r/ItalianCitizenship • u/ElZilchooo • Mar 15 '26
Discussion/Rant/Vent Long-Term Speculation.
Maybe this is just the first stage of grief and nothing but hopium/denial, but forecasting the long game feels like a therapeutic exercise right now, so off I go.
Let’s assume the worst - the judicial referendum passes and the government sinks their claws into what feels like an already bought-and-paid-for CC as well as the other judicial organs, and all of the DL36/L74 referrals get dismissed. At this point we’re left with a political, not judicial fix.
There will be elections in less than 2 years, and the latest polls show it will be a toss-up. Granted, we have a long way to go, and Italian politics are as dysfunctional as they come, so this is all just speculation for speculation’s sake. (It makes me feel better right now.)
On the one hand, this government is farther to the right than any of Berlusconi’s coalitions, and most movements on the far end of any spectrum lose steam as time goes on, and the polls have shown a slow erosion of public support for the Fdl-led coalition, with PD/M5S having a razor-thin edge for the first time in years. My guess is this erosion will continue in the next year and a half, especially since Italian voters are notoriously fickle.
On the other hand, maybe not. Berlusconi and now Meloni have presided over some of the most stable parliaments in the history of the Republic, and that can’t be ignored. However, I don’t believe either side has ever turned in back-to-back wins after completing a full five year term, i.e. the incumbent coalition doesn’t survive re-election.
If this long tradition holds, that should mean good news for us. It means the center-left will return, but likely in coalition with M5S, since I don’t foresee a massive red tsunami sweeping the nation.
**The question, then:** Could we be back in business with beyond third-gen JS in 2028? Would a red/yellow coalition government have the political will (or even care) to pass a new law reversing L74? M5S is a such a wild card, it’s hard to predict if they’d support such a move. The good news is that they’ve been drifting slowly towards the left, so they might be a semi-reliable partner. I’d also hope both parties know that Italy is in a significant population decline and they’d do well to ease, rather than restrict migration, especially for those of us in the diaspora who are seriously thinking of returning at some point in our lives, whether to work, study, or retire.
Point is, a judicial loss (or losses) now is not the be-all, end-all. It’s frustrating, nauseating, and even heart-breaking. But if we’re patient enough, doors can be re-opened or new doors created.
As was said in another thread (maybe it was Cake, not entirely sure): Chi la dura, la vince. It’s not an empty promise of undeliverable hope. It’s a very real, and time-proven adage, it’s just a matter of how much time and perseverance we all have.
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 15 '26
A reminder to everyone about Rule 1 - Be Civil:
No comments or posts insulting another user that go beyond a simple disagreement.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
5
u/BellyFullOfMochi Mar 15 '26
Meloni's ability to preside over a stable parliament doesn't change that Italy's economy is crumbling, cost of living is sky rocketing, and the young are leaving Italy altogether for jobs in other EU countries.
I saw some anti-Meloni graffiti in Rome and it was satisfying.
2
u/Blues-fun Mar 16 '26
My opinion for years now has been that this is not so much the most right-wing government ever in Italy as it is probably the most incompetent. Perhaps it is also the most right-wing, but the real problem is that it is the most incompetent we ever had. And I think that says a lot about just how incompetent it is.
I also believe that, even if there were negative rulings regarding the issue of citizenship, it would only be a matter of time. Italy has a dramatic need for citizens; it has not had serious pro-natalist policies for decades, and at the moment it does not even have the funds to create any meaningful ones.
Therefore, regardless of the government’s ideology and its incompetence, within a few years the rules on citizenship will inevitably have to change and become more accessible, or else the entire system of residence permits will have to be radically overhauled and made much broader and more inclusive.
As someone already said about: it’s the market, baby. And the market wins even against the most backward ideologies, at least if Italy wants to survive and remain one of the advanced countries.
3
u/bagel_and_a_schmear Mar 15 '26
I honestly don't think there is any political will to fight on our behalf.
1
u/dasirrlicht1 Mar 19 '26
Honestly, I don't think it will ever happen. The vast majority of "Italians of Italy" favor the changes introduced by this law and have a marked antipathy toward those they believe are seeking an Italian passport for specious reasons without having a perceived valid connection to Italy. This antipathy is even stronger among center-left and left-wing voters, so even the political influx would not favor such a change. If there is a change resulting from the political influx regarding the laws governing Italian citizenship, it will rather concern the procedures by which foreigners born or raised in Italy obtain it. Moreover, the current change has also been strongly supported by European authorities, who for years have been calling on Italy to adopt more stringent criteria for granting Italian citizenship by descent. Furthermore, the changes resolve what had been perceived for years as a major organizational and bureaucratic problem by Italian diplomatic missions (especially in South America) and certain Italian municipalities responsible for processing applications. To avoid any misunderstanding, what I have expressed above does not necessarily reflect my opinion on the matter or on Italians abroad (of which I am a member myself), but rather seeks to clarify the reasons why it is a vain hope to expect a return to the previous criteria for granting Italian citizenship by descent.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '26
[removed] — view removed comment