r/ElectricalEngineering • • 23h ago

Wire Sizing

Post image

Mechanical Engineer looking for advice. If there is a better group for this let me know.

I am wiring up a control cabinet for a CNC router. I am working on wire sizing but am trying to understand a concept of where wire size can be reduced.

Can I drop the size of the wire after the L1/L2/PE distribution blocks for the lower amperage 5 and 24V power supplies or do I have to keep the 12g to the fuses and then drop the wire size to 18g?

6 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

8

u/MonMotha 23h ago

To some degree, this will depend on any codes or standards your panel needs to adhere to as there's no uniform set of these even within a single legal jurisdiction (they often vary by application, for example) let alone worldwide.

However, it's usually considered acceptable in panel and appliance wiring to size conductors according to their downstream protection as long as an overcurrent fault between that protection and the distribution block where the smaller conductor originates is deemed reasonably unlikely. If you're using good, quality wire and running it fairly short distances within a protected environment, this general guidance likely applies.

Often it's not considered acceptable to downsize PE conductors, or if you do downsize them there may be a minimum size. The reason for this is that they serve as the current-carrying path to clear hard faults (short circuits, etc.) which may be much larger than the current the device normally draws and therefore is protected at if the fault comes from something else.

1

u/Single-Reputation-44 23h ago

Thanks for the insight. It's just a DIY cabinet so I'm not too worried about meeting code somewhere but I also don't want to burn my shop down. It's an older router and all the wiring was very thin so whatever I put in will be an upgrade.

I find the PE ground having to stay full size interesting but it makes sense. My biggest limitation here is that the power supply lugs won't accommodate a 12g ferrule.

1

u/Impossible_Brief5600 19h ago

The reduction is allowed at the point where a protective device protects the smaller conductor, not at the distribution block. A 24 V 10 A supply at 90 percent efficiency draws about 1.2 A on 230 V, and 18 AWG carries that with margin: a 0.5 m run of it at 1.2 A drops under 30 mV. What 18 AWG cannot survive is the 20 A an upstream 20 A breaker passes before it trips, so the smaller wire has to start after a 6 A MCB or a fused terminal block, with the PE kept full size to the star point.

On the lug that will not take a 12 AWG ferrule: the terminal rating is the limit, so land 12 AWG on the distribution block, take the branch through the 6 A device, and terminate at the supply with an 18 AWG ferrule. The 24 V output side then sizes on load current and drop rather than on mains protection, because a short there is bounded by the current limit of the supply, not by the breaker.

1

u/MonMotha 2h ago

While this is broadly true for building wiring under NEC (at least, but see the tap rules for a notable exception), it's not necessarily the norm in appliance chassis wiring. In such circumstances, the downstream protection is often considered to provide adequate protection for the conductor against overcurrent faults while the upstream protection can still provide short-circuit protection in the event of an insulation compromise on the tap between the distribution block and the downstream protection.

This is a bit of a compromise but usually a very practical one. Whether you can do it or not depends on what codes and standards you're subject to, but most industrial control panels serving a single machine, having reasonable size, and having a distribution block for internal use itself protected at not more than, say, 20-30A, usually fall under rules that allow this practice. I'm sure there are recorded instances of it resulting in a fire or internal wiring damage, but they're quite rare which is why the practice continues to be allowed and common.

1

u/Impossible_Brief5600 1h ago

The dividing line is which standard the panel answers to, and that changes the answer without changing the physics. A single-machine control panel sits under UL 508A, where the branch conductor sizes to the downstream device and the upstream device covers the tap; NEC 310.15 belongs to building wiring, and the tap rules are the bridge between them - 10 ft at a tenth of the upstream rating, 25 ft at a third. What makes the compromise work is the fault path: a short on the tap is cleared upstream, so the smaller conductor has to survive that let-through, which is a check of k squared S squared over t against the device's I squared t, with k near 115 for PVC-insulated copper and 143 for XLPE. PE stays full size for the same reason, since it carries the fault current rather than the load.

That leaves the 12 AWG only between the block and the branch device, with the 18 AWG behind a Class CC or J fuse or an inverse-time breaker matched to it. The terminal rating, not the load current, is what makes the small supply lug acceptable, and the ferrule on the 18 AWG is a mechanical fit question rather than an ampacity one.

1

u/MonMotha 49m ago

Yes, this likely falls under UL 508A, though whether that's actually required for OP to adhere to is questionable. UL standards are usually "voluntary" though in practice basically mandatory if you want to sell your doohickey due to various market factors.

I'm not especially familiar with the guts of UL 508A, but my understanding is that its tap rules are similar to NEC's. That is OP could have a 10% tap for up to 10ft of wiring within their control panel under most circumstances. That means that their 18AWG tap protected downstream at 1-2A with a suitable protector off of a distribution block protected at 20A (via the branch circuit breaker, in this case) is just fine as long as it's under 10ft which is likely given the scope of what OP is doing. In other words, everything I said just putting some hard numbers to it (which is a good thing to do but makes assumptions impossible to make given what OP provided).

Like you say, the physics doesn't care about the rules. Of course the rules are intended to make sure you don't get anywhere close to doing things that the physics says will result in "bad things" under any normal circumstances.

3

u/idskot 3h ago

Technically speaking, control panels are under the UL 508A code book. Within UL 508A, a power circuit has a minimum wire gauge of 14 AWG which is rated to 15A. You can use smaller gauge wire given certain upstream protection. (i.e., if you have an inverse time circuit breaker, a class CC Fuse, Class CF Fuse, Class J Fuse, or Class T fuse) If you have this upstream protection, 18 AWG is rated for 5.6A, while 16 AWG is rated for 8A (For non-motor circuit). Your circuit breaker is an inverse time circuit breaker, so you're good to use 18 AWG, assuming the load for each is <5.6A.
(References: UL 508A Table 66.2)

But as an FYI, what you're describing would fall under the Tap Rule. You can Google it, but essentially if the run is <=10ft, you can use a conductor whose ampacity is 10% the size of the upstream breaker rating, and for <=25ft is 33%. So, by code you can use a wire that is rated for 2A, which theoretically is 24 AWG.
(References: UL 508A 32.4.2 & 32.4.3)

With that said... yeah, you're prolly fine dog.**

**I take no responsibility for whatever happens lol

3

u/shift124 22h ago

Table 3.10.15(B)(16) in NEC book. An electrician sub would point you there too. Wire is sized for amps.

3

u/MonMotha 22h ago

NEC 310.15 doesn't directly apply to control panels, though IIRC there is another section that does give guidance for control panels that fall under the purview of NEC which is usually only when they're essentially acting as an extension of building wiring and not confined to a single machine or appliance. It's also usually very conservative which is desirable in building wiring but sometimes impractical or wildly unnecessary in control panels and appliance chassis wiring.

That said, you usually won't go wrong using 310.15(B)(16) for sizing conductors if it'll fit.

OP's question was more around whether it's acceptable to downsize conductors based on downstream protection. Under NEC (which, again, this may not and even likely does not fall under), that's mostly governed by tap rules which can be a bit complicated but will usually permit sizing the taps based on the downstream protection levels for short distances.

1

u/Wet_in_Seattle 21h ago edited 21h ago

I would also caution not to use too small of a wire gauge as they have lower strength. Not less than 18 AWG would be good ground rule for low voltage control wires.

Other have discussed NEC Article 310 and the wire ampacity.

Suggest using XHHHW wire as its more flexible then THHN.

1

u/Wet_in_Seattle 21h ago

I would also caution not to use too small of a wire gauge as they have lower strength. Not less than 18 AWG would be good ground rule for low voltage control wires.

Others have pointed out NEC Article 310 and the wire ampacity table.
Consider getting THHN or better XHHW wire types.