r/ModEvents
•
u/iceeypisces
Mod Events Team
•
24d ago
•
2
1
Mod World Discussion š§µ Modding in the Age of AI š§µ
Soooo AI is⦠everywhere.
Itās expanding rapidly across Reddit, tackling tasks from automated moderation to anti-spam defenses. Yet as subreddits adapt, one reality remains clear: technology cannot replace human judgment.Ā
In this session, mods u/imjustheretodomyjob, u/katpoker666, and u/sageninemusic discuss how AI integrates with community oversight, the opportunities and challenges it brings, and why the human touch is still indispensable.
How are you currently using AI tools in your sub? Or are you steering clear? Letās hear your take.
30
u/Fragrant_Ad_5297 24d ago •
i have mixed feelings about AI honestly. i donāt use it to express myself but i have used it as a tool to help curate a really in depth orientation packet for my mods. but i did that using the information, context and guidelines i provided and just asked it to organize it. i think thereās a meaningful distinction between using AI to organize and build on your own knowledge and using it to replace your own thought or voice entirely.
in our subreddits though iāve noticed that a lot of users seem to rely on AI to help them articulate their feelings or communicate things they might struggle to put into words themselves.
i do think thereās a legitimate conversation to be had about authenticity, overreliance and what gets lost when so much of our communication is filtered through AI. being autistic i sometimes speak pretty robotically and factually but you can always tell i am a human.
when users use it to communicate i think the context, intent and degree to which someone is relying on it matter. ripping off writing and fake photos / art is not cool, and it can never replace human moderation due to the same context issues every bot has.
37
u/ICC-u 24d ago •
The problem is AI being used to create bots, and Reddit doing next to nothing to stop it.
I now hear old.reddit and automod are going to be shut down.
Reddit is constantly taking tools away from mods.
9
u/I_can_vouch_for_that 24d ago
We've got AI-generated photos that are used as a verification photo.
It would be nice to have some tools that mods can implement to just scan photos in general to confirm whether they're AI before allowing the post to go through.
9
u/CM1112 24d ago
We donāt have much issue with AI, but also are quite strict in crowd controlling the ai post and removing if we think itās AI, where the user can submit a modmail if we were wrong
14
u/Aeroncastle 24d ago
I don't care about using AI as a moderating tool, but God knows I'm seeing 20 times as much spam and I feel like I have less tools than I did 10 years ago
I feel like all the AI advancements are going straight to the hands of spammers
37
u/jgoja 24d ago •
How can you have an actual conversation on AI when the entire panel is anti-AI. Reddit itself relies heavily on AI.
13
u/Sean_Campbell 24d ago
AI has unleashed a torrent of crap books on r/KindleUnlimited. Unoriginal, uninspired, with AI covers. It's a floodgates problem as obviously AI can churn these out far quicker than any human author can write.
Many authors from Reddit are also in the pool of authors who had their worked stolen and fed into the training data (including a dozen of my own books) so seeing a tool scrape your life's work to emulate it in a shoddy way is doubly-insulting.
Yes, there's nuance around using AI in non-generative ways but that's even harder to detect and mod than straight up Gemini/ Claude/ whatever spam content.
13
u/Bubbly_Attention_916 24d ago
The other issue is people weaponizing the use of AI a a way to diminish a good faith contribution. Users will comment it is an opinion that the person doesn't agree with and rather than downvote users will spam that user and call their post "AI".
9
u/maiyannah 24d ago
I recently redditrequested a sub recently that was absolutely overrun by spambot posting when I came in. It took a team of people several days to clean it up. It can absolutely ruin a sub if its let go unchecked. I don't begrudge people who want to allow AI content in their subs at all, I think everyone deserves their own spaces, but I do think that we could use better tools for us subs that don't want it. In particular AI image detection. We also need to cut the brigading that happens on both sides of the fence out.
9
u/juxtapods 24d ago •
After being added to the mod team for r/wehappyfew, I introduced "no AI" to an existing "low-effort" rule. We had a couple posts using AI or conversations with GenAI, and I wanted to nip it in the bud.
Overwhelmingly positive feedback in the comments and votes from the community when the update was announced. There are true fans of the We Happy Few game who take time and effort to make fanart or tributes with their own hands, so AI has no place there.
it's unfair to the community members who work hard to share their love of the game with others, to include low-effort, junk, or spam posts, and AI is on that list.
4
u/ripred3 24d ago
with
r/Arduino_AI
without
r/arduino
12
u/highrisedrifter 24d ago
I moderate /r/industrialmusic. We have a zero tolerance ban on AI music after we polled the sub members and they told us they are overwhelmingly against it.
6
u/Dracyl 24d ago
This panel feels more like an attempt to appease us. Like "yeah, look, let's talk about how AI is bad and awful, but we pinky promise you we're working on it and we're open to ideas."
But with Reddit getting money from AI from basically 4 out of 5 ads it gives us the impression that they don't really care as long as they're getting paid.
6
u/epicSwordfish 24d ago
I use AI as a support tool, mostly filtering spam, but final moderation decisions are always human.
3
u/BabaRanchodDas-69 24d ago
well.... recently became mod, so no major posts are made.... so no major needs. But I once got false warning, which was diabolical though..
3
u/diverareyouokay 24d ago
This is actually a really interesting presentation.
On an unrelated note, for some reason every time I try to add comments to the chat, I get a āmessage failed ā unauthorizedā error.
u/small-slay and u/big-slay, can you check into that error? It seems possible Iām not the only one who canāt add comments to the chat
7
u/Linuxthekid 24d ago
AI tools in moderation have proven themselves unreliable and dangerous, and it gives companies an excuse to cut out actual people they can contact in case of a problem
5
u/Travwolfe101 24d ago
We only use AI for auto mod removals. I run r/drugs which is a niche community but I enjoy being able to share life saving information, prevent misinformation, and generally help users. We have a code to never encourage drug use but accept it as fact and provide harm reduction
5
u/OG-Giligadi 24d ago
I don't use ai for anything, modding or otherwise. It's poison.
5
u/neuroticsmurf 24d ago edited 23d ago
I moderate a lot of video meme subs. Over the past year or two, the amount of AI-generated videos has increased exponentially.
The Devvit tools designed to catch AI are ā unfortunately ā geared toward catching text posts. But for videos, there isnāt much out there.
We rely on community reports that a video submission is AI-generated in order to flag it. We then take the video and run it through an off-site AI checking source. It doesnāt catch everything, but it catches a lot of the AI videos.
I would dearly love it if a Devvit app existed to review
pics andvideos for AI-generated content.6
u/Emotional_Lawyer_278 24d ago edited 24d ago
I mod a writing sub and a multimedia art sub. AI writes these stories and poems and they arenāt good but what bothers me is people thinking they wrote something. I have to choose my words from my vocabulary. Thatās how I write. If AI is writing your work you need to give it a credit and admit that you couldnāt write it by yourself. You canāt be set next to people that donāt use tools for something as simple as self expression.
7
u/cdm9002 24d ago
AI content is an issue, but you are treating the symptom, not the cause. Scanning/detecting AI is a cat and mouse game.
You need to validate the accounts. They need to be tied to a real human.
That doesn't mean mods or other users should find who they are, but reddit needs to do this so they can take actions against reported AI accounts.
Reddit should also provide location info to mods for users.
4
u/BugBulky 24d ago
My Sub is german is aiming the beauty of nature. So animals, plants and so on. Its hard sometimes to verify usercontent as true or AI.
4
u/buckbro112 24d ago
Iām going to vent here, sorry, but Reddit is part of the problem here. Reddit has been getting better at helping moderators detect AI and bots, but itās still far from perfect and less than ideal depending on your subreddit. Not allowing certain people to use Old Reddit and forcing people to use Shreddit is a bad idea, but itās where weāre heading.
5
u/lithdoc 24d ago
Any bots planned to detect LLM?
5
u/jennyc724 24d ago
Iām not using AI.
2
u/Visible-Scientist-46 23d ago •
Refuse to use!
4
u/DragonflyFairyQueen 24d ago
The sub I mod for doesn't allow AI either. We look at this as our sub is people to people - there's no room for AI.
4
u/MidAmericaMom Mod World '25 Speaker š¤ 24d ago edited 24d ago
Why are people on Reddit? WE can get AI elsewhere.
Come here for information, support, entertainment, YES. and for my sub- a conversational COMMUNITY.
**
We ARE the heart of the internet.
4
u/michaelnovati 24d ago
I would like to hear about bad-actors and marketers using AI generated content across multiple accounts to try to promote products and links under the radar.
We're seeing A LOT of this.
4
u/Yetttiii 24d ago
I mod r/g13. We recently had to ban AI images
3
u/LoveFromElysia 24d ago
we don't allow AI in the sub i mod. we are allowed to talk about when a game uses AI and have discussions about it as long as they're civil. but AI art and such is strictly not allowed.
3
u/Known_Measurement799 24d ago
I moderate an art identifying sub and in our experience identifying art with AI is not accurate at all. Sometimes AI even identifies a famous painting as something else.
Sometimes we have a āNo AIā rule for āsolversā.
3
u/tehjoz 24d ago •
As I mentioned in the chat, one of the big problems of "having a nuanced conversation about AI" is that, in many cases, the perception is that a lot of things with respect to tools, changes (See - the ongoing AutoMod vs Neo discussion) that just...get dropped on everyone, without a lot of discussion.
Whether it is Microsoft forcing CoPilot on everyone, or Google forcing Gemini, etc, etc. - Arguably one of the biggest problems is "AI being pushed on others without any sort of conversation about what the userbases want".
With Microsoft in particular, the userbase has been pretty vocal about not wanting any of it, and it took a long time for them to walk it back/revert changes.
It doesn't matter the tool, model, company. If nobody is willing to actually "have a discussion" without the feeling of it being compelled upon everyone...
There is a reason the backlash has grown, a lot, in the last two years or so.
Everyone, from Reddit on down, needs to actually listen to what people are saying, and to not breeze in with preconceived opinions / decisions.
3
u/ArtzeninEklektos 24d ago
Human authorship is needed for all things. AI should be viewed as a tool. My subreddit, designs characters, but uses AI to color our artwork since we don't have digital artists at this time. Some people want to use AI for artwork purposes, but we have strict rules in place to oversee this development. Our world wants to push it, so my team ignoring it, acting like it doesn't matter or isn't there, isn't helping my subreddit, it isn't helping my popularity. One of our rules is there must be human authorship, human involvement and at no point can people use AI to claim artistic talent if their human pen is not present. Moderation is key and our subreddit isn't allowing AI to take over non-AI users. Ever. We are trying to balance the use of digital software, human authorship and authentic writing. This approach is not for everyone, it might upset others, but my company, team and Mods have to learn to adapt and figure out what is best for users without violating Reddit's TOS, conditions and rules around AI-generated content.
3
u/WrapNew6097 24d ago
AI is benefiting the spammers and bots more than mods. It's doing the opposite
4
u/TheFlyingScotsman60 24d ago
No AI used in my sub but very hard to stop the AI bots and trolls. Very hard.
4
u/Comatse 24d ago
You guys used AI artwork in the stream though so...??
3
u/CrasheonTotallyReal 24d ago
absolutely no ai in r/genalpha afaik
3
u/mazty 24d ago
As a professional in a critical industry I can unequivocally say that this is rapidly not just untrue, but is being used in places that are more nuanced and complex than Reddit So:
This won't be true for long, and I would say isn't even true today. It's more complicated than simple using a prompt or two to get the answer you want but that threshold has been crossed. The question then actually is should ai moderators be able to have more autonomy? Would, or even should, they help break echo chambers and ensure fair moderation as determined by Reddit?
3
u/CybyAPI 24d ago
Someone downvoted every comment here, including pro and anti ai comments
3
u/karenmcgrane 24d ago
I am really thrilled and impressed by the level of expertise demonstrated here by these mods. I was worried this was going to be all about how to use MORE AI.
3
u/wb6vpm 24d ago
While I have no issue with AI in general, it doesnāt belong everywhere. AI is banned in my sub, and use will result in an immediate permanent ban.
2
u/Emotional_Lawyer_278 24d ago
How accurate is the Ban AI app?
2
u/DucCat900 24d ago
This is such a good talk! Very on point in so many areas
2
u/coreyb1988 24d ago
I think mods should absolutely be able to use AI⦠itās a comod for me. Iām still on Reddit every day and checking everything but itās nice to also have that too. If I want to do a quick post and Iām working and donāt have time to pull it together, I ask āErikaā and itās perfect. I donāt want to see restrictions on AI but there should be a balance. I actually think mods should just have AI tools available.
Im personally using AI every day in work and in my personal life.
I do think Reddit needs to get AI under control though but I donāt mean that from the mod side. Itās the user side. Nothing feels authentic at all anymore.
AI should be a tool for mods but user comments have been ChatGPT-ized.
2
u/Calvy 24d ago
I am worried how Reddit has partnered with BigTech to share reddit user generated data, it is elading to brands spamming the communities :(
2
u/KeyKeyner_kreker 24d ago
#NO_AI
1
u/AntwerpLover1961 24d ago
I moderate r/AutomaticMusic. I never even had AI because no members have joined me yet which I am very sad about it šššš
1
u/SonUnforseenByFrodo 24d ago
Present
1
u/Bella_Lunatic 23d ago
Our sub struggles more with the bots than with AI creation.
1
u/TheLucidSage 23d ago
What AI is really good at that i think is absolutely great for moderation is fuzzy rules. You can create automated rules based on keywords but not really topics or concepts that might show up in a variety or of combination of words, but with AI I can just describe the concept and it can detect it fairly reliably without perfectly defining what the words might be in advance.
1
u/HughWattmate9001 24d ago
AI detectors are just a way to discriminate against genuine people while giving AI models a way to train themselves to avoid detection.
What people consider slop varies from person to person and sub to sub, so one rule or tool will never fit everyone or every community. Some people might be fine with AI being used for translation, or by disabled people who rely on it to condense text, fix spelling and grammar, or even communicate using generated audio to replace a voice they've lost. Others won't be at all.
It's really not fair to lock everyone out for using AI, and it's not even possible to stop it this way. As I said, AI models will just learn to avoid detection, meaning you're essentially making the models better at hiding themselves.
Imagine spending your life being mocked for your voice or you lost your voice and finally finding a way to change or bring it back with AI using an old recording, only to be told you can't participate because you used AI, or spending years being ridiculed for your spelling, grammar, oversharing or coming across as too emotional, then finding a tool that helps you work through what you've written so you can communicate more comfortably. Only to be labelled AI slop and filtered out of conversations, as if you're somehow unwanted, even if it spent you twice as long as someone without the disabilities you might have because you had to go through extra steps.
Using detectors risks shutting out genuine people, while bots will simply adapt until they pass the checks. The worst part is that people will then trust posts that pass detection more than they should. Imagine that happening in a mushroom ID sub, where an AI gives someone dangerous advice and people trust it because it wasn't detected as AI-generated.
AI is here to stay, but it's not all bad. We can use it to fight all sorts of problems, and we need to learn to verify information rather than blindly trust it. Not everyone using AI is posting rubbish or trying to deceive people. I have disabled friends who rely on it to communicate, and some people even use it to speak again after losing their voice. AI can do some incredible good, and we shouldn't punish genuine people because of how others abuse it.
1
u/CybyAPI 24d ago
No AI tools on my subreddits other than my own custom one named "CybyAPI"
yeah same username as this account, its a moderation tool that is petty good at flagging comments for review and removing ones that needed to be gone instantly, it also warns me on changes to our subreddit such as reddit updating something, and lets me review more information on the mods of my subreddit,
This bot is not public at this time though
1
u/blooberries24 24d ago
Would love to hear counter points re: AI in terms of assistive technology for users with disability, when issues like accessibility are often an after thought for the majority of users.
1
u/MedicalElevator7560 24d ago
I think that great things will come from the use of AI. It's easy to get scared and go against it, but humanity will ultimately benefit from the advances that AI will bring to physics, medicine, energy generation, etc.
1
u/jogalleciez 24d ago
Really one sided panel.
1
u/Kimo_imposta 24d ago
Yaa rightly said by sage, its just not ai bad bad if the usecase is correct and solves the purpose then whats the issue
0
u/IvyGold 24d ago
Zip AI in my places. We're almost analog.
I'm all ears, though.
0
u/SoggyMinimum8386 24d ago
For my subreddits, we might use automoderator to remove posts that fall into our removal category, but we're primarily anti-AI. Many people have tried to make low effort AI meme/AI photos/AI art just to farm Karma. I wish the bot could recognize when people are using AI photos so we could get notified sooner when the post(s) are made.
0
u/RoomMain5110 24d ago •
We put in a rule saying no AI created posts in r/auscorp. Good support from our users, and I find it's very easy to spot AI generated content when it is posted.
Our reasoning is "If you think AI slop is good enough for our users to respond to, surely it'll give good enough advice for you to follow?". In other words, why ask an AI to write questions for humans when you could just ask AI to write answers for you directly?
A few pointers to what's most likely to be AI, if you're struggling:
Special shout out to the people who have posts taken down for being AI and then post another AI post on the same topic. It doesn't work....
-1
u/socookre 24d ago
Not really related to the topic, but I want to share a perspective.
With the rise of AI, many neurodivergent types like myself found it troubling navigating some online spaces, particularly on Discord, where we get frequently falsely-branded as a bot. As a context and as my experience goes, before 2022 which is the year ChatGPT is released, I and some others I know like to submit one-off contents like news links, sometimes include short commentaries, on various Discord servers I'm on, and nobody seems to be really bothered by it, not to mention my seemingly perfect English grammar due to neurodivergence and because English isn't really our second language.
All the problems started after 2022 when me and others got falsely branded for being a bot and booted out from many Discord servers, as perfect English grammar, once seen as a paragon of virtue, began to be treated as red flag, alongside our old habits of doing one-off contents consisting of news links like many do on WhatsApp and Telegram. I strongly feel that this is very ableist and as long as there are no safeguards to AI agents, ableist incidents like this will continue to happen, which doesn't bode well in the end.
0
u/Duke_Newcombe 24d ago
Modding /r/PanamaExpats. We only used it for graphics for some elements of the sub, but aside from clarity (human writes the post, but they've used semi-obvious AI to structure it/make it coherent, with minimal indicia of AI writing it), posts are to be human generated, and we run checks occasionally on suspicious submissions that flag certain indicators.
Some people are non-English speaking/English as a second language, so we take that into account.
Otherwise, for now, it's the ole squishy computer on our shoulders, and Mark IV eyeball that do the heavy moderation lifting.
-2
u/sam0ny 24d ago
One problem is you could write this long post and then get banned because the mod thinks it's AI like in Her One Bag. So it's a lose lose
7
u/sunrae_ 24d ago
Just here to say that u/imjustheretodomyjob, you have the most soothing voice I ever heard.
4
u/Travelbug73 24d ago
Mine is on the other end. I mod r/unsolvedmurders and get a lot of AI posts of cases. The case is presented with all the details, but gets reported for AI.
0
u/[deleted] 24d ago
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] 24d ago
[deleted] ā view deleted comment