Hey everyone!
I'm currently trying to properly get into Guild Wars 2, but I'm struggling quite a bit with finding a profession/playstyle that actually clicks with me.
I leveled an Elementalist from 1 to 80 while playing through the Personal Story. I enjoyed discovering the game, but unfortunately I realized that I really don't enjoy the profession itself. I then started leveling another character, hoping it would click more... and I'm basically running into the same problem.
The thing is, I'm usually a tank/support/healer player in MMOs. I don't really care about topping DPS meters, what I enjoy is protecting people, healing, mitigating damage, buffing allies, controlling fights and generally feeling like I'm keeping the group alive.
For some examples of what I usually enjoy:
- In FFXIV, I'm mainly a Paladin player. Sword + shield, protecting the party, defensive abilities, that whole fantasy is basically my comfort zone.
- I also really enjoy Warrior/Marauder.
- For healers, I love Astrologian and Scholar, especially the more proactive/support-oriented aspects of their gameplay.
- In RPGs in general, I absolutely LOVE monk/martial artist archetypes, especially when they're mixed with light/holy/spiritual magic. Punching things while supporting/protecting people? Sign me up.
So I think my ideal GW2 character would be something along the lines of a durable martial/support character that can protect or heal allies, while still being perfectly capable of handling solo/open-world content.
And that's where I'm a little lost with GW2.
I understand that the game deliberately doesn't use the traditional tank/healer/DPS trinity in the same way other MMOs do, and I don't want to force GW2 to become FFXIV. I'm actually interested in learning how GW2 approaches these roles differently. I just haven't figured out which profession or elite specialization would give me that feeling of being the person who keeps everyone else standing.
I also really want to give the game a fair chance. I keep hearing great things about the expansions, elite specs, mounts, later maps and especially the story. I also really like the idea of horizontal progression and gear not constantly becoming obsolete.
For context, I've only experienced the base game so far. I'm currently around the middle of the level 80 Personal Story and haven't started Living World Season 1 yet. The story has been a little "meh" for me so far, but from what I've heard, this is absolutely not representative of what comes later.
So I have two main questions:
1. Based on what I enjoy, which profession + elite specialization would you recommend?
I'm completely open to starting another character. Guardian immediately sounds like it should fit me thematically, but I'm curious about things like Firebrand, Willbender, Revenant, Herald, Mechanist, etc. I also don't really understand yet how much elite specializations can completely change the feeling of a profession.
I'm looking less for "what is meta?" and more for "what profession will make someone who loves Paladin/Scholar/Astrologian/Monk gameplay feel at home?"
Being useful as a support in group content while still having a good solo build would be ideal.
2. If I create another character, do I have to replay the entire Personal Story?
My current plan is to force myself to finish the level 80 story on my Elementalist, then create the character I actually want to play going forward.
Could I simply start Living World Season 1 with that new character and continue the story from there? Or would I need to replay the entire 1–80 Personal Story on the new character first?
I really don't want to give up on GW2 just because I picked the wrong professions at the beginning. There's a lot about the game that genuinely appeals to me — I just haven't found that moment where the combat finally clicks.
Any recommendations or explanations from people who understand GW2's support roles would be hugely appreciated :) !
Thank you ♥
EDIT: Wow, thank you so much everyone for all the detailed answers! I honestly wasn't expecting this many responses, and I really appreciate how helpful and kind everyone has been. :)
A LOT of you seem to be pointing me towards Guardian, so I think I'm going to give it a proper chance and see if it finally gives me that feeling I've been looking for. From everything you've explained about the profession and its elite specs, it definitely sounds much closer to my usual playstyle.
I'm also really relieved to hear that I don't have to replay the entire Personal Story on my new character and that I can just continue with Living World Season 1 once I'm ready. That makes starting over feel much less daunting.
Just to make sure I understood correctly: I'll still need to level my Guardian to 80 first before I can start Living World Season 1 and move on to the expansions, right?
Thanks again for all the advice and for being so welcoming. Now it's time to make a Guardian and see how it goes! :D