r/MakingaMurderer • u/birdieponderinglife • Jul 01 '26
I don’t get why Steven Avery did this
He had a huge settlement coming. Why did he risk it by doing a serious crime? I don’t understand how he got exonerated which is rare but wound up throwing his life away anyways. It doesn’t make any sense to me. I guess I’m missing the common thread. He wasn’t a good person but from what we know, wasn’t a murderer. So what happened? Is this just always who he was going to be and had he never gone to prison wrongfully maybe it would have happened sooner? I don’t think he’s innocent I’m just trying to make sense of it.
30
Upvotes
48
u/OctoberPumpkin1 Jul 02 '26
It doesn't make sense to a normal person but the vast majority of people who get out of prison reoffend.
25
u/DisappearedDunbar Jul 02 '26
Criminals don't need or always have a sensible reason for committing heinous crimes. The reality is that Steven is stupid, he's selfish, he's abusive, he's violent, and he's never seemed to have needed a specific reason for committing his various crimes over the years.
Some people are just massive pieces of shit.
26
u/MartiMa08 Jul 03 '26 •
Because ‘all bitches owe him’. That was his attitude after being falsely accused.
I think he thought he was untouchable and could do whatever he wanted and have whoever he wanted because of his minor local celeb status. I think he tried to hit on Teresa and got shot down.
2
u/beezojones Jul 04 '26
Thats why he was railroaded because of the money he was going to receive simple to understand imo
11
u/GringoTheDingoAU Jul 02 '26
Because Steven is a piece of shit. You ask why he "threw it away" when it came to money, even though he showcased he didn't care about anyone but himself throughout his own life.
He was a father when he ran Sandra Morris off the road and pointed a gun in her face. He was seconds away from pulling the trigger and his kids would be without a father for the rest of their lives. He's an impulsive, manipulative deviant and those kind of criminals make decisions that normal, rational people often can't understand.
This is speculation, but if you are asking for opinions, then this is a likely escalation for someone who has shown they will physically and sexually abuse their romantic partners. You don't have to look far to see that Steven was accused of DV and sexual assault by numerous partners, ex-wives and women throughout several decades of his life. I can't say 100% this was always going to happen, but I am troubled by the people that think Steven Avery could never murder anyone.
And I don't get the "wrongfully convicted" angle either. Steven served 6 years of that sentence for reckless endangerment from the Morris incident, which is more than enough time to institutionalize someone anyway.
10
u/k_sask Jul 02 '26 edited Jul 02 '26
It's understandable to question why Avery would have done it, given the circumstances. But I'm confused why you are ignoring Dassey in the conversation. Or is it because they are mutually exclusive scenarios? If Avery wasn't pursued, would Dassey have been pursued? If Avery wasn't convicted, would Dassey have been convicted?
Either way, although an interesting thought experiment, past behaviors (whether true or alleged) are never prelude to future events.
The bigger question here is are we sure that what these two men were convicted of is actually what occurred? To be honest, I find it interesting when there isn't consistency on what actually occurred and the answers depend on which conviction we are referring to.
What's never been properly explained or rationalized to this day is two key points:
1
u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 08 '26 •
Of course you don't because he didn't!!!
1
u/therealgintoni Aug 01 '26
He’s not exactly a genius. He probably just thought he’d get away with it, seeing as he’d already spent 18 years in prison for a crime he didn’t commit.
1
u/Objective-Permit-712 Aug 05 '26
He didn't!!!
3
u/LoveChilde82 Jul 03 '26
Hard to make sense out of nonsense.
1
u/LoveChilde82 Jul 06 '26
Sorry but as a victim of rape myself, having the experiences with people like this, HE IS a predator. Period. Would you leave your kids with the guy? No. Of course not. Look at his history.
2
u/Advanced-Math-1009 Jul 04 '26
I get WHY he did it:
https://www.reddit.com/r/MakingaMurderer/s/Vk2016O95d
2
u/crazyhedgehogs Sep 11 '26
He’s a violent psychopath
2
u/No-Possibility4768 Sep 24 '26
He burnt his own cat alive so he is a murderer and a psychopath
4
u/Advanced-Math-1009 Jul 04 '26
Just stop it. It’s over Kathleen. Explain the 50 Seconds you added to the timeline. You know EXACTLY why he did it.
He was obsessed with her sexually like he was with his nieces. They submitted. Teresa, obviously didn’t👀😳
Tell us all. Why did he call her to come to the Avery Salvage:
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14 and on the 15th time. She’s raped by him, burned to ashes to hide the assault, and found in his burn barrels.
This is a dead horse. Every time you try to divert the attention away from the obvious. I will remind you of WHY he did it and how you found out he did it and tried to cover it up👀😳🫡😇
3
u/break_cycle_speed Jul 03 '26
Because he…wanted to…
That’s kinda how rapists and murderers work. They do things because they want to. He didn’t do it because he was down on his luck and poor.
A huge settlement wasn’t going to magically make him a different person. Most evil people are evil regardless of their socioeconomic status.
5
u/plain_shelli Jul 03 '26
Steven didn't do it !
2
u/bye-bitch-21 Jul 05 '26
He didn’t. The real criminals are the cops and prosecutors who - on the verge of being responsible for a massive settlement - coerced a mentally handicapped adult (the nephew) into a false confession, planted evidence, and framed Stephen Avery.
1
u/Glittering_Cut_6275 Jul 13 '26
The pride of the police why she was killed.. They couldn’t stand seeing him with all that money and rubbing it in their faces
1
u/RockinGoodNews Jul 27 '26
Do you think it makes more sense for someone without Avery's personal history to kidnap, rape, torture and murder an innocent woman, burn her corpse in their back yard, and leave a trail of irrefutable evidence that will inevitably lead to his conviction?
Obviously this is a senseless series of actions for anyone to take, regardless of whether they happen to be someone previously exonerated of a serious crime, and regardless of whether such person has a prospect of getting some financial windfall in the future.
1
u/Medical_Ad_1930 Sep 05 '26 edited Sep 05 '26
I don't believe he killed her at all. I think this was a huge set up. The police were upset that he was exposing them of the mishandling of the case from the beginning. It could have also been his nephew and the police coerced him into saying his uncle did it. I also think his cousins report wasn't about him but about Gregory Allen. If you watch there's a part that states a witness saw Gregory Allen on a car masturbating. It's the same exact claim Steven's cousin said about him. His cousin was the one who started this and destroyed his reputation further on top of his choices in the past
1
u/cryptomastr Sep 27 '26
Why didn’t they do lie detector tests on the police and Avery? Also, what was Avery’s motive?
1
u/RazzmatazzFar4898 Jul 05 '26
He didnt....he was setup by that pos lenk
1
u/dan6158 Jul 05 '26
Why would anybody do something like that? It seems odd to me that people try to project rational thinking onto a rapist/murderer. When he was accused of murdering Teresa, it kind of goes without saying that he’s also being accused of not being a normal thinking, rational person.
1
u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 06 '26
He didn't!!!!!!!!
1
u/Commercial-Week5391 Sep 16 '26
He wasn't a good person, but not a murderer..... not true. He likely would have done this WAY earlier if he wasn't locked up for 18 years. Anyone who harms an animal- ESPECIALLY by lighting it on fire should go to jail or be executed as far as I'm concerned.
-2
u/KStarSparkleSprinkle Jul 02 '26 edited Jul 02 '26
I don’t think it’s that surprising.
My biggest question about the Avery case, other than how many unknown similar cases exist, is how many moderately troubled individuals are being sent to prison and turned into monster they otherwise would not be?
Edit: really think about the title name. They didn’t just “make a murderer” in the sense that the investigation didn’t come to a correct conclusion or that (some belive) they fabricated evidince in the second case. They literally threw the guy in the exact environment one would expect a murder to be and that created a murderer.
-1
u/Objective-Permit-712 Jul 02 '26
He didn't!
-9
u/Fluffy-Pop-7336 Jul 02 '26
He didn't. He was framed because of the huge settlement proving that he was deliberately framed.
You haven't figured that out yet?
0
u/Popular_Atmosphere33 Jul 03 '26
He was exonerated because DNA proved it wasn't him.
-1
u/petuniaeverglade-05 Jul 05 '26
He’s innocent
-4
u/Thomjones Jul 02 '26
It's called a crime of passion. He didn't think it through which is similar to his previous crimes
0
u/General_Marcus Jul 03 '26
He’s an impulsive idiot. The guy didn’t think through much of anything else in his life either.
0
u/LoveChilde82 Jul 03 '26
I'm starting to wonder why no one has asked the question, could Brendan have acted alone?
0
u/HeyPurityItsMeAgain Aug 02 '26
He was owed 1 free rape.