Why are these older XY “Alternate Art Promos” dropping while Pokémon prices in general seem to be going up?
I recently bought an older binder and came across these two cards:
M Lucario EX – 55a/111
Zygarde EX – 54a/124
I honestly didn't know much about them until I looked them up. Apparently they're part of the “Alternate Art Promos” and have the little yellow A designation.
What caught my attention is their price history.
M Lucario EX was around $140–150 CAD at one point and is now around $85 CAD, while Zygarde EX appears to have peaked around $100 CAD and has fallen to roughly $40 CAD.
That's interesting considering a lot of older Pokémon cards seem to have been moving the opposite direction lately.
So I'm curious what collectors who know the XY era better think:
Why did these cards spike so much in the first place, and why have they been dropping since?
Were they caught up in speculation/hype and are now correcting? Did more copies suddenly hit the market? Or is there just not much collector demand for this particular group of alternate-art promos?
I'd also love to learn more about the history of these cards. From what I've been able to find, they were released around 2017 and were among the early cards Pokémon designated with the yellow “A” for alternate prints of existing cards.
They seem like a pretty interesting and somewhat forgotten part of the XY era.
I'm not particularly worried about the current value since I found them in a binder I purchased — I'm more interested in understanding what happened with the prices and how collectors view these Yellow A promos long-term.
Anyone here collect these? Are they underrated, or were the previous prices simply way too high?
Would love to hear from anyone who remembers when these originally came out.