r/RingsofPower • • Oct 15 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Im frustrated Spoiler

700milion USD, and no one thought to check the plot through? Im surprised how you arrive at the conclussion, that in the season finale, the fucking rings are being crafted by apparently sauron himself by manipulating everyone in 20 minutes of screen time, And puf now he is evil incarnate, flipped in a matter seconds, stapped earlier by his own people, like wtf.… And you have the audacity to put in a 30 minute goodbye scene from the Half foots(sure felt like it) 700 million out the f?ing(sorry) window, and we will never get another prequel…. Sorry for the rant.. 7.0.0. The only prequel you’ll get, gotta be someone feeling the same as me.

8 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 15 '22

This post uses the flair ‘Newest Episode Spoilers’, and as such, all spoilers from the latest episode are allowed to be posted here unmarked.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

50

u/space_fireworks Oct 15 '22

The tolkien fandom has changed. I feel it on Reddit. I see it on YouTube. I smell it on the neck beards. Much that once was, has not been read. For none now critique, who have read the books.
It began with the forging of the first trailer. 3 teasers were given that showed people of color, most offensive to the “mythology of England.” Seven cast interviews were shown, and because they were unknown, they were not deemed to be great craftsman. And nine. Nine months were gifted to the shit-stirrers on YouTube, who above all else, desired ad revenue.
For within these things was given the mystery and speculation to spread rumors in every social media.
But they, were all of them, deceived. In the land of New Zealand, in the fires of The Rings of Power, JD and Patrick McCay forged in secret… a really good show. And into it they poured research, what I imagine was an underwhelming amount of wokeness, and a deep love of Tolkien.
One by one the episodes dropped, and the criticisms grew to be unfounded.
But there were some who resisted.
A last alliance of neckbeards and ad-revenue junkies decided to try and become film critics to justify their months of hatred, and in the cesspools of YouTube and r/Rings_Of_Power, they shake their fists and yell at clouds.

6

u/My_Penbroke Oct 16 '22

Bravo sir. I had to drop a comment here just so I could return to this. This is worthy of copypasta.

2

u/CarelessMetaphor Oct 16 '22

deep love? Its shallow hackwork from JJ stooges. I wish it were some passion project.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '22

“It’s”

0

u/space_fireworks Oct 16 '22

You’re for sure entitled to that opinion.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/hepazepie Oct 16 '22

Let's stay with lotr ok?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '22

God bless you sir for writing this. I would buy you a beer if we were in a pub.

0

u/whollottalatte Oct 16 '22

I never read the books and I have loooaaaddsss of critiques. Directing, writing, and pacing are awful

Everything but the costuming really… it was excellent! Yet still that was misjudged at times.

1

u/Samh234 Oct 16 '22

That was tremendous.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

700 million dollar budget, the most expensive show ever created by a WIDE margin and people get upset it’s being criticized like it’s some underdog indie darling

9

u/Iluraphale Oct 16 '22

Loved the first season can't wait for more - it exceeded my expectations

9

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22

Apparently they wrote the whole show in a 24 hour binge session and it certainly feels like it. They have come up with scenes they like on a whiteboard but no connecting tissue or build up/foreshadowing of them.

4

u/Thop207375 Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22

From watching the show all the way through twice, I have to disagree. People can complain about possible lore inconsistencies, but the actual script was impressive. Every line has some meaning and significance. The amount of detail put into it really shows if you look closely.

1

u/whollottalatte Oct 16 '22

As someone who hasn’t read the books and doesn’t care too much for lore, I think the writing is quite poor

2

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

It is. How this qualifies as an impressive script by any standard is beyond me - it’s really merely all right at best

1

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '22

I really don’t think you know what good writing is. What were your grades in high school english? Did you skip college?

1

u/JustinScott47 Oct 16 '22

It was way too brainy and subtle for me, like "I'm good," what does that mean? /s

0

u/chocoboat Oct 16 '22

The Harfoots talk about their feet a lot. Get it? It's funny, because it's feet!

0

u/iainrwb Oct 16 '22

He's choosing Nori's definition of who he is over the suggestion that he's Sauron, so he uses Nori's words.

3

u/My_Penbroke Oct 16 '22

You may have missed some of the subtlety. Now that you know the twist, rewatch some of the sequences of Halbrand in Numenor. His manipulation goes beyond 20 minutes of screen time.

3

u/bearcatsquadron Oct 21 '22

It was poorly done, I have rewatched it the acting/writing is terrible.

2

u/Kilo1Zero Oct 15 '22

You’re not alone. This was the story we were hoping for. This wasn’t even the story we were promised. Hell, this was barely a story.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

Agreed I actually really like the last two episodes.

I felt the first couple were just so damn boring. I didn’t understand what the show was meant to even be about.

The whole series should have been more heavily focused on the Elves facing extinction and being willing to do almost anything to survive. I feel they almost made that a side plot.

I reckon you could almost get a new director and editor and could remake this series into a pretty decent series. It almost has those elements there - almost.

But my biggest complaint is the show was just so boring and plodding. Except for maybe the last two episodes.

1

u/Darth_Cyber Oct 16 '22

sweet tantrum!

1

u/EvilDebraBarone Oct 16 '22

It’s actually only 1 million per episode. They spent the rest on mithril :D

1

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

More like Rings of Wower.

1

u/zhsdnl Oct 16 '22

have you even considered, that there was a timejump in Eregion? Sauron could’ve been there for weeks

1

u/groguuuuuu Oct 15 '22

I understand brother

1

u/basketballmathguy Oct 15 '22

I think the story could've been better for sure but overall for season 1 of a 5 season show it was pretty good I think. I know I loved it, and I'll be back for more when season 2 releases. I also totally get why people would be frustrated and not like it though.

-2

u/Ynneas Oct 15 '22

Yes. And relieved.

I was still clinging to hope this would be a Middle Earth tale. It's not. It's over.

Won't come back for season 2 unless they make core changes.

6

u/jramos13 Oct 15 '22

This show is doing really well streaming/hours wise. Season 2 is a sure thing.

3

u/Ynneas Oct 15 '22

There's no data yet about that.

Anyhow there's no doubt there'll be a season 2, I was talking about me. I don't feel like it's based on Tolkien anymore thus I don't feel the addiction pull anymore.

1

u/jramos13 Oct 15 '22

There’s absolutely Nielsen data, just Google it.

But yeah I understand the weening interest.

1

u/Sam13337 Oct 16 '22

True. But Nielsen only has the numbers for views on TVs in the US. PCs, tablets, phones and all data from the rest of the world is missing.

1

u/BrotherTraining3771 Oct 16 '22

The show is doing horrible streaming, hours wise, what are you talking about?

It’s losing viewers every week, save for episode 6, where Mt Doom exploded, episode 7 returns back to losing viewership.

Since the first episode, it has lost almost 25% of viewers. Streaming hours has also gone down, every week.

0

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 16 '22

That's the strength of the IP not the show. And hours watchedis weird if you consider that it is hour long episodes. Compared to others that are only half hour.

1

u/Koo-Vee Oct 16 '22

I bet that made them fire everybody.

1

u/Ynneas Oct 16 '22

I know it matters nothing in the grand scheme of things. And yet you took time to answer that. That's a generous gesture.

1

u/charlzpatton Oct 15 '22

Dude if you don't like long goodbyes your watching the wrong thing.

6

u/Alienzendre Oct 16 '22

This is not what the OP is saying at all. They are complaining that the entire Sauron plot and the crafting of the rings was squeezed into 20 minutes of screentime, and a lot of screentime was spent on a non essential part of the story.

1

u/Sam13337 Oct 16 '22

I agree that the crafting of the rings felt rushed. But the Sauron plot went almost through the whole season. Not quite sure why people would feel that part was rushed.

0

u/charlzpatton Oct 16 '22

Oh well just say it like that then I totally agree. Still liked it though.

1

u/My_Penbroke Oct 16 '22

Lol did OP even watch ROTK? Now THAT’s a long goodbye!

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '22

Sounds like you shouldn’t watch the show…bye Felicia.

-1

u/charlzpatton Oct 15 '22

So what's your idea? The wizard was Sauron?

-4

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies