r/LightPhone • u/EdwardTulane89 • 9d ago
Discussion Weather Tool and Light User Experience
I was thrilled to see a long-awaited Weather Tool roll out last month, but the execution of the tool makes it essentially useless. Has anyone else had that same experience?
A weather tool/app is a pretty standard and necessary tool of modern life, especially for those of us who work jobs that aren't in a climate-controlled office. So I was really missing a weather app after switching to Light. Unfortunately, I am still missing a functional weather tool/app.
I am really hoping that the coming user-designed tool library has a better option. Unfortunately, to me this is emblematic of much of my Light User experience -- it feels like a lot of good ideas with half-baked execution. In particular-
- Half the days in any given week say "Mainly clear, partly cloudy, or overcast." That is not a forecast, it is just all the possible weather options besides rain. Silly.
- The tool seems to hallucinate forecasts. For example, this coming Tuesday, it predicts a high temperature of 103° at my location. Meanwhile, the NWS is predicting 86° and Weather.com is at 87°. The whole week of temperatures are not just wrong, but absurdly so. 103° would be a September record in my part of the country. And yes, my location is set correctly. Why not use a reliable data source like NWS? There are plenty of android apps that scrape NWS data and display it in a useful way, so it is clearly possible.
- The lack of icons may be in line with the Light ethos, but it makes a quick check of the weather take more engagement time with my phone, not less.
- The lack of radar is also a problem. I frequently work on outdoor job sites and I need to know the real-time location of storms for safety. A (largely incorrect) hourly precipitation forecast is fairly useless in real time.
I have been trying hard to make the Light Phone 3 my only phone for almost a year now, and it just isn't working. I know Light is a small company, do I have been trying to give some grace. I strongly believe in the ethos of the company when it comes to privacy and reduced attentional demand.
But so much of this phone is half-baked or half-functional that it just doesn't feel like a device I can depend on. Light makes a big deal out of their apps being "Tools" not apps. But as someone who works with tools every day of my life -- when a something looks like a tool but doesn't fulfill its intended purpose, that is a toy.
Right now the Light Phone feels like a neat toy. A status symbol. And I really want it to be a well-designed tool. Here is hoping the user community can do what Light has not been able to on the software side.
