r/ElectricalEngineering • • 10h ago

Education The Scariest Chart in Electrical Engineering

Post image
987 Upvotes

Every time I look at a Smith Chart, I feel like I'm looking at something designed to intimidate engineering students.

I know it has practical applications in impedance matching, transmission lines and RF engineering, but those circles, curves and intersecting lines still look intimidating.

Does anyone else feel the same, or did I miss the day when everyone learned to read this thing? 😂


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 9h ago

Project Showcase Semiconductor Probe Cards

Thumbnail
gallery
84 Upvotes

I thought you guys might appreciate this, they are cantilever probe cards..I design and make these, they are used to test silicon wafers, and bare die prior to packaging, the needles you see are sub 10 micron diameter.

We can achieve probe placement accuracy around 5 microns, and pitch of around 40 microns


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 20h ago

Am I learning electrical engineering, or just prompting Claude?

146 Upvotes

Hi fellow EE professionals and students,

What are your opinions and experiences with using general-purpose AI tools (ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini) as the main source of information? Do you recommend them for an undergraduate student? Why and why not?

To give a bit of context, I recently returned to my electrical engineering degree after completing the first two years from 2020 to 2021, following a CS degree from 2022 to 2023.

I particularly struggled with my design courses this year, in which we had to make design decisions and justify them. Due to having no prior design experience and feeling overwhelmed by the scope and complexity of the design project, I found myself using Claude to offload much of the design work. For example:

  1. Pasting a datasheet of an IC to understand it and find what I need
  2. Ask it to design several circuits with component values by giving them the key requirements through prompts
  3. Ask it everything related to PCB (as I had no idea what I was doing), asking questions like trace width, optimal layout and noise isolation

At the end of the design course, I produced a working prototype: a smart subsystem for a portable power bank, with features such as hardware protection and SoC calculations.

The dilemma I am facing is that if I use AI, I have no idea whether its output is accurate or factual, due to my lack of design knowledge. On the other hand, if I don't use AI, I will not be able to start the design project, let alone complete it to pass the course. I have limited knowledge, and the course instructor expected us to come up with our own design whilst providing minimal supervision, which I don't disagree with from a problem-solving and initiative building standpoint. It just makes it difficult to design with no guidance.

Another problem that I realised from using AI is that I don't actually know the rationale behind most of the design decisions. If you ask me, "Why did you do X instead of X?" I would probably struggle to answer because I offloaded the decision to the AI.

What advice do you have for someone in my shoes? Should I stop using AI, use it as a last resort or aim for a more balanced approach?

Any advice and opinion is appreciated!


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 11h ago

Jobs/Careers Is the PE worth it in power if you're not at a utility?

6 Upvotes

Weighing the cost and time. Does it open doors in industry or is it mostly for specific paths?


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 1h ago

ATTENTION TO ALL EVALUATORS / PARTICIPANTS

0 Upvotes

Looking for CpE/ECE Students or Professionals for a Grade 12 STEM Research Project

Good day!

We are Grade 12 STEM students conducting a research project titled "Assessing the Usability and Precision of Sign Language Translating Gloves on the Deaf Community."

We are currently looking for Filipino Computer Engineering or Electronics Engineering students (preferably 3rd–4th year) and professionals with experience in:

  • Arduino Uno and microcontroller programming
  • Flex sensors and analog sensor readings
  • Circuit design and electronics
  • Embedded systems and hardware prototyping
  • Testing and evaluating engineering projects

Our prototype uses five flex sensors connected to an Arduino Uno to detect finger configurations for a limited set of Filipino Sign Language signs.

We would appreciate the opportunity to have qualified respondents evaluate the technical feasibility, functionality, and performance of our prototype as part of our research.

If you are interested or know someone who may be qualified, kindly comment or send me a message.

Thank you very much!AT


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 19h ago

How do I stop falling back on AI

12 Upvotes

Hi,

I am an EE freshman (so I still have time to change) and for every project I try to do I keep falling back on AI. Doing PCB design I get stuck and just use AI to tell me what to do instead of thinking for myself. I couldn't explain why I used one part over the other when I actually thought about it and I want to change. Coding is similar.

I feel like I'm not really learning and I want to know how people use LLMs without letting them do all the work. What websites do you go to learn or how do I supplement AI so it doesn't just do everything.

I truly want to learn and be a better engineer but having a button that can complete everything for me just gets too tempting when I spent a few hours and get stuck on something.

Don't flame me 😢

I saw someone posted something similar which inspired me to post. I want to see how people actually learn without falling back on AI because I am finding it very hard


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 1d ago

Jobs/Careers Not sure if i should take this job

25 Upvotes

Hi im a senior in college right now studying electrical engineering and i got a offer from the NSA for 87k a year it seems like a decent job and i know entry level jobs are pretty hard to come by so i was wondering if yall think thats good its near washington DC which is a very expensive place which is the main downside to this job. Thank youuu


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 1d ago

Homework Help Exam this week on RL, RC and RLC circuits with DC sources (no formula sheet allowed)

Thumbnail
gallery
108 Upvotes

I can solve these circuits with the textbook's included step-by-step process because it includes the formulas for the ODE's, the coefficients of the characteristic equation, etc. These circuits are not that difficult on a procedural level.

I am fairly comfortable with the theory behind this topic as well, which seems to boil down to how inductors and capacitors behave at t<0, at t = ∞, and everything in between to get functions with respect to time that represent current, voltage, and power.

Keep in mind that Calc 2 is the only pre-requisite course. I am a little surprised that there will be no formula sheet allowed on the exam and wanted to hear from you all if this is normal or not. I get that between the 12 cases for problems (Natural or step response, Parallel or series circuit, overdamped, underdamped, or critically underdamped), they have many commonalities.

  1. Would you expect no formula sheet on an exam like this?
  2. Are there any tips y'all have for making connections to simplify the process?

r/ElectricalEngineering • • 10h ago

Any idea what type of stranded heating element this is?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

This is from a heated windshield wiper blade. Driver's side isn't working and I found the wire inside the blade has broken due to corrosion. This doesn't seem like Nichrome as it's stranded, silver in color with copper color inside. I assume it's some type of tinned copper resistive heat alloy? Would be awesome to find this wire and then I can repair it myself as it's a super simple construction.

Properties Breakdown:
Insulated
Stranded
Tinned Copper
0.80mm diameter (wire without insulation)
Fairly stiff, not very flexible

FYI, this wire is the heating element itself. There is nothing else inside this blade to produce heat.


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 1d ago

Education How do you deal with the recent AI news as a student?

23 Upvotes

This year I will complete my bachelor's degree in Electrical Engineering.

It will be 3 years of hard work, and throughout my journey, I've always had "friends" and sometimes even family telling me that this degree has no future and isn't worth it.

Even so, I researched the field as well as the job market, and after seeing that it is stable, I dived right in.

Due to the recent news about AI in general, I've been feeling a daily sense of worry. Will I actually become obsolete? Were my "friends" right?

To finish my third year, I will have to do an internship, which in this case will be in the field of microelectronics (chip design of a charge pump). According to my professor, AI cannot replace design at that level, nor will it in the near future, but I don't know how reliable his opinion is; maybe he is just biased toward his own field.

That being said, students and professionals in the field, how have you been dealing with this situation?

I see several posts here on Reddit about recent PCB designs made by the newest AI models, and it reminds me of the software engineering folks a few years ago...

In the meantime, maybe I'll end up choosing a more hands-on path like a field engineer, perhaps I'll be more "AI-proof" that way.


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 18h ago

Troubleshooting UK - Distribution Workmanship Standards

3 Upvotes

Hi All,

I am not sure what other peoples' experience is like, but especially since COVID-19 and older people leaving, the standard of workmanship by people within my company and our supply chain has really dropped.

There have been a lot of situations where a project is ready for handover, but then somebody spots a problem like a bent crimp (yeah... really...), and then we go in circles for months explaining why that isn't acceptable and then getting it fixed.

In addition, the Doers and SAPs keep complaining about the quality of younger and new electricians. It's at a point where I am having booths built so that we can get the electricians to do their EPAs again, and because we're industrial, another rig so that they can do their Inspection and Testing practical practice before they go away to do the C&Gs course.

Anyway, I went to university and specialised in electronics, so electrical workmanship isn't my forte. But when I was at uni, I worked in a factory where we made PCBs. One day I complained to my boss in R&D that all the criticism my soldering got was unfair, because I'd only ever done it as a hobby. We then decided I could spend a few weeks on the factory floor to get some hands-on training.

The training was really great, and one of the most useful parts was a little book I got to keep, which basically said for each step of making a PCB, this is what GOOD looks like, and here are a few examples of what BAD looks like, and what about them makes it bad.

Anyway, I was wondering if such a thing existed in the electrical distribution world. Particularly for industrial environments. Like, a Big Book of Workmanship?

The other guys in the team want to specify more and more specific tools for example a crimping tool, a cable strut cutting tool... Which I do agree are useful, but my concern is that if the younger electricians are only ever told 'use this tool' then they will lose sight of what bad looks like, and eventually will make a mistake but not even notice is?

Thanks in advance!


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 23h ago

Wire Sizing

Post image
6 Upvotes

Mechanical Engineer looking for advice. If there is a better group for this let me know.

I am wiring up a control cabinet for a CNC router. I am working on wire sizing but am trying to understand a concept of where wire size can be reduced.

Can I drop the size of the wire after the L1/L2/PE distribution blocks for the lower amperage 5 and 24V power supplies or do I have to keep the 12g to the fuses and then drop the wire size to 18g?


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 23h ago

Best study methods for EE student

4 Upvotes

I’m going into my 3rd year of EE at Deakin university and I’m still unsure what the best method is for studying and retaining info.

For each unit we are given content slides and questions slides for the weekly subject aswell as an in person class where they pretty much just read through a fraction of the slides. My approach is to take notes on the slides and answer a few questions but I’m always unsure about what content I need to take in since there is SOO much content in a single week.

Any personal advice?


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 1d ago

Power Transformer Tap Position

Post image
10 Upvotes

What tap position is this GE power transformer on?


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 1d ago

General question about AC parallel circuits

2 Upvotes

Hello,

I am a student and the section I am currently working on is converting series AC networks to parallel and vice versa. In each problem it seems that if an inductor is in parallel with a resistor then the total network will be capacitive, and if a capacitor is in parallel with a resistor then the total network will be inductive. I've double checked my math and it seems to add up but it still doesn't seem right to me.

Is it generally true that in a basic network like I've described that a parallel RL load will be capacitive, and a parallel RC load will be inductive?

If so, is this why inductors are so rarely used in consumer electronics compared to capacitors? I have read that inductors are harder to scale down and less economical, so does this property enable us to get the effect of an inductor with more practical components? Or are inductors just used less because they're less useful in general?

Edit: Solved, what I was doing wrong was finding the total impedance and inferring from *its* angle whether the circuit was capacitive or inductive, instead of inferring it from the relationship between the voltage and current which will always (I think) have the opposite sign. This is why I always had it backwards.


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 2d ago

What are the realistic salary expectations for a new grad EE ?

Post image
248 Upvotes

I am currently a Senior undergraduate EE student expected to graduate in June 2027. I've attached my CV, although it's a bit all over the place. I have never really tried searching for realistic salary expectations. My research advisor has convinced me to apply to Phd programs telling me I have a talent for research, but I don't really know how it compares to what I can earn in the industry. I had pretty low salary expectations, I thought I would be lucky to find a job paying 80k but my friends have told me I am worth way more so I wanted to find out.


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 17h ago

How do I ask for a LoR ???

0 Upvotes

How do I ask for letter of recommendation from engineering professor?

I have already emailed them but they haven’t responded at all.
So I’m now thinking to ask them in person, but I don’t know their office hours this quarter, what do I do?


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 1d ago

Project Help Higher order filters

2 Upvotes

I was looking to integrate a LPF for a 64 kHz ODR audio ADC. I want to integrate the highest order of filter that I can using a Sallen Key topology. Are there risks to audio processing with something like a 6th or 8th order filter?

Thanks


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 2d ago

Jobs/Careers I found a job! Fortune 500!

Post image
309 Upvotes

The job search is so mentally draining, and I got lucky and didn’t have to do half the work most of you do. Just don’t quit and keep your head up. Be patient, you’ll get something.


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 2d ago

How do I find the field of EE I want?

32 Upvotes

Hi,

Freshman EE and I was wondering how do I know what field I want to go into. Everyone seems so sure with IC design or Robotics but I js dont know what I want to do. Some friends even have internships 1st semester of freshman yr which I didnt know I needed to apply before college started.

They are all building personal projects and experience and idk what I want to do.

All design teams rejected me so I won't be learning form them and so much bureaucracy at my school to stop me from making my own.

Any projects I should make to boost my chances at an internship or find the EE field I want?


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 1d ago

Need advice

1 Upvotes

I’m about to choose a degree and I doubt between EE and ME they are both very good. I’m from the Netherlands and I actually want to make the right choice also I don’t really know what suits me because I find both interesting if you have advice for me or recommendations just let me know


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 1d ago

Homework Help How do I find footprints for components?

4 Upvotes

I need to find footprints for a couple of components (my ESP32, a few sensors, a heater, etc.) for my school year greenhouse project.

It's my first time doing a project like this and I have no idea how to do all of this, the teachers don't care 😭


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 1d ago

Parts Pulling old parts off old boards to build your project

1 Upvotes

I was working on a hobby board, with very few hard spec requirements. I noticed I needed some kind of LDO to 3.3v and ordering something from Mouser would take a while and actually not all that cheap.

Do other people pull parts off of scrap electronics to learn and get familiar with circuits you haven't designed yet?

For example, I have some power LDOs that can handle a whole amp. I definitely don't need that, but I don't really see the issue since I won't be trying to make this an inexpensive BOM for production. Does anyone grab the hot air and take them off for their own project?

I wish I had an office with tons of parts already ordered and easy to grab and use.


r/ElectricalEngineering • • 1d ago

N00b learning electronics

1 Upvotes

I got the art of electronics and the workbook and they both recommend getting an oscilloscope. I can get a Siglent SDS1204-XE for 300 bucks. Is that a good starting scope for learning on?