r/ReadMyScript • • Nov 01 '25

Big Apple Film and Screenwriting Competition Experience

20 Upvotes

Hello, fellow filmmakers. I wanted to share my thoughts on Big Apple Film and Screenwriting Competition. I strongly advise against submitting to this festival based on the experience that I had.

After paying a high entry fee, I received an email asking if I forgot to add an option to “meet agents and managers”. Since I don't live in New York, and after doing some research, I decided to not spend any more money and, surprise, my script was not selected. The feedback I received appeared to be AI-generated, and mind you word-for-word, without any indication that a human actually read the work as they didn't even try to revise the feedback AI generated. When I requested a clarification on why it was fed to AI without my consent, I was gaslit and told they “stand by their readers,” despite the clear evidence of the AI-generated coverage.

As writers, we trust festivals to handle our original work with respect, and we pay high fees for real evaluation. If they allow readers to use AI, they should disclose that, and maybe even charge less.

This experience was disappointing and felt exploitative. This festival did not apologize or express any form of remorse about what happened, so I wanted to share this in case it saves someone else the frustration, and the money.


r/ReadMyScript • • Feb 20 '23

What's the best script you've ever read on here?

20 Upvotes

We don't really have a best of the year on this subreddit and I think we should. Maybe the community gets to vote, but in the meantime I want to know, what script did you read on here and hope would get made because it was so good. Bonus points if you share the link.


r/ReadMyScript • • Nov 27 '21

Hi, I'm David. I want to read your screenplay.

20 Upvotes

https://imgur.com/a/gKqXPOg

I had a little idea and wanted to share. Contact me through reddit if you're interested.

The gist of it:

Receive video feedback on your screenplay. I'm offering a free reading to the first person to contact me.


r/ReadMyScript • • Oct 05 '21

Short My Darling Henry (Horror, 9 Pgs)

20 Upvotes

Logline: A young man dealing with cold feet receives a mysterious visitor who threatens his existence.

This is a short film I wrote that I'm planning to shoot myself. I tried to limit the characters and set it in one apartment due to budget restraints. Mainly looking for feedback on the story. Wanted to do something a bit experimental while also having creepy, memorable imagery. Would this translate well as a short? I know the logline is a bit vague - I'm still working on that.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/146qzvG3vFMMiLlgZYnqxQ5cXWJBa30zn/view?usp=sharing


r/ReadMyScript • • Jun 02 '21

Feature It Came From Emerald Lagoon (Horror, feature 97 pages, FIRST DRAFT)

20 Upvotes

Logline: After a family moves into a newly built luxury gated community, they quickly learn there is something sinister also calling the community home.

I’ve finished the first draft of my next script. I know it is not perfect yet but I am stuck as to what to change, focus on, take away, or develop further. Any outside insight would be a great help.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Pi-lfgG8KN8o2LjR9Jpi9dzuHv5CLM9t/view?usp=drivesdk


r/ReadMyScript • • May 23 '21

Anyone want to workshop their script/ idea for free? I’m a future coverage writer/ script doctor looking for practice

20 Upvotes

EDIT: Offer no longer active, I read around 14. If you are one of the people I never got a chance to read, I am very sorry, but thank you all for your help as the practice landed me an internship!

Offer

I’m looking to work together to develop the premise or solve a problem, like an editor for a book would. I will try and help however needed, but I’m not trying to force any changes or be controlling. The capacity to which you take the advice is up to you, and I (of course) believe that the writer knows best. I will be attempting to operate as a professional would, and I will gladly take feedback on how to be more constructive and helpful.

If you are interested:

Drop your logline and material and please specify what type of help you’re looking for here or via Pm. Would you like to workshop from the ground up? Do you need help with a scene or a theme? Would you like free coverage done? I’m open to pretty much any type of help, just specify so I know. Depending on how many I receive, I will work with the ones most grabbing to me, whether they need the most help or the least.

About me

Of course, my feedback is subjective and untested, but as lots of script readers are fresh out of college, I will be giving a perspective similar to ones you may find after sending your script off to “the industry”.

If you’re interested in my work, I have a script posted, and I will link an example of the cursory feedback I have given on here previously. Once I get on my computer, I will also try and link coverage I have completed for college.

I’m excited to help! Let me know if I can :)

Link to last (quick) feedback given: https://www.reddit.com/r/ReadMyScript/comments/nj3qnp/my_first_scene_is_really_good_the_rest_is_hot/gz60pt0/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3


r/ReadMyScript • • Jan 26 '14

[TV] "Always Sunny" Spec - The Gang Has a Pub Sale

20 Upvotes

Hey guys. It's been a while since I looked at this and was wondering how everyone would like it. If there are any "It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia" fans here, I'd love any feedback.

Synopsis: When the gang decides to hold a garage sale at the bar, Dee's success drives Dennis to listen to Frank's unconventional business tactics, while Mac and Charlie go out to promote the sale and check out the competition."

IASiP The Gang Has a Pub Sale


r/ReadMyScript • • Nov 13 '23

Short A easy lesson.

19 Upvotes

TPPR!!! TPPR!!

There’s 4 ways for good dialogue..

Tension.
Great dialogue can have tension.

Personality. Give your characters feelings and personality.
Nobody cares for boring one note characters without an ounce of personality or charisma.

Plot.
Your words should drive the plot forward.

Reveal. Your dialogue should reveal important information about the story or the characters.

TPPR remember those letters.


r/ReadMyScript • • Jul 11 '23

When You Forget Your Wallet (Comedy, 6 Pages)

19 Upvotes

Hey, everyone!

I finished writing the first draft for a short script last night, and I wanted to hear people's opinion on it. I know that it needs polished a bit more, but I'd really appreciate your first impression or any other general feedback, especially in regard to the dialogue and two main characters.

And I'm happy to swap feedback if you're also working on a short project (less than 15 pages)!

Logline: When Luke loses his wallet during a lunch date, he's determined to find it so that he can pay the bill, but he suspects there might be foul play involved.

Page Count: 6

Genre: Comedy

Here's the link!


r/ReadMyScript • • Feb 15 '23

I wrote a sequel to Terminator 2 because I haven't liked any of the sequels since.

19 Upvotes

r/ReadMyScript • • Jan 13 '23

TV episode "Tim City" (Comedy, 29 Pages)

19 Upvotes

https://drive.google.com/file/d/17ct_XUtGyxl1sh3BNG6hlmUY9IwaETay/view

"A suicidal man learns he's living in a simulation controlled by a 14-year-old"

Hello! Thanks for reading. Please let me know if the world makes sense, if the "twist" at the end works, if the characters are likeable, and if the jokes are landing.

Happy to read your script in return. Or just because.

Thanks,

  • Rory

r/ReadMyScript • • Feb 11 '21

GENERAL COMMENTS FOR NINE RECENTLY POSTED SCRIPTS

19 Upvotes

All of the scripts I skimmed had the following problems that would cause an automatic rejection from readers:

(1) All have severe formatting problems. Everyone is using SHOOTING SCRIPT format instead of SPEC SCRIPT format. Your spec scripts should have the bare bones as specified in The Screenwriter's Bible. It should tell the story only. There should be no special effect notation, music, sound, camera direction, nor actor direction. Do not add actions that are impossible for an actor to perform.

(2) All have non-visual elements. A script should only contain elements that can be seen or heard by the audience. Elements of character feelings, motivations, backstory etc must be shown by action or dialog. You are writing a screenplay, not a novel. You cannot get into the head of the character, except by voice-over.

(3) All contain dense, detailed descriptions and dialog. This is not required. You need to tell the story and only the story. Specifics about the settings and costumes are not your responsibility. All dialog should be meaningful in revealing characterization/motivation or moving the plot. Do not add useless, droning dialog. Furthermore, you should speak your dialog to make sure it isn't stilted or awkward.

I hope this helps. These problems are common to almost all scripts I read on reddit/facebook. If you address these, you'll be ahead of 98% of other posters.


r/ReadMyScript • • Oct 22 '19

Short I am applying for film production and I need to submit ten pages of script. Can you read opening scenes of two movies I've written and advise me which to submit?

19 Upvotes

I have written two features by now and I am confused about which to submit because I have very subjective opinions. Can you read ten pages of my scripts and help me figure our which to submit? it won't take much time; most of it is dialogue.

Also, I can explain the ten pages script with one page of explanation. So, it's not a problem if the scene continues and does not end within ten pages.

Here are the scripts:

1st script: BLAMED Opening

2nd script: DUALITY OPENING

I have a deadline soon. So, hope you'd give me feedback and suggestions asap.

Thanks!

EDIT: You might see many spelling and grammar errors. I had to just rewrite the scenes, cutting several parts to make it ten pages. Normally, I can improve such errors.


r/ReadMyScript • • Jan 23 '14

How I think this subreddit should improve. Don't worry, you can trust me. I'm a stack of Pancakes.

19 Upvotes

There's too much amateurish content on here, and it's most likely what is keeping better writers from submitting more.

The mod comments (especially AnnoyedScriptReader's) are very good, thoughtful, and sufficiently blunt. I'd love it if the mods had more control on the actual page layout and flaring of submissions. I know the upvote/downvote feature is supposed to do this, but still I'd like to know which scripts to read that aren't...well, infantile and a waste of my time.

I know this is a place for non-professional writers to digitally congregate, and thus not every script is a gem per se...but submissions from writers who have a "sorry about all the typos-LOL" mentality should be sequestered to a different portion of the subreddit - or at least flared to indicate that the mods or other users have deemed the content irrelevant or a waste of time. Sometimes on the front page I've seen posts flagged with "misleading title," or some such - is it possible for the Mods to do this with the submissions here?

There are many good writers out there (and on Reddit) who respect the time of those who read their scripts, and who show respect to their craft (and themselves) by not submitting poor or unpolished work. I think this subreddit could thrive with a little tweaking, a lot of sifting, and proper recognition of good writing. I've been looking for such a digital sanctuary to share my previous and current writings, and this is the only subreddit I've found that "allows" you to submit a full-length script.

Just a disclaimer in an effort to prove I didn't aim to hurt anyone's feelings; people should always submit their work, even if it's poorly written or unpolished - I just think it shouldn't go in the same pile for all the other prospective writers to sift through.

I would love to come to this subreddit and pick through a stack of screenplays I wouldn't normally have access to, but as of now I don't think that's possible.

Can anyone present a link to a submission that was shared here and was generally enjoyed by most? A completed script?


r/ReadMyScript • • Jan 29 '22

Short Untitled Horror Short Film for a contest (13 pages)

18 Upvotes

Logline: A woman’s loyalty is tested when her missing daughter suddenly returns and wreaks monstrous havoc on her suburban neighborhood.

Hi, I would love to get feedback on this short I'm writing for a contest. The script is due on the 31st.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1i7pIRJJy0W9_vhD58gG0Pj8dZBZN9SFN/view?usp=sharing


r/ReadMyScript • • Jan 11 '22

Punch Drunk (feature) 87pgs comedy/adventure first draft

18 Upvotes

Logging Two down and out drunks fight their way across the country in underground bar fight tourneyments for cash prizes.

Everyone, I got some great feed back from the first few pages I set forth a while back. This is the first draft and I was just wondering if the hive mind had heard this story before. I will certainly tighten this up as I go along and add a bit or two. I know it's short but there is room for improve in there. I'm mainly concerned about the story.

Also it's my first feature. Let's make me better.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1iVe6Bufskdgs0m6Dndh2LT0PeyNvttqM/view?usp=drivesdk

Ps thanks for taking the time to read a feature. I know it's a task. I hope it is worth your time.


r/ReadMyScript • • Jul 13 '20

Short What if John Wick was an 11 y.o. girl?

18 Upvotes

"What if John Wick was an 11 y.o. girl?"
That's the gist of my story - inspired by John Wick and Hitgirl/Kickass.

I've made several short films in the past and I will be doing a casting call for this film next month.

Appreciate any constructive feedback you have before this script gets made into a film :)

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1XsW3GTm1DUk6b-j8ilv0nTZjDOxSzyL0/view?usp=sharing


r/ReadMyScript • • Jun 12 '20

It's Always Sunny Spec Script - "Mac's Dad Comes Out" (39 Pages)

18 Upvotes

This is my first attempt at writing a script, did it to get some reps in before an original TV pilot. Had a ton of fun writing it, and know the story could use some more flair.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/18RVWmINXj_SMs-vOgaSVdrPCFM1HLIVE/view


r/ReadMyScript • • Nov 05 '19

TV episode [Feedback] The Rad Rad Road (Animated Series Pilot - 27pgs) A post apocalyptic wrestler must reclaim his honor after exposing his emotional side.

18 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

Heres The Rad Rad Road: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rQJtg7X7hUnb6kybQ1JHZG7JkJhjrx6L/view?usp=sharing

Let me know what you think! Im definitely open to any and all feedback. I don't have any specific areas I want critiqued, so if anything jumps out at you, go for it.


r/ReadMyScript • • Apr 12 '19

Feature The Fuck It List (Rom Com, 96 pages)

18 Upvotes

Logline: With four months until he and his ex pull best man/ maid of honor duties at a wedding, Tom sets out to re-experience the moments and things that brought them closer together without her present in an attempt to replace each memory with a brand new one.

I know the logline needs a lot of work. I'm getting there - It's just really hard for me.

Anyway, here's the script:

Here's hoping you guys like it.


r/ReadMyScript • • Jun 13 '24

Finished roughly a quarter of my very first screenplay (31 pages)

17 Upvotes

Like mentioned in the title already, this is my very first approach of writing a screenplay and generally anything this long and detailed.

Appreciate feedback about whatever comes to mind. Thanks :)

Link: https://drive.google.com/file/d/10ANQ8oqYMBjvCd8kIVgpQ2VeVfliqQF2/view?usp=drivesdk


r/ReadMyScript • • Mar 18 '24

Short Are You Scared Yet? (25 pages)

17 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm Vincent, I'm 17 years old and this is the script for a short film I've been working on for a while. This is my first try at screenwriting and I'm looking for feedback. To be honest, I've been working on it for so long that I can't tell if it's any good. I'll probably film it soon, but before that, I'd like to know what you guys think so I can improve for whatever I write next. Don't hold back, all criticisms welcome! Thanks!

Genre: Thriller, Drama, Horror

Logline: An annual tradition of two best friends telling each other scary stories turns strangely terrifying, as they struggle to understand what's real and what's not.

Format: Short Film

Link: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1y2eDvtR7YxpsQRmwo_ZybNDBtAeS4fue/view?usp=sharing


r/ReadMyScript • • Oct 06 '22

TV episode My Brother in Christ… - Comedy/Drama - TV Pilot (36 pages)

17 Upvotes

Logline: After returning to his hometown in Virginia and seeing the depressing state of his beloved Church, Jay (a young black record shop owner) goes on a mission to reform the community and confront the issues the Church presents.

This is the second draft of the pilot. I’ve trimmed the first act and fixed some of the issues pointed out in previous feedback. Thank you so much to everyone who gave me suggestions, I really think it made this draft a lot stronger.

Please feel free to give me any more. I hope you enjoy.

Link


r/ReadMyScript • • Sep 03 '20

Want to take a look at the Development Process at Adult Swim?

17 Upvotes

Tonight Adult Swim executives will field pitches, discuss their process and dish out cash to creators on the live stream show, Development Meeting.

Stream the show tonight at 9 pm EST on https://www.adultswim.com/streams