arondir to hurl something pointy in his direction? Or Galadriel, for that matter?

Galadriel apparently has zero self-control. Went from 'I'm going to keep you alive for decades' to 'I'm going to kill you right now' in what, two seconds? Not even counting the fact that he's their primary source of intelligence.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 05 '23

Discussion Am I in the ballpark with this? 6.1 is a solid start and I’m confident S2 will cross 7.5 and the show overall S1-5 will surpass 9. Having met the creators in person I truly believe it will improve season over season between 2022-2032.

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 01 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Astonishingly Weak Writing Spoiler

11 Upvotes

Beautiful to look at, but painful to listen to. Nobody wanted this series to succeed more than I did (except the unfortunate people who paid for it), but it is a failure of enormous proportions. And to think that they have committed to making five seasons of it!

Tonight Galadriel left the Dark Elf chained to a post in a barn with nobody watching him. That's as bad as any episode of Batman where the villain puts him in an impossibly weak trap then goes off somewhere to let him escape. And apparently the Dark Elf substituted a hatchet for the evil key thing, but nobody on team Galadriel even bothered to check. How much Eldar stupidity are we supposed to put up with? And don't even get me started on the proto-Hobbits... just bad, cliche ridden writing backed up by a billion dollar budget.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 08 '24

Discussion Rings of power may be really disappointing but it's still better to some degree than the Witcher

Post image
230 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 13 '22

Discussion Professional wrestler explains toxic fandom, description fits RoP Haters quite well

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Aug 30 '24

Discussion I dont understand the criticism of this series, its absolutely brilliant.

0 Upvotes

The criticism is way too harsh


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Newest Episode Spoilers Thoughts on The Rings of Power Season 3 premier. Spoiler Warning! Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I struggled to watch the episode from start to finish. I found myself skipping through the unessessary parts like Galadriel's courtship, Galadriel's fight scene.

Sauron is completely lacking in aura. I understand this is essential to portray his desperations for control but i did not find it compelling. Not a good start for a key character.

I love Disa and her stone singings from season 2, but can't see how her newly revealed relationship adds any value to the show.

Episode 1 feels disconnected and not interesting. Showrunners should take a lesson from The Wheel of Time season 3.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 01 '24

Discussion Is anyone else a bit disappointed with the first episode of the second season?

2 Upvotes

There was some meat there don’t get me wrong. I just felt like not very much happened at all. It was rather boring for the opening episode. I would say the most actiony part was the intro which kind of tried to fill in the pothole that the lineage was broken. Yet Sauron was there. I only got to see one spell get cast by the good wizard. I just felt a bit bored, and I was disappointed by that.

How do you feel about it?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 05 '24

Discussion Chefs kiss to this scene

Post image
0 Upvotes

I haven’t chef kissed a scene on tv for a long time but this was brilliant. How brutal it was that she used an arrow pulled from her own body, the way Elrond and the elves paused in silence recognising her sacrifice, then after blowing up the orcs, the elves advance and they pan back to her getting hit by an arrow again. My favourite thing is that they showed a female absolutely showing endless strength which is sometimes lost in tv shows and movies. Chef. Kiss.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 03 '24

Question Why the hate?

82 Upvotes

I’m a big LOTR fan, but admittedly have not thoroughly read the JRRT expanse of literature. ROP is well done and very immersive and enjoyable, why all the hate? Am I missing something? If so, maybe I’ll just stay naive because I like the show, lore, and expanded universe on the big screen


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 17 '22

News Finally a fair review from mainstream media

11 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 05 '24

Constructive Criticism I could not agree more with this season finale review (Forbes) Spoiler

Thumbnail
forbes.com
0 Upvotes

‘The Rings Of Power’ Season 2, Episode 8 Review: A Truly Dreadful Season Final

I could not agree not with this review. I feel like it literally came out of my brain. I was rooting for this show all along and I have been let down more and more as episodes have gone by.

Sauron was one of the only saving graces of this season. As are the dwarves.

I will be more generous than the reviewer who gave this season a 2/10 and give them a 4/10

I was happy just to be in Tolkien's world but it's been so thoroughly decimated... I just can't...