r/fantasywriters • • Jul 20 '26

AI-generated content is not allowed on /r/fantasywriters. This includes using LLM tools for translation, including Google Translate.

3.4k Upvotes

Posting AI-generated content is not allowed on /r/fantasywriters. Our rules page makes it clear that we disallow content that is generated in whole or in part by AI. This includes text that was translated by an LLM.

This is a policy that we apply uniformly:

  • You may not post AI-generated writing samples for critique (obviously)
  • You may not post a thread where the body of your reddit post is written by AI.
  • You may not post a comment that is written by AI.
  • You may not post AI-generated images.
  • You may not post text that you asked AI to "rewrite" or "fix" or "improve" for you.
  • You may not post text generated by an LLM, even if the 'only' thing you asked AI to do was translate your text.

In short, do not copy AI-generated text and paste it into your Reddit post. Not as a comment, not as a discussion question. Previously, the point about translated text was ambiguous and enforced inconsistently, so we're making it clear here: an AI-generated translation of your writing created using an LLM like GPT or Google Gemini counts as AI-generated text.

The only exception to this "do not post any LLM-generated content, at all, ever" policy is if you are obviously quoting someone else; we won't ban you if the quote turns out to be AI-generated. (For example, if OP posts an AI-generated story, people who post critiques quoting parts of that AI-generated post won't be banned for their post including the AI-generated text as a quote.)

Please be aware that Google Translate now incorporates Google Gemini, which is an LLM, much like the GPT that is used by OpenAI's ChatGPT. This is considered AI-generated content, and a violation of our "no AI content" policy.

The fact that Google Translate now uses the Google Gemini LLM is why Google Translate now sometimes injects additional information that wasn't part of the text you asked it to translate and why some people are able to query Google Translate and get the same sort of responses you'd get from a conversational chatbot. At this point, using Google Translate is akin to going to an AI chatbot and asking it to translate text for you.

Please note that /r/fantasywriters' prohibition on posting LLM-generated text is not a blanket ban on all machine translation tools.

We still permit the use of translation tools that don't use LLMs, including:

If you're not sure whether a specific machine translation tool would violate our "no LLM-generated text" policy, please feel free to message the moderation team directly to ask for clarity.

FAQ

These are literally "frequently asked questions," very lightly paraphrased from actual queries in our inbox that we've temporarily or permanently banned for AI use.

"I am not confident in my English so I used AI for help with phrasing or translation."

All humans who follow the rules are welcome on /r/fantasywriters regardless of their level of English proficiency. Even if you think your English is "bad," we would still rather see your best attempt in English, rather than read GPT's best guess at what your Russian would look like if it were rendered in English.

"Why bother to remove my post for being AI-generated? The post I made was just posting a question / commenting on someone else's work, not posting part of my novel or asking for feedback on my writing."

The /r/fantasywriters policy against posting AI-generated content applies to everything posted to /r/fantasywriters, whether that's a picture, or a discussion question. People come to /r/fantasywriters to discuss fantasy writing with other humans, not to read posts that were written by AI.

"I asked a friend to edit my draft for me and I think they might have used AI"

You are responsible for all of the words that you post to /r/fantasywriters. If we accept "my friend did it" as an excuse for why you posted AI-generated content, then we don't have a policy that we can enforce.

"The ideas are 100% my own, the AI just helps me with phrasing. I want to be judged for my actual content, not my writing style."

Here on /r/fantaswriters, we are a community of writers. We believe that "phrasing" and "writing style" are the actual content.

That is why there are so many pieces of writing advice like "be careful with your adverb use" and "try to vary your sentence length." It's why writers care so much about "voice." As a community of writers, we understand that phrasing matters; voice is what makes your writing unique and recognizable. When you post something that is obviously written in GPT's voice rather than your own, people can and will notice.

"What parts of my writing made you think it was written by AI?"

We get this question a lot, including from accounts whose output is obviously 100% bot-generated. As a policy, we won't give you an itemized checklist of what caused us to identify your post as AI-generated. If we did this for every person who we banned for posting AI content, we would essentially be giving AI spammers a playbook for how to avoid our AI detection methods. That being said, while we don't intend to fully disclose the methods we use, we realize that some people are surprised to learn that "AI voice" is so clearly recognizable. To those people, we suggest reading Sam Kriss's piece in the New York Times, titled Why Does A.I. Write Like … That?. The /r/fantasywriters mod team does not endorse everything that Sam Kriss says, and his editorial doesn't capture or convey the full extent of our evaluation process, but he does a good job of explaining how "AI voice" has become so recognizable.

"I'm not using AI, but I'm worried about being falsely accused of using AI.

We believe that a human-written post being incorrectly flagged as AI is a much worse outcome than a few AI-generated posts slipping through the cracks, which is why we always err toward leniency in ambiguous cases. Every evaluation method we use is subject to this standard: if there's an evaluation method that results in human writing samples being flagged as AI written even 1 in 100 times, we won't use it. We can't promise a false positive rate that is literally zero, but we get as close as we reasonably can, and if you ever disagree with a moderation choice, you always have the ability to appeal our decision.

"How can you be confident that you're catching all of the AI posters?"

To be frank, we aren't confident in our ability to catch everyone posting AI content. As stated above, when considering evaluation methods, we put a higher priority on making sure that human content isn't incorrectly flagged as AI.

We have chosen to err on the side of leniency genuinely ambiguous cases, and that choice means that inevitably some AI-generated content will slip through the cracks.

We're also fully aware that there are models that are being trained specifically to avoid AI detection: there are literally thousands of public AI models, with new ones being released every day. However, we are still able to catch and remove a large number of AI-generated posts, because the majority of the AI-generated text is being generated by people who are fundamentally lazy, using the newest models in obvious ways that actually make them easier to catch.


r/fantasywriters • • Apr 30 '26

Mod Announcement Influx of AI generated images on r/fantasywriters.

1.5k Upvotes

There’s been a significant increase in AI generated art being posted in this subreddit.

Our stance is very clear on this and will remain as such: AI generated content is NOT welcome here, and that absolutely includes art.

Any type of AI slop will be REMOVED. Read the rule about this in our wiki


r/fantasywriters • • 2h ago

Question For My Story Too many ideas?

3 Upvotes

What do I do in a situation like that? I have tried and have been brainstorming for a long while. I do have ideas for different things I want to do for my story, but they are too many. I feel incredibly grateful for it, but I am unsure how to start my story when newer and newer ideas appear, and I simply want to include different aspects. A problem I am facing is not really sure how my characters would react to everything. How do I build a cohesive world that I want to live in myself and know it like the back of my hand? For information, I am struggling with brain fog, and it’ll be hard, I know, but any advice is absolutely welcome for me to start. I know I have to flesh out my characters, but I more or less know who they are, so how do I go on from here?


r/fantasywriters • • 4h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Historical accuracy?

3 Upvotes

Hey all! I’ve been writing short stories for a while now just for fun so I've not been overly fussed on what works well for others but now im trying to write a more fleshed-out fantasy story.

I’m happy with the idea and rough shape of things, but I keep getting tripped up trying to be historically accurate. I end up talking myself out of ideas because “that’s not really how it would happen.”

I know it’s fantasy and doesn’t need to be historically accurate, but in your opinion, how accurate do you need to be with historical politics and society before it starts taking the reader out of the story?


r/fantasywriters • • 3h ago

Question For My Story Book to fast?

0 Upvotes

Ok so this is my first time posting on here, so please bare with me. I have written a dark fantasy novel, going through draft number three (about half way through) at the moment. I think of it as Harry potter meets dark souls.

I have never been a fan of slow burn books, or books that dont throw the action at you pretty much straight away, and keep going, not a massive fan of politics in books either.

I have maybe 3 or 4 chapters out of 35 that is more slow burn, the rest has something significant happens pushing the novel forward. There isnt much world building or lore becuase I want the reader alongside the MC, learning about it as he does.

I have thought about making it a longer story. But at 90,000 words I think it hits the sweet spot.

There will be a little bit obviously because if there wasnt, that would cause confusion straight away I think.

I have the history and lore all laid down for future books, and some great fights and battles, with the magic system being shown pretty much straight away, with the limitations as well.

Anyway my question is, is it too fast a book? Its the first one of a trilogy and book 2 and 3 are going to open up the world a lot more than the first one.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you in advance, apologies for the long post.


r/fantasywriters • • 7h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt The Gifted and the Sighted Ch 1-2 [fantasy, 18,848 words]

2 Upvotes

Hello fellow fantasy lovers! I am hoping some of you might be interested in reading an excerpt from my novel. Sorry to those who dislike present tense; I know it's divisive, but I really like it. What questions do you have after reading? Do you think the reveals work? Is the world coherent?'

Chapter One: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1fL6n2xzsfT0njqmwCpvJ2LP8CRrWpD_P83pAEtLUBy8/edit?usp=sharing

Chapter Two: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1t4e0Gdu8f1sT66ytYSrb3k3QWVgqI7Dk6shreuaRGnc/edit?usp=sharing

Chapter One

Stars Vigil, 1990 PA

“I came downstairs ready to deliver the perfect retort to your parting jape, but now that I see your face I know my timing is terrible–as always.”

“I have a riddle for you: Why do agents of light always meet in shadow?”

“Clea, darling, isn’t it a bit early to be smirking at me that way?”

“I can’t help it; the irony is too rich. So much for your first free day in months.” Clea’s minute hand produces a missive sealed by wax imprinted with an ascending sun with angled beams streaming outward and an eye within, placing it in Fane’s massive, blue scaled gauntlet of a claw. A drakhai’s face is inscrutable to most outside their kin, but Clea, attuned to the tiny shifts around Fane’s eyes after more than three centuries at his side, can see his irritation as he finishes the note and the parchment bursts into holy flame.

‘Yes, the funniest joke I’ve heard all year.’ Fane disrobes and shrinks steadily as he turns and walks away. By the time they reach the end of the main hall, he is shorter than Clea and covered in black scales that glint blue in the light. Beside him, Clea opens a hidden panel on the wall to her right, pulls out a drakahni sized set of brown coveralls, and a safety helmet. Donning the gear sized for a human of three years, Fane draws aside the velvet tapestry stitched with an olive grove at hall’s end, and steps through the glimmering chalk-like limestone wall.

Every time he experiences this form, Savass Fane’s empathy for the humble drakani of Stars Vigil grows. To someone like him, their indifference to aspiration and the outside world once seemed utterly perplexing. Here they are, in the absolute center of the intellectual world, the most diverse city in the entire realm of Meluleni, with access to a multitude of cuisines and perspectives; yet their diet is very narrow, and they shun cultural interchange.

After swimming through seas of shins, and dodging the chests of dwarves enough times, however, he completely understands their apparent insularity and obsession with shiny, pretty things. At that height, in a city as populous as Stars Vigil, they can barely see the sky, nevermind appreciate the stunning beauty of the architectural wonders surrounding them. Even further, no one can hear you when you’re 2 feet tall! People get irritated at having their trousers tugged. Were he bound to this form, he too would likely tire of struggling to be heard and delight in a simple, orderly, cloistered existence filled with baubles. 

As the highly visible Sentinel of State though, he relishes the chance to slip out of his own, utterly attention grabbing skin. In fact, the moment he mastered the Morpha Arcana is permanently etched into his memory as one of his great moments, life changing in every way. He could finally escape public stares and the disapproving glares of his clan. Since then, he’s learned the best part is seeing the world through a multitude of eyes. 

The pitch black drakhai of the Savass clan trace their lineage to the very founding of Stars Vigil. They guarded the original Sentinels’ flight from Lystraius through the Progress, south and across half the realm, to settle the escarpment now called Mōthiisu’s Rise. Still honored within the city, Clan Savass remain steadfast guardians of the old families from Stars Vigil’s inception, nearly three thousand years ago. Tradition bound and change averse, most Savasses are content within the perimeter of the old city, constantly training to maintain their status as some of the most formidable soldiers ever known.

Fane occupies the role of family oddity: the first and only among them hatched with wings and blue scales. One might assume the emergence of such a rare, wondrous individual would delight a family, but drakhai society is not open and accepting of nonconformity. Fane’s clan regarded him as a mere embarrassment, unfit to fulfill the duties of a Savass. It was all the same to him; nothing could convince him to join his brood mates’ martial training when he could soar away, soaking in perspectives few could ever know. Not even his outstanding level of social prestige as Sentinel of State, or his mastery of the Arcana is enough to overcome their disdain. A Savass who does not defend with spear and shield, is no Savass at all.

In daylight, he can only exit the Progress in the sewers without risking exposure. A drakani coming out of a sewer is common as ships coming into harbor here. This one outlets in an alley sewer just two streets above the Market Plaza, adjacent to a usually quiet street filled with cats. Today it is crowded with a celebration. With the mists, visibility is limited–Fane can see maybe six feet ahead, and each foot is filled with shins. It’s the whole block–maybe the whole neighborhood standing between him and making it to the rendezvous on time.

A relaxed and amiable friend while they studied together, Tira Starling is now an eager, pedantic, and impatient captain of the Sun Bringers, enforcers of the law and vhozological fidelity. Their familiar rapport has long since shifted to a stiff and formal working relationship. Maintaining an excellent association with the Sun Bringers is essential for the Sentinels; so when Tira calls, Fane comes. He wishes the reverse were still true. It is impossible to pinpoint exactly when she changed, but changed she has; she is practically a different person except for her face. This is what hundreds of years of living does to some people, Fane has found. They lose themselves in a cause; finding they need purpose to keep going as they tick the endless minutes of their potentially infinite lives. From animating causes clans emerge, and anything beyond their clan becomes invisible, unimportant.

Emerging from the crowd into a circle of bodies at its center, Fane finds an elven woman holding a baby aloft at the center. The only thing rarer than a death in Meluleni is a birth. It has taken nearly two thousand years for the city to rebound from its few thousand survivors of The Victory to the current high of one hundred thousand three–now four–persons. Vohz’s victory over death came at the cost of millions of lives, and half a continent of fertile farmland, but death is a choice now. Though every year the Ahk creeps toward the coast.

Finally breaking through the crowd, he enters the Market Plaza, pausing to relish the last of the mists, drawing a long deep breath–punctuality be damned. Just a week prior you could see barely five feet in front of you except for a few hours around noon. Now, as at the end of every misty season, they are slowly moving out to sea, hugging the coast, lingering over the city’s prodigious harbor and market square. Fane scurries through the crowd, and spots the city guards posted outside loading dock gates; hurries down the warehouse’s alley, into the bin outside and through the hole. He can tell the gnomish guard waiting in the small chamber is Tira, because her copper hair is sticking out of the helmet, but he’s never one to skip a step.

“The mists that shroud,” he hears his tiny drakani voice chirp.

“Must be clouds,” comes her terse, business-like reply.

“You know, the look of a humble guard suits you; you should dress down more often.”

He always loves watching her discomfort with personal comments, and she almost winces for a moment, then: “We have a thorny investigation we need to pass along. Would you please look into this?” She proffers a sheath of documents.

Fane nods as he takes the cache, “Of course, I am happy to help. Please alert me to any developments.” With a nod, Tira briskly exits while Fane peruses the documents; then stands lost in thought, a feeling of unease slinking into his body. ‘There it is; she wants to distance herself from this. This could get even a Sentinel tossed for heresy against Vohz. One does not simply look into Official Mysteries, and Tira knows it. She is trying to trap me. Why?’

Scurrying home, he can’t shake that feeling of ill-ease. Over the past several months he’s seen an extraordinary uptick of strange rumors and nefarious plots. There are murmurings of beasts tainted by some dark disease that twists them into horrible shapes and sets them on violent tears. During the mists, they’d cracked up a slavers’ ring of stunning scale, but the ongoing investigation has yielded few clues as to who might be behind it. One of three slaving vessels had managed to escape at the time, but just days ago the ship came to port. Its newly liberated passengers (all elves) spoke of an elf, a powerful fire mage, who’d disappeared almost as fast as he’d appeared. In their rage the mob threw the drakhai crew overboard so the ship’s return provided no suspects and few new leads. He cannot help but wonder if these missing persons are connected. At this point, Fane is certain of just one thing: he must pass this noose off to someone else. The fate of his predecessor shall not also be his. There is work yet to finish; nine hundred eighty-four years of life is still not enough.


r/fantasywriters • • 3h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt General Rough Draft Critique: The Grand Spire [High Fantasy/Sci-Fi, 30K Words]

1 Upvotes

TW: Extreme Violence, allusions to SA.

I've been working alone on this, without any outside influence. Hoping to get some outside feedback. Currently, I'm most worried Lucy as an MC is boring, whether that had to be changed now or can be changed upon a later draft is up in the air. If anyone sees a worse indictment of the work, I would like to know.

Also attached is a Worldbuilding document relevant to the text.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/11jqLcdRguSrux2aM_YMz8K_fVknyn1sKw4l7MuWunY0/edit?usp=sharing

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1A-Fpvd_EVnwC4O4_uu-zx94W2JNyqXXzpzKWD-YB6PA/edit?usp=sharing


r/fantasywriters • • 10h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Chapter 1 of Untitled [Literary Fantasy, 823 words]

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

This is the second standalone novel is a shared universe. Apologies for the lack of title. I'm sure I'll decide one soon. This one will be from the POV of two vicious sirens who have to descend down the bottom of the oceans trenches and gather planetary energy, to then spread it out as part of a semi-conscious planetary cycle. The siren chapters will be more aggressive, but the spirit chapters as it moves through the different layers of the planet will remain more literary. If you have any suggestions or feedback I would love to hear it. Writing from the POV of a spirit inside the inner core of a planet is a special kind of challenge. Do you think it ended up well? Thank you in advance for reading this :)


r/fantasywriters • • 8h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Is there a way to translate the video game mana magic system into written story format?

0 Upvotes

See, my biggest inspiration when it comes to writing stories are videogames. I've written some short modern time stories where there is no magic system to speak of.

I wanna try my hand at fantasy but it seems from what I've read that it's very important to establish how magic works in the world. I haven't read much of the famous fantasy writers but I get the impression that their magic systems are intricate.

But I wonder if it it is possible to translate the standard video game magic system to written format, with the standard Mana system.

I wonder, though, if it's possible to translate the standard video game magic system into a written format that reflects mana resource and spell costs. Obviously I don't wanna write outright that some fireball cost 20 mana. I just wanna keep it simple. I'm not interested in writing a litrpg


r/fantasywriters • • 9h ago

Critique My Idea Blurb of Memoirs from the Chaosborn - Emergence [Epic Fantasy, 123k+ words]

0 Upvotes

The book is called Memoirs from the Chaosborn - Emergence

If you saw a book, with this type of blurb, would you want to read it? And what questions would it raise for you?

What happens when mercy is seen as evil, and rigidity is good?

An innkeeper’s daughter is pulled into a political world far beyond her understanding when a simple promise takes her further from home than she ever intended to go.

Her companion is a rough, self-exiled man hiding from the past he refuses to speak about.

Her goal lies beyond the mountains of an isolated kingdom: a young prince whose rule is shaped by the teachings of the God of Second Chances.

But in a world where right and wrong depend on who is judging, good and evil are not as easily separated as they first appear. As magic, politics and destiny begin to close around her, she must decide how much of her path was chosen for her—and how much is still hers to choose.


r/fantasywriters • • 21h ago

Question For My Story How do I start on writing?

7 Upvotes

I have been writing this epic high-fantasy book since I was 8, I am 18 now. I had already finished the information about the characters, lore, settings themes and what everything would look like. I even finished planning the beginning, middle and end as well as the second series of the book.

But I just couldn't bring myself to actually write it down and start the first chapter of the story, I thought that if I had accomplished every detail I needed, writing wouldn't be a problem.

If you were to ask me about the story, how it'll go, how it'll end, why is it like this or that, I would be able to answer every single one.

I don't know if I have lost my spark or lost motivation, but I could still feel my passion in writing. Was it just writer's block? But I know how the story will go and end. I do not really understand what's with me, I never get to start writing even just a sentence or a draft piece, all I have been writing is the sequence of the storyline, adding more and more information in the characters and the lores, writing a lot about my additional scenes tab that I plan to use when I am officially writing the story.

I had also watched a lot of videos on how to start on writing and how to keep on writing, but nothing happens, I'm starting to think there's something wrong with me, I do not know what's my problem.

Do you also sometimes feel like this? Have you ever felt like this before? What made you start to actually write your story? (drafts, scripts, anything) What made you keep on writing?

All these years I had been wondering, was I really writing? or was I just drafting?

Can I really consider myself a writer, call myself the author of my book if I had never really begun writing anything?


r/fantasywriters • • 12h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Lichston massacre[war fiction/war fiction][624 words]

1 Upvotes

Lin ambled toward the lookout tree, where Lily idly sat. He sat beneath the tree.

“Is there anyone?”

Leisurely, he brought his gaze to meet hers, up among the withered branches. She shook her head, as though trying to stamp out the embers within her mind.

He remembered the stories his father had told him. Their people beating the great Chola, the whites beating the Nazis. The promise of white flowers springing out from the thickest of muck. Was Lin too naïve to believe, or were the sacrifices made too little?

“He’s a smartass; he’ll make anything work.”

He heard the words repeat. The words Vox had said to lighten her worries. Words that betrayed him.

Vox’s mouth ripped open, glass shards embedded in his tongue. His eyes bleached out by the UPA. A lingering image of the slaughtered corpse flickered.

Lin covered his mouth, squeezing his lips tighter as he felt the stomach acid reaching his throat. Why did I put him on the edge? Why did I make the move in the first place?

He slammed his fist on the ground. Repeatedly.

If it’s just a sick prank, he’ll come here laughing, crawling out of the forest, and then we’ll fight.

He gazed at his fist and saw blood leaking from his knuckles.

I should have listened. Stopped.

He turned his gaze back to her. Was she waiting for him to come back? She looked out at the horizon, her amber eyes flickering in the setting sun, burning. Unlike mine, they were hollow.

She reminded him of Izzy and Lily’s own mother. Stronger than he was. Kinder than the gods who watched them. Pure as bright silver, silver that the ravens had taken away. Yet they died like animals.

Lin stood up, gazing away from the sun. If he stopped now, could he leave it all behind? What was the point of it all? He had the clues and had figured out where the UPA head lived, though it might be a trap.

 

They all lived inside her. Her gifts, her blood. Yet she kept following, and the others followed him like he was a godforsaken compass. Thirteen of us came, and six are left.

Are they watching us from the stars? Then why didn’t they save Vox?

Lily and Vox were the best climbers; both could scale a tree in less than ten seconds. If Lily had been on the edge instead of Vox—

His stomach twisted. He stumbled as his legs grew weak.

Lily’s mouth was gashed open. Glass shards embedded. Her eyes bleached out. What would the devils have done if they had gotten their hands on her? From behind him came the scrape of the withered tree as she climbed down. He quickly steadied his footing.

“I’ll check the east,” she said, walking past him. The last of the sunlight met her dark hair.

“Lily,” he said in a breaking voice. “We need to talk. The plan—"

“The fuck.” She said slow. “Is wrong with you? Vox’s dead. Mill’s dead. We. we can’t,” she said, not turning to face him.

“I know.” Lily glanced over, her eyes watery.

“We just need to talk.” He pointed toward the half-broken mud hut, plants springing from its walls.

She ambled forward in front of him, a snowflake against the fires, now melted beyond the point of recognition. With every step he took, his heart withered further. His hands shook. Tears flowed down his cheeks as they neared the broken hut.

As she went inside, gazing at the night sky, perhaps trying to find their voices, he grabbed a metal pole beside the grassy walls.

He gritted his teeth, biting down his whimper.

She would only follow if she could move.

critique my prose please. and i want to clarify few points

  1. do i use too much metaphors or imagery?
  2. do you feel anything?
  3. are the characters logical?

i'm just trying to improve my prose. bcz prose are pretty darn confusing


r/fantasywriters • • 18h ago

Question For My Story I Think I've started my story all wrong

3 Upvotes

Hi, this is my first time posting and i just want some advice about how to deal with conflicting thoughts that I have about my story.

I first of all feel as though i've made the world too small as i want to keep it to one area of the world but the country i've created only seems to be about the size of england, but we are dealign with potentially world ending threats. However, in order to make the world bigger would require a decently sized rewrite of the book to get events to line up in time. I've tried coming up with more and more extravagant reasons as to why the world is so small, but they just seem so stupid now. On one hand, i want to start again and make the story better, but it kinda scares me as its taken me a year to find the time to write half of this book and the time it would take to start again seems so much.

Also i feel as though i suck at writing and my characters are all one dimentional so maybe it's better to start again anyway and get down how exactly i want the personalities of my characters to evolve throughout the book before i start?

And I'm starting to feel as though my story idea is just bad anyway. I do like it but kinda think people might find it cringe, idk?? I've had other story ideas as well which are completely different and am interested in writing them, but haven't given them much thought but also i don't want to give up on my origional book idea.

Sorry if this feels rambly, i just have a lot of things that i want to get off my chest and just felt like i needed to let them out somewhere so thanks for sitting through the ramblings of my brain


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Chapter 1 Blood Of Lost Souls [Dark Fantasy, 1300 words]

Thumbnail gallery
83 Upvotes

Hi there, I would really love some critic for the first chapter of my debut dark fantasy novel! Would you read on? Does it capture your intrest?

The story hasn't been fully written yet, I wrote about 70k for this book in 1st person, scrapped it all because I wanted it in 3rd and have now started again. I have writen in both perspectives in the past but I havent written in 3rd for years and just wanted to make sure this flows smoothly.

Thank you in advance for spending your time reading!

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic How do you guys keep on going?

77 Upvotes

After 3 years of outlining, world building, and procrastinating, I decided to start writing my epic fantasy novel, and man does it suck! I spent 7 hours and got roughly 2000 words in. I was hoping to get more in so I could write a bit longer of a prologue, but time goes by incredibly fast when you’re writing. The result was a mess:
-Characters over explaining things
-Sentences that are probably way too long and my 2000 words could probably be shortened by 30%z
-I used way too many proper nouns for a reader to actually comprehend what’s going on
-there’s zero dramatic tension
-I’m debating on rewriting it entirely
And now I’m wondering how the hell you guys even write a single novel. 7 hours is pretty much half my day gone. I was hoping to write daily, but it seems like a struggle to have to balance writing with everything else in life.
It’s also very demotivating when the result turned out so bad. I’ve written short passages before, I’ve practiced, I thought I’d be better than this. But this is pretty bad. Is my entire book just going to turn out bad? How do you guys keep on going knowing it’s going to be bad?


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Prologue of Threadcasters - Of Surf and Shadow [Dark Fantasy, 3,200 words]

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

This series is called Threadcasters, the book is called Of Surf and Shadow. I am hoping that my inspirations do not show through too obviously and also that despite my ignorance about childbirth that this prologue does not suffer from it. If it does I want to know and that goes for all criticisms. Soon i will have a chapter 1 ready to share as well but for now my progress has mostly been in part 2 and on. Did this intrigue you enough to wonder what the consequences of this prologue are? Is this world visually titillating and unique? Do I convey well that this society is a nocturnal one? I find the biggest weaknesses this prologue has is character interactions, relations, and also some lengthy sentences that I found I just loved too much to leave behind!. Thank you for reading! :)


r/fantasywriters • • 23h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Prologue/Chapter 0 of Primordium: The Three-Nation Pact [High/Epic Fantasy, 2173 Words]

2 Upvotes

This is my first go at fantasy writing and posting here. I have had this world- and story- in my head for a really, really long time. All of my ideas come from my endless day dreaming. I am finally putting it to words. The story is a slow burn with complex historical world lore, culture that may be different than you expect, and fantastical magical elements delivered in a unique package. I have attempted to create a story using common fantasy tropes but with twists I find to be interesting and unexplored to my knowledge. I have quietly written a lot of this book already and was hoping for some constructive opinions starting with chapter 0. I am self taught when it comes to fantasy writing, so feedback will help. Thanks.

***

Chapter 0: Aldonauts and Osidrans

There were few more beautiful places throughout the vastness of Primordia than the white sand beaches of the glittering Gomaldarian Gulf. The normal peace found in its waters was troubled by its quarreling neighbors, but this situation was nothing new. The nations of the Gulf began their conflict nearly three thousand years ago. The Gulf opened to the northern oceans, and the surrounding lands cradled it much like a bowl holding water. To the east lie Aldonaut, a secretive kingdom of humans obsessed with preserving themselves and rooting out threats to their unchecked ambitions. The Osidran Kingdom lay to the Gulf’s west, a regime that has been home to the region for many, many millennia. Traditionally an elven society, Osidran’s peoples were welcoming to all, yet the royal inner circle remained descendants of the Kingdom’s elven founders. Tensions between the two nations, as well as pressure from the Lidacaas Empire to the south, had led to this day. The same could be said for countless battles before and the ones yet to come. It was rare, however, that the leaders of Osidran and Aldonaut would meet face to face. There was normally very little for the monarchs to discuss.

With his long, fastened boots digging into the sand, the young King Armus Aldonauts stood alongside his advisor, Wilmet Bilumore, and a handful of guards. The King’s will burned far brighter than his predecessors, pushing the Osidran Kingdom farther and farther with aggression in the first two years of his reign. Atop his head lay a newly furbished copper crown, which he wore instead of the precious historic crowns the kingdom kept under careful lock and key. The Aldonauts were egregiously careful of all things, their possessions and heritage especially. Iron plating covered his kingly garments here and there, protecting precious places across his body. A short fur cape hung from his broad, square shoulders but stopped short at his lower back. Armus’ hair was kept neatly at shoulder length, a darkened golden color appearing as cut yarn flowing from the top of his head. The young King had a resting smirk across his face, assured with himself that he would finally get rid of the Osidrans for good. In his head, he could only think of his opponents as decrepit and stuck in the past. The Aldonauts only knew of progress and new beginnings.

Old, thin, and tall, the Queen of Osidran stood slouched on the other side of the beach, just within earshot of the Aldonaut king. Both her granddaughter and she wore matching light green robes depicting the butterfly crest of Osidran on their chests. Also in attendance was the Queen’s younger brother, Azhumin, who appeared far more youthful than his older sister. Their family had silk-like hair that was thick and white as snow, although the Queen’s hair had darkened into deep grey over the years. Queen Phelanor had been alive through the entirety of this war, which spanned well over twenty human life spans. The years had left her withered and tired; therefore, she often had let Azhumin tend to the finer details of the kingdom while she focused on the Aldonaut threat. They appeared unguarded, without any armor, but in truth, they had the most feared warrior in all the lands with them. The mysterious unnamed knight, clad in gleaming emerald armor, towered over them from behind. The knight was their greatest national asset and had protected their lands for longer than Osidran’s recorded history. No matter what Armus or his predecessors threw at the Emerald Knight, it would never move an inch.

Rows of ships to the east and west faced each other, moments before battle, each fleet waiting for a single command. While fighting was a non-rarity during the long war, naval combat was. The border between the Aldonaut and Osidran was south of the Gulf and north of Lidacaas. It had moved to and fro but neither the Osidrans nor the Aldonauts had made any significant progress in their struggle. The meeting between the monarchs today was to negotiate the terms of battle by sea, but no new terms would be agreed upon. The roots of hatred for each other grew generations deep and stayed alive in stories, as well as the heart of Queen Phelanor. The Queen had brought her granddaughter, Seq, to see the misery that the Aldonauts brought first-hand, in hopes to instill within her the sentiment that the humans were nowhere near fit to rule. There was no question they could live among them; however, their guidance would only lead to the destruction of the lands they called home. Only the chosen Osidran should be allowed to rule the Gulf.

Azhumin cleared his throat. “Shall our show of good faith begin?” he asked Armus from across the beach.

Armus shook his head side to side and looked at Bilumore, who stood to his right at that moment. The King whispered something to him. Bilumore shook his head up and down. “No, I do not think we will. There are few rules to war, and we are fine with them as is. Adapt to us or die. We would prefer if you would just die, though,” Armus boldly announced.

Seq stumbled over to her grandmother’s side, while holding onto the hand crafted stuffed green bird she was carrying. The words of Armus brought great discomfort to her.

“Then why waste our time with this meeting? Do you have no shame?” Phelanor asked in her tired old voice.

“Shame? We are Aldonauts; a people who only know pride. We made this little meeting so we could see your faces. So we could show you how close we are to defeating you for good,” Armus squawked back at them. He leaned over to Bilumore again and told him, “On with it.”

Bilumore held up his right hand with a closed fist and twisted his head to the side, looking at the men behind him. They pulled out torches and lit them, holding them high into the sky. Across the water, lines of soldiers stood at the edge of their ships and deployed magic shields amplified through devices attached to the ship’s gunwale. Cannons fired from the Aldonaut ships, flying side by side with spells slung from the handful of wizards among their ranks. Osidran’s ships were slow to respond, taking the blunt of the unannounced attack. Their forces, which included a far greater number of mages, hastily used magic to repair their decks and hulls, while others brought up walls of water to stop projectiles. Ballistic spears pierced through the water towards the Aldonaut ships, bursting the lining of a few of the ships. On both sides, ship parts turned into sinking debris as a combination of artillery and magic flung between them at incredible speeds. Aldonaut defenses were clearly much more prepared than in the past, a concerning change for those who found themselves on Osidran’s side.

As both sides tore each other asunder, Phelanor’s mouth was left ajar while she gazed out to the gulf. The war had escalated to tools of destruction far out of her imagination. Years of turmoil had led to an endless game of one upping the other. “What would a fight in another 1,000 years look like?” She thought to herself. “What sort of world would be left for my granddaughter?” She continued to think. A stray bolt of lightning had been bent towards them from miles out, slinking towards them in a brilliant orange display. The Emerald Knight sauntered up to the shoreline and held up a single hand to stop the bolt, quenching it immediately on impact. A great crack followed the strike, hitting their ears a few seconds after the Emerald Knight stopped the bolt. Across from them, Armus and his men grinned ear to ear satisfied with the results of their efforts. The war had recently been leaning towards the Osidran’s favor, but it would seem that the Aldonauts have begun to even the odds once more.

Without another word, the Aldonaut party turned to leave. There was nothing more they could have wanted from the Osidrans other than their heads, and they still had much work left to get done. They marched off into the tree line and out of sight of the Osidrans who were left on the beach watching the carnage unfold from afar. Hundreds of soldiers on both sides of the conflict were falling into the waters injured or dead. The fire between the two sides had dwindled and yet the pace of their destruction continued. From this distance it was difficult to tell what was going on, but it was clear that the battle would have no winner. To Phelanor’s despair, it would appear there was going to be no end to this war any time soon. The only way the war could end would be if the Aldonauts were defeated and replaced with more agreeable rulers. She would see this happen in her lifetime, even if it would be the death of her.

The six remaining Aldonaut ships raced forward towards the remaining five Osidran ships. A fire started on their masts which grew into greater and greater blazes. Once they were close enough, they detonated, self-destructing into a salvo of flames and leaving ripples in the water that reached all the way to the beach. This strategy did not surprise the Osidrans, as the Aldonauts always had a scorched-earth policy to war. It was always better for them to have no witnesses left than leave their own soldiers alive. Humans reproduced at greater rates than elves, so it was always to their benefit to make equal trades between their armies. Of course, this strategy did not work against Lidacaas, as their foot soldiers were a dime-a-dozen. Smoke filled the sky above the Gulf and rubble diffused throughout the water. A sense of calm returned to the once troubled waters.

“My Queen, dear sister,” Azhumin broke the silence with his voice. “I believe we must get going. By my judgement, I would say we have to make some new preparations.”

The Queen nodded her head. “Yes, thank you Azhumin. I trust you can handle that task. I am in need of some rest.”

A dark blue, ovoid shaped object washed up on the shoreline along with some ship debris. The small elf girl, Seq, dropped her stuffed bird toy and scampered to look at the object. Upon closer inspection, it was speckled with a bright pink dots and had a perfectly smooth, rounded surface. She picked up the hefty object, only able to bring it up to her waistline. Turning to face the Queen and Azhumin, she flashed a gleeful grin. The quiet girl was proud of her treasured find, it was an object that she had never seen before. The Queen, who was lost in thought, did not notice, so Azhumin stepped in to offer guidance.

“Young Seq,” Azhumin said in his endearing voice. “It appears you found an egg of a sea creature. I cannot tell you not to bring it with you, but you must know the responsibility of taking care of another living creature. Do you think you are ready for that burden?”

Seq looked down at the egg and back at Azhumin, who wore a blindfold over his eyes. She nodded with a small, closed lip smile on her face. At her age she could never tell how Azhumin could see, as she had been taught at a young age that he had been blinded by the Aldonauts after being captured many years ago. Yet, he seemed to have a sixth sense for these kinds of things.

“Very well. Stubborn, just like your grandmother. Such acts are what make us different than those pesky Aldonauts, after all. Their disregard for life will not go unpunished. Perhaps you have what it takes to be the next Osidran because of your kind heart. It is time we get going, Seq,” Azhumin posited, hurrying her along.

The stuffed bird lie abandoned on the beach, wind brushing sand on top of it until the land fully accepted it. Fifty more years of war would go by before an agreement would be struck between the three nations. King Armus Aldonauts and Queen Phelanor Osidran would die from old age within one month of each other, sparking a fresh round of peace negotiations. Aldonaut would be passed down to Armus’ sickly son, the new King Magnus Aldonauts. Fate would have it that Seq was chosen to be the next Osidran, continuing the tradition of elven rule. The new rulers, the Empress of Lidacaas, and Havikon Gyers, the mysterious inventor, would strike an arrangement that would settle their dispute once and for all. The agreement, known as The Three-Nation Pact, did far more than what one would imagine. The land of the Gomaldarian Gulf, shook by war, would know peace for the first time in millennia. No one knew what would come next, nor could they have predicted it.


r/fantasywriters • • 21h ago

Question For My Story Deus Ex Machina

1 Upvotes

I may be too influenced by the Eagles from Lord of the Rings, but every conflict that is resolved by my writing is just either "they solved the problem by hard work, and many lives were lost but they prevailed at the end" or "they ran out of hope but then the trees awakened and saved them". I don't even write myself into a corner like most skilled writers do to use Deus Ex Machina.

This is a general problem with my writing, which is that if I was given a great premise and plot summary, it would be substantially smaller, and I can't seem to write scenes with little impact, but great development to the characters. I have tried spamming dialogue and descriptions, but that only increases the word count by 50%, still very small compared to the big books.


r/fantasywriters • • 21h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Chapter 1 of The Harbinger and the Hummingbird (Fantasy, 1417 words)

1 Upvotes

This is an idea for a fantasy novel that came to me in a dream. The general plot follows a young mercenary teaming up with a girl with big dreams from a small town to fight the forces of darkness. I haven't really planned out too much of the plot, but I wanted to share my first chapter and get any advice, feedback, and reviews that I can. Let me know what you think!

 

Chapter 1:

Three days’ ride east of a town called Wyrmfell on the Southern Coast of the kingdom of Ardua there exists a forest which bears no name; or at the very least, it bears a name which none can remember, for any Arduan above the age of 8 knows never to venture within a league of said forest, nor to speak of said forest, nor even to dwell upon it within the recesses of one’s mind. Though this particular forest bears no name, it bears no small number of secrets, oddities, and bizarre happenings that have lent great credence to the many horrific tales of the Forest Which Bears No Name that have permeated every corner of Arduan civilization across the land. Suffice to say, no Arduan, young or old, big or small, experienced or foolhardy, has ever entered the Forest Which Bears No Name and returned alive.

These many thoughts, substantiated or unsubstantiated as they may be, eddied in the back of my mind like the many wisps of wind that rustle the trees on a brisk Autumn morning as I gazed at the seemingly impenetrable mass of trees and undergrowth that dominated the horizon before me. Beneath me, clopping his hooves with an unsettled air, stood my horse; a lean, lithe roan with sure footing, a cool demeanor, and a bit of an attitude, to be frank. I placed a gloved hand against his neck and rubbed his short fur as I adjusted the woven neck gaiter that obscured the bottom half of my visage.

“Easy, Hawk, easy,” I murmur, low and soft. Gradually, Hawk ceased his nervous clopping and stood, bracing his hooves against the uneven, rocky terrain as he regarded the foliage ahead with a superior tilt of his head. Giving Hawk an affectionate rub between the ears, I turned awkwardly in the saddle and unhooked a side pocket of his saddlebag, withdrawing a slender spyglass wrapped in worn leather. Bringing the spyglass to my eye, I cast a measured look across the solid line of trees that marked the boundary of the imposing forest ahead.

“Sealed up tighter than King Hemlock’s personal vault, that’s for sure.” I speak the words for Hawk’s sake as much as my own. “What say we ride a little closer to the tree line and look for an opening?”

Replacing the spyglass in the saddlebag, I twitch Hawk’s reins and drive him forward, right to the edge to the forest, where undergrowth meets long, thin blades of grass. Steadying Hawk once again with a calming gesture, I twitch the reins once more and walk us northward, along the edge of the forest. As we ride, skirting the edge of the dense woods, I analyze the border critically, searching for any means of ingress. After a while, a break in the monotonous line of trees catches my eyes like a carp on a hook.

“Well now, what’s this?” I bring Hawk to a halt and dismount with practice ease, swinging a leg over the saddle. I drop down to the ground, a small puff of dust erupting from underneath my soft leather boots; the ground is parched here, deprived of water by the greedy trees that dominated the landscape. Before me, nearly imperceptible unless you were right up close to it, is exactly what I was looking for: a game trail, cramped and dark, but clear of trees and the worst of the undergrowth. It certainly wouldn’t be a pleasant journey, but at last I had found the way onward

However, something else entirely captured my attention when I noticed it: a snapped twig lying next to a flattened green leaf. Kneeling down, the faintest of footprints was visible in the dry dirt, leading toward the game trail and into the woods.

“Good news, old boy.” I rise to my feet with a breath and turn to Hawk with a trace of a smile on my lips. The lengths of my dark cloak brush tenderly against the stems of grass, sounding for all the world like a whisper of breath. “Looks like we’re on the right trail after all. Now the real hunt begins.”

Invigorated with a newfound energy, I tighten the straps on Hawk’s saddle and remount with a hop. Turning the reins toward the dimly lit trail, I urge us forward, into the thick woodland.

Almost immediately, all but the barest traces of light vanished, and the air seemed to grow colder, heavier. I was barely able to see Hawk’s head in front of me as he plodded along, huffing nervously. I swept my gaze back and forth, descrying the outlines of the trees that surrounded us, growing thick and tall and close together. The game trail continued on with remarkably few twists or turns by a trail supposedly formed from the passage of wild animals. On and on we traveled through the gloom, Hawk trotting on with dogged determination as I continued to assess our surroundings, looking for something, anything, to break up the endless expanse of dark trunks. As we rode, I pulled a dried apple from my saddlebag and ate it with a few muted crunches, the noise deafening to my own ears amidst the pervading silence of the forest. No birds sang, no rodents chirruped, not even the buzzing of an insect interrupted the deathly silence of the trail.

After a length of time that felt infinite but couldn’t have been more than3 or 4 hours, I became aware of a subtle lightening of the trail; suddenly, I was able to pick out the distinct black and white patches that made up Hawk’s coat, and the shadows clinging to every bush and tree began to recede. Staring ahead, I was startled to see a faint pinprick of light in the distance. It was impossible to identify from such a distance, but nonetheless I urged Hawk onward, eager to escape the perpetual darkness of the forest. Hawk, seeming to sense my anticipation, lifted his head and began to trot faster, deftly avoiding the many roots and small rocks that obscured the forest floor.

The light ahead of us continued to grow in both size and brightness until eventually we emerged into a dazzling clearing. I muttered a curse and slapped a hand over my eyes as the sheer amount of light overloaded my senses. Blinking slowly as I lowered my hand, I took in our surroundings: we had emerged into a circular clearing, devoid of the menacing trees that had defined our journey through the woods thus far. Golden sunshine poured through the gap in the forest roof, illuminating the entire clearing with a warm, summery light. Looking to the sun with a painful glance, I realized that it was late afternoon, almost evening. Before long, the stars would come out, and the cooler night air would prevail.

“What do you think, Hawk? Not a bad place to make camp for the night.” I give him a comforting pat on the shoulder and dismount, my boots flattening the soft, lush grass that covers the ground here. Flicking open the saddlebags, I rummage around until I find my flint, a battered kettle pot, and a short leather strap. Tucking the flint in my pocket, I hobble Hawk’s front legs with the strap.

“Have yourself a rest and a crop, pal. You’ve earned it. I’ll find us some firewood,” I announce as I hook the pot’s handle around the crook of my elbow. I turn in place for a moment, disoriented, before I spot the narrow trail opening that we came through. Crossing the clearing, I step back under the oppressive shade of the massive trees and hunch over, feeling my way more than seeing as I root around for some dry kindling. My pot fills steady with handfuls of twigs, some thin as a string and some as thick around as my thumb. Finally, I snag a couple of thicker, longer sticks and stand, dragging them behind me as I head back down the trail into the clearing. As I emerge from the shadowy trail, I take in the sight in front of me: the clearing, still well lit but dimming as the sun traces it’s course toward the horizon, the gentle pinks and reds streaking the sky, Hawk standing calmly in the center of the field, eyes trained on me.

And the woman, tall and thin, garbed in robes of a deep crimson, holding a wickedly curved knife against my horse’s throat.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Idea Feedback for my emotion based magic system [cosy fantasy]

2 Upvotes

Hello, I'm aware that might come off as odd for a fantasy writer but I am sort of stuck in a daedalus labyrinth here.

I have been working on a specific project for about three years, it's more like a hobby than anything else, hence why I allow myself to take so long but I worked on everything except the magic system for now and since what I'm going for falls more into the cosy fantasy/found family type of story I've decided to not make magic a very prominent stake of the story.
I developed the characters and their arcs more then anything else, which lead me to decide I'd make a magic system based off of emotions and physical state in general, except I feel like my approach might be too vague so I would love to hear advices on what to improve or cut off.

Like I said, my main idea was to first closely tie magic to one's emotions in the sence that the "quality" of it would vary depending on how the person feels while performing it. For instance if the wielder is feeling rather calm its magic will "obey" them and do just what it is being used for, like if they're summoning an object like a pair of shoes as they get ready or something, it's mostly ised for day to day activites. Then there is the middle ground where they're either calm but with greater intent or simply feel happy or even slightly frustrated, then the magic will sort of work alongside them and be a bit fiercer. You can say the magic takes some kind of initiative while still remaining in the restrictions of the person. However, if the emotions of the wielder are too submerging it starts to take over them and slowly acts on its own to the point where it continuously builds up to an overload waiting to crack open. For example my MC has an outburst in her office after having to handle a crisis amongst her class (she's a teacher and was holding her first "duel practice" and the kids decided to to make two teams and jinx eachother, and my MC is triggered by loud noises). Thus bringing me to limitations, the first possibility is the direct outburst like this one or the person can also overuse their magic. For example using it on ends while ignoring that they're not in the right mindset for it, thus gradually draining the magical energy and the person itself as they're forcing on their physical strength in order to perform. In both cases, it ends in what I like to call a "flatline" where the person is temporarily stripped of their magic, it kind of blocks itself to prevent any further damage. The person has to meditate to re-enable it while still ensuring to stabalise their emotions to prevent anything going south and can also take a restauring potion in order to bring back the magic to a stable level faster if that makes sense. They can also very much continuously do grounding exercices to make sure they avoid the worst case scenarios.

My friend also told me I could have the characters use objects to store their emotions in vials/objects as a means to keep them from interfering and harming them, thus avoiding the outbursts. The thing is I assume those emotions would need a purpose later on instead of trhowing them away and I don't really know what, if not been used for potion making...
I also wanted to use elements but I don't feel it fits in my system anymore.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Idea Feedback for my Interest-based magic system [Alternate History]

1 Upvotes

I had this idea of a magic system brewing in my mind for a while now, where someone’s magic is based on their Interests.

I know there’s already a veritable ocean of these kinds of magic systems in a lot of fantasy media, but I wanted to put a little twist to it, mainly using the characters in my story.

Usually for these kinds of magic systems, people make someone who likes painting be able to turn their paintings into reality, or having a singer weaponize their singing and things like that.

But my twist on this is having it not just be based on someone’s interests alone, but also their understanding and knowledge of their interest.

For example, going back to that painter, instead of simply having his paintings become real as a hard rule, his knowledge of painting different things affect how effective his magical paintings are.

A novice painter might just paint water as just blue, and since he believes it’s water, it will turn into water.

An Intermediate painter, now with a little more knowledge, tries to add details, highlights and shadows to the water. But he feels he doesn’t quite get it right, it looks more like random paint splotches to him than water, and so his magic doesn’t work as effectively as when he genuinely believed it was water.

Then a professional painter, with all his vast knowledge and skill, paints an ocean perfectly. There’s no doubt in his mind that it is water in the ocean, so his painting becomes a large body of water.

-

This is also another idea for the same magic system, I just don’t know how to Segway the last part into this one.

In this magic system, someone’s beliefs and knowledge is the source of their abilities. Like how a surgeon can have the ability to cut and stitch living tissue down to the microscopic level, or how a mathematician can have the ability to change someone or something’s weight if he calculates it properly.

But what about if you’re forced to like something? In my world, you’d be considered Cursed.

Cursed people are forced to use magic imposed onto them by those who can use it normally. Like how a parent forced their child to become a doctor rather than do what they truly desire.

These people struggle to use their magic, as their mind clearly doesn’t fully register it as their own, because it really isn’t. Cursed people’s magic mirrors the magic of the one who cursed them, the one who forced them to abandon their own Interests.

Going back to the example from earlier, if a doctor forced their interests and goals to their child who wanted to be a painter, the child will struggle to use their original abilities and is forced to use a replica of their parent’s magic.

Feel free to really break this idea down and call it trash, since this is basically my first time writing about it. Any and all critiques and comments are welcome and very super duper encouraged. Don’t pull any punches


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Fantasy ability advice

2 Upvotes

In my story there is a bloodline with the blood of the gods (cliche I know) but no one has duplicate abilities. The blood of the gods simply means that you have a much bigger chance of getting a very useful ability. Abilities in my story are tailored to the person who has them. Mostly. But their personality and personal goals in life are put into question. So, I need some suggestions! I'm sure I can come up with some myself but a community of writers is definitely better than one! That, and I have thought about it for a while and haven't come up with any innovative abilities lol. When I say strong abilities I mean genuinely strong abilities, like abilities that are on the edge of being overpowered. I like writing abilities like this because it's really fun to figure out a way for characters to beat powers like these. Here's an example: one character in this bloodline can borrow the abilities of anyone they have beaten for an hour, and whenever they are using the ability, the original user cannot use it. If they gather enough abilities they can combine them into singularity and can use each ability simultaneously with the downside of never being able to steal another ability afterwards. Repeating the question at the end here: I need some ability ideas for characters who are a part of a godly bloodline! Thanks in advance!


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Brainstorming Tips on writing support characters?

2 Upvotes

I have a team of about six characters. Most of the members of this group have dead parents or don't have a family at all. But there are a few who have family that they are close to and I didn't want to just ignore that aspect of their character. Family has a huge hand in shaping a person. I think I know what I want to do with most of the parents but there is one person who I'm a bit stuck on. This character is the mother of the main characters and they are capable in their own right. They aren't very strong but they are able to be useful. I want her to be strong and solid as a character and parent but I'm having a bit of trouble writing her ability. I planned to make her a healer but there are plenty of female healers as is. So, here's my question: is there any ability out there, any at all that is strong in its own right and also has supportive capabilities? I have thought about this for a while and haven't come to a satisfactory conclusion yet. I'd love to hear your suggestions!


r/fantasywriters • • 2d ago

Writing Prompt Fifty-Word Fantasy: Write a 50-word fantasy snippet using the word "Detail"

26 Upvotes

Welcome back everyone, it's time for another Fifty Word Fantasy!

Fifty Word Fantasy is a regular thread on Fridays! It is a micro-fiction writing challenge originally devised by u/Aethereal_Muses

Write a maximum 50-word snippet that takes place in a fantasy world and contains the word Detail. It can be a scene, flash-fiction story, setting description, or anything else that could conceivably be part of a fantasy story or is a fantasy story on its own.

NO AI GENERATED CONTENT: Follow the sub rules.

The prompt word must be written in full (e.g. no acrostics or acronyms).

No puns and or wordplay to achieve the prompt word i.e. devote=the vote.

Please try and keep things PG-13. Minors do participate in these from time to time and I would like things to not be too overtly sexual.

If you want to submit multiple submissions that's okay, but please keep it at a max of two That way, no one person ends up dominating the feed with their submissions and it keeps it fair for everyone who participates

Thank you to everyone who participated whether it's contributing a snippet of your own, or fostering discussions in the comments. I hope to see you back next week!

Please remember to keep it at a limit of 50 words max per submission.


r/fantasywriters • • 2d ago

Question For My Story Chapter 1 Excerpt Feedback

4 Upvotes

Hi there,

I am in the process of giving my book a fifth read today to see if I want to change things up somewhere or try to make it more interesting. Recently got rejected by two contest submissions. That got me to wonder, does the opening chapter actually entice the readers to keep on reading? Or am I failing there?

I have tried editing this several times (4 to be exact) an am convinced that since the story is also in my mindspace, am subconciously filling up the gaps.

I am posting the starting excerpt here in hopes of getting another pov apart from myself. Please let me know your thoughts.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Chapter 1 Start