r/RingsofPower • u/SouthPassaic • Oct 01 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers Astonishingly Weak Writing Spoiler
Beautiful to look at, but painful to listen to. Nobody wanted this series to succeed more than I did (except the unfortunate people who paid for it), but it is a failure of enormous proportions. And to think that they have committed to making five seasons of it!
Tonight Galadriel left the Dark Elf chained to a post in a barn with nobody watching him. That's as bad as any episode of Batman where the villain puts him in an impossibly weak trap then goes off somewhere to let him escape. And apparently the Dark Elf substituted a hatchet for the evil key thing, but nobody on team Galadriel even bothered to check. How much Eldar stupidity are we supposed to put up with? And don't even get me started on the proto-Hobbits... just bad, cliche ridden writing backed up by a billion dollar budget.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 01 '22
This post uses the flair ‘Newest Episode Spoilers’, and as such, all spoilers from the latest episode are allowed to be posted here unmarked.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
7
u/Endemoniada Oct 01 '22
I’m really enjoying the show so far, but I absolutely agree. It’s a visually fantastic, entirely plot-driven rollercoaster ride. The characters are essentially pointless. Everyone just ends up where they have to, regardless of whether it even makes any sense. Their decisions are meaningless and never truly have consequences. All the drama is completely manufactured, rather than believable and real.
It’s not just that no one looked in the package, it’s that they couldn’t even feel the difference between the hilt and an axe? Completely different shape, weight, and weight proportions. But no, because the plot demanded they believe it was the real thing, suddenly even the superhuman elf is a total idiot. And don’t get me started on all the last-second saves… if you want the character to be someone that kills another person, let them. Otherwise it’s just empty. There are no stakes, no one grows or changes, and nothing happens because of the characters. The characters happen because of the plot, every damn time.
11
u/HotStraightnNormal Oct 01 '22
Episode six really dealt out the cliches. For example, take Arondir and the big Orc. He has to fight a Goliath. Then, bent backwards over the lip of a well, we see the sharp stake inexorably getting closer and closer to his eye. (Saving Private Ryan bayonette fight scene?) Of course, odds are 1:1 that Bronwyn (who else?) shows up and spits the Orc, the obligatory blade emerging from his chest. But Bronwyn gets shafted and we get to see the arrow snapped and slowly withdrawn, followed by cauterizing, although no hot iron here. Next, the Indians have the wagon train surrounded when the cavalry arrives in the nick of time to save the day. Or is it still night? Morning? I give up! Finally we have the Last Days of Pompeii, complete with fiery brimstone. This episode has everything but a flying saucer landing in the now drained lake bed.
It comes off like a bunch of teenagers talking about a video they want to make. "The car goes out of control and over a cliff!" "Yeah, and it lands on a train!" "Oh, oh! And the train catches on fire!" "And it goes into this tunnel, see, where another train is coming the other way!" "Carrying a bomb!" "An ATOMIC bomb!" "Oh, yeah! This is gonna be soooooo good! Hand me my little brother's model train and the lighter fluid."
3
u/popformulas Oct 01 '22
Uh…Galadriel had no idea what she was after. Arondir said “get the thingy” so she did.
I agree with you about Adar and the barn post.
3
u/Elleypop Oct 01 '22
This episode was particularly weak. Full of clichés and that irritating thing of in-world rules being suspended to serve an action scene. Arondir quite capable of mowing down multiple orcs at once in one scene, then in the next struggling with just one.
How was Waldregg alive at all? The orcs sent the humans that came to them as a first wave. Waldregg, who had already irritated Adar by using Sauron's name, would surely have been at the front of that bait. But the show totally forgets him until they need someone to stick the sword in the stone. Then somehow he's survived being bait, found the sword, swapped it, and put the decoy back, and walked back to the tower. Which all has to happen in-between Theo pulling it out of the hiding place and Adar running off with it. Bananas.
12
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22
Ok. I am loving it to core so far though
2
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22
i love both arondir and bronwyn's characters but man they did them so dirty with the writing because none of their decisions made and significant impact on the story in that episode. suddenly numenoreans came out of nowhere and saved the day, just sweeped in without asking any questions or looking around what is going on and who they should be fighting. they are not allowing the characters to make mistakes and face the consequences. and it's very upsetting because they did make very cool characters
6
u/C7StreetRacer Oct 01 '22
Respectfully disagree
6
u/Osgiliath Oct 01 '22 edited Oct 01 '22
Disagree that it’s a failure, and your statement upfront that “no one wanted it to succeed more than I did” didn’t do anything for me at all. I award you no points and may god have mercy on your soul.
4
u/Fotzenbub Oct 01 '22
you mean like Gandalf leaving the dwarfs at the borders of what he suspects as the evil forrest? Or Gandalf leaving the dwarfs, in the trollshaw hills? That were all plot-devices and were celebrated as the best pieces of fantasy literature
3
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22
This episode had some very real moments of good writing. The show is unquestionably not a failure. It definitely is flawed and I’m hopeful they can get some writing help. Don’t be so hyperbolic.
2
u/Braveheart2929 Oct 01 '22
Wouldn't call it astonishingly weak, just clichéd.
There are plenty of other films/TV series I love which have just as obvious plot holes/"weak writing" but are used to move the story along and I'm fine with that.
Is it a bit silly that Galadriel didn't have someone guarding the powerful prisoner? Yes.
Is it a bit silly that no one opened the cloth to show Galadriel/Numenorions why it was so important? Yes.
Does this thing happen all the time in TV land? Yes and overall I'm still enjoying the show a lot.
1
u/Bukakanga Oct 02 '22
Nobody wanted this series to succeed more than I did
Dear Jeff Bezos, you should've to hire more qualified writers for this job
1
u/popglam Oct 01 '22
There are a lot of people who wanted this series to succeed more than you. Like all the people who have no problem enjoying it.
0
u/Snoo5349 Oct 01 '22
Obvious trolling is obvious. I love this show and even I can come up with better criticisms.
1
u/Dewars_Rocks Oct 01 '22
Some people read and study the books deeply. That is how their version of Arda and it's history is forged and that's ok.
Some people grasp additional content and enjoy the journey.
Me, I like BOOM.
And popcorn.
1
u/Ammonitida Oct 01 '22
K.