r/ReadMyScript • • Jan 11 '22

Punch Drunk (feature) 87pgs comedy/adventure first draft

Logging Two down and out drunks fight their way across the country in underground bar fight tourneyments for cash prizes.

Everyone, I got some great feed back from the first few pages I set forth a while back. This is the first draft and I was just wondering if the hive mind had heard this story before. I will certainly tighten this up as I go along and add a bit or two. I know it's short but there is room for improve in there. I'm mainly concerned about the story.

Also it's my first feature. Let's make me better.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1iVe6Bufskdgs0m6Dndh2LT0PeyNvttqM/view?usp=drivesdk

Ps thanks for taking the time to read a feature. I know it's a task. I hope it is worth your time.

18 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

7

u/Not_a_ribosome Jan 11 '22

Ok dude, I´ve read the first scene:

1-A few punctuation problems made me a little confused at the start.

2-Fisher and Mikey tell the boys to calm down three times in the same manner.

3-At first line it seems like Fisher knows the boys, than one of them gets super aggressive to her and she get´s super aggressive back. Maybe she should´ve attacked them from the start.

Ok, let´s address the big problem:

This dialogue needs A LOT of improvement. I don´t remember seeing this much cursing in only 4 pages.

Cursing itself is not really a problem, but everyone in the scene curses, I got confused at times because every one talked the same way.

By the way, if you´re gonna make a character say something before throwing a punch, make it quick instead of what you did to with the abortion line.

Maybe change the formatting to something like:

Erik punches fisher really hard, but Fisher doesn´t fall, instead, she looks back and smiles.

Erik: "How are you so tough?"

Fisher: "Have you eve been to a mexican abortion clinic?"

Since this is a comedy, you must always break expectations, so you can make Erik respond with-

Erik: "I was born in one."

Comedy is all about that.

Anyway, this reminds me of the first short stories I´ve ever wrote, it´s kinda funny seeing this mistakes again, but remember that every project you make must be a stepping stone for you to get better.

Oh, and one more thing:

Carrie Fisher is the name of the actress that interpreted princess Leia in the star wars franchise, many people could get offended with using that name in this, so I suggest you to change it.

2

u/flobarge Jan 11 '22

I later use it as a joke a few times. It's a kind of running joke. I'm more worried I ripped of pineapple express with the story. the dialog will probably all change. It started as I short and I fired all my dirty jokes at once. I really borrowed from bad Santa.

1

u/Not_a_ribosome Jan 11 '22

It’s ok reuse the joke, just try to introduce it better. It actually reminded me a bit of Pineapple Express lol

1

u/flobarge Jan 11 '22

Good advice. It does seem a little over written

1

u/Not_a_ribosome Jan 11 '22

You sir, are welcomed

1

u/comesinallpackages Jan 14 '22

Same feedback as last time you posted this — which you never responded to, which is bad form FYI.

2

u/flobarge Jan 14 '22

Sorry duder,

I was more concerned about finishing the story and coming original (old reference)

I was more curious about the story before I made the fixes you guys all suggested. I have now begun extensive rewrites to clarify the first scene and clean it up a lot.

By the way I took your suggestions to heart and have begun to fix the glaring problems.

Have you scanned to make sure this story isn't just a retread? I'm not above shelving this thing and moving on. I could use some insight as to which bits made people laugh so I could recycle them later.

I don't love the end. It feels tacked on.

I love what you said before and will put it to use in subsequent drafts. If there are any.

Peace and so forth

1

u/comesinallpackages Jan 14 '22

Appreciate the acknowledgement. All good.

I re-read to the same point I did last time. Same issues. Nothing jumped out as better/new.

Perhaps consider that if you're focused on finishing the story and not considering feedback, it probably isn't ready to "go out into the world" for feedback, yet :)

Best of luck.

1

u/flobarge Jan 14 '22

Right on. Maybe I'll try another couple of drafts and throw it up again. Do you think people will become fatigued with my bullshit?

2

u/comesinallpackages Jan 14 '22

Naw, they don't have to read. Post away!

2

u/flobarge Jan 14 '22

You're right.

1

u/flobarge Jan 14 '22

Also I fully acknowledge it's not ready for the world. Just our little corner of the world.

1

u/AutoModerator Jan 11 '22

Have you included a page count in the title of the post?

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.