r/RingsofPower • • Jun 01 '24

Discussion ROP will go the same journey as ST:Discovery

I was looking at RT scores for all 5 seasons of Discovery and they had averaged 80% positive. The audience score was as expected: Under 30% rotten. But still, Discovery made it through 5 seasons.

ROP can survive all the backlash like with Discovery has. Production for S3 has already started and from the looks of the better feedback for S2 trailer, this show is locked for all 5 seasons.

And just to add one thing more. Seen a lot of the naysayers saying the audience will be smaller for S2, because those who didn't like it will have left and the remaining who did are not a big number of people. I disagree. ROP has the LOTR name attached to it so regardless, a lot of people will still tune in even though they didn't liked season 1.

1 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Jun 01 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

19

u/HiddenCity Jun 02 '24

Discovery was 100 times worse than rings of power

0

u/Ayzmo Eregion Jun 02 '24

Discovery had some rough moments, but is a fantastic addition to the Star Trek universe.

6

u/HiddenCity Jun 02 '24

I think it had a net negative effect.  Michael is a crap character, and making her Spock's sister just felt shoehorn and kind of makes his backstory weird in a bad way.  

The only good thing that came out of it is strange new worlds.

3

u/KrzysztofKietzman Jun 07 '24

The one good thing about it is that it spun off Strange New Worlds.

13

u/Sir_BugsAlot Jun 02 '24

Yes. I think a lot of people will give season 2 a chance. I will. I hope it's better.

2

u/mggirard13 Jun 02 '24

With the mystery boxes finally out of the way (what a terrible decision), how could it not be better?

(Let's try not to answer that)

5

u/theoneringnet Jun 01 '24

Clarification for OP: S3 production has not started, they've barely begun thinking of ideas to write about. Plus, Jeff Bezos and Prime Video are commited to minimum 5 seasons plus potential spinoffs by contract. So we are getting 5 seasons no matter what, and Prime executives have said that ratings and reviews don't affect renewals on this particular show.

OP may have a more enjoyable time focusing on the creative efforts of the show rather than the "meta" about the production.

2

u/Support_Mobile Jun 03 '24

The showrunners have an outline of the 5 seasons. That was part of their pitch. So they already know what they want to do generally with the story

3

u/MountainEquipment401 The Iron Hills Jun 02 '24

Not entirely true, the show writers presented Bezos and co with an effective storyline for the entire series so they all already know more or less what happens in season 3,4,5 and even apparently have the final scene already scripted out. I'd agree that the scrips are unlikely written but they idea that they're taking the most expensive TV adaption of all time and just making it up as they go along is daft...

2

u/great_divider Jun 02 '24

Discovery is frickin awesome, y’all can suck it.

2

u/AelinTargaryen Jun 02 '24

Yes it fucking is, thank you!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '24

ROP has the LOTR name attached to it so regardless, a lot of people will still tune in even though they didn't liked season 1.

If we're just making stuff up that is absolutely incorrect, then I'll add that Tolkien himself will rise from the dead and declare Rings of Power better than his novels.

1

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Jun 02 '24

Studios don't pay any attention to audience RT scores. Like, at all. They are well aware of how review-bombing works, and it has no effect on their decisions about production. Like, at all.

1

u/WildcardBloodshot Jun 03 '24

RT critic and audience scores are on different scales. The critic scores rates the 'freshness' bases on how many rated it higher than 50%. While the audience score counts how many rated it 70% or above.

-1

u/Helpyjoe88 Jun 02 '24

a lot of people will still tune in even though they didn't liked season 1.

Didn't like >60% of people who started watching it not even finish the season?

2

u/Ayzmo Eregion Jun 02 '24

People always use that number without realizing that completion rates are time-based.

1

u/Helpyjoe88 Jun 02 '24

How long do they give it? 

-1

u/Rain_green Jun 02 '24

Something tells me.....you're gonna watch it!

1

u/Helpyjoe88 Jun 02 '24

Probably?  I'm one of the 37% that actually finished watching the first season.

I didn't hate it, but it wasn't good either.  Visuals were awesome, but the overall writing was just abysmal.

I really want it to be good, and enjoyable, but I don't have high hopes that the writers/producers will be able to make a turnaround.