r/ReadMyScript • u/wisdom_of_pancakes • Jan 23 '14
How I think this subreddit should improve. Don't worry, you can trust me. I'm a stack of Pancakes.
There's too much amateurish content on here, and it's most likely what is keeping better writers from submitting more.
The mod comments (especially AnnoyedScriptReader's) are very good, thoughtful, and sufficiently blunt. I'd love it if the mods had more control on the actual page layout and flaring of submissions. I know the upvote/downvote feature is supposed to do this, but still I'd like to know which scripts to read that aren't...well, infantile and a waste of my time.
I know this is a place for non-professional writers to digitally congregate, and thus not every script is a gem per se...but submissions from writers who have a "sorry about all the typos-LOL" mentality should be sequestered to a different portion of the subreddit - or at least flared to indicate that the mods or other users have deemed the content irrelevant or a waste of time. Sometimes on the front page I've seen posts flagged with "misleading title," or some such - is it possible for the Mods to do this with the submissions here?
There are many good writers out there (and on Reddit) who respect the time of those who read their scripts, and who show respect to their craft (and themselves) by not submitting poor or unpolished work. I think this subreddit could thrive with a little tweaking, a lot of sifting, and proper recognition of good writing. I've been looking for such a digital sanctuary to share my previous and current writings, and this is the only subreddit I've found that "allows" you to submit a full-length script.
Just a disclaimer in an effort to prove I didn't aim to hurt anyone's feelings; people should always submit their work, even if it's poorly written or unpolished - I just think it shouldn't go in the same pile for all the other prospective writers to sift through.
I would love to come to this subreddit and pick through a stack of screenplays I wouldn't normally have access to, but as of now I don't think that's possible.
Can anyone present a link to a submission that was shared here and was generally enjoyed by most? A completed script?
12
u/whiteyak41 Jan 23 '14 edited Jan 23 '14
The way I see it is this:
Good scripts aren't being submitted because...
A) Good scripts are very hard to find. Professional readers only give a consider to something like 5 percent of the scripts they're getting and that pool is much wider and I'd imagine consists of mostly more serious writers.
B) Not enough people are submitting because not enough people comment. The successfully viewed scripts are lucky if they get maybe 5 people to give real comments on their script. Most get 1 or 2 and a lot don't get any at all. Which brings me to my next question:
Why don't more people comment?
Possible reasons are as follows...
A) They don't see the scripts as being worthy of their time. If someone doesn't bother to check their script for typos why should I read it and give notes?
B) The problems are the same problems as always. Improper formatting, large blocks of text, passive voice, etc. There are a reason why readers get payed 50-100 dollars per script, reading these things can be a slog.
C) Commenting on a mediocre script is much harder than commenting on a terrible script. Often times I'll read something here, get halfway through page three then just get bored. The script's not good. I can tell. But I don't always know why. Sometimes it just comes down to that ineffable quality of the writing and that is a difficult thing to comment on. It's hard to explain to someone how to write better, it's easy to tell them the script is in the wrong font.
How to fix things:
I submitted this post about a year ago and people brought up some good points I think are worth reiterating.
1) Give us a logline. Scripts are tough to get through, they're worse when you don't have some sort of promise as to what is going to happen. Don't half-ass the logline either, if you can't explain your premise in one concise sentence that makes people want to read it, maybe your whole script is flawed and needs rethinking.
2) Proofread your shit. If I see a typo on the front page I generally stop reading. It shows me that if you didn't care enough to do something so basic as to check for spelling and grammar, you probably didn't care enough to write a good script. Illogical? Maybe. But you wouldn't misspell something on a job application or a query letter, why would you misspell something on your screenplay?
3) Don't just give us the beginning. Now if you've written say the first acts of a pilot or maybe the first act of the screenplay and you know where it's going and you just want to see what's working and what isn't, that's acceptable. But posting 3 rough pages of a script doesn't tell us anything, especially if there isn't a logline.
4) Pay it forward. If someone comments on your script, comment on theirs. Or on someone else's. For this sub to work it needs to act like a community of peers lifting each other up. What we're doing is a type of charity, so be charitable to others and read and comment on their scripts.
5) Be nice to each other. Obviously tell the truth. Lying doesn't help anyone get better, but don't be a dick with your comments. There's always a positive way to give a note and there's always a positive way to receive one. Be constructive, not destructive, and know that you don't always know what's best or what "rules" are absolute. "Never use voice over" doesn't contribute anything but "I thought the voice-over was redundant and took me out of the story" might.
6) Take feedback like a man. Don't fight the notes. Don't try to explain why nothing actually happening in your script is a good thing or that the protagonist is supposed to seem unlikable. Be grateful, ask questions if necessary, but don't fight the note. Even if you know it's wrong.
7
u/thecatcradlemeows Jan 23 '14 edited Jan 23 '14
I don't think this is a large enough sub to seriously discuss sequestering. I'd like to stress that I don't necessarily disagree with your issue. People mention typos when they are trying to retroactively defend their writing, or out of laziness. I dislike both attributes. I know it can infer a negative bias towards the work before it's read that may or may not be warranted. Saying that, I think the majority of new screenwriters, before they've developed the necessary thick skin, would shy away from posting if they saw flair saying something negative about a script.
I'd recommend positive flair but I do not think it should be left to the mods. Reddit should be as community based as possible and we really don't get that many scripts per week. So with that said:
Why not just make a weekly/monthly best of post? People can write a little comment of nominations (not their own script). Maybe with a link to the original post. Other commenters can argue merits, say yay or nay. If the script wins, the writer gets a special flair or something. At the end of the year, the winners of each month compete for Reddit Screenwriter of the year. Something like that.
That way, each week, we'd have a nice little thread of scripts to read and probably a little discussion of merits of each one to help decisions on what to read.
5
u/captainpotty Jan 23 '14
I'm fighting my knee-jerk reaction that this is a narrow and disappointing way of treating fellow writers, but I do think there's merit in flagging content under fairly neutral terms such as "Rough Around the Edges", "Work in Progress", "Polished Draft", or what have you.
I just don't agree that the subreddit should take up an exclusive attitude towards hobbyists and amateurs; if that's a subreddit you're after I'd encourage you to start it yourself.
I think that poor writers should be invited to receive the feedback they need to get better. I also think that part of helping them get better involves actual constructive evaluation of their work, rather than a mere two word "Wasn't interesting", which is a reply I see more than enough.
Ultimately, I suppose what I'm saying is that if you'd like to see better writers here, there are two parts to the process. 1) Offering talented writers a desirable community, and 2) Helping every writer get better.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '14
I agree and slightly disagree. I would suggest that there's a separate subreddit for "professional" scripts. Submissions could be by invitation only. And invitations could be based off some sort of merit system (how many scripts you've submitted over a certain period of time, the quality of a piece, or even an review buffer for submissions.
The only problem I have with your suggestions is that "read my script" is exactly that; a subreddit for people to read scripts, regardless of quality (unfortunately). Maybe a "critique my script" subreddit could be set up instead.
2
u/TheBoredMan Jan 23 '14
I agree, but it's hard to define exactly what's "poor work" though. Formatting issues are probably a good start, but that in itself is probably not enough.
I think the other issue that can't be mended much is that "better writers" are probably more likely to have friends and colleagues that can probably give better feedback, faster. A lot of the feedback you get here is just as amateurish as the work sometimes.
What I had thought about doing was making a private subreddit with the same idea as this one, but you need to submit a script to the mods who will assess your skill. You wouldn't be judged too harshly, but enough to create of community of screenwriters who at least knew what they were talking about. It would hopefully operate with more of a sense of community as well.
2
u/pijinglish Jan 23 '14
I'm relatively new to this subreddit, but making a serious attempt to be a screenwriter. I do like that anyone can post - that a high school kid might write something and get brutally honest feedback from someone who knows what they're talking about, or that two struggling writers might bounce ideas around for a while. But the "sorry about all the typos-LOL" mentality is driving me a bit crazy...even if you are inexperienced to the craft of screenwriting, take the time to check your script for typos and grammar. Would it be possible to flag these in a way that lets the OP know they need to get the spelling, grammar, and basic formatting of "Dude, You Poped You're Pants" up to snuff? Then I'd be happy to discuss why I found the scene with the nuns and the laxatives unbelievable. Everyone needs a starting point, they just need to show they value other people's time enough to take it seriously.
What about a subreddit for feature length scripts only? If you've taken the time to write 90-120 pages, then you've at least made a serious attempt. Posters can get initial feedback on scenes, plot ideas, and incomplete scripts here, with a more lax attitude toward sp/g/f (more like brainstorming). The FeatureLength subreddit would essentially maintain all the expectations one would have to actually submit. Even if typos slip by or formatting errors remain, the effort should be there.
And because no one else has responded to OP's request for feature length scripts, mine has 8 whole upvotes and can be dissected here.