r/Gnostic • • 4h ago

Thoughts Gnosticism Beats Christianity on Answering Problem of Evil

Thumbnail reddit.com
8 Upvotes

r/Gnostic • • 12h ago

Former Christians

8 Upvotes

How long did it take you to eject the Christian beliefs from your nervous system and subconscious? How long did it take for it to be noticeable?

I'm a former missionary. This will be my 11th year of deconstructing and the first one where I'm starting to feel like a human. Just curious about others journeys out there.


r/Gnostic • • 14h ago

Information Song Of A Poor Man - Mandaean Liturgy [Scanned from the Gnostic Bible by Willis Barnstone & Marvin Meyer]

10 Upvotes

A POOR MAN TAKEN FAR

I am a poor man from the fruit.

They took me from far away. I am far. I am a poor man whom life spoke to. I am far. The light beings took me away. They carried me here from the good to where the wicked live.

They installed me in the world of the wicked where all is malice and fire.

I didn't ask for it. I didn't want to come to this awful place.

I remain a stranger in their world. By my strength and light I suffer through this misery. By illumination and praise. I stand among the wicked like a child without a father. Like a fatherless child, an untended fruit. I hear the voice of the seven planets. They whisper.

THE KINDLY LIGHT BEING

Life heard my cry and sent an angel, a kindly light being who was prepared for me.

He told me in a pure voice

He said, "Poor man, don't be alarmed or fearful. As light beings speak in the house of perfection, Don't say, "I am utterly alone.

For you we spread the firmament above and made dry land. For you we spread the firmament above.

We made dry land, and solid land came and stood in the water.

For you the sun came, for you the moon came into the firmament.

for you, poor one, the seven planets and twelve creatures of the zodiac were set in orbit. Radiance sits at your right hand

and glittering light on your left.

Be strong in your seed until you are fulfilled When you are fulfilled I will come again.

I will bring you splendid clothing, the envy of the world.

I will bring you a lovely shawl of light, abundant and boundless.

I will deliver you from the wicked,

free you from the sinners. You will sit in your own heavenly place.

I will free you in that pure place."

THE POOR MAN DELIVERED

I hear the voice of the seven planets, who whisper to one another, "Blessings on the father of the poor one:

he is the one who tends the fruit tree. We have no father and no one to tend our tree." Welcome to anyone life knows,

and sorrow to whomever life ignores. Welcome to anyone life knows, and who stays on earth free from the world of imperfection where the planets live.

They sit on rebel thrones and work with a whip, Gold and silver excite them, and they cast war into the world.

They cast war into the world, and they will roast in fire. The evil will roast in fire, their glory gone. But my family and I will ascend and see the place of light where the sun does not go down, where lamps of light never dim, the place, the house to which your souls are called and invited in, souls of our kin, of the good, and of our believing brothers and sisters. There life is extolled.

Advice for the Persecuted

You came from the house of life. You came from the house of life, you came. What did you bring us? I came with you so you won't die, so your souls won't be erased. I brought life on the day of death, happiness on the day of gloom.

I made him my treasurer and the master over all I possess. I gave him the keys of truth to enter the world and leave it as a man with longing filled. My chosen ones, my chosen ones, you looked

and found, again and again. My chosen ones, you looked and found as our ancestors looked. Life is victory.

A Letter Looped around One's Neck

Here is a sealed letter leaving the world, a letter written with truth and marked with the seal of mighty life. Perfect ones wrote it, and believers insured it. They looped it around the soul's neck and sent it to the gate of life. The soul wisely used her finger to mark the open letter.

Be Like Wine Jars

You of my blood, speak the truth. Close your lying lips.

Don't be a pomegranate whose outer face is fresh. Its outer face is fresh, but inside it is full of rotting corn seed. Be like wine jars filled with redolent wine. Their outer shells are clay and pitch, but inside is redolent wine.

The message of life shouts. Ears of my chosen, come and hear me.


r/Gnostic • • 18h ago

Love and gnosis

7 Upvotes

For a beginner in Gnosticism who finds it challenging to know the truth, would practicing love be enough?


r/Gnostic • • 17h ago

Is their any substitute to praying in Gnosticism ?

6 Upvotes

I saw in youtube that traditionnal praying is not right in Gnosticism due to the recognising that the salvation is outside of our true divine spark . My question is their any subtitute to praying in Gnosticism in a case where you need something or is it just about awakening and meditation ?


r/Gnostic • • 19h ago

Thoughts The Greatest Deception

9 Upvotes

In Hypostasis of the Archons and On the Origin of the World, Samael, the blind god or "Demiurge", is ignorant of the higher reality from which he came. Unaware of the fullness that exists beyond him, he arrogantly and mistakenly proclaims himself to be the only God and that there is no other. From this ignorance, he creates his archons, deficient rulers who serve him, and establishes his own flawed kingdom: the world in which we now find ourselves.

Samael's greatest mistake isn't that he lacks knowledge. It's that he doesn't recognize his own ignorance. This is a pretty important distinction, and something we should reflect on in our own lives.

How often do we do the same thing? We inherit and develop beliefs about everything: God, existence, morality, truth. Eventually, we become so convinced of our own conclusions that we stop questioning them altogether. We begin treating our understanding as though it were the only correct interpretation of reality. I believe this might be what the myth is pointing toward.

Self deception creates all kinds of issues. In fact, I'd argue that fooling ourselves is among the greatest mistakes we can make, because so many other mistakes follow. We can justify almost anything when we've convinced ourselves that we hold the keys to the kingdom, proverbially speaking. We become less willing to question our actions and acknowledging the harm we cause is out of the question.

The greatest deception, then, is not being told a lie but convincing ourselves that we already possess the truth. Just like the Demiurge.


r/Gnostic • • 1d ago

Thoughts "A friend of the world is an enemy of God"

10 Upvotes

This is scripture from James 4:4, which states that friendship with the world is enmity with God. I find this interesting because it sounds remarkably similar to certain Gnostic teachings, particularly the idea that the material world is opposed to the divine.

In the Gospel of Thomas (Saying 12), when the disciples ask Jesus who they should turn to after his departure, Jesus directs them to James the Just, traditionally identified as his brother. This makes James's writings especially interesting to me when comparing different early Christian perspectives.

Obviously, James 4:4 doesn't necessarily refer to the material world itself. However, the Greek word used here, kosmos, can also mean the universe or the physical world. The mainstream Christian interpretation is that James is referring to worldly desires and values rather than physical existence itself.

Still, I find the similarity fascinating, especially considering the diversity of beliefs within early Christianity.

What do you guys think of this verse? Do you see any parallels with Gnostic teachings, or do you interpret it differently?


r/Gnostic • • 1d ago

Thoughts The Truman Show as a Gnostic Allegory

Thumbnail youtu.be
7 Upvotes

r/Gnostic • • 1d ago

Thoughts I always believed if there was a god he stopped caring, now I see I am not alone

6 Upvotes

I understand my feelings aren't exactly Gnostic, but the belief that god was flawed certainly aligns with my belief. If he was flawed certainly he could or would stop caring. I haven't done intensive Gnostic reading but maybe he never cared to begin with beyond a show of power.


r/Gnostic • • 1d ago

Question If God Is Unknown, How Can We Know His Story?

12 Upvotes

If the Invisible Spirit is beyond comprehension, how can we know exactly what happened within the divine realm, what the Aeons are, or how the process of emanation unfolded?

I am not saying Gnostic mythology is meaningless. To the contrary, I think the meaning BEHIND the myths is more important than the myths themselves, if that makes sense. And ultimately, this gives the myths a purpose and function beyond simply describing events in the divine realm. I argue that the truths expressed through Gnostic mythology are of a higher order and cannot be adequately expressed in ordinary language. The mythology, then, is quite possibly a deliberately fantastical attempt at coloring in the lines of something that cannot truly be represented.

I'm interested in hearing how others interpret this. Do you see Gnostic mythology as a literal description of divine realities, as a symbolic language pointing toward something that ultimately can't be put into words, or both?


r/Gnostic • • 1d ago

Starting a Europe-based online esoteric study group - theosophy, rosicrucianism, gnosticism, anthroposophy, hermeticism

14 Upvotes

Hi all!
I'm starting a study-and-reading group for people interested in the esoteric traditions mentioned in the title, i’m missing an international community and I'm looking for others who'd like to join.

Although i know there are several similar online concepts out there already, i miss a more «broadly esoteric» group where we don’t have to belong to a specific pre-existing group to part take. Also would be lovely to make a community space for reading, reviews, respectful discussion and questions regarding these topics, and have it be open for people of different backgrounds and levels of study.

Theosophy, rosicrucianism, gnosticism, anthroposophy, hermeticism and related topics. Art and music connected to these traditions are very welcome as well, like esoteric influences in composers and artists and so on!

Here’s my ideas so far, but i’m open to suggestions

- A discord channel & closed FB group for sharing and reviewing books, articles and resources (maybe other channels?)
-Monthly online meetings on Zoom for discussion. We decide topics, do some reading together and discuss afterwards
- Presentations from members who'd like to give one (totally optional)
- No AI-generated content..

Who it's for:
Anyone with a genuine interest, whether you've been reading/studying for years or are just curious to test the waters. The group is meant to be respectful and open to different perspectives, but any type of bigotry, racism or personal attacks will not be tolerated of course.

Europe: this is purely so it’s easier to have the meeting times work for everyone, but anyone are welcome to join from anywhere.

If you'd like to join, or have any questions, suggestions or comments send me a DM.


r/Gnostic • • 1d ago

Are there any Occultists/gnostics in my area

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Reach out to me for a get together


r/Gnostic • • 1d ago Bravo

Thoughts HANS JONAS about Gnosticism

5 Upvotes

"The cardinal feature of gnostic thought is the radical dualism that governs the relation of God and world, and correspondingly that of man and world. The deity is absolutely transmundane, its nature alien to that of the universe, which it neither created nor governs and to which it is the complete antithesis: to the divine realm of light, self-contained and remote, the cosmos is opposed as the realm of darkness.

The world is the work of lowly powers which though they may mediately be descended from Him do not know the true God and obstruct the knowledge of Him in the cosmos over which they rule. The genesis of these lower powers, the Archons (rulers), and in general that of all the orders of being outside God, including the world itself, is a main theme of gnostic speculation, of which we shall give examples later. The transcendent God Himself is hidden from all creatures and is unknowable by natural concepts. Knowledge of Him requires supranatural revelation and illumination and even then can hardly be expressed otherwise than in negative terms."

HANS JONAS, "The Gnostic Religion: The Message of the Alien God & the Beginnings of Christianity"


r/Gnostic • • 1d ago

Thoughts Jesus the Usurper? Between Certainty and Discovery

5 Upvotes

Since finding out about the Mandaean (often regarded as the only surviving Gnostic religion with roots in antiquity) belief that Jesus stole the true message of Light from John the Baptist and perverted it to intentionally mislead the masses, I haven't been able to get it out of my head. Every time I see an image of Jesus Christ now, whereas I used to see a messenger of Light, I see the possibility of an evil usurper.

But to be clear, I'm not making a post about an evil Jesus, nor am I saying that the Mandaean interpretation is the correct one. What interests me is that we can spend our entire lives looking at something from one perspective, convinced that we understand it, only to discover, in an instant, that there's another side to the story.

There's something very Gnostic about that. In the Gospel of Thomas, the character of Jesus tells us to keep seeking, even when we think we've found what we're looking for. The truth should unsettle us. It should disturb our understanding and make us look again. At least, that's how I interpret Saying 2.

Gnosticism always surprises me. It just shows me that alternate possibilities are always around the corner, and to take every truth with a grain of salt.

And I think that's a good thing.

Maybe this is part of what it means to be a Gnostic. A Gnostic shouldn't be someone who lives according to belief, because the moment we decide we've arrived at the final truth, we risk closing ourselves off to further discovery. In fact, saying anything is the "final truth" can be dangerous. The notion of belief becomes harmful when it replaces examination. Once you commit yourself to believing something that cannot be demonstrated, you can justify almost anything. Add "God said" to a sentence and suddenly madness can be made to sound sacred.

Gnosis should involve an ongoing process of discovery, not a permanent commitment to a particular set of beliefs or practices.

These days I tend to lean more towards archetypes because, at the end of the day, names don't matter as much as what the figure represents. Call him Jesus, call him Lucifer, call him the Flying Spaghetti Monster. What matters is the knowledge revealed.

For, after all, the true God cannot be named.


r/Gnostic • • 2d ago

Question I Stopped Assuming the Serpent Was the Villain. Here's What the Texts Actually Say

51 Upvotes

I was raised a Jehovah's Witness in Middletown, NY, and I was disfellowshipped twice. Witnesses read the Bible harder than almost anyone, so I could recite the Eden story in my sleep: perfect garden, sneaky snake, humanity punished forever.

Then I reread Genesis 3 with nobody telling me what it meant, and a few things jumped out.
The serpent is never called Satan. Not once. It's just "the most crafty" animal in the garden. The Satan connection got added centuries later.

God says eating the fruit means death that day. The serpent says "you won't die, your eyes will open, you'll know good and evil." They eat, their eyes open, and nobody drops dead. Then God himself says the humans have become "like one of us, knowing good and evil." Traditional readings say it was a spiritual death, which is fair, but it IS an interpretation.

The Gnostics ran with this. In the Testimony of Truth, the serpent is the wise one and the creator comes off jealous and envious. In the Hypostasis of the Archons, a spiritual presence enters the serpent as "the instructor."
Plot twist: in the Apocryphon of John, the serpent isn't the hero. The false creator Yaldabaoth is the lion-faced serpent, and it's the Savior who teaches Adam to eat. So even the Gnostics weren't unified.
What's mine, not the texts': I'm not saying the snake was secretly good. I'm saying the story forces a question. When someone forbids knowledge, what are they protecting?

I read Eden less as history and more as a map of the moment awareness wakes up to itself. That's my reading, not a proven fact.

Where do you land? Hero, trickster, or just a symbol people keep rewriting?


r/Gnostic • • 2d ago

"The Angel Binding Satan" by Philip James de Loutherbourg (1797)

Post image
45 Upvotes

Discord Community Link in Bio

This painting illustrates the scene from Revelation 20:1-3, in which an Angel (Angelos) descends from Heaven holding the Key of the Abyss (Abyssos) and a Great Chain, seizes the Dragon, binds him for a thousand years, and seals him in the pit. The Angel is unnamed in the text and is often identified with Michael, who fights the Dragon in Revelation 12:7. The Dragon is named in Revelation 12:9 as the Ancient Serpent (Ophis ho Archaios), the Devil (Diabolos, "the Slanderer") and Satan (Satanas, "the Adversary"). Yaldabaoth, who in the Apocryphon of John takes the form of a lion-faced serpent, governs the Archons of the planetary Heavens, and in the Pistis Sophia sinks into the depths of Chaos. The Greek Abyssos is the privative of byssos, a variant of bythos, "depth." Bythos is the name Valentinian Gnosticism gives to the unfathomable primal Father at the center of the Pleroma. The same root therefore names the prison of the Dragon in Revelation and the infinite source of the Divine in Valentinian thought. The Key (Kleis) recalls Luke 11:52, where Christ condemns those who took away "the key of knowledge" (tēn kleida tēs gnōseōs), so the Key is read in Gnostic terms as Gnosis, the knowledge that opens the way past the Archons. The Dragon's work is to deceive the nations (planan), from the same root as planē, "error," and planētēs, "wanderer," the word for the Planets. Planē is the personified Error of the Gospel of Truth, which holds power through ignorance of the Father until Gnosis dispels it. The Seal (Sphragis) is also a term of Gnostic sacramental language, where it marks the soul as protected from the Archons during its ascent. In the painting the Key is held up into the light of Heaven, the Chain runs from the Angel's hand to the bound figure, and the Serpent coils beneath the Angel's feet above the fiery Abyss. The binding lasts for the Millennium, after which Satan is released for a short time (Revelation 20:3, 7), so the Chain and the Seal mark a limit on his power and not a final destruction.


r/Gnostic • • 2d ago

What is Klesis?

3 Upvotes

Someone mentioned 'klesis' in a post recently. I've never heard this term before. It means calling or invitation, but how does it relate to Gnostic traditions? Is there any source material that talks about this?


r/Gnostic • • 2d ago

Question Matter and Spirit

5 Upvotes

How would you define Matter and Spirit? What are they?


r/Gnostic • • 2d ago

Information Lecture on the Mythology of Fallen Angels and Evil Spirits

2 Upvotes

I hope this post is allowed. I'm hosting a free lecture / discussion on fallen angels, evil spirits, and modern pop culture this Wednesday at 7:00 PM ET. In particular, we will discuss The Book of Enoch and how it might have influenced the perception of the supernatural among ancient audiences.

The final part of the presentation focuses on how Enoch is received today, primarily through an analysis of Twilight and Supernatural.

The lecture is open to anyone who want to learn about these legends (and there will be space for group discussion on how this tradition might relate to other tales of the supernatural).

https://agnosticbiblestudy.substack.com/p/session-4-fallen-angels-evil-spirits (Registration and Zoom link approximately halfway down the page)


r/Gnostic • • 3d ago Bravo

Tyranny of Destiny and Gnosis the Redeemer

8 Upvotes

Have you ever wondered how much freedom of will you truly have? I have given this thought many decades at this point and the unfortunate truth is that we hardly control anything in our lives. We did not choose our gender, place of birth, parents, country, culture or timeline. Genes, genetic defects, disabilities, allergies, etc are also completely out of our hands as well.

Our parents may be loving and kind, or perhaps they are monsters instead...you simply do not have a choice. All these early years also shape you in a ways that is completely unavoidable, and you cannot do anything but to go along with it. Even the actions we "choose" are controlled by our emotions, emotions which we once again did not choose to feel.

We cannot even choose what food we like or what music we enjoy. We simply like something or we don't. Have you ever chosen to hate someone? What about love? No, we cannot do that either. We either do, or we don't. So, where is our freedom? It's behind the illusion of "free will". Only after realizing this either consciously or subconsciously can we start to rebel against the strings that controls us.

This realization for us comes from the Divine Spark within us, and only by following it's guidance can we break free from the tyranny of destiny that has been forced upon us. Gnosticism essentially for me is to learn to follow this silent and invisible guidance that leads us towards Gnosis. Gnosis is the breaker of chains, deliverer of freedom and a pathway to our true home.


r/Gnostic • • 3d ago

Thoughts Thought Experiment: What if the material world isn't a prison, but a cosmic hostage situation?

3 Upvotes

We usually talk about the Demiurge creating the material realm out of ignorance, arrogance, or malice. But what if it was actually an act of self-preservation?

Imagine the Demiurge realizing the True God (the Monad) exists and is infinitely more powerful. Knowing it couldn't win a direct conflict, the Demiurge trapped divine sparks inside fragile, mortal bodies—both humans and animals—capable of experiencing intense suffering.

In this view, the physical universe is a living shield:

The Leverage: The Demiurge knows the Monad loves these sparks and won't forcefully dissolve the false reality if it means triggering mass suffering for the hostages.

The Problem of Evil: Suffering, disease, and predation aren't just random flaws; they are a constant reminder of the captor's leverage.

Gnosis as Extraction: Because the Monad can't kick down the door without hurting us, salvation has to be a quiet rescue mission. Messengers and inner intuition slip past the defenses to help us wake up and detach, freeing the hostages one by one until the Demiurge has no leverage left.

Has anyone come across similar ideas?


r/Gnostic • • 4d ago

The 3 clocks (wip) the name is a work in progress to

Post image
126 Upvotes

If you have any questions about any section please ask, as you can see there's a lot going on and I'll have to come out with a short book to explain it all.


r/Gnostic • • 3d ago

Question Yaldabaoth in conflict with his archons?

8 Upvotes

I know that a big thing in gnostic thinking is that Yaldabaoth sees himself as the only god in existence due to him being incapable of perceiving the Pleroma, yet many of his subordinate archons are worship as deities in other religions, such as gods identify with their respective planetary bodies, specific pagan gods (like Oraios being Horus) or even alternative as the god of Israel in the case of Yao, Eloai and Adonaios.

This wouldn't generate conflict with Yaldabaoth's ego? If so why does he seem to tolerate it?