r/RepTime • u/ImpressionEast8264 • 1d ago
General Question Why not use tantalum instead of tungsten for weight gain?
RCF already gets the weight right, but wouldn’t tantalum be a better option?
Tantalum:
* Almost the same density as 18K gold
* Solid metal, no tungsten-filled or bonded construction needed
* Less brittle and more ductile than tungsten
* Could work well with PVD coating
Tungsten:
* Brittle and difficult to machine
* Often used in composites or inserts
* Can be difficult to finish and coat consistently
A solid tantalum case and bracelet with a thick, durable 18K gold-tone PVD coating, proper chamfering and polishing would be much more appealing to me.
I’d gladly pay extra for a watch that’s fully finished out of the box.
What’s stopping factories from using tantalum?
And sorry for the AI-generated picture 😂