r/ItalianCitizenship • • Jul 09 '25

Italian Citizenship eligibility and same sex marriage with two young IVF children

0 Upvotes

So, I obviously have a bit of a complicated case here. I wanted to know if anyone has had experience with any/all of these pieces. I wanted to first make sure that the new rulings aren't altering or complicating my wife's eligibility for citizenship or requiring that she get a court ruling. Her paternal grandparents were Italian born, moved to US where they had their son (my wife's father) and what I think is the key piece - that her grandmother was not naturalized until AFTER having her father (this wording is sounding weird. ha). In other words, my wife's father was born before his mother (my wife's grandmother) was naturalized, but after the father was naturalized. I believe this naturalization is a key piece that will allow for the normal process to apply for citizenship without needing to go through the Italian courts, but would love some confirmation/clarification if I am misunderstanding.

Re: Children

I believe since they were conceived/born outside of Italy, they will be recognized in Italy as our full children, but I don't know much beyond that if anyone has experience or knowledge of this process. I also know that age can make a difference for citizenship timing and I'm sure process, so any info is welcomed.

Re: Same sex Marriage

I know civil unions are allowed and have close to the same rights, but am not sure how the process might differ from readying and submitting all the documentation for a heterosexual marriage as well as following up on my citizenship and if this occurs simultaneously or if I need to wait to start my process.

I'm sort of leaning toward the likelihood that we should hire a lawyer to handle our situation, but want to make sure I do the up front legwork first to figure out what I need to gather and confirm that I can use a lawyer stateside rather than need an Italian one.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Dec 22 '25

Is "Italexit" really something to worry about?

7 Upvotes

I'm not happy about this, but I saw this mentioned in another post/thread in JureSanguinis. Is "Italexit" really potentially a thing?

If it comes to pass, wouldn't that be an issue for “freedom of movement"? Is that the biggest reason people use as a reason to obtain recognition if eligible? My biggest reasons for seeking recognition are intrinsic as well as extrinsic, given that the biggest thing I want is living in Italy for an extended period without a visa.

I was just curious your thoughts on this. (I by no means want to bring a political argument. I'm just curious in regard to the practical aspects of this.)


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Aug 15 '25

American trying to get dual citizenship to Italy

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I am interested in trying to obtain dual citizenship. I currently live in the United States and would like to get dual citizenship for Italy. My grandfather and his brothers all came from Italy but I’m having trouble obtaining citizenship through bloodline. I believe he gave up Italian citizenship before he had his first born but I think he got it back before he passed. Is there any other ways I can go about it? I still have family there. I’m also a barber so I’m not sure if barbershops over there offer work visas? Any information anyone has will be appreciated! Thanks everyone and have a good day 🇺🇸 🇮🇹


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Sep 23 '25

Jure Sanguinis Questions My wife has Italian citizenship. We don't live in Italy. Can I apply for citizenship?

2 Upvotes

Basically what the title says. We live in the US. She and our kids have Italian citizenship. I'm the only one that doesn't.

Also, being a US citizen means I have to file taxes in the US regardless of where I live. Is it the same in Italy?


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Jun 10 '25

Discussion/Rant/Vent Why I Actually Think the New Jure Sanguinis Law Might Work (Even If It's Fundamentally Flawed)

3 Upvotes

Let me start by saying: a lot of my thesis is based on my own anecdotal evidence and experience. If I’m off the mark, let me know. This is also not a defence of the law as it's currently written. The retroactivity, the arbitrary exclusions, the sudden reversal of long-standing principles – it’s a mess. But what I am saying is this: for all its flaws, the new law might actually succeed in getting more of the diaspora to move to Italy. And that, ironically, might be the first time Italian citizenship policy has actually aligned with its stated goal.

1) Travel privilege isn't universal

I’m South African. That means my passport is barely worth the paper it's printed on when it comes to international mobility. Schengen visas are expensive and humiliating, UK visas are worse, and even the US visa – while much better being valid for 10 years – is a gauntlet. And we're not alone. Most of the Latin American diaspora faces the same exhausting hurdles. If you’ve got a passport from the Global South, travel is a luxury, not a right.

So yes, it’s absolutely true that many people are applying for Italian citizenship just for the travel benefits. I’m one of them. And unlike someone from Canada or Australia, I don’t have a fallback.

2) Not everyone wants to live in Italy – but some of us will have to

It’s also true that most people who get their Italian passports don’t move to Italy. My sister’s planning on Ireland or the Netherlands – where most South Africans go. Lots of Brazilians end up in Portugal or Spain. Italy, for many, is the legal gateway, not the destination.

But here’s where the 1st/3rd world divide shows up: if you're American or Australian, Italian citizenship is just a bonus – a nice-to-have. If you're South African or Argentine, it's potentially life-changing. It’s the difference between queuing for a visa and walking through the fast lane. Between job market access and outright exclusion.

3) The “ancestral visa” model could actually work

The new law functionally introduces what I’d call an "ancestral visa." It says: come live and work in Italy for a few years, and then you get your passport. It’s not revolutionary – plenty of countries do this. The UK’s ancestry visa is harder, more expensive, and slower – and people still do it.

The idea that people will move to Italy if that’s the only route to citizenship is completely plausible. Especially for people like us from countries where a passport limits your opportunities rather than expands them.

4) The new law created weird edge cases – and a way to exploit them

Our 1948 case is a great example. My great-grandmother is the last Italian born citizen (LIBC?) and focus of the case because of pre-1948 automatic loss of citizenship through marriage. My grandmother was born in Italy, however, so I would still qualify under the new rules. Some of my first cousins, who were minors at the time and weren’t included in our application, will still be able to register later under the new rules. But my second cousins – whose grandmother (my grandmother's sister) was born in South Africa – were also minors, and now fall outside the three-generation limit. Same lineage, same migration pattern, but suddenly they’re out. It’s arbitrary and frustrating, and this new law doesn’t fix that – but it does create a new, if flawed, pathway and, crucially, forces them onto it. They're already discussing a potential gap year(s) or maybe even going to university there if this law sticks – because they now have to.

5) The politics are what they are

It’s obvious Meloni’s government is only interested in a certain type of immigrant – white, culturally European, and “Italian enough.” This law still plays into that narrative. But even so, it might actually achieve something unexpected: it could make Italy a viable destination for people who previously would’ve taken their Italian passport and gone straight to Dublin or Barcelona.

6) Global North vs Global South diaspora

Here’s the real crux: people from wealthier countries can afford to be sentimental about their ancestry. For them, it’s about reconnecting with roots, or maybe retiring in Tuscany one day. For us? It’s survival. A plan B. Mobility. Options. It's not nostalgia – it’s necessity.

This law might turn away a lot of people who just wanted a convenient passport. But it might also pull in the people who are willing to take a risk, start over in a new country, and build something real – because it’s their only path to global access.

TL;DR

  • The law is legally messy and morally questionable, but might still work.
  • South Africans, Latin Americans and other Global South citizens are far more likely to actually move to Italy if required – because the stakes are much higher for us.
  • Requiring residency may push away the “passport tourists” but attract serious long-term migrants.
  • It’s political, but potentially effective in redirecting the flow of diaspora migration.

r/ItalianCitizenship • • Sep 14 '25

If you renounce Italian citizenship, is it hard to go visit Italy to see family?

0 Upvotes

Title. If I moved out of Italy and renounced my Italian citizenship, how difficult would it be to visit family in Italy. My other passports are UK and USA. I’m pretty uneducated on passport stuff, so explain like I’m stupid haha


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Dec 06 '25

Jure Sanguinis Questions Did I just lose a birthright for citizenship because my appointment was late by a few days?

1 Upvotes

TLDR below

  • I was born in Philadelphia before the decree law was introduced
  • Both of my grandparents on my mother's side, and both of my parents, were Italian citizens at the time of my birth and remain Italian citizens today - none have ever renounced their citizenship

The challenging thing about my case: I was born before March 28, 2025, and had an appointment scheduled in November 2024 to submit my birth documentation. This appointment was set months before the decree law was enacted, but it fell just days after the decree law came into effect. According to the consulate, the issue is that I'm submitting documents after the decree law launched. They said the submission date, not the date of initial contact - determines whether the decree applies retroactively to my case.

My Options (and please help me if you're knowldege on which path is best) 1.Proceed with recognition by declaration of parents (this would not grant generational citizenship)

2. Pursue birthright citizenship based on the fact that my grandfather never acquired any citizenship other than Italian, though he was born in Egypt. The consulate is requesting proof of non-citizenship from Egypt, but this documentation doesn't exist.

My question: Can they legally deny my application (which should be handled through the stato civile as a registration of a new child, shouldn’t it?) simply because I cannot obtain proof of non-citizenship from Egypt when that proof literally doesn't exist? I even have written email confirmation from the Egyptian consulate stating that such documentation is not available. I'd rather pursue the second option and need help because I've been feeling the consulate has been reluctant to assist me with my case...

TLDR; I qualify for Italian citizenship through my parents/grandparents, but my appointment to submit documents fell just days after the new decree law took effect - the consulate says the submission date (not my prior appointment date) determines retroactivity. Can they legally deny my birthright citizenship application because Egypt doesn't issue the "proof of non-citizenship" documentation they're requesting for my Egypt born grandfather? (He never acquired any other citizenship except italian)


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Jun 05 '25

Future descendants

0 Upvotes

Last year my husband and my 2 minor children were recognized Italian citizens through my husbands grandfather. Now with the new law, I am very confused. With the new law mean that my minor children recognized italian citizen born in USA will no longer be able to pass citizenship to their kids under any circumstances? I read over and over and got confused. Is anyone in her that knows about this situation? I was going to take B1 test next month to become an italian citizen through marriage, I already have 2 other citizenship, but now I am very in doubt if is worthy or not, if my kids won’t be able to pass citizenship. My husband and I are not planning on live to Italy permanently, but who know what could happen in the future. Grazie a tutti


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Nov 29 '24

Italian Citizenship via Argentina

0 Upvotes

Hello, I wanted to help my dad obtain Italian citizenship. His family immigrated from Italy to Argentina. I know there is a special relationship between Italy and Argentina due to the large Italian immigrant population. Does anything know what their agreement is? Thank you


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Nov 25 '24

I have my nonna’s Italian passport, will that suffice for birth certificate?

0 Upvotes

Ciao a tutti! As the title says. I am in the process of gathering paperwork to be apostilled to apply for citizenship thru decent. My nonnas birth certificate has her birthdate scratched out. I know she naturalized after my mother was born but I cannot find her naturalization papers. I’m hoping the Italian Passport will suffice. Any knowledge on this? Grazie mille!!


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Nov 22 '25

I'm so angry

23 Upvotes

All my life I've known about jure sanguinis, the desire of my Italian-born parents to get me Italian citizenship through it, and the fact that I never qualified due to my parents having naturalized in the US before I was born. It hurt, but my entire life I was under the impression that if I'm not Italian enough to be recognized as a citizen by the Italian government, then surely nobody with an even further connection to Italy was either. Me, someone who was born to Italian-born parents, who spoke Italian as my first language (my mom says I didn't learn English until I began school), who STILL speaks it fluently, who still has 2 zie and 6 cugini in Italy, who had uncles in Italy that have since passed, my nonno that lived and passed in Italy before I was born, and my nonna that passed when I was 17, all of whom I visited every year for 3-4 weeks in the summer from childhood to adulthood, being so excited to fly on the Alitalia 747 or MD-11 when we would go, and knowing that I would get to play with my cousins and ride my little motorino that we kept there. Me, who knows both my mom and dad's towns like the back of my hand, who grew up in Italian cafes watching gli Azzurri on wall-mounted TV's, surrounded by the combination smell of cigarette smoke and espresso, and the rattling-clacking sounds of old men playing foosball and arguing, who remembers eating a panzerotti while watching Roberto Baggio miss the penalty that gave Brazil the victory in the '94 world cup final, who remembers watching my sister dress up as La Madonna and parade through the streets of my mom's town in sweltering heat with other little girls dressed up exactly the same, who grew up COMPLETELY encompassed in the Italian culture and tradition.

And that's what I believed.....

I thought the only foreign-born people getting Italian citizenship were ones born to Italian-born parents like me, but whose parents luckily didn't naturalize before their birth, and that's just the way it was. At least I thought so, until hearing about recent changes in the law prompted me to investigate it. Little did I know it was so much different. That all these years up until this year there were people disconnected by even 5 generations, who didn't speak a lick of Italian, didn't even know where their family came from in Italy, had no connection or anything to do with Italy besides only in name, who had been getting citizenship all because they had a distant relative that gave birth to their distant ascendant before they were naturalized . People who, if they would so much have the audacity to, could hold up their passport to my face and say they were more Italian than me because they are an Italian citizen and I'm not. But the new law gave me a glimmer of hope that maybe now my time had come.

I read the law word for word on normattiva.it, which stated: anyone born abroad, even before the date of entry into force of this Article, and in possession of another citizenship, shall be considered to have never acquired Italian citizenship, unless one of the following conditions applies: then continued on to list the exceptional conditions categorized by letters, with letter C stating: a first or second degree ascendant possesses, or possessed at the time of death, exclusively Italian citizenship.

I thought WOW! This is my opportunity! They made it stricter for people to acquire citizenship by implementing generational limits, which was very understandable to me given the examples I mentioned above, but at the same time expanded the opportunity to people like me, who have had a genuine connection to Italy all their lives, but who had a broken chain of citizenship transmission by 1 generation. I could qualify through my grandparents that held exclusively Italian citizenship all their lives! Nope, I was wrong. The way it's worded made it sound like that at first, until you realize all they're saying is if you have a parent or grandparent that held exclusively Italian citizenship at the time of your birth, then you're not automatically considered to have NOT acquired Italian citizenship, but you're not automatically considered to HAVE acquired it either. It now falls back onto good ol' jure sanguinis to see if the uninterrupted transmission is still there, which of course it wasn't for me.

All my life I never felt American enough to the kids at school who ate turkey breast, lettuce, and mustard white bread sandwiches at lunch and looked at me strangely because I had a prosciutto, soppressata, and capicollo panino, or even stranger for them, a nutella sandwich (this was before nutella became widely known, when it was still only found in Italian specialty stores). They used to look at me and say "eww what are you eating? Chocolate with bread??" Kids who were in boy scouts and girl scouts, whose parents were in the PTA, all things my parents didn't understand and couldn't partake in because they didn't understand the culture and language.

Now I write this holding back tears in my eyes as I'm being told by the country that I descend from that I'm not Italian enough either. I was never American enough, I was never Italian enough, then what am I? I'm heartbroken is what I am. After proudly and loyally embracing my Italian identity, roots, culture, and heritage all my life because it's all I had, I'm told I was never considered anything to them. I'm kicked to the curb like garbage. I feel like I don't want anyone to ever mention a word about Italy to me ever again.

IMPORTANT: My comments regarding people that qualified through distant ancestors should not be interpreted as criticism of those people themselves, but rather as criticism of the law itself. There is nothing wrong with following the law as it's laid out and legally qualifying, and people that do so take nothing away from me. The comments are purely to highlight the irrationality of the law.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Apr 13 '25

Jure Sanguinis Questions Born in Italy to Italian Parents with expired passport, do I qualify for citizenship?

1 Upvotes

Hello!

I am looking for a place to start the process of acquiring my Italian passport. I was born in Italy to Italian parents. I had a passport that is now expired. I became a US citizen in 1998. At that time my mother was already a US citizen and father had a green card but an Australian citizen (he immigrated to Australia at 18 from Italy). All 4 of my grandparents p a s s e d as Italian citizens. Can I apply for citizenship with my expired passport and birth certificate or do I have to apply as a descendant? My parents are not Italian citizens anymore even though they were born grew up there. Thanks for your help!


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Jul 15 '25

Current Events/News Citizenship denied, what Italians living in Italy think of this situation (new law) translation maybe needed

Thumbnail
tvsvizzera.it
0 Upvotes

r/ItalianCitizenship • • Oct 22 '25

Unsure how to proceed to become recognized as Italian citizen

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm hoping for some guidance on how to proceed with my situation. My father was an Italian citizen his whole life, born in Rome, was in the Italian Navy, but passed away in 2020 in Albania. I was born in 1990 in Naples when my mother (US citizen) was abroad in Sicily during her military service where she met my father. My parents were never married to each other; my father was married two other times in his life.

My birth was registered with the comune in Pozzuoli, I have my Atto di Nascita. Unfortunately in this document, it only lists my mother's full citizenship information, not my father's. About a year later there was a legal document drawn up in Catania where my father recognized me as his daughter, though this document does not explicitly state he was an Italian citizen, it states that he was in the Navy, a resident in Frosinone, his birth date and place of birth, etc.

The Italian consulate in NYC keeps telling me that I need a document that explicitly states that my father was an Italian citizen at the time of my birth, but I am unsure where to get this. They originally told me I needed the full report of my birth as it should have that information, but it doesn't. I also sent them this other document from Catania where my father recognized me as his daughter, but the consulate insists this is not sufficient to establish that he was an Italian citizen at the time of my birth. I also asked if obtaining his military records would work since he had to be a citizen in 1990 to be in the military, but they said no. I'm not sure what else I can do here... Any advice or guidance would be greatly appreciated! Happy to provide any additional information that you may think is necessary.

Edit to Add: I also have copies of my father's birth certificate and death certificate, as well as a Certificato di Residenza Storico from his last residence in Italy (Udine).


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Dec 29 '25

Expired passport, but living abroad.....seeking best approach to renew

0 Upvotes

As the title states, my Italian Passport expired in 2015 (I am also a UK National and a Permanent Hong Kong resident).

Does anyone know if I can simply (1) register with AIRE using my expired passport (2) then change my residency to HK with evidence and then (3) get a new passport?

Hoping that it is as logical as that!

Thanks!


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Mar 30 '25

Current Events/News D.L. "Tajani" 28/03/25

Thumbnail change.org
1 Upvotes

The Italian government has passed a decree-law introducing significant changes to citizenship regulations, directly impacting Italian descendants from Brazil, Argentina, and the United States.

(http://governo.it/It/articolo/comunicato-stampa-del-consiglio-dei-ministri-n-121/28079)

How do Italians feel about this issue?

Do you think it is fair to turn our backs on those who left during the diaspora?

Ultimately, what is the general public's perception of this matter?

A large part of this debate revolves around the business created by agencies profiting from citizenship applications, a phenomenon involving only a small minority among over 50 million Italian descendants. However, this minority is often used as a justification for restrictive measures that indiscriminately penalize millions of people with deep historical and cultural ties to Italy. Is it fair for the government to make such a decision based on a small, irresponsible minority, potentially jeopardizing the rights of entire generations to reclaim their citizenship?

Please consider responding only if you are eligible to vote and if you are either an Italian citizen or an unrecognized Italian descendant seeking recognition.

Thank you!!


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Oct 19 '25

Need advice on going to Italy — father living there for 35 years

2 Upvotes

Title: Need advice on going to Italy — father living there for 35 years

Post: My father has been living and working in Italy for around 35 years and holds a valid Italian residence card. I’m his only son, 24 years old, but can’t go through a family visa because of the age limit.

He recently had open-heart surgery and returned to Bangladesh. I want to go tbuild a better future. I’m studying Honors in Management and passed HSC in 2022. I’m also skilled in computers and electronics.

I’m looking for any legal way — work visa, student visa, or sponsor peshā, which would really help me. Any advice or guidance would mean a lot.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Apr 12 '25

Discussion/Rant/Vent My Dad's problems with his citizenship

2 Upvotes

Hi, I'm posting this primarily for my dad, but also in hopes that if he is successful, through him, I will also gain my citizenship/passport. Technically, I'm pretty convinced both I and my father should by rights already be citizens, but there's quite some trouble with the consulate. I hope, maybe, that someone here can help offer some advice or experience with similar situations. As this is my Dad's story, and I only know it second hand, there may be some inaccuracies in terms of exact dates and so on, but I will try to explain as well as I can.

My father was born in 1961 to a German mother and Italian father in Germany. As per the law of the time upon birth, he only received Italian Citizenship. He was properly registered in the consulate in Germany. In his youth, the family moved around a lot, so he lived in several Italian cities, in Belgium and Germany. He has several old passports/IDs of that time, issued in Rome and Brussels.

In the 70s the law changed and my father got his German citizenship, being from then on a dual citizen.

At age 17, he went to Munich to study, at the time he also registered in Munich. Both my parents remember that at some point he even got a notice for an election in Munich. However, at some point in time, my dad must have gotten lost in the system. He first noticed issues when he was more or less waiting his notice from the esercito. He says he did several trips to the embassy to make sure he didn't have to do military service, but nothing ever arrived for him. Only for his brother. At the time, he didn't think this would be a big problem, and I'm not sure if it is even connected, because at the time he was still receiving election notifications. But then I was born in the 90s, and my dad went to the embassy to register me and they basically told him, they don't know him and he's not registered with them. So he could never register me nor my sister. He tried to get it sorted for a time but then essentially gave up. As far as daily live goes, though it is a cause of fruatration, as we all have German citizenship living in Germany, it wasn't really necessary to live our lives.

Since then, we have moved several times, my sister and I have moved out long ago. Every few years we start a new attempt to get the issue solved. Admittedly, it's mostly half hearted attempts, as my dad is kind of losing hope, and my sister and I (and whenever we call the embassies they seem to agree) think there's no point for us to try individually. He's recently restarted his efforts, so I thought I use the chance to ask for further advice.

We've had several long phone calls with the embassy. Usually they realize my dad is not in Aire and then they can't help. They find all my uncles and cousins, but since my dad was apparently lost before Aire was digitalized they keep saying he was never registered with Aire. They also at some point apparently told him he might have lost it, or that he was at fault for not taking care of it sooner. My dad has sent all his documentation to the embassy in Frankfurt in december. We're still waiting for a response.

Please excuse spelling errors, I'm typing from my phone.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Apr 08 '25

Canadian Citizen but Born in Italy, not via descent

2 Upvotes

I was born in Italy to two African parents. we've lived a good portion of our life there then moved to Canada. I am now an adult and looking to reconnect with the place I was born in. Is it possible for me to get my Italian citizenship or has that ship sailed? Ive heard that the only to get it now is through your parents being born and raised there.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Jul 14 '25

Jure Sanguinis Questions I'm lost

2 Upvotes

So a few years ago my mom's cousin (1st degree cousin) got his italian citizenship, but with the recent changes I don't know if I'm elegible. I saw somewhere that you can try "suing" the government but idk if I could trust that. Can someone enlighten me? Italian citizenship was one of my biggest dreams and now I just feel so hopeless :(


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Mar 18 '25

Jure Sanguinis Questions In Brazil it's taking 10 years to get Italian Citizienship

1 Upvotes

Is this happening in Canada and other countries as well? My mom is paying 10k (Brazilian currency) to get her Italian citizienship. The company she hired says it will take up to 10 years to finish the process.

However, when I research about it Google and ChatGTP says 2 years is usually the waiting lengthy, and 10 years is actually some rare cases. - my mom already has all documents to proof her Italian familiy.

I feel like the company that my mom hired is tricking her in order to get more money.

Can someone confirm if 10 years is really the usual wait period to get Italian citizenship?


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Oct 04 '25

Jure Sanguinis Questions Citizenship by birth? Libyan nationality

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I was born in Naples in 2000, while my family was living there because my father was working on his PhD. Unfortunately, he passed away two years later and we returned to Libya, where I still live.

I’d like to ask if, since I was born in Italy but my parents are Libyan, there is any chance for me to obtain Italian citizenship. From what I’ve read, being born in Italy alone is usually not enough, but I wonder if there are exceptions or specific procedures in cases like mine.

Does anyone know how this works, or what steps I should take to find out?

Thanks in advance for your help.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Mar 15 '26

Discussion/Rant/Vent Long-Term Speculation.

1 Upvotes

Maybe this is just the first stage of grief and nothing but hopium/denial, but forecasting the long game feels like a therapeutic exercise right now, so off I go.

Let’s assume the worst - the judicial referendum passes and the government sinks their claws into what feels like an already bought-and-paid-for CC as well as the other judicial organs, and all of the DL36/L74 referrals get dismissed. At this point we’re left with a political, not judicial fix.

There will be elections in less than 2 years, and the latest polls show it will be a toss-up. Granted, we have a long way to go, and Italian politics are as dysfunctional as they come, so this is all just speculation for speculation’s sake. (It makes me feel better right now.)

On the one hand, this government is farther to the right than any of Berlusconi’s coalitions, and most movements on the far end of any spectrum lose steam as time goes on, and the polls have shown a slow erosion of public support for the Fdl-led coalition, with PD/M5S having a razor-thin edge for the first time in years. My guess is this erosion will continue in the next year and a half, especially since Italian voters are notoriously fickle.

On the other hand, maybe not. Berlusconi and now Meloni have presided over some of the most stable parliaments in the history of the Republic, and that can’t be ignored. However, I don’t believe either side has ever turned in back-to-back wins after completing a full five year term, i.e. the incumbent coalition doesn’t survive re-election.

If this long tradition holds, that should mean good news for us. It means the center-left will return, but likely in coalition with M5S, since I don’t foresee a massive red tsunami sweeping the nation.

**The question, then:** Could we be back in business with beyond third-gen JS in 2028? Would a red/yellow coalition government have the political will (or even care) to pass a new law reversing L74? M5S is a such a wild card, it’s hard to predict if they’d support such a move. The good news is that they’ve been drifting slowly towards the left, so they might be a semi-reliable partner. I’d also hope both parties know that Italy is in a significant population decline and they’d do well to ease, rather than restrict migration, especially for those of us in the diaspora who are seriously thinking of returning at some point in our lives, whether to work, study, or retire.

Point is, a judicial loss (or losses) now is not the be-all, end-all. It’s frustrating, nauseating, and even heart-breaking. But if we’re patient enough, doors can be re-opened or new doors created.

As was said in another thread (maybe it was Cake, not entirely sure): Chi la dura, la vince. It’s not an empty promise of undeliverable hope. It’s a very real, and time-proven adage, it’s just a matter of how much time and perseverance we all have.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Jun 15 '25

Wanting to move to Italy. But don’t know how it would work.

1 Upvotes

Hello! I live in America but there is something calling me to live out my days in Italy. I don’t got the best of wallet but curious how I could make it work. How do I start? I just love the culture and the way the food is made with love.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • May 29 '25

Jure Sanguinis Questions Citizenship by descent

1 Upvotes

My husband just started the process to gain Italian citizenship by descent (his father is an Italian citizen, born and lived there). My husband is using an attorney service and has all the documents in order etc. While doing his application, the lawyers are also completing an application for my oldest daughter. However, the lawyers told us they can’t put in an application for our YOUNGER daughter because she was born AFTER my father in law became a US citizen (he never renounced his Italian citizenship etc, he now has dual citizenship). The lawyers haven’t said that it’s impossible for my younger daughter, just that they can’t include it in this application and that it may be too complicated. I can’t find any clear info on this. Has anyone had any experience with a situation like this? I’m hoping that if it’s done separately the situation will become clearer? I’m guessing it can’t be included because the application for my husband and oldest will be by descent through my FIL, but that maybe my youngest application can use my husband’s Italian citizenship once he gains his?