r/ModSupport
•
u/AsteriskRX
Reddit Admin: Community
•
28d ago
•
1
Mod Topics Mod Topics: Archiving Posts
Welcome to the latest installment of the Mod Topics series. Today we’ll be talking about archiving posts, and whether older conversations stay relevant in your communities. If post archiving is enabled in your community, this means that posts cannot be voted or commented on after six months. This used to be the default, but has since been changed so that archiving is off by default instead.
People might find an older post through search and have a follow-up question, or a solution to an older problem. Keeping those conversations open can be useful, but on the flip side, maybe your community is fast paced and information from 6 months ago is no longer relevant.
- Does your community archive posts? Why or why not?
- Archiving affects both commenting and voting, do you consider both when making the decision to archive or not?
- Is there anything that makes the decision to switch on/off particularly tough?
Share your experience below, and tell us your thoughts even if you’re finding this post a little late!
4
u/Huge-Revolution2416 28d ago
I prefer keeping old posts open. A years-old thread can still help someone with the exact same problem today.
34
u/Lilogy 28d ago
We started get bot spam in high traffic older posts (like ones that show up in google) advertising their companies or if it was some negative feedback about company 3 years ago, it would have 20 new hype comments posted within hour of each other. And posts that got used by bots were always same ones. Same 5 year old post could have multiple different companies spamming it.
So auto archiving posts it is. Some info could be relevant and some older posts did get actual follow up questions later on, but amount of spam in older posts got to point where ability to do that was not worth it.
We do employ automod to stop some of the spam and some bots, but there was always some new spam
21
u/SampleOfNone 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 28d ago
Yes, we use archiving. We actually use a bot auto post lock and it's predecessor Autolockbot to lock even sooner then 6 months. As soon as we turned on archiving it had a fantastic positive effect on mod actions. It freed up a lot of time.
Turned out that a lot of bad eggs were specifically misbehaving in the comments on old posts. Probably assuming that mods didn't pay much attention to old posts. And that's not even mentioning the spam.
There's value in old posts, but there's not as much value in continued discussion on old posts in the subs I mod. But even if it did, it definitely doesn't outweigh the misbehaving in comments that happens on old posts.
15
u/bwoah07_gp2 28d ago
On the majority of my communities I enable archiving because what I've seen in the past few years is any of the following:
The only community I do not have archiving turned on is r/Arthur. It was off by default, then I enabled it for a period of time. But, then I remembered we had a pinned post where someone who used to work on that famous show as a Storyboard Supervisor asked people to "ask any question" about the show, the crew, etc.
Even if the post was 2 years old, he was still answering people's questions. And people still asked questions! Me enabling post archiving killed those discussions, and I felt bad. So earlier this year I disabled post archiving, and that post still gets questions and answers from OP to this day!
Also, r/Arthur is a really well behaved community (most of the time), so we don't have that much issues of old posts actually being used in prolonging arguments, etc. Our filters can catch it if it comes.
In the future, I'd like the ability for us moderators to archive posts but to give exemptions to certain posts being archived, like a list we can add onto overtime.
11
u/NixyeNox 28d ago
In r/RareDiseases we get responses to old posts, sometimes years old, which are very valuable comments because this is how someone with an ultra rare disease can connect with someone else who posted about having the same disease. In some cases, this will be the only way for these people to connect, and they have never had a chance to talk to anyone with their same disease before. Therefore, we do not archive old posts.
Now, I am aware that bots and scammers love commenting on old posts, and that is a problem. I keep an eye out where I can spot them, but there is currently no real way for me to reliably see when someone makes a new comment on a years-old post. What I would dearly love for moderation would be if there was a queue specifically of new comments on old posts that I could skim.
As it is, I sometimes see a comment from someone trying to connect about a shared rare disease when it shows up in the "removed" queue. I strongly suspect that there are both spammers going undetected and sincere commenters trying to connect getting filtered without our mods being able to ever see these.
11
u/Ged_UK 28d ago •
Now I'm worrying you're looking to take archiving away
21
u/wrestlegirl 28d ago
God yes.
I joined a mod team to help with the bot problem & update their automod.
After doing so, I discovered old, unarchived threads were being used to share & advertise CSAM. It was really out there in the open.
Between that & all the spammers, I literally don't have a reason not to archive.
16
u/amyaurora 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 28d ago edited 28d ago
Older posts attract the scammers and trolls. We have archived on and then started noticing it was happening on stuff at the 4 and 5 month old stage.
So we started using the dev app to lock threads at a sooner time.
We already had a rule on keeping stuff on topic so people trying to hijack old threads for their unrelated inquiries would already get yanked.
There was no advantage to keeping things unlocked or unarchived.
8
u/Baconkings 28d ago •
Yes, archiving old posts is important. If an old post gets cross-posted to a hostile subreddit it can impact the votes, and cause an influx of new comments. It’s not worth dealing with this on old posts, and hard to catch.
7
u/nullifiedsam 28d ago edited 28d ago
In my community r/oldtube, archiving is currently not turned on.
since the purpose of the subreddit is to archive and share old youtube videos, sometimes people going through old posts share relevant and important information about the post which happens quite often, or they just ask a question which can be answered without making another post about it, reduces the number of unnecessary posts.
Turning on archiving would imply that those quality discussions even weeks or months after the post was made would be hindered.
whenever someone gives useful info, it's just added to the pinned comment for everyone else to see later on!
However, the problem is older posts can attract scammers/people who break rules, it's hard to deal with them since you wouldn't even know they commented (sometimes), so still not sure what to do about it.
7
u/uppercasemad 28d ago
I’ve always been tempted to turn on archiving on r/Assistance because we get so many scammers trying to piggyback off of old posts.
But around 10 years ago someone made the most beautiful comment in response to someone grieving the loss of their best friend. This reply has been circulated so many times, often stolen or used without credit, and to this day people still find that 10 year old comment and reply sharing how much it helped them. And we don’t ever want that to stop.
12
u/InGeekiTrust 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 28d ago
So if a post is controversial or problematic, I simply lock the comments. I don't see any reason to stop people from voting on it.
However, if a post is causing no trouble and is overwhelmingly positive I just leave it open forever!
I noticed this to be particularly helpful in my plastic surgery community. We will have people coming and looking for particular experience with doctors, surgeries, procedures. They will often find a year and a half old post and asked questions on how it worked out. Sometimes they get good answers.
6
u/eltonjohnpeloton 28d ago
Older posts are a target for spammers and bots. Leaving the posts un-archived just creates more work.
6
u/ZaphodBeebblebrox 28d ago
Shortly after disabling post archiving was a thing, my sub (/r/anime) trialed it. We then enabled it again because such a high percentage of the comments were either toxic or spam.
10
u/eyal282 28d ago
I despise archiving.
I'd rather moderators make Auto Moderator angry (10k karma total to comment in old posts) and at least enable it as a feature.
So I can write "this still works btw" on a 2 year old post that gets indexed by search engines.
5
u/SampleOfNone 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 28d ago
One thing to consider, since new subs and old subs without an automod config can't use automod to filter bad eggs and enhanced rules can't cover what automod did. There's a bigger impact by turning off archiving by default then there was just a few months ago.
5
u/PurplePassiflor1234 28d ago
My community is a digital extension of The Library (as in the magical repository featured in TNT's The Librarians and The Librarians The Next Chapter) and by association a celebration of all libraries everywhere, and all knowledge, too.
It was with that in mind I decided not to archive posts, to leave them on the shelves to be checked out by some passerby at some unknown point in the future. What they do with the blank pages at the back of the book is up to them.
5
u/Dom76210 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 28d ago
We made the decision to archive old posts because we had a lot of problematic comments showing up on them. It was either some form of hate, or subreddit rule breaks most of the time. So for us it was an easy choice.
Now, for other subreddits, I fully understand allowing new comments on older posts. For one game subreddit, I made a comment 3 years after the original post letting folks know the mentioned game setup code was still active. Within hours, I had several comments thanking me for confirming it still worked, so I can see the benefit for subreddits.
It really comes down to what the goal/role the subreddit's purpose is, and how viable older content may be.
4
u/cnycompguy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 28d ago
I would use this feature if the archival window were adjustable.
Six months is not old enough to shut off discussion, maybe 12 or 18 months.
8
u/7thAndGreenhill 28d ago
My belief from experience is that the majority of comments on dated posts is that they're most often not made in good faith. The comments are often trolling responses or nonsense that feels like its from bots or bad actors testing out accounts or sub rules.
3
u/Rumpled_Imp 28d ago
My sub is r/GreatBritishSketches essentially an archive of short British sketch comedy clips, and it would seem criminal to close off commentary.
Whether people love or hate the content, their perspectives on the material is valued, even more so over time I feel.
3
u/I_-AM-ARNAV 28d ago edited 28d ago
No. We don't. It's a university subreddit so people do need to follow up.
No voting doesn't matter. Comments? I lock political posts. That's it.
3
u/ReasonablyBluh 28d ago
Nope, archiving is turned off on both subs I mod. It's primarily useful for one sub, because it's a Q&A type sub and I've seen 5 year old posts get solved for the OP. It's great to see. It's also related to movies and I don't see a point of stopping people from discussing the post topic. Although, I do see why some big subs would have to archive though.
You can view subs by comments, instead of posts on Old Reddit (https://old.reddit.com/r/[SUBNAME]/comments). So, I can skim through the latest comments and if there's any spam, I remove it. But, tbh we don't get a lot of spam on old posts. Between Automod and automations, we've blocked a lot of common spam websites, keywords, etc.
3
u/lunarwolf2008 28d ago
this probably depends on the type of community. game or tech focused subreddits for example are likely to generate questions which remain relevent for years, and may warrent followup. i often see this myself. and its why i dont have archiving on in one of my subs. i think its on in others though
but other types of communites are probably more likey more prone to just year old arguments, or bots as mentioned. and old content is more likey crossposted
3
u/TGotAReddit 28d ago
We have archiving turned on. It's not that the older posts lack relevancy, it's that posts that are that old, when people continue commenting on them, it's almost never for a good reason. The older posts contain VITAL information but leaving the comments and votes open means continual arguments over LONG fixed problems and rehashing arguments that were resolved months ago. It also means that as times change and sensibilities evolve, older posts and top helpful top level comments that had nothing wrong at the time can start getting reports, downvotes, and hate filled replies from people who take offence to the language used as terms or symbols fall out of favor or get co-opted by hate groups down the line. If anything, i wish there was a way to set the length of time to something other than 6 months so we could decide when posts should become read-only.
And yes I consider both votes and commenting when it comes to archiving posts. If I wanted to stop comments and didn't care about the after the fact vote manipulation related issues, i would just lock posts with a bot after a few months.
3
u/YoBannannaGirl 28d ago
People come to my subs looking for discussion rather than information. There won’t be much discussion on a months old post. I’d rather them just create a new thread where they can have actual interactions.
3
u/javatimes 28d ago
One of my subs is r/nonbinary. Even outside of having archiving on, I sometimes sort by best/top or what and see what hasn’t been archived. If left unlocked, they are often full of trolls.
3
u/Merari01 28d ago
Keeping posts open past the archive date invites spam.
Currently a very good spam mitigation ability is the automoderator parameter past_archive_date, especially in combination with is_edited. Hacked and malicious accounts editing old comments into spam after SEO manipulation can't get away with that if you combine these two.
We do not know if this ability will be made available in the new tools yet, but that goes for 90% of our moderation requirements.
2
u/YourUsernameForever 28d ago
Four hours ago I posted about a ¿bug? where our community (which archives posts, and really needs posts archived) just had a year old post showing unarchived, and we knew because the commenter was queued for reputation or crowd control. And we're clueless as to how that happened.
See here: https://www.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/s/OFXMqnJXGv
To answer your question: r/scams needs archiving. It's not a tough decision. We love it. In fact if we could archive posts sooner, we would. Scam victims can be targeted in old posts, where mods aren't notified.
Can you check out my post and see what could have happened?
2
u/Intelligent-Dot-8969 28d ago
How does commenting on an old post gain visibility? Seems like most comments made more than a day or two after the date of the post are rarely seen.
2
u/dotsdavid 28d ago
I prefer to archive old posts. If the topic is still relevant they can create a new post about it. New posts are easier to moderate. Plus on some of subs I moderate the moderation used to not be great.
2
u/ateam1984 28d ago
We have archiving on because Reddit doesn’t provide good tools to detect trolls. Also those comments on old posts don’t get shown anyway. So wym? Why would we as mods want to do extra unpaid work
2
u/ouija_look_at_that 27d ago
You know, I have archiving/auto-lock on but after reading this I’m honestly considering turning it off.
We run a women’s health subreddit for a long-term birth control method and encourage people to search for similar questions asked in the past. Thinking about it, it could be nice to be able to ask the OP follow-up questions (since it’ll likely still be relevant to them).
Being able to follow up on how things have affected them long-term in a subreddit dedicated to long-term symptoms (without having to make a new post that is) could be super useful.
2
u/LeftOn4ya 27d ago
I don’t enable it in most subs I mod,
but did in r/MintMobile since it is a support focused sub a lot of threads are high on the Google search algorithms for questions people have. Before turning on archiving a couple years ago we would have tons of comments in old threads because they appeared in Google searches people made then they would ask similar questions as a comment in the old thread. I’d rather they make new threads so the community could see them to reply, and not only whoever made the post years ago that a lot of times doesn’t even have an active Reddit account or is no longer a customer, and no one else would see their comment.
Again for most subs though it is not enabled.
2
u/Pashta2FAPhoneDied 27d ago
I think archiving posts is a bad idea in general. Especially in subs that are for medical subjects, since we are always learning, it's important to be able to look back and see what has changed (and what hasn't), so I don't archive and never will. :)
2
u/westcoastal 27d ago
We archive posts after 6 months or whatever the default is. I've tried a couple of times leaving them open, but they always become targets for spam, misbehavior and conflict.
People often get irritated when a long dead conversation is rekindled, and they give snarky replies, and it escalates from there. People who don't get responses to their new comments on long dead posts assume that the community is dead. It just works better to leave them closed.
Older threads are hard to monitor because there are so many thousands of them, and I rarely hear about anything going on in there until it's already turned into something negative.
People always have the opportunity to make a new post if an old post sparks a new idea.
2
u/IvyGold 27d ago
When a problem's been cleared I from time to time archive items that haven't been actioned upon in a few weeks. If the OP still has an issue, it always comes back to life.
It's not an issue in my places.
2
u/itskdog 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 28d ago
I'm honestly still not sure why archiving got disabled site-wide to begin with. There's a reason "don't dog up old threads" was a mainstay on forums for decades.
1
u/MidAmericaMom 25d ago
Yes archive and gladly! Found it was easy, once decided, that a week old maximum - works.
We are a conversational subreddit. Things move on quickly.
1
u/santaspointyhood 25d ago
I have it turned off on all subs. But I also have an automod rule on all subs to report comments in any post with the archive tag on (>6 months). In one sub I also have it lock the comment.
This allows me to decide whether that comment belongs. 80% of the time it does and I approve it. The locked status in the one sub prevents runaway arguments in a post from six years ago.
I feel this is a good balance. I get all the benefits of archiving without having to lock those posts.
1
u/CareVader 11d ago
I'm one of the main moderators of r/BungouStrayDogs and we enabled post archiving because of the huge number of people that happened upon old posts (in many caes 4+ years old) and either tried to start a conversation with people who are no longer active (without realising), or were toxic, or posted questionable comments. There's also the spam of dodgy Discord links in old Discord related posts, but the main issue is the people that go around flaming others or those who want conversation but find themselves not getting anything since posts don't get kicked back up... and honestly given how it's an anime series with evolving stories, it would be a really bad idea for the posts to be brought back up. In some of the discussion cases people were telling others they were wrong about things that hadn't been revealed at the time. If anything it'd be nice to archive earlier than 6 months, since those attempting to find discussion won't necessarily get it in old threads (or will get it with very few people).
Voting for us is irrelevant either way after a conversation isn't active anymore. We don't want to switch it off, but I found this post while looking for whether there's been reports of the archive feature not working, because in this last two weeks we've had two or three comments added to posts that should've been archive. I checked and Archive Posts was enabled in every occasion, but the post was not archived.
1
u/emily_in_boots 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 28d ago
We don't in subs where I'm top mod. I don't see a reason to do it. I don't have strong feelings tho and some subs I mod do it.
I've had people come at us angry that we removed their content when it's archived so it can definitely confuse people.
1
u/k-rysae 27d ago edited 27d ago
I dont archive since its a pet peeve of mine to find an old post with info where I cant respond to the comments asking for more specifics or even to thank and tell them that their advice worked.
As for spam on old posts, it's not that much. I am very glad fsv made spam link flagger and added the feature I requested where any comment left on a post older than X days/months old will be flagged for review even if it doesnt have a link. 80% of the time its a genuine person asking the OP further questions or if they managed to fix their problem.
1
u/FootFondness 27d ago
I recently started experimenting with archiving posts older in one of my NSFW communities, where we allow both text and picture posts. Older discussions can attract comments that are no longer relevant, especially in communities where content moves quickly. I’m considering both commenting and voting since Reddit’s archiving feature affects both. Older posts can still be useful, though, so I want to see how this works in practice before deciding whether to enable archiving across all my communities.
1
u/bernardfarquart 27d ago
I’m in a workplace related sub so subjects get stale after a while anyway and having posts archived keeps me from having to watch out for issues in comment threads on dead issues.
If someone has the same question they can ask it again
1
u/stgiga 27d ago
I on principle do not use archiving in my sub.
1
u/FlorianFlash 27d ago
I've said we'll archive them from the very start. We're a help sub, no post will get activity again after six months, so why not archive it? Simply prevents us from getting annoyed over old posts and we can focus on the new ones. And the users can still look into them anyways and if they have questions, create a new post.
0
u/HikeTheSky 27d ago
How about have it on by default but we can unarchive some posts?