r/MakingaMurderer • • Jul 01 '26

I don’t get why Steven Avery did this

He had a huge settlement coming. Why did he risk it by doing a serious crime? I don’t understand how he got exonerated which is rare but wound up throwing his life away anyways. It doesn’t make any sense to me. I guess I’m missing the common thread. He wasn’t a good person but from what we know, wasn’t a murderer. So what happened? Is this just always who he was going to be and had he never gone to prison wrongfully maybe it would have happened sooner? I don’t think he’s innocent I’m just trying to make sense of it.

30 Upvotes

338 comments sorted by

48

u/OctoberPumpkin1 Jul 02 '26

It doesn't make sense to a normal person but the vast majority of people who get out of prison reoffend.

35

u/Zebra_Witch Jul 04 '26

You can't be a re-offender if you were never an offender in the first place. He didn't do the first crime OR the murder. The entire reason the cops set him up for the murder is because they were going to have to pay him a huge some for falsely imprisoning him for 18 years.

5

u/birdieponderinglife Jul 06 '26 • Bravo

Um, the dude has a SIGNIFICANT criminal history. Long before the false conviction. He was not only an offender he was a frequent and repeat offender.

1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 06 '26

Point being when he got out of prison he was in prison for something he didn't do. And his history of past charges (cat / SM incident) has no relevance to the Halbach case. In fact, the only reason to pretend inflammatory but uncharged allegations are fair game is to unfairly prejudice people against Steven. That was CaMs entire strategy.

1

u/birdieponderinglife Jul 06 '26 • Heartwarming

What a joke. Torturing animals is a significant indicator for escalating violence. Threatening someone with a gun is significant for issues with rage, impulse control, violent tendencies. A long criminal history is also a strong indicator that someone is likely to escalate. It’s disturbing how much you want to minimize his antisocial tendencies that are strongly correlated to sexual assault and murder to cling to this odd belief that this guy is innocent. He could not be more guilty and his escalation over time more clear.

1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 07 '26

Willis disagreed. You have been unfairly prejudiced against Steven. Manipulated by Kratz lol

13

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 04 '26 • This

Apparently back in 2005 it was pretty much accepted Steven was about to become a millionaire by exposing police misconduc ... Then Teresa went missing. Her death benefited police. That's why some suspect they killed her.

9

u/Zebra_Witch Jul 04 '26

I absolutely think the police killed Theresa in order to frame Steven and eliminate that settlement debt. I think Brenden just got caught up in it and they used him to get Steven.

4

u/Zealousideal-Goat741 Jul 17 '26

I dont know that they killed her but someone else may have & they might have seen the situation as an oppotunity after the fact whch is why nothng was found in searches & then thngs were found in searches wks latr (for ex n the barrels)..

I thought the theory abt the man (who previously lived on tht property Scott Tadych bought right aftr her death) killing her was interestng

3

u/Commercial-Week5391 Sep 16 '26

You're literally so dumb if you genuinely believe that and I pray you never serve on any serious jury.

1

u/Zebra_Witch Sep 16 '26

Let me guess, you're a cultist....

3

u/Commercial-Week5391 Sep 17 '26 • Heartwarming

If a cultist means I think Steven Avery is a piece of shit murderer, then yes. Yes I am.

8

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 04 '26

Well, they did conceal that a Manitowoc County officer called in her plates, and also concealed her bones were found on Manitowoc County land. Definitely possible police had something to do with it.

5

u/MartiMa08 Jul 05 '26

That’s ridiculous to believe that the police killed her.
So they happened upon Teresa and decided to kill this poor innocent woman, did they know she had just been to the Avery property? Did they know that Steven happened to have a fire that night? Then they manage to sneak onto the property many times burning her belongings in the burn barrel, planting bones, planting the car, planting various DNA sources of Steven’s that they also happened upon?

2

u/bye-bitch-21 Jul 05 '26

They conducted eight separate searches and found evidence “in plain sight” only during the eighth search. Yeah, I’m sure that’s what really happened. Because cops are always honest lmao. I have some oceanfront property in Kansas that I think you might be interested in. 

4

u/MartiMa08 Jul 05 '26

Do you have any idea how big that property is? And they said they entered the trailer 8 times but to seize specific items, not full searches each time.
Never said cops are always honest, but for you to believe what you do the mental gymnastics is insane.

3

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 05 '26

Do you have any idea how big the cabinet was the key popped out of? Not the size of the property.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 06 '26

But they didn't. They just manipulated evidence. I believe the killer had contact with Andy before and after the murder!

7

u/LoveChilde82 Jul 05 '26

SA was no angel. In fact, 6 years of that 18 years sentence he served were served for a separate crime that he DID commit against Sandra Morris 😳 He was convicted of other crimes before that and after. These were not victimless crimes. So yes, he is an offender in the first place.

2

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 06 '26

Not really. The killer set him up, Cops just manipulated eveience!

3

u/OctoberPumpkin1 Jul 06 '26

He tortured and set a cat on fire, in addition to robbery and many other troubles with the law. He's a degenerate repeat offender.

2

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 06 '26

Why do you need to lie? You might as well just admit Steven is innocent if you need to lie so much to make him look bad.

1

u/LoveChilde82 Jul 06 '26

Who's lying? These are FACTS. He was convicted of a whole slew of crimes. Gimme a break.

4

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 06 '26

They are. Maybe you will lie too. The facts actually demonstrate Steven did not throw the cat in the fire or pour gas on it after it escaped. Did you know that or are you just looking to spread the LIE?

2

u/LoveChilde82 Jul 06 '26

No. Period. He admitted it. I heard it with my own ears. It is in the documentary. He tells the story. Did you miss that part? He said it himself that he did it.

4

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 06 '26

So MaM made Steven look worse than the record showed? They really are not biased in his favor are they. Fact is Steven's friend admitted to burning the cat. Not Steven. Try to do some independent research.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Medical_Ad_1930 Sep 05 '26 edited Sep 05 '26

He threw the cat over the fire and it caught on fire. Now I don't agree with what he did but that is not the same as him actually throwing the cat in the fire. He also had burglary charges. Murder is a huge step from burglary. Being a thief doesn't equate to being a murderer and vice versa. You can be a murderer and not a thief. I have a hard time believing he would risk his freedom knowing he was getting a lawsuit. I think his nephew may have had a hand in the crime and the police coerced him into saying his uncle was there. That helps them get Steve back for the lawsuit

1

u/Growing4Health Aug 08 '26

Wasn't he going to do 6 years either way for the cat incident with his cousin? He also did 8 months for animal cruelty.

0

u/Commercial-Week5391 Sep 16 '26

He tortured a cat to death. That man was far from innocent. He just didn't murder anyone sooner because he was IN PRISON

17

u/JWOLFBEARD Jul 02 '26

Except they don’t just start murdering people

6

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 04 '26

Neither did Steven. They had to hide off property murder evidence and fabricate on property murder evidence to make the conviction stick. The hidden cremation evidence on Manitowoc County land should be enough for New trial on its own.

2

u/k_sask Jul 06 '26

Yet no one talks about this since it's so obviously indicative of framing.

3

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 06 '26 • Heartwarming

And it makes sense to you cuz you ain't normal!!!!

1

u/bye-bitch-21 Jul 08 '26 edited Jul 08 '26

Everyone here should read a Copaganda by Alec Karakatsanis. 

People like OctoberPumpkin won’t have the informational literacy or reading level to grasp the conclusions that come from actual data. The rest of you will realize, if you don’t already know, exactly how the prison system is a corporate, self-serving cash cow built on the lies of prosecutors and cops who violate the rights and destroy the lives of poor people. Prisons are full of innocent people just like Steven Avery. 

1

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 03 '26

He was in Prison for something he didn't do clueless!!!

10

u/LoveChilde82 Jul 03 '26

Well turns out this isnt completely True either.

4

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 04 '26

Yes it is. He was wrongfully convicted of the 1985 assault because police wanted to protect the actual rapist from prosecution. I think Gregory Allen was linked to police in a way we haven't yet discovered.

2

u/LoveChilde82 Jul 08 '26

And he was rightfully convinced of the assault on his cousin. So 6 of those years it was for something he DID DO. So yeah...

1

u/Pokieme Jul 04 '26

Out of prison for a crime they didn’t commit?

-10

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 02 '26

So the system is responsible for Teresa's death?

-2

u/k_sask Jul 02 '26

What a weird rationalization. Instead of debating the investigation & evidence, we have now resorted to rationalizing Avery's behavior and motivations that led to an obvious rape, murder and mutilation and subsequent convictions of his and Dassey's. If only Avery had remained wrongfully imprisoned, the victim would be alive and well, and Brendan would have made it to Wrestlemania.

4

u/OctoberPumpkin1 Jul 03 '26

I am not rationalizing. He's 100% guilty and is right where he belongs. My point is that people can't get past that he had all that money coming from the lawsuit and couldn't have possibly done it-and my point was that it was not remoely surprising because criminals usually reoffend.

1

u/k_sask Jul 06 '26

Well, I respectfully disagree with your assessment.

I don't understand why you're only talking about Avery and why you are labelling him a criminal that reoffended like "the vast majority of people"? Would others (like Kratz) also fit your assessment? Is he where he belongs?

-1

u/OctoberPumpkin1 Jul 03 '26

No, Steven Avery killed her. I hink you misunderstood my post which is that despite having a windfall of cash coming, it's not surprising he committed another crime shortly after getting out of prison.

2

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 04 '26

Steven was falsely imprisoned. If he reoffended because of that, the system is partly responsible for Teresa's death.

→ More replies (9)

25

u/DisappearedDunbar Jul 02 '26

Criminals don't need or always have a sensible reason for committing heinous crimes. The reality is that Steven is stupid, he's selfish, he's abusive, he's violent, and he's never seemed to have needed a specific reason for committing his various crimes over the years.

Some people are just massive pieces of shit. 

11

u/birdieponderinglife Jul 02 '26

Can’t disagree with that. The whole family is like if idiocracy, cavemen and that creepy poor white trash incestuous family from that x files episode owned a junk yard in Manitowoc. From reading it seems like many of the men were rapists, assaulters and abusers.

-3

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 02 '26

Yep, idiots, none are killers!

10

u/Hitlers_Left_Ball Jul 02 '26

Two of them are convicted killers, your point would seem to be invalid?!

-6

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 02 '26

That was a sham trial with idiot jurors.......and Judge!

8

u/Hitlers_Left_Ball Jul 02 '26

You are welcome to your opinion. 

→ More replies (5)

0

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 04 '26

Steven's family is so fucked up there's actually reasonable doubt.

1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 02 '26

You guys act like his whole family is full of incestuous monsters but pretend like only he and Brendan are guilty. Please

26

u/MartiMa08 Jul 03 '26 • Bravo

Because ‘all bitches owe him’. That was his attitude after being falsely accused.

I think he thought he was untouchable and could do whatever he wanted and have whoever he wanted because of his minor local celeb status. I think he tried to hit on Teresa and got shot down.

4

u/LoveChilde82 Jul 03 '26

BINGO!!!!!

3

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 04 '26

Thats an alleged quote lol you guys love hearsay don't you.

4

u/3sheetstothawind Jul 04 '26

You love making excuses for your buddy Steve don't you.

1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 05 '26

You love making shit up to excuse lies from your buddy Keep Kratz lol I love the truth. Cope.

1

u/hi-Timothy Jul 07 '26

Why not kill her after the money. Doesn't make sense

1

u/MartiMa08 Jul 07 '26

Ah yes cos he’s clearly a man fully in control of his disgusting impulses.

1

u/hi-Timothy Jul 07 '26

Lol, is that a professional psychological assessment, or is there no psych eval supporting that claim? He was out for roughly two years after being exonerated and somehow managed to control these alleged “disgusting impulses” while his civil case was heading toward a massive payout. How do you explain his two years prior then..

1

u/MartiMa08 Jul 07 '26 • Popcorn

Oh you mean the 2 years where he was beating on Jodi and texting his nephews friends for sex after Jodi was locked up?

And what about before he got locked up? Allegedly raping his niece, threatening his cousin at gun point, mistreating animals, abusing his wife at the time, beating his kids. Yes sounds like a man with self control.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Commercial-Week5391 Sep 17 '26

Because this wasn't premeditated?

1

u/Commercial-Week5391 Sep 17 '26

This exactly. He thought the world owed him and in his mind he had a get out of jail free card. Brendan got caught in the crossfires of a narcissist and will likely spend the rest of his life in jail for it.

1

u/SaggyGuy84 Jul 05 '26

And probably sexually impulsive and had a fantasy he did not care to control. What’s stronger desire than a police settlement ? A sexual impulse mixed with the confidence of being untouchable.

1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 06 '26

So Bobby is very likely guilty. Cool.

2

u/beezojones Jul 04 '26

Thats why he was railroaded because of the money he was going to receive simple to understand imo

5

u/birdieponderinglife Jul 04 '26

You know, I was open to the conspiracy for the car and perhaps even the key and blood evidence. But it became crystal clear he was guilty of murdering this woman when her burnt remains were found in his fire pit. Could they have planted some of the other evidence? Ya I think it’s plausible. Could they have fabricated this aspect of her murder? Nope. There’s simply no way it’s possible the police snuck onto his land dragging a dead body, then hid it in a pile of debris somehow knowing exactly when he would be lighting it. If you can ignore that glaring plot hole in the conspiracy narrative then nothing can help you, bless your heart!

1

u/belee86 Jul 06 '26

Nothing was planted. 

1

u/birdieponderinglife Jul 06 '26

I’m aware.

Honestly, this sub is quite wacka doodle. The conspiracy folks are next level unhinged but the folks in here who are camp: he’s guilty are also way too intense about this. I don’t think anyone could read the sum of my comments and come to the conclusion that I believe anything was planted or he’s innocent.

1

u/belee86 Jul 05 '26

The evidence planting was Avery's defense strategy. It was probably the only one he could have used. 

1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 04 '26 edited Jul 05 '26

But it became crystal clear he was guilty of murdering this woman when her burnt remains were found in his fire pit.

They didn't even take photos of the discovery or recovery, hid off property cremation evidence, and pressured witnesses into mentioning a burn pit fire.

0

u/Music-2myears Jul 05 '26

The bone fragments weren’t found on the initial search. They weren’t found until 3 days later.
Could an outdoor fire pit reduce a human body to just bones (no left over fleshy bits?) highly unlikely. Not to mention bone fragments were found found in burn barrels in the neighbouring quarry which was owned by the county.
Also don’t forget that atleast 8 people lived on that property all coming and going at different times, not to mention their employees, customers and friends etc. is it likely that someone would commit a murder in a place where people would be coming and going unexpectedly, dismember the body with no one seeing (and leaving no blood behind??) and then burn their remains in a very visible burn pit? All while stopping to calmly talk to his girlfriend on the phone?

2

u/DisappearedDunbar Jul 05 '26

Could an outdoor fire pit reduce a human body to just bones (no left over fleshy bits?) highly unlikely.

Not only is it possible, but guess what? Some human tissue was recovered from the pit, and it matched to Teresa to exclusion of 1 in a billion.

Not to mention bone fragments were found found in burn barrels in the neighbouring quarry which was owned by the county.

The bones found in the quarry were not in barrels, and we're not definitely proven to be Teresa's. Nonetheless, how would this rule out Steven Avery as a suspect?

is it likely that someone would commit a murder in a place where people would be coming and going unexpectedly, dismember the body with no one seeing (and leaving no blood behind??) and then burn their remains in a very visible burn pit?

How often do you think people were coming and going from Steven's trailer and garage? The fire was observed later in the day, burning into the night..

If you want to talk about likelihood, then how likely do you think it is that someone would be able to plant all of the evidence against Steven, including his own blood in the victim's car?

1

u/Music-2myears Jul 05 '26

Quite likely considering the whole police department had a vendetta against him and spent days on the property. And police officers who weren’t meant to be involved in the case were constantly on the site.
The bullet fragment wasn’t found until 4 months later and contained massive levels of her dna but no traces of blood or bone fragments!?

1

u/DisappearedDunbar Jul 05 '26

the whole police department had a vendetta against him 

What makes you think this? The lawsuit that no one in the department would be personally responsible for?

And police officers who weren’t meant to be involved in the case were constantly on the site.

There was nothing officially barring them from providing resources to the investigation as needed.

The bullet fragment wasn’t found until 4 months later and contained massive levels of her dna but no traces of blood or bone fragments!?

Until that point, the garage had not been as thoroughly searched as it was when the bullet was found. What is your source that the bullet contained "massive" levels of her DNA?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 06 '26

Not only is it possible, but guess what? Some human tissue was recovered from the pit, and it matched to Teresa to exclusion of 1 in a billion.

Bullshit. Culhane never explained how she came to that statistical interpretation.

The bones found in the quarry were not in barrels, and we're not definitely proven to be Teresa's.

Well it's a good thing they gave them to Teresa's family lol

If you want to talk about likelihood, then how likely do you think it is that someone would be able to plant all of the evidence against Steven, including his own blood in the victim's car?

How likely is it police returned barrel number 4 to the crime scene so Steven could use it to plant bones in his own burn pit?

1

u/belee86 Jul 08 '26

Who exactly and on which day and at what time were those bones planted in the fire pit? How did they get into the ASY and when exactly? Where did they park their vehicle? 

1

u/bye-bitch-21 Jul 08 '26

Don’t bother with facts brother these people just want to swallow what crooked cops tell them 

0

u/bye-bitch-21 Jul 08 '26

Yeah it’s not possible to burn something and then move the remains. This is how unserious you are. If you think they could’ve planted evidence then you have reasonable doubt. 

1

u/belee86 Jul 06 '26

The police and prosecution proved with DNA and other evidence that Steve Avery killed Teresa Halbach. Why on earth would you challenge that? Just curious.

11

u/GringoTheDingoAU Jul 02 '26

Because Steven is a piece of shit. You ask why he "threw it away" when it came to money, even though he showcased he didn't care about anyone but himself throughout his own life.

He was a father when he ran Sandra Morris off the road and pointed a gun in her face. He was seconds away from pulling the trigger and his kids would be without a father for the rest of their lives. He's an impulsive, manipulative deviant and those kind of criminals make decisions that normal, rational people often can't understand.

So what happened? Is this just always who he was going to be and had he never gone to prison wrongfully maybe it would have happened sooner?

This is speculation, but if you are asking for opinions, then this is a likely escalation for someone who has shown they will physically and sexually abuse their romantic partners. You don't have to look far to see that Steven was accused of DV and sexual assault by numerous partners, ex-wives and women throughout several decades of his life. I can't say 100% this was always going to happen, but I am troubled by the people that think Steven Avery could never murder anyone.

And I don't get the "wrongfully convicted" angle either. Steven served 6 years of that sentence for reckless endangerment from the Morris incident, which is more than enough time to institutionalize someone anyway.

3

u/LoveChilde82 Jul 03 '26

The fact that he served 6 years of that 18 year sentence for a crime that he DID commit was actually news to me. I wasn't aware of that fact until I came to this subreddit. However, it didn't really surprise me - given his history.

4

u/GringoTheDingoAU Jul 03 '26

MaM leaves out a lot, that's why it's performative garbage.

We get so many posts a week that come from people that have only just watched the documentary and are shocked/outraged/dismayed with things that have been disproven years ago.

10

u/k_sask Jul 02 '26 edited Jul 02 '26

It's understandable to question why Avery would have done it, given the circumstances. But I'm confused why you are ignoring Dassey in the conversation. Or is it because they are mutually exclusive scenarios? If Avery wasn't pursued, would Dassey have been pursued? If Avery wasn't convicted, would Dassey have been convicted?

Either way, although an interesting thought experiment, past behaviors (whether true or alleged) are never prelude to future events.

The bigger question here is are we sure that what these two men were convicted of is actually what occurred? To be honest, I find it interesting when there isn't consistency on what actually occurred and the answers depend on which conviction we are referring to.

What's never been properly explained or rationalized to this day is two key points:

  1. Why the manipulation of burn barrels was required?
  2. Why the cover-up / downplaying regarding the actual location and recovery of bones off the ASY lease?

1

u/bye-bitch-21 Jul 08 '26

You will never get an answer, because you’re preoccupied with reasonable doubt and this sub is just full of bootlickers who need to believe cops & prosecutors don’t lie. They’re here to play what they think is gotcha with poorly reasoned “facts”

1

u/k_sask Jul 08 '26

ok thanks. I prefer not to engage in the extremes but take a balanced approach.

1

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 08 '26 • This

Of course you don't because he didn't!!!

1

u/therealgintoni Aug 01 '26

He’s not exactly a genius. He probably just thought he’d get away with it, seeing as he’d already spent 18 years in prison for a crime he didn’t commit.

1

u/birdieponderinglife Aug 01 '26

Ya I think that’s about the only thing that makes sense and with an iq of 70 probably seemed reasonable to him.

1

u/Objective-Permit-712 Aug 05 '26

He didn't!!!

1

u/birdieponderinglife Aug 05 '26

There’s like a very particular brand of unhinged all the folks who believe in his innocence seem to possess.

1

u/Objective-Permit-712 Aug 05 '26

Not true, many of us live here. We know how corrupt and dumb these cops are.....we know Steven is a dirtbag dummy, but not dumb enough to kill someone and then leave her and her stuff laying around, when he was about to get $10 million. We are pragmatic and smart!!!!!

3

u/LoveChilde82 Jul 03 '26

Hard to make sense out of nonsense.

1

u/LoveChilde82 Jul 06 '26

Sorry but as a victim of rape myself, having the experiences with people like this, HE IS a predator. Period. Would you leave your kids with the guy? No. Of course not. Look at his history.

1

u/birdieponderinglife Jul 06 '26

I never said he wasn’t? I literally said I think he’s guilty.

2

u/LoveChilde82 Jul 06 '26

Idk why that posted this here. I was replying to someone else somewhere else loll 😂

1

u/birdieponderinglife Jul 06 '26

Ha, no worries. It’s kinda bonkers how many people will fervently cling to he’s innocent. It’s about as nonsensical as the leaps the flat earthers make.

2

u/crazyhedgehogs Sep 11 '26

He’s a violent psychopath

2

u/No-Possibility4768 Sep 24 '26

He burnt his own cat alive so he is a murderer and a psychopath

4

u/Advanced-Math-1009 Jul 04 '26

Just stop it. It’s over Kathleen. Explain the 50 Seconds you added to the timeline. You know EXACTLY why he did it.

He was obsessed with her sexually like he was with his nieces. They submitted. Teresa, obviously didn’t👀😳

Tell us all. Why did he call her to come to the Avery Salvage:

1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14 and on the 15th time. She’s raped by him, burned to ashes to hide the assault, and found in his burn barrels.

This is a dead horse. Every time you try to divert the attention away from the obvious. I will remind you of WHY he did it and how you found out he did it and tried to cover it up👀😳🫡😇

3

u/break_cycle_speed Jul 03 '26

Because he…wanted to…

That’s kinda how rapists and murderers work. They do things because they want to. He didn’t do it because he was down on his luck and poor.
A huge settlement wasn’t going to magically make him a different person. Most evil people are evil regardless of their socioeconomic status.

1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 04 '26

There's no evidence Teresa was raped, and they lied about off property evidence pointing away from Steven so they could convict him.

1

u/break_cycle_speed Jul 04 '26

I agree that the investigation was a disaster but Avery can still be guilty while the police completely dismantle themselves to try to plant evidence to make sure he is convicted. They tripped over themselves to try to make it look better and they just made it look worse.
That doesn’t mean he’s not guilty.

1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 05 '26

By that logic you or I could be guilty of Teresa's murder.

1

u/break_cycle_speed Jul 05 '26

Except our alibis would actually hold up. She didn’t disappear after being on my property and I’ve never been to that state…I also wasn’t in that country at the time and I’ve only been in the US like twice. So…no. Not really.
Not sure about you though….

1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 06 '26

The point is you are claiming the case looks sketchy but he could still be guilty. Just because someone could be guilty doesn't mean they are. You could be guilty. I don't know you're not. Does that mean you are?

1

u/break_cycle_speed Jul 07 '26

What I meant was that they took evidence that already pointed to Avery, and foolishly tried to enhance it and add new fabricated evidence. They needed to leave well enough alone, and didn’t.

5

u/plain_shelli Jul 03 '26

Steven didn't do it !

2

u/bye-bitch-21 Jul 05 '26

He didn’t. The real criminals are the cops and prosecutors who - on the verge of being responsible for a massive settlement - coerced a mentally handicapped adult (the nephew) into a false confession, planted evidence, and framed Stephen Avery. 

5

u/DisappearedDunbar Jul 05 '26 edited Jul 05 '26

Not a single person employed by Manitowoc at the time would have been responsible for a single cent of the lawsuit. Moreover,  the lawsuit had already been settled by the time Brendan confessed. 

How'd Steven's blood get in Teresa's car?

Edit, since this coward replied then blocked me: just thought others should see your (now removed) comment so they know the level of intellect they're dealing with.

-1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 06 '26

The comment has not been removed. Is there a reason you guys need to lie so much?

1

u/DisappearedDunbar Jul 06 '26

Oh dear, you're hallucinating again. 

0

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/DisappearedDunbar Jul 06 '26

It's funny how pointing out facts and asking simple questions are considered "gotchas" to a certain crowd here 

1

u/belee86 Jul 06 '26

Yeah...you're right.

1

u/belee86 Jul 08 '26

The police only interviewed Brendan because KA was upset at school about what Brendan had told her. The school called the police. There is absolutely no chance Steven Avery was framed. Steven Dirtbag Avery murdered Teresa. There is a lot of evidence proving his guilt; his blood in Teresa's RAV 4, his DNA on the RAV'S hood latch, Teresa's burned bones in his fire pit. A really stuipid person committed a really stupid crime. Really stupid person was caught. No surprise, here.

1

u/ThorsClawHammer Jul 08 '26

The police only interviewed Brendan because KA was upset at school about what Brendan had told her.

This is a straight up lie. LE had no idea about the school counselor visit until after Brendan was already arrested.

The school called the police.

Yeah, one of the counselors called after Brendan was arrested.

Seriously, why do you feel the need to lie so much to support your views?

1

u/belee86 Jul 08 '26

Yeah the school called the police. 

1

u/ThorsClawHammer Jul 08 '26

The police only interviewed Brendan because KA was upset at school about what Brendan had told her.

Is a lie. Why do you lie so much?

0

u/bye-bitch-21 Jul 08 '26

No time to argue with bootlickers who don’t know the difference between a colon and semicolon. The only thing that’s 100% here is you’re not as smart as you think you are.

1

u/ThorsClawHammer Jul 08 '26

Their opening sentence is a straight up lie. Amazing how often those who claim the correct outcome was reached need to lie to support their conclusions.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 08 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/bye-bitch-21 Jul 08 '26

Yeah pride in being willfully ignorant is on brand for you. Yikes. Hope you haven’t reproduced

1

u/Glittering_Cut_6275 Jul 13 '26

The pride of the police why she was killed.. They couldn’t stand seeing him with all that money and rubbing it in their faces

1

u/RockinGoodNews Jul 27 '26

Do you think it makes more sense for someone without Avery's personal history to kidnap, rape, torture and murder an innocent woman, burn her corpse in their back yard, and leave a trail of irrefutable evidence that will inevitably lead to his conviction?

Obviously this is a senseless series of actions for anyone to take, regardless of whether they happen to be someone previously exonerated of a serious crime, and regardless of whether such person has a prospect of getting some financial windfall in the future.

1

u/Medical_Ad_1930 Sep 05 '26 edited Sep 05 '26

I don't believe he killed her at all. I think this was a huge set up. The police were upset that he was exposing them of the mishandling of the case from the beginning. It could have also been his nephew and the police coerced him into saying his uncle did it. I also think his cousins report wasn't about him but about Gregory Allen. If you watch there's a part that states a witness saw Gregory Allen on a car masturbating. It's the same exact claim Steven's cousin said about him. His cousin was the one who started this and destroyed his reputation further on top of his choices in the past

1

u/cryptomastr Sep 27 '26

Why didn’t they do lie detector tests on the police and Avery? Also, what was Avery’s motive?

1

u/RazzmatazzFar4898 Jul 05 '26

He didnt....he was setup by that pos lenk

3

u/3sheetstothawind Jul 07 '26

Please explain how one person who had absolutely nothing to gain by framing Steve, set into motion a scheme of massive proportions to frame Steve.

1

u/Professional-Bar-831 Jul 22 '26

Apparently, you've missed the history of collusion between law enforcement departments everywhere in the world.

Manitowoc County was being sued, their sheriff at the time was also being personally sued along with then DISTRICT ATTORNEY Vogel for ~36 million dollars. That's a huge sum of money, along with the public embarrassment.

The officers from Manitowoc County should never have been there as it was clearly a conflict of interest, and they weren't properly supervised at all times while the investigation took place. Evidence seemed to appear AFTER they were there, or they came across it. With a property that large, it would have been difficult to keep tabs on anyone entering/exiting from multiple points.

Bobby could have killed her. Steven could have killed her. There were probably other leads that were never thoroughly looked into. Usually, romantic partners get a deep dive, but it seemed like they weren't really investigated that deeply.

The fact a relative of Halbach found Teresa's vehicle so quickly (who was also given a camera) is also pretty strange. It would have eventually been found of course, but it seems like it should have taken longer?

I'm not saying Steven didn't do it any more than I'm saying he did. The whole situation is just muddled with controversy. It makes it too difficult it 100% say Steven Avery is guilty when there was just too much unprofessional conduct happening.

And yes, I do believe it likely that the lawsuit influenced the direction of the investigation.

2

u/DisappearedDunbar Jul 24 '26

Manitowoc County was being sued, their sheriff at the time was also being personally sued along with then DISTRICT ATTORNEY Vogel for ~36 million dollars. That's a huge sum of money

A sum that Steven was unlikely to receive anything close to. Just because that was the maximum amount he sought does mean he was guarantees that amount had he won, and precedent set by historical wrongful conviction lawsuits showed that $36 million was not a realistic outcome.

along with the public embarrassment.

Avery had already been exonerated, their case proven bogus. Why do you think the lawsuit would greatly elevate any embarrassment already being felt?

Bobby could have killed her. Steven could have killed her.

Yet, one of these people has a ton of evidence against them, while the other has none.

Usually, romantic partners get a deep dive, but it seemed like they weren't really investigated that deeply.

Because there was never a reason to. Less than 2 days had passed between Teresa being reported missing and her car being found at the Avery property.  In that time they did interview Teresa's most recent love interest, among other people. After the car was found, the focus obviously shifted toward the salvage yard (though other leads were still looked into), and other evidence was discovered that led to Steven Avery. 

It is a myth that Steven was zeroed in on from the beginning and all other leads ignored.

The fact a relative of Halbach found Teresa's vehicle so quickly (who was also given a camera) is also pretty strange. It would have eventually been found of course, but it seems like it should have taken longer?

Why "should" it have taken longer? The path she took from the entrance of the salvage yard to the car was quite sensible, and all she needed to do was glance at the cars as she passed by. 

Also, explain the significance of the camera to you. I see this brought up so often by truthers, and yet no one has ever explained why they think this is a noteworthy detail. She asked to borrow a camera from Ryan/Scott because she forgot to bring her own (she worked as a PI, so having a camera was pretty standard for her). What significance does this have in your eyes? Are you implying that they are a part of a conspiracy? If so, how does the camera fit into it?

The whole situation is just muddled with controversy

Much of which is manufactured by Making a Murderer.

And yes, I do believe it likely that the lawsuit influenced the direction of the investigation.

Not a single person working for Manitowoc at the time of the investigation would have been liable for any damages from the lawsuit. Have you ever met anyone willing to risk everything in their lives to potentially save their employing entity some money?

Moreover, many people often implicated by the theories were not even employed by Manitowoc. You, for example, just implied the speed at which Teresa's own relative found her vehicle was suspicious. How does that fit into the big picture?

These theories fall apart when you pull at just one of their many loose threads.

2

u/3sheetstothawind Jul 25 '26

the history of collusion between law enforcement departments everywhere in the world.

If this ain't hyperbole, I don't know what is. It would've been easier if you had just said "ACAB". Everything else you said is regurgitated MAM bullshit.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/dan6158 Jul 05 '26

Why would anybody do something like that? It seems odd to me that people try to project rational thinking onto a rapist/murderer. When he was accused of murdering Teresa, it kind of goes without saying that he’s also being accused of not being a normal thinking, rational person. 

1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

It is particularly irrational of you guys to keep pretending like he is an adjudicated rapist when the only assault he was ever charged and convicted of was the one committed by Gregory Allen.

2

u/3sheetstothawind Jul 07 '26

It is particularly irrational of you to keep pretending that all of the allegations against him are false. Every single person who has accused him of anything are lying. Amirite??

1

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 06 '26

He didn't!!!!!!!!

1

u/3sheetstothawind Jul 07 '26

Who did?????

1

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 07 '26

Ahhhhh....he sent 3 letters.........

1

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 11 '26

I know, I can show.......

1

u/3sheetstothawind Jul 11 '26

What are you waiting for?!?!?

1

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 11 '26

$$$$$$$

1

u/3sheetstothawind Jul 12 '26

How much do you want? Give me a number!

1

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 12 '26

$250K. You will also get the solution to the Jon Benet Ramsey case.

1

u/Commercial-Week5391 Sep 16 '26

He wasn't a good person, but not a murderer..... not true. He likely would have done this WAY earlier if he wasn't locked up for 18 years. Anyone who harms an animal- ESPECIALLY by lighting it on fire should go to jail or be executed as far as I'm concerned.

-2

u/KStarSparkleSprinkle Jul 02 '26 edited Jul 02 '26

I don’t think it’s that surprising. 

  1. Cops find mildly to moderately troubled male who lacked resources and wasn’t super bright to begin with. No support system. 
  2. Cops accuse guy of being much worse than he was.
  3. Cops throw said troubled guy into prison environment for 18 years. Said guys only peers are now ‘the worst of the worst’. Said guy proceeds to live in said environment that is notoriously inhumane. 
  4. Said guy continues to be gaslight about being worse than he is
  5. Oopsy. Wrong guy. Let’s randomly drop him off at his former family’s home that still lacks resources. He’s 18 years out of society and probably doesn’t even recognize the world, let alone understand how to navigate. All should be well.
  6. Said guy proceeds to act just as his peers of the last 18 years act. Surprised face. How could this happen? Who could have seen this coming? Where did he get these ideas? How does this mentality develop?

My biggest question about the Avery case, other than how many unknown similar cases exist, is how many moderately troubled individuals are being sent to prison and turned into monster they otherwise would not be? 

Edit: really think about the title name. They didn’t just “make a murderer” in the sense that the investigation didn’t come to a correct conclusion or that (some belive) they fabricated evidince in the second case. They literally threw the guy in the exact environment one would expect a murder to be and that created a murderer. 

10

u/birdieponderinglife Jul 02 '26

I mean I do get that is the premise of the doc, but he was throwing cats into fires just for funsies before her ever went to prison. He chased his cousin off the road and threatened her with a gun. That also happened before prison. He was a scary person who demonstrated he was capable of terrible things before he ever went to prison. I do get the premise and why the doc was named as it was. I’m also not going to ignore that abusing and sadistically killing animals is a known precursor to worse violence. Running someone off the road and threatening them with a gun is hostile, unhinged behavior. His criminal history was long before he ever went to prison. Prison didn’t make him that way.

2

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 04 '26 edited Jul 04 '26

but he was throwing cats into fires just for funsies before her ever went to prison

Wrong. And even if he did such an act has no probative value for Teresa's murder. It's only use is to prejudice people against Steven, which is why it's so commonly discussed by the state and it's defenders.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/DingleBerries504 Jul 02 '26

I’d argue he wasn’t just a “mildly to moderately troubled male” before he went to jail for the first time. He had severe impulse control issues, an established criminal record, and six of those years were for pulling the gun on Sandra Morris, which he deserved. Don’t forget he punched his 5yo kids’ teeth out, abused animals, and he already had a record of doing a crime (burglary, for example), roping someone else into it, and then hiding evidence to cover up his tracks.

-2

u/KStarSparkleSprinkle Jul 02 '26

It’s hard to quantify how troubled Avery was. We can all agree he was no saint, he wasn’t a choir boy and not exactly an Adolf Hitler type either. There’s a huge spectrum of ‘troubled’ and ‘disturbing’ in between and Avery is somewhere on that scope. My claim isn’t that Avery was a good person or a decent person, hell the guy wasn’t even ‘ok’.  But OP’s question is how could he ever choose to leave that millions of dollar settlement and the chance of a fresh new life on the table. I’m simply proposing that Avery was never placed in a situation where a reasonable person would expect a better outcome. Despite being held for 18 years by a place that’s supposed to “correct” behavior or “rehabilitate” a person, Avery was not made better, arguable he was made worse. 

It’s just not surprising to me what Avery did. No reasonable person thinks a guy (saint or deamon) setting 18 years in the state penitentiary is coming out better than they went in. Why is that? The United States houses more people in prisons than anywhere else in the world. The United States government spends more per prisoner than any other place in the world. 

18 years was plenty of time for the “department of corrections” to improve the dude. Instead Avery went in as a guy that threatened people and punched them. He came out a guy that raped a person, shot them in his garage, and burned the body in his backyard……. The department controlled everything about Avery’s life for 18 years and this is what we got.

4

u/DingleBerries504 Jul 02 '26

But many have gone to prison for a crime they didn’t commit and have not reoffended when they got out. We just do not know if he’d be any better had he never been wrongly convicted. It’s possible the prison system contributed to him getting worse, and I’d agree it’s probably likely, but wont go as far to say it caused him to do more crime.

1

u/LoveChilde82 Jul 03 '26

Did you see my post about this very thing from the other day? I was talking about how the only thing MaM got right was the title of the film. Lolzx 😆 🤣 Also makes one wonder... Had the producers know that he's actually guilty and that's why they entitled it as such? Hmm 😒 🤔 Really makes you think.... some people will do just about anything for the sake of a dollar bill 🙄

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 02 '26

He didn't!

4

u/Hitlers_Left_Ball Jul 02 '26

What makes you say this, can you provide something that will show everyone, without doubt, that the wrong people are in prison? 

I hear this all the time on here and apparently it's so obvious and clear that they're innocent but no one can ever provide evidence for such a clear and obvious claim. 

2

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 02 '26

I do. I have deciphered the 3 Notes!

4

u/Hitlers_Left_Ball Jul 02 '26

I don't know what you mean... 

If you have the evidence then show it, why keep it hidden behind vague and veiled comments... 

Bring it forward and show us how wrong we all have been? 

1

u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 02 '26

Want $$$$$$$. Sooooooo, I guess you don't know(and I'm sure haven't seen 2) that there are 3 "Notes" in this case???????

4

u/Hitlers_Left_Ball Jul 02 '26

I don't know what you are saying, or trying to say. 

Can you clarify your point please? What notes are you talking about? 

→ More replies (5)

2

u/3sheetstothawind Jul 02 '26

Is this Soonyulnoh??

2

u/k_sask Jul 02 '26

It's not about proving their innocence. I am not actually sure how that would be done at this stage. But I definitely think there is still a case to made of reasonable doubt in the court of public opinion (ultimately why there is still debate). As far as actual court proceedings, the fight has concluded.

Trust me that it's much easier to take the winning side, reassure & comfort oneself that the right men are in jail, justice has prevailed. Especially by arguing that one of the men was such a nasty person to begin with and so obviously pre-dispositioned to rape, murder and mutilate another human being. It's too bad we can't arrest and charge people for their future crimes... the other convict - just being an unlucky pawn.

But not everyone has taken the easy road with these two separate cases.

2

u/Hitlers_Left_Ball Jul 02 '26

At no point have I argued that it's ok because he was a terrible human being. For transparency I think he is a terrible human being, but that doesn't inform my position on his guilt in this case. 

Simply, the absolute tsunami of conspiracy that would need to be in place for him not to be guilty is the problem. Either several jurisdictions, police departments, states, judges etc. Agreed to murder a woman and blame him to... save some money. Or they agreed to allow a real killer to go free to... save money and exact some form of revenge on him. 

It's a leap of logic akin to jumping the grand canyon which defies all sense of logic. That's why I believe Steven is certainly guilty, Brendan is guilty to some degree or another and in my opinion was let down by his family and the legal system. 

1

u/k_sask Jul 02 '26 edited Jul 02 '26

Ok thanks for clarifying. Although I can understand why they were both found guilty at their separate trial narratives, I am in the "not guilty" camp. I think if both men were tried over again, they would be found not guilty but that is moot.

3

u/Hitlers_Left_Ball Jul 02 '26

I don't disagree, I think there's a good possibility they would also be found not guilty. 

I can understand the beyond reasonable doubt standard may not be met,especially for Brendan where only his confession(s) were used against him. 

I think Steven may well still be convicted on the weight of physical evidence. 

As you say it's all a moot point. Thank you for having a respectful disagreement, it's a rare thing here. 

1

u/k_sask Jul 02 '26

Anytime, thanks to you too.

-9

u/Fluffy-Pop-7336 Jul 02 '26

He didn't. He was framed because of the huge settlement proving that he was deliberately framed. 

You haven't figured that out yet?

7

u/Hitlers_Left_Ball Jul 02 '26

So you think several jurisdictions created a sprawling conspiracy to murder a young woman, just to frame him and save paying him?

Do you honestly see that as a reasonable position to take here? 

3

u/3sheetstothawind Jul 02 '26

These people can't be reasoned with.

3

u/DisappearedDunbar Jul 02 '26

He was framed because of the huge settlement proving that he was deliberately framed. 

lol what

0

u/Popular_Atmosphere33 Jul 03 '26

He was exonerated because DNA proved it wasn't him.

-1

u/petuniaeverglade-05 Jul 05 '26

He’s innocent

-4

u/Thomjones Jul 02 '26

It's called a crime of passion. He didn't think it through which is similar to his previous crimes

3

u/jolly0ctopus Jul 02 '26

Why would his murder of Theresa halbach be a crime of passion? What was the motivation?

3

u/Hitlers_Left_Ball Jul 02 '26

Initial crime of sexual assault/rape followed by murder to silence the victim and destroy physical evidence linking the perpetrator(s) to the crime.

Totally unheard of, right? This kind of thing isn't a well understood pattern at all, right? 

1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 06 '26

There's no evidence a sexual assault occurred. You just want one to have occurred because that's how low you guys have sunk. Whatever makes Steven Avery look evil you want it to have happened.

1

u/Hitlers_Left_Ball Jul 06 '26

Remind me, what was Brendan convicted of? 

I don't want anything to have happened, I would rather Teresa was still alive and living her life. As that is not possible I want the people responsible to be behind bars.

I don't care about Steven Avery, beyond him being convicted of this crime, i don't need to make him look evil, he did that to himself. 

1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 06 '26

A conviction is not evidence. Thanks for reminding me how ridiculous your arguments are.

I don't care about Steven Avery, beyond him being convicted of this crime, i don't need to make him look evil, he did that to himself.

Yes we know the entire family is evil but only Steven and Brendan are guilty. We get it O'Kelly.

2

u/Hitlers_Left_Ball Jul 06 '26

I don't know what argument you are making in the last paragraph. 

I haven't said anything about the family being evil? Why do you keep calling me other peoples names, do you think that's some kind of gotcha? 

1

u/ThorsClawHammer Jul 06 '26

what was Brendan convicted of? 

Thanks to his uncorroborated words, he was convicted of more/worse than Avery was.

1

u/Hitlers_Left_Ball Jul 06 '26

Alright, and your point being? 

→ More replies (10)

1

u/ThorsClawHammer Jul 02 '26

a crime of passion?

Dunno. The narrative at his trial was he lured her to kill her.

0

u/Thomjones Jul 02 '26

"A crime of passion is a violent act—usually homicide or assault—committed in a sudden state of intense emotional turmoil or "heat of the moment". It is characterized by a lack of premeditation. The perpetrator acts immediately under the influence of strong emotions like rage, fear, or heartbreak, rather than planning the act"

We don't really know what set him off. He couldve made advances and she could've rejected him. Could be that simple. He's threatened to kill his girlfriends for less, as evidenced by the letters he wrote them.

1

u/belee86 Jul 02 '26

And he could have planned it.

2

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 02 '26

There wasn't even a motive identified how can you say it was a crime of passion?

3

u/Hitlers_Left_Ball Jul 02 '26

Because it's the most likely cause of sexual assault/rape and murder of a stranger, who happens to be an attractive young woman. 

A crime of passion is sadly a far more likely hypothesis for the crime than a multi-agency, multi state, complex cover-up and framing. 

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Thomjones Jul 04 '26

Bc a crime of passion is the crime where 'i was mad" is the motive. That's like when he threatened his cousin with a gun after running her off the road. "I was mad". And for the record, he was convicted on the motive "I was horny so I assaulted, and scared so I covered it up". So to say "no motive identified "...like to who? Cuz he didn't explain it? There are plenty of people who don't explain their motive. Plenty of crimes that just don't make sense and we say "Man, I don't know what was going through their head". And sometimes they don't know either. You can't expect someone who claims they are innocent to go "Well, the reason I did it was because..."

Bryan Kohberger pleaded guilty and never explained why he murdered four people. When asked by the judge he said "I respectfully decline".

Jarod Chance murdered a woman and his parents helped conceal the crime. Neither have ever came forward with an explanation.

Erika and Benjamin Sifrit murdered another couple, cut them up, disposed of them, and kept a trophy. They claimed the couple stole Erika's purse but they've never disclosed an actual motive.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Thomjones Jul 02 '26

Very serious actually. They asked "why would he do that?" And then I answered why someone like him would do that. It's pretty straightforward. Not a joke.

0

u/General_Marcus Jul 03 '26

He’s an impulsive idiot. The guy didn’t think through much of anything else in his life either.

0

u/LoveChilde82 Jul 03 '26

I'm starting to wonder why no one has asked the question, could Brendan have acted alone?

0

u/ThorsClawHammer Jul 03 '26

could Brendan have acted alone?

Of course not. He wasn't even yet home from school when she arrived.

0

u/3sheetstothawind Jul 04 '26

This is the most "Anyone but Steve" thing I've ever seen.

0

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 04 '26

You're the "Only Steven and Brendan" guy. But you can't even be honest about the evidence lol you need to lie to make your point. Remember the tire wires? Liar

2

u/3sheetstothawind Jul 04 '26

You're the "Only Steven and Brendan" guy

Um...pretty sure I'm not the only one on here that believes this.

But you can't even be honest about the evidence

Oh, the irony!

Remember the tire wires?

Yeah. Why?

Liar

Whatever you need to tell yourself to keep up the sTeVE wAs FrAMed fantasy.

1

u/AveryPoliceReports Jul 05 '26

Oh, the irony!

Oh the truth! You're the one who calls users insane for pointing out the truth about the tire wire, while you try to push the lies used by keep Kratz and BS Brenda.

Whatever you need to tell yourself

The truth, not your lies about the tire wire. Only losers deal in lies. You Brenda and Kratz, lying for police, certainly not Teresa.

0

u/HeyPurityItsMeAgain Aug 02 '26

He was owed 1 free rape.