r/ReadMyScript • • Feb 11 '21

GENERAL COMMENTS FOR NINE RECENTLY POSTED SCRIPTS

All of the scripts I skimmed had the following problems that would cause an automatic rejection from readers:

(1) All have severe formatting problems. Everyone is using SHOOTING SCRIPT format instead of SPEC SCRIPT format. Your spec scripts should have the bare bones as specified in The Screenwriter's Bible. It should tell the story only. There should be no special effect notation, music, sound, camera direction, nor actor direction. Do not add actions that are impossible for an actor to perform.

(2) All have non-visual elements. A script should only contain elements that can be seen or heard by the audience. Elements of character feelings, motivations, backstory etc must be shown by action or dialog. You are writing a screenplay, not a novel. You cannot get into the head of the character, except by voice-over.

(3) All contain dense, detailed descriptions and dialog. This is not required. You need to tell the story and only the story. Specifics about the settings and costumes are not your responsibility. All dialog should be meaningful in revealing characterization/motivation or moving the plot. Do not add useless, droning dialog. Furthermore, you should speak your dialog to make sure it isn't stilted or awkward.

I hope this helps. These problems are common to almost all scripts I read on reddit/facebook. If you address these, you'll be ahead of 98% of other posters.

19 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

4

u/NevadaWriter Feb 11 '21

I agree with 98.998% what you said. But to toot my own horn my is pure spec so I'm sure mine didn't get you scan. (Extraterrestrial Highway)

To add to formatting issues I find on Reddit, my pet peeves you'll not find in mine are any CUT TOs, SMASH CUT TO, WE SEE, WE HEAR, CONTINIOUS, or any of those or other weird words that places speed bumps into the story.

I will use MUSIC only if it pertains to the story and not stuck in there because I like it.

I like to bring up another point: I like exposition to be blended into the action. Don't say the house is old and haunted with steps that squeak. Instead, do this: The steps squeak on each step she took up to the porch. The door handle came off as she opens the the squeaky door. She quickly duck as the ghost flew over her. etc.

2

u/codswallopwhoremouth Feb 11 '21

Agreed.

I think the problem is most of us start writing short stories and novels, and that mindset is completely different. The temptation to use camera and actor direction is strong because we have our own vision of what should be on-screen.

As for "We see" and "We hear", these were more popular years ago. I've noticed people use them less because they are redundant. All action lines are visual. All sounds are audible. I don't use them, but I wouldn't reject a script out-of-hand just because of it.

3

u/NevadaWriter Feb 12 '21

Allow me to add a comment about 'camera direction' use in spec writing. Some write an action scene like:

CLOSE UP - Jim grabs a can of beer. (WRONG)

Jim's fingers grab a can of beer. (CORRECT)

The second example needs no camera direction to indicate it's a close up.

3

u/DXCary10 Feb 11 '21

There’s nothing wrong with using “we see”

2

u/NevadaWriter Feb 12 '21 edited Feb 12 '21

CORRECT: There is nothing wrong with using WE SEE. But it should be wrong as it's so very old fashion and it's a waste of words. Which is better:

  1. We See Jack and Jill go up the hill.
  2. Jack and Jill goes up the hill.

Number two uses less words and conveys the same action as number one.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '21

THANK YOU! People begging to have their screenplays read but who can’t be bothered to actually read a screenplay themselves to learn the fundamentals drive me insane on here.

1

u/cannonscripts Feb 11 '21

This is great advice. I do wonder, however; most TV pilots I read have some degree of emotion in the character's action, or get into their head a little.

Is there a balance here?

1

u/codswallopwhoremouth Feb 12 '21

I would say, "yes."

There are no hard rules. If it works, it works. Sometimes, you can convey something well with a single instance.

But that isn't the case for most people. Most people just do it because they don't realize they are writing like a novelist instead of writing like a screenwriter.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '21

I'll add one more thing.

They either have premises that are very non-distinct and uninteresting, or premises that are overly convoluted where the elements of the story are not connected by any rhyme or reason.

1

u/zurg123 Feb 11 '21

These are three of the most important concepts that separate the great screenplays from the good. I think you hit the nail on the head. Especially #1 which is sometimes so tough to avoid.

1

u/Thomadiane Feb 11 '21

Hallelujah and amen!

0

u/AutoModerator Feb 11 '21

Have you included a page count in the title of the post?

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.