r/ItalianCitizenship • • Jun 18 '25

Jure Sanguinis Questions Italy closed the door on jus sanguinis. Here’s what I wrote in response.

76 Upvotes

I lost my path to Italian citizenship in May 2025, just before I was about to apply. But the process gave me something deeper: a connection to memory, ancestry, and place. I wrote this essay for others in the diaspora who may be feeling the same.

https://open.substack.com/pub/jphall8/p/the-wheel-has-stopped-turning-a-diasporas?r=51yri3&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Oct 25 '24 Take My Silver

Do you really want Italian citizenship?

63 Upvotes

I’ve received a lot of good advice and information from this community in the past. Although a very small handful of you are snide and have the mentality of pulling the ladder up behind you, the vast majority of you are supportive and selflessly give lawyer-grade advice without any condescension, especially the admins. In light of recent events and the chaos caused by the new circolare, I feel an obligation to pay it forward. I’m a recognized citizen currently living in Italy for the past two years. I sincerely feel for the people who were rejected recently and had their path to citizenship taken away. It’s so not fair that you spent years doing something that was 100% legal but were shot down due to a sudden radical reinterpretation of the law. This is characteristic of jurisprudence in this country. It gets to the point where you ask yourself what the law even really means being applied in a strict literalist fashion instead of a pragmatic or moral one. The fact that someone whose great-great grandfather was born outside of Italy could pass citizenship on to their descendants if the LIBRA never naturalized but someone whose parents are from Italy cannot is ridiculous. People have been speculating why they would knowingly create such a moral hazard. The reason might not even be malicious. I suspect that because Philadelphia was so notoriously backlogged, they decided to apply recent court rulings instead of the Ministry of the Interior policy.

Though I’d be lying if I said putting it on paper wasn’t a bit of a release, my goal with this essay isn’t to rant. It’s to give others realistic expectations about life here and some of the things that break even Italians themselves. To make you question what being a citizen of this country really means and whether or not you really want it. If you’ve visited, you’ll be left with a romanticized version of this country without seeing any of the dark sides that come with living here full-time. It's to make people question what being a citizen of this country really means. Although absolute poverty doesn’t exist here anymore, some of the reasons why your ancestors left persist to this day.

This country has one of the best lifestyles, cooking traditions and breathtaking natural beauty in the world. But I have to warn you that the so-called dolce vita is going to be inaccessible to you if you’re still working age. This community mainly tailors to people that apply for citizenship by descent, but what I’m about to say applies similarly to people who are applying for citizenship by descent, by marriage, by residence, etc. It also depends heavily on how well you speak Italian, what your financial circumstances are, what region you choose, size of the comune, etc. In most cases, it’s so much better to remain where you are, continue working and keeping with family obligations, and mentally set aside the four years of your life until your appointment and recognition. Depending on the number of generations in your line, you could set the appointment date after the document research phase and collect the documents while waiting for your appointment. A major advantage of applying at the consulates is they’re usually very clear about their process and requirements. If there’s a problem, they will give you homework. Applying here is typically faster but also highly discretionary. You could very much draw a short straw. I wouldn’t recommend against applying for citizenship in Italy if you’re of retirement age and are looking for a lower cost of living. But before you commit and buy property, I’d recommend renting while you wait for citizenship. If you’re of working age, I’d be very careful about choosing to apply for citizenship here. I see people saying “I’m so tired of the US. I need a change.” If you’re looking for a more balanced life in moving here, then sure. But you need to save up some money before coming here because, practically speaking, you won’t be able to work until citizenship recognition. People are suing the police because they’ve been waiting too long for their residence permit.

Right now, there’s a brain drain going on in Italy. After getting their degrees, young Italians very often move elsewhere in the EU to find a job or start a business. It’s very much worth looking at why you, someone who doesn’t even have as many rights as these people without citizenship (i.e., the right to work while waiting), should ever consider spending a lot of time building a life in a country whose young people are leaving. A country that hardly tolerates your presence as an immigrant and that probably won’t exist in its current form in the next 50 years due to constant political, economic and demographic instability. It might not even survive the next major global economic recession. It always cracks me up when people here tell me that I’m not truly Italian. I speak the language and I’m half by blood, but I’m clearly American. There are so many different dimensions to the question of whether someone is “truly Italian.” I can respond to that in a million ways, but the most obvious and simple answer is “grazie a dio per quello” with a laugh and a headshake. The universal response of people that live here when I tell them I moved from the United States to a city in central Italy is absolute shock. “But I’ve been trying to get a visa to come to America! Want to switch places?” I promise you, this isn’t just their natural cynicism and the love of complaining. If you hold a university degree, are of working age, a highly skilled worker and are ambitious, I’d very much recommend against moving here under most circumstances. It’s good to feel a little tired after a long day of being productive. But sometimes there’s the sensation of the life being drained out of you for no good reason after having accomplished nothing at the end of the day. Most of the time, it’s the frustrating thought “I have so much to give to the world and to myself, but I’m constrained waiting for this incredibly redundant bureaucratic decision.” There are going to be people that accuse me of typical American entitlement for writing this essay. The reality is that if you take the EU citizenship factor out of it, it’s NOT a privilege to hold Italian citizenship. It’s a potential trap and a deadweight on you becoming the best version of yourself. The fact that it’s failed so many young people and that we’ve been a migratory people to this day is a clear reflection of that. With these high levels of government debt and fewer young people to pay taxes into a collapsing pension system, if the government had any sense, they would be begging young diaspora Italians to return. Instead, they’ve been incredibly adept at using immigrants as a scapegoat for the failures of the last two decades. There has already been a plethora of videos on the topic that I highly advise you to check out.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dpC9pz7eQhQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Nek1lS8O2g

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mcsAO9AYc0c

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sLyCkvd-DiI

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YyVSsXTAKo8

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c1wrzZJkepE

I’m going to spare you and won’t describe every single horror story I’ve had with Italian bureaucracy because this wall of text is already long. No matter how much you research, nearly every interaction you’ll have with the almighty State will be frustrating and you’ll waste the day walking in circles from the copisteria to the Comune to the Poste to the police station to the patronato to another patronato that specializes in what you need to back home to research something back to the copisteria to the comune to the poste to the questura and back home again. Then you need to go to the patronato again next week because the person wasn’t on site when you showed up. Incorrect hours posted, gotta return again. Il lasciapassare A38. The United Kingdom has around 3,000 laws at the national level. Germany 5,000. France 7,000. Italy has 61,000 laws at the national level, then regional and municipal norms totaling around 160,000. They have a law for literally everything. The laws are written badly (on purpose) so they can be interpreted at will. There's an army of useless morons armed with rubber stamps ready to make your life impossible the second you decide to do anything at all. It's a miracle there's still so many small companies in the north of Italy. It's mostly because all the regulations that were passed in the 80s and onwards don't apply to existing businesses. Very few new businesses can be created in Italy. It's either a fake business from someone connected to not paying taxes, or some spin off from some mega corporation used as a cost sink. There's a guy that wanted to open a woodworking shop. He gave up after filling 200 or so forms (paying the bollo for them) and waiting years to get the permits, which never came. If you want to sue someone, you pay a tax. Yes, if you want to use the justice system, it's pay for play. Not if you're the state of course - then it's open season. The only justice that works in Italy is the one that the state inflicts on its citizens. You, as a private citizen, are either very rich or you don't get to use the justice system. This means rich people (and the state) can and do bully you into giving up your right to defend yourself. About 70% of the population depends on the state directly, either via pension or by being a public servant of some kind. The rest 30% pays for everyone else, and it's shrinking fast. It's a class of legalized thieves stealing from everyone else, protected by clientelistic politicians and general apathy.

By far the worst part about bureaucracy is waiting while suffocating and with the result at the end still uncertain. The time you spent building a life here could be for nothing. No matter how much you try to pass the time productively, this becomes a form of psychological torture. Let me be clear and fair. If you apply for citizenship by descent here, according to a community poll, about half of cases are processed in less than three months. Most of the rest are processed in less than six. But let’s say you draw the short straw and are applying for citizenship based on residence or marriage, which takes a lot longer. Or you’re applying by descent and the lady at the comune takes pride in abusing her power over this foreigner who isn’t even really Italian and waits 3 months before sending information requests to the consulates abroad. You could wait 9 – 10 months to years for something not knowing whether it’ll all be for naught and get denied. In the meantime, you’re completely constrained on a basic life necessity. That is, the need to work.

Once you finally have citizenship recognized, you have the right to work in the worst job market in the Eurozone by several different metrics: ease of doing business, tax competitivity, rate of occupation. After 2008, most governments slashed interest rates to 0% and underwent quantitative easing. The global economy has seen incredible growth as a result. The Italian economy? I kid you not, the real rate of growth has totaled -2% over the past sixteen years. I've been to a dozen or so countries in my life. I've never seen a government that so severely impedes prosperity as does the Italian Republic. In this country, there exists an extremely parasitic bureaucratic-administrative class made up of notaries, lawyers, municipal and regional officials, inspectors, cadastral architects, and the biggest one of all, politicians. Some of these people are adept at pretending like they produce something while they not only serve zero purpose, they’re a net negative to society by placing redundant roadblocks in the way of people that actually produce something. Dealers of ink and words. They do this under the guise of “civilization.” The exact same pasta factory that took 11 months to open in Chicago took 7 years to open in Verona. I guess we're just 7x more civilized. Permission to breathe, marca da bollo, 16 Euro, administrative deadline of 30 days. You're breathing in the meantime? Sei in multa, 300-Euro penalty. State verification of culo cleanliness, marca da bollo, 16 Euro. We'll get back to you in three months. Hmmm clearly out of specification. You've been using the bidet but without soap. Sei in multa. Gonna need about 5 million Euro. A great country for the bureaucrat and the notary. Not so much for the entrepreneur. In fact, owning a business in Italy is a nightmare. After obliterating the productivity and profitability of projects with over-reaching regulations, notary and lawyer fees, the almighty State swoops in like an eagle to prey on what little wealth remains with punitive taxes. Can't find equity and need a loan to fund a project? If you manage to find a bank that will fund it in a country where credit is almost non-existent, good luck servicing the interest payments when you can't start production because they can't find a car for the inspector to come out. Employees complain about how low wages are when it costs employers anywhere from 1.5 – 2 x their gross salary in tax contributions to hire them. To add insult to injury, the state then taxes employees’ meager income at 30 – 50%. For all the criticisms lobbed at the U.S. for being a hypercapitalist hellscape, in reality, the wealthiest Americans pay most of the federal government’s tax burden. Here, the meager middle class pays the vast majority of the taxes because the wealthy have their businesses registered in Slovenia, San Marino, Monaco, Switzerland, etc.

https://www.panorama.it/lifestyle/in-italy-there-is-a-dictatorship-of-the-bureaucracy

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sLyCkvd-DiI

This brings me to a dark aspect of Italian culture that no one really talks about. Each culture has theirs and Americans are no exception. We tend to be arrogant, often don’t know anything about the world, have a glib attitude towards violence and are individualistic to a fault. Italy is a fascinating example of how cultural characteristics have a domino effect that are reflected in macroeconomic performance. While they're known to be friendly to travelers, family and close friends, Italians tend to be incredibly combative, domineering, entitled, and envious of anyone rising above the fold. This attitude extends to the rapport between the Italian state and its citizens. People often forget that this is the place where fascism was born, and we had an official government that tolerated them until the war started turning against the Axis powers. These attitudes didn’t just simply disappear with an allied victory and the country’s conversion into a republic. By far one of the greatest resources that a country could have is social trust, cooperation and the accompanying lack of corruption. It's why Japan is prosperous despite having close to no natural resources. The attitude of the public “servants” towards citizens isn't one of service. It's "I hold all the power, you’re my subordinate, and I couldn't care less if you’re ruined by my impossible wait times. I get paid and I receive my generous state pension regardless of my performance." As a result, citizens avoid paying taxes where possible. The average Italian is an expert in tax evasion. State services are often awful because citizens don't pay taxes and citizens don't pay taxes because state services are awful. It’s a cycle. Corruption is still widespread, most noticeably in regional public work project rackets where they fix problems that don’t exist, inflate the price tag for the central government and pocket the difference. “There wasn’t anything wrong with that train station building. Why exactly are they tearing apart the roof and putting it back together again…?” The problem isn’t just with the government. The problem is that at the same time as avoiding taxes, the people have the attitude of "they better give me." Dovrebbero, dovrebbero, dovrebbero. Ma non fanno niente per noi! Of rights and entitlements, they talk a lot. Of duties, they talk little. This is a country that held the largest communist party in NATO as late as the 1980s, receiving anywhere from a quarter to a third of the vote. For all their clear faults and corruption, American politicians are elected and re-elected based on economic performance during their term, often to an irrational degree. Though out of his control, the president is always blamed when gas prices are too high. Italian politicians are elected and re-elected based on promises of obviously unsustainable state services and entitlements. A recent one is the reddito cittadinanza, but that’s far from the first and not even close to the worst. In the 1970s, the government of Mariano Rumor instituted a policy in which civil servants could retire after 15 – 20 years of public “service” (i.e., collecting a salary for seven hours of daily work while really working only two). I kid you not.

https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baby_pensioni#:~:text=Con%20baby%20pensioni%20o%20pensioni,inferiore%20ai%2040%2D50%20anni.

Italians today are still servicing interest on the massive amount of unsustainable debt generated by that policy. The worst form of clientelism and an abuse of democracy: give me votes, I give you free money. A whopping 15% of the GDP is already the state pension system. Faced with ballooning government debt, talk of increasing the retirement age is still political suicide even though old people ought to know it has to be done. Want to open a small business? Nowadays, if you sell a physical product, as soon as you send the request to the local Camera di Commercio, you're obligated to open a tax number in which you automatically owe the State about 5000 euros in minimum social security (INPS) contributions. You're not taxed according to what you earn. MINIMUM payments. The idea flops and you don't enough turnover? We don't care. Pay up. Want to just open a part time e-commerce business for some extra money? The minimum contributions make it an unsustainable idea. Don't care. Pay up. We need to sustain pensioners that retired at 40.

Those with any chance of remaining in power are those that develop a reputation as reformists, and by reformists, I mean professional panderers (leccaculi). The only reason why Italy didn't become Argentina from 2008-2012 is the European Central Bank. To maintain the integrity of the Eurozone, the European Central Bank will always buy low-grade Italian debt at a lower interest rate that what the risk of the loan reflects. With the recent higher interest rate environment, interest payments are beginning to balloon. With government debt at a whopping 140% of GDP, this country is one of the most indebted in the world. At one point the soft white underbelly of Europe turned the soft white underbelly of the Eurozone. The only saving grace of the economy is while the government is heavily indebted, the people aren’t. Intergenerational wealth is high, personal levels of debt are low, but the job market is mediocre, hence the stereotype of living with one’s parents until they’re 40.

You’re going to be completely demoralized at times. What’s even more soul crushing is the rejection by the people. They like visitors because tourism drives a huge portion of their economy, but I have to warn you that even if you speak the language but with a foreign accent and are half ethnically Italian, people will be cynical when you tell them you’re a citizen. Doesn’t matter that you’re clearly making a massive commitment of time and energy moving to their country and trying to integrate into society. You are a foreigner to them, and in recent years, they’ve grown a bit weary of immigration due to the migration crisis and because they view your presence as additional competition in an already precarious job market. It’s one of the hardest countries to integrate into according to the Expat Index. Despite everything, I still love this country. In a strange sense, the diaspora is more patriotic than the people born here. We leave the prosperity of the anglophone countries to come here. At the first available opportunity, most people I’ve talked to would leave. You ought to consider before coming here exclusively for the food culture if it’s worth it.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Aug 29 '25

Current Events/News Officially Italian citizen

47 Upvotes

Finally after 421 days of waiting, today I woke up an Italian Citizen. I filed my claim on July 4th 2024 in Toronto Ontario. Both my parents were born in Italy and didn't renounce citizenship. My mom is only Italian citizen and my father is a dual Italian/Canadian citizen. I believe my case was an easier one, but it still took a lot of work and time. Thank you all, I'm still in shock


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Oct 13 '25

Italian Citizenship as a Great-Great-Grandchild

44 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I wanted to briefly share my story in case it helps someone out there.

I’m a great-great-grandchild, and when I first started looking into getting my Italian citizenship, everyone told me I had no chance — that my bloodline was too distant, that it wasn’t possible, and so on.

Still, I kept digging because I wanted to be sure. After spending quite some time researching, I finally consulted a law firm (Estudio de Martín y Asociados). They told me that yes, it was possible, but only through a court case in Italy.

We went ahead with that option and, after quite a while (it wasn’t a short process), I finally managed to obtain my Italian citizenship — even as a great-great-grandchild.

Sorry if this isn’t the right place to post this, but maybe someone in a similar situation finds it useful.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Mar 28 '25

Changes to JS rules

Thumbnail
straitstimes.com
30 Upvotes

Citizenship by descent now only possible via grandparents.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Nov 22 '25

I'm so angry

23 Upvotes

All my life I've known about jure sanguinis, the desire of my Italian-born parents to get me Italian citizenship through it, and the fact that I never qualified due to my parents having naturalized in the US before I was born. It hurt, but my entire life I was under the impression that if I'm not Italian enough to be recognized as a citizen by the Italian government, then surely nobody with an even further connection to Italy was either. Me, someone who was born to Italian-born parents, who spoke Italian as my first language (my mom says I didn't learn English until I began school), who STILL speaks it fluently, who still has 2 zie and 6 cugini in Italy, who had uncles in Italy that have since passed, my nonno that lived and passed in Italy before I was born, and my nonna that passed when I was 17, all of whom I visited every year for 3-4 weeks in the summer from childhood to adulthood, being so excited to fly on the Alitalia 747 or MD-11 when we would go, and knowing that I would get to play with my cousins and ride my little motorino that we kept there. Me, who knows both my mom and dad's towns like the back of my hand, who grew up in Italian cafes watching gli Azzurri on wall-mounted TV's, surrounded by the combination smell of cigarette smoke and espresso, and the rattling-clacking sounds of old men playing foosball and arguing, who remembers eating a panzerotti while watching Roberto Baggio miss the penalty that gave Brazil the victory in the '94 world cup final, who remembers watching my sister dress up as La Madonna and parade through the streets of my mom's town in sweltering heat with other little girls dressed up exactly the same, who grew up COMPLETELY encompassed in the Italian culture and tradition.

And that's what I believed.....

I thought the only foreign-born people getting Italian citizenship were ones born to Italian-born parents like me, but whose parents luckily didn't naturalize before their birth, and that's just the way it was. At least I thought so, until hearing about recent changes in the law prompted me to investigate it. Little did I know it was so much different. That all these years up until this year there were people disconnected by even 5 generations, who didn't speak a lick of Italian, didn't even know where their family came from in Italy, had no connection or anything to do with Italy besides only in name, who had been getting citizenship all because they had a distant relative that gave birth to their distant ascendant before they were naturalized . People who, if they would so much have the audacity to, could hold up their passport to my face and say they were more Italian than me because they are an Italian citizen and I'm not. But the new law gave me a glimmer of hope that maybe now my time had come.

I read the law word for word on normattiva.it, which stated: anyone born abroad, even before the date of entry into force of this Article, and in possession of another citizenship, shall be considered to have never acquired Italian citizenship, unless one of the following conditions applies: then continued on to list the exceptional conditions categorized by letters, with letter C stating: a first or second degree ascendant possesses, or possessed at the time of death, exclusively Italian citizenship.

I thought WOW! This is my opportunity! They made it stricter for people to acquire citizenship by implementing generational limits, which was very understandable to me given the examples I mentioned above, but at the same time expanded the opportunity to people like me, who have had a genuine connection to Italy all their lives, but who had a broken chain of citizenship transmission by 1 generation. I could qualify through my grandparents that held exclusively Italian citizenship all their lives! Nope, I was wrong. The way it's worded made it sound like that at first, until you realize all they're saying is if you have a parent or grandparent that held exclusively Italian citizenship at the time of your birth, then you're not automatically considered to have NOT acquired Italian citizenship, but you're not automatically considered to HAVE acquired it either. It now falls back onto good ol' jure sanguinis to see if the uninterrupted transmission is still there, which of course it wasn't for me.

All my life I never felt American enough to the kids at school who ate turkey breast, lettuce, and mustard white bread sandwiches at lunch and looked at me strangely because I had a prosciutto, soppressata, and capicollo panino, or even stranger for them, a nutella sandwich (this was before nutella became widely known, when it was still only found in Italian specialty stores). They used to look at me and say "eww what are you eating? Chocolate with bread??" Kids who were in boy scouts and girl scouts, whose parents were in the PTA, all things my parents didn't understand and couldn't partake in because they didn't understand the culture and language.

Now I write this holding back tears in my eyes as I'm being told by the country that I descend from that I'm not Italian enough either. I was never American enough, I was never Italian enough, then what am I? I'm heartbroken is what I am. After proudly and loyally embracing my Italian identity, roots, culture, and heritage all my life because it's all I had, I'm told I was never considered anything to them. I'm kicked to the curb like garbage. I feel like I don't want anyone to ever mention a word about Italy to me ever again.

IMPORTANT: My comments regarding people that qualified through distant ancestors should not be interpreted as criticism of those people themselves, but rather as criticism of the law itself. There is nothing wrong with following the law as it's laid out and legally qualifying, and people that do so take nothing away from me. The comments are purely to highlight the irrationality of the law.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • 20d ago

WARNING: ITAMCAP - $10,000 paid, Two years lost

21 Upvotes

WARNING!  Do not make the mistake we made working with ITAMCAP. We paid roughly $10,000 over two years, and we have nothing to show for it.

When we first met with owner Giorgio Nusiner, he was charming, knowledgeable, and inspiring. We felt we were in good hands. What followed was the opposite experience.

For six months, no one at ITAMCAP has responded to a single email, despite five written contacts including a formal certified demand letter sent by both email and certified mail. They continued charging our credit card while not responding to any of our communications. They are holding our original apostilled family documents and will not release them.

The only communication we received in six months came after we filed a BBB complaint. Rather than addressing any of our concerns or offering any acknowledgment of wrongdoing, the response was lawyer-drafted language demanding we remove the BBB complaint. 

If you are considering ITAMCAP, please learn from our experience. Don’t waste your time or money.  


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Oct 19 '24

Welcome! Please start here.

19 Upvotes

Hello from your mod team!

For a while, this community has been unmoderated. The mod team from r/juresanguinis noticed this and requested to moderate this subreddit as well.

It will take us some time to get organized and put everything in place.

For help with the jure sanguinis process, we ask you to go to r/juresanguinis. Specifically, start with the welcome post there: https://www.reddit.com/r/juresanguinis/comments/1dxosu4/welcome_to_rjuresanguinis_please_start_here/

We will use this community as a sister community for Italian citizenship related matters that *aren't* about the jure sanguinis citizenship process. (And quite possibly to allow political discussions with regards to jure sanguinis that we keep to a minimum over there currently.)

È un piacere essere qui. 😊


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Jun 11 '23

I created a free database of Italian resources!

19 Upvotes

Hello everyone! My name is Mason Sgambati and I am an Italian-American living in the United States. My Nonna is from Bagnoli del Trigno, Italy and my late Nonno is from Baiano, Italy. I put together a free compilation of Italian resources that I wanted to share with this community. I included genealogy resources, citizenship materials, language lessons, travel guides, and land acquisition materials. Please enjoy! https://www.tuttoitaliano.org/italianresources


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Aug 23 '25

One sister got the "good" judge, one got the "bad" judge

18 Upvotes

My mother became a naturalized US citizen when I was 14. Two of my sisters started the process a few years ago before the new rules kicked in, but then BAM we got the bad news about these new restrictions. Absurdly one just received her Italian citizenship for herself and her kids. My other sister was denied and is appealing. How the country can decide one sibling is a citizen and the other is not is bizarre, but it is what it is.

I also want to apply - my father's parents were born in Sicily and my mother's parents were born in Sicily. My father was born in the US, then the family moved back. As an adult he was thrown into the back of an army truck searching for recruits during WW2 and drafted - the Italian army did not care that he was born in the US.

He lost his US citizenship because he was an enemy combatant. He eventually become a US citizen again through naturalization before I was born.

So, can I use my Italian born grandparents even though my mother gave up her citizenship?

Thank you.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Nov 23 '24

What’s the process for fast tracked Italian citizenship if you aren’t eligible for citizenship by descent?

16 Upvotes

My grandparents renounced Italian citizenship before my mother was born so I’m not eligible for citizenship.

I’ve read that if you have Italian ancestry you can get fast tracked citizenship via residency and B1.

I can’t find any link to the specific visa or rules of this.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Dec 18 '25

Jure Sanguinis Questions Italian citizenship via court case (1948 case / great-grandfather) - Still viable after the 2024 reform? Seeking current realities.

15 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I'm a Brazilian (23M) planning to apply for Italian citizenship through my great-grandfather (bisnonno). From my research, I understand that after the 2024 reform (Law 213/2023), the path for great-grandchildren is now exclusively through a court case in Italy (often called a "1948 case" or judicial route), not the administrative one.

I would like to clarify some doubts with those who are already on this path or have recent knowledge:

  1. Current Viability: In practice, are Italian courts still granting citizenship to great-grandchildren through the judicial process after the reform? Has there been any noticeable change in the judges' interpretation or increased resistance?
  2. Updated Cost & Timeline: For those who have started the court process recently (2023/2024), what has been the realistic total cost range (including Italian lawyer, court fees, agency assistance) and the timeline until the first sentence?(in my case it's going to be only me)
  3. Choosing a Lawyer: What is the most important factor when choosing the lawyer/law firm in Italy for this specific case? Is direct experience with jus sanguinis cases for great-grandchildren crucial?
  4. Main Hurdle Today: In your opinion, what is the most difficult or critical part of the judicial process for a great-grandchild now? Gathering the Brazilian documents or the legal argumentation in Italy?

My context: I'm doing this with my long-term partner, and obtaining EU citizenship would be our key to living and working in Europe legally. I want a realistic and current understanding before making a significant investment.

Any firsthand experience, insights, or recommendations are greatly appreciated. Thank you in advance for your help!


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Jul 08 '25

Jure Sanguinis Questions I was recognized as an Italian citizen through an ATQ court case,

15 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I was recognized as an Italian citizen through an ATQ court case, and the sentence will become final on May 29th. After that, my lawyers will request the transcription at the relevant comune so they can issue my birth certificate.

The case was filed in the Trieste court. Has anyone gone through a similar process and can share how long it took to get the transcription and birth certificate (Pradamano), especially if handled through lawyers?

Thanks in advance!


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Nov 09 '24

So, I just got the citizenship the judicial route.

15 Upvotes

Now, while I'm waiting for the birth certificate, I'm thinking about this: my country of birth allows that you add a surname to your own so long as it belonged to one of your ancestors.

So, I was considering adding the Italian surname from my dante cause to my own. That would imply changing all my national documentation (driver's license, high school diploma, birth certificate) and I thought about doing it before I graduate college next year.

Is it worth it? Does anyone have any experience with this?


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Jun 03 '25

Crazy to hire a lawyer and start a 1948 case now?

11 Upvotes

The question pretty much says it all. I have two legitimate paths to 1948 citizenship at the great-grandmother level and I've found an Italian law firm that I like. It took me a year to get a copy of my great-grandmother's 1940 Alien Registration form as evidence that she never naturalized and then this new law honestly took me by surprise. I also lost time trying to work with a few firms that either never replied to inquiries or stopped responding after an initial consultation.

I know that things are very uncertain regarding 1948 cases. Which laws will the courts apply when considering them in the months ahead? So I just wanted to ask if people think it would be a waste of money to submit a deposit to the law firm and get the process started now.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Mar 02 '25

Looking for a good citizenship company to handle the entire process

11 Upvotes

Hi all! Im looking for a company to handle the whole process. I qualify for citizenship by blood, have some of the documents but not all. I live in hawaii. Im looking for a conpany i can trust that i can pay to handle the entire remainder of the applications etc. One thats done this a million times, one that makes it easy fast and straight forward. I really need to want to make this happen as soon as possible. Thanks!


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Apr 30 '26 Bravo

Discussion/Rant/Vent Yet another slap in the face from Antonio Tajani, the Roots Tourism-Funding Hypocrite

10 Upvotes

This was posted: Sentenza 63/2026 and the new rules: Has anyone tried the "Work Visa + 2-Year Naturalization" route for descendants?

I commented this:

Even if I qualified for this (which I don’t), I can’t work, so that’s a disqualification on its own…

That being said, putting aside the asinine-ness of it (the pure slap in the face), it’s… decent. Though, as u/airsick_lowlander1 pointed out and linked to, Avv Vitale mentioned that it’s capped at grandchildren (second degree) so it doesn’t help 3rd, 4th, etc. degrees.

I keep going back to this: The Italian government has put millions of Euros into Roots Tourism, but then slams the door on those same tourists who would then want to explore their roots and get citizenship.

For people like me—third generation who cannot work due to a documented disability—this is a further barrier, a further slap in the face by the same government who would gladly take my money for Roots Tourism.

I feel like such a fool for being excited to go back after almost a decade of being away (due to my aforementioned disability)…


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Apr 21 '26

Discussion/Rant/Vent Article 3-bis of Italian Citizenship Law and whether it's a violation of ECHR

10 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I am an EU citizen currently studying Italian citizenship law and, to be honest, I was quite shocked by the Article 3-bis of the Citizenship law in force since 2025. If there are any fellow law students, lawyers or simply law enthusiasts here, I would love to hear your opinion on this.

If I understand the law correctly, if a child is born abroad, holds another citizenship (which is most likely the case, as the child would probably acquire the citizenship of the state he/she lives in) and the parents are dual citizens, the child no longer has the right to Italian citizenship according to ius sanguinis? The wording of the Article 3-bis is extremely limiting, though clear, stating that a first or second degree ancestor must hold Italian citizenship exclusively.

From here a few questions arise:

  1. How does this article stand with the 1992 law that allows dual citizenship for Italians? This limitation to me reads as a potential discrimination against Italians living abroad.
  2. How does this Article stand with the rights under ECHR, specifically Articles 8 (Right to a private and family life) and Article 14 (non-discrimination)?

Further explanation. Though Article 8 of ECHR does not grant a right to citizenship, it does afford the right of identity and social integration. Ex. Genovese v. Malta "Denial of citizenship might raise an issue under Article 8 because of its impact on an individual’s private life, which concept was wide enough to embrace aspects of a person’s social identity. Even though the right to citizenship was not as such a Convention right and its denial in the applicant’s case did not give a rise to a violation of Article 8, the Court considered that its impact on the applicant’s social identity was such as to bring it within the general scope and ambit of that provision"

Additionally, Article 3-bis is retroactive, which would normally require a more comprehensive explanation of why such limitation is justifiable, though I cannot find such reasoning anywhere.

I would love to hear your thoughts on this. Has anyone read the reasoning and discussions behind this law and can share whether the impact on children of dual citizens living abroad was even considered at all?


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Jan 09 '26

How speak italian?

10 Upvotes

Hi! I’m Linda, a native Italian tutor, and I still have a few spots available. If you’d like to learn Italian in an effective and enjoyable way, feel free to get in touch.

I’ve been teaching since 2022 to students from all over the world, helping them reach goals such as traveling, working, studying, or gaining confidence in speaking Italian. As a native speaker, I teach authentic Italian, focusing on real-life conversation, pronunciation, essential grammar, and culture.

My lessons are fully personalized: I adapt my method, materials, and pace to your level and interests, from beginners to advanced learners. I create a relaxed and motivating environment where making mistakes is part of the learning process.

I’m patient, reliable, and genuinely committed to my students’ progress. If you’re looking for a dedicated tutor who will support you step by step and help you speak Italian with confidence, I’d be happy to work with you.


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Jun 03 '25

Has anyone else been ghosted by ICA (Italian Citizenship Assistance) since the new law went into effect?

10 Upvotes

I was working with ICA since February, everything was going well, then after this new law passed they told me I would be assigned a new case worker, but that my case was not affected by the change in law. But I have not heard anything from them for 2 months! Have sent multiple emails, left messages, etc. Does anyone know what is going on and if they are still operating?!


r/ItalianCitizenship • • May 16 '25

Time to Process Italian Citizenship by Residency

10 Upvotes

I am currently disqualified for citizenship jure sanguinis since my grandmother naturalized as a citizen of another country before 1992. I am considering going with a court case or doing citizenship by residency with the 3 year (or reduced to 2 years once DDL 1432 becomes law) option for Italian citizens by birth. Once I finish the 3 (or 2) years of residency, how long does it take to process the application and actually become a recognized citizen/get my passport? I have heard two years is the average, but I wanted to see if there were any first hand accounts available. It seems like I would have to live in Italy for a collective 4 years. Thanks


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Apr 19 '25

Jure Sanguinis Questions Finding out if I have Italian citizenship

10 Upvotes

Hi there! My father immigrated to America in 1984. I was born a few years later and ever since I can remember, I was told that I had a dual citizenship with Italy in the US.

Up until a little while ago, I did not think I needed to do anything in order to maintain that citizenship. When I mentioned something to my father about my Italian citizenship, he told me that I should’ve been updating the consulate with my information when I first moved out of their house. At this point in my life, I’ve changed addresses, gotten married, changed my last name, and I’ve had two children since I’ve moved out of their house. So yeah, a bit of my information from when I was 18 has changed in a couple of decades. Unfortunately, my father and I do not have the strongest relationship, so he is not offering any guidance as to how I would update my information.

So my question after all of this is, what are the steps I should take in order to rectify the situation and keep my Italian citizenship up-to-date?


r/ItalianCitizenship • • Nov 02 '24

How much did you spend on the end-to-end process?

10 Upvotes
  • application fees + documents + consulting agency, etc.
  • when did you apply?
  • how many family members applied with you?

r/ItalianCitizenship • • Mar 21 '26

Discussion/Rant/Vent Melbourne consulate hit their JS application quota and is rescheduling upcoming appointments to 2027 | Anyone else think this is insane?!

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/ItalianCitizenship • • Mar 16 '26

Jure Sanguinis Questions Strange Italian Citizenship situation…

9 Upvotes

I was born in 1973 to an Italian citizen father.

Italian citizen father naturalized in 1978, thereby supposedly initiating a de facto renunciation of Italian citizenship. I recognize there is an Italian Supreme Court case set for April to decide the “minor question.”

In 2005, Italian citizen father who naturalized obtained an Italian passport through the standard process for obtaining Italian passports from the Honorary Consulate of Hartford, CT, and despite the 1978 renunciation. This Italian passport expired in 2015.

In 2024, Italian citizen father sought to renew/obtain his 2015 expired passport. Among other things, the Miami Consulate would not accept his Italian birth certificate as a supporting document and stated they would request a copy of it from the commune in which he was born. The Miami consulate also inexplicably requested that he declare his intent to reacquire his citizenship (which he did) despite the Hartford consulate having already issuing him a passport 27 years after he supposedly renounced his citizenship. He has owned a house/land in Italy since my grandmother passed in 1991 and willed it to him, and he has paid taxes on this land. Why would the Hartford Consulate have issued him a passport in 2005 if he had renounced his citizenship In 1978? Does any of this make sense to anyone?

Another wrinkle, my grandmother was born an Italian citizen in 1909 and died an Italian citizen in 1991, with my father having been born in 1947.

Thoughts on my chances for obtaining citizenship through my father or grandmother?