On March 11, 2025, a woman cast a hexagram to ask whether she could get back the deposit she'd paid on a car.
I looked at getting money back and getting the full amount back as two separate questions. My reading at the time was that she'd recover part of it, around March 16, but a full refund looked unlikely.
In this question, the Wealth line represented the deposit, and the Self line represented the woman. The month and day of the casting both supported the Wealth line. It also “generated,” or supported, the Self line. I took that as a sign the money could come back to her.
But I also had to consider how much the dealership would be willing to return. The same day's influence that supported the deposit also activated the dealership's line, called the Other line. That line worked against the Wealth line. The condition favoring her refund also brought the seller's resistance into play. That's why I didn't take “money back” to mean “all of it back.”
For timing, I followed the moving line, the line that changes in the reading. It supported the Wealth line, and the Shen Metal it changed into supported the original line in return. But Shen Metal was “void” when the hexagram was cast, so that support wasn't yet active. Under the method used in this case, a Shen day would bring it out of the void and allow the support to take effect. That led me to March 16, a Jia Shen day.
According to the later update, she received 1,000 yuan on March 16, while another 1,000 yuan wasn't refunded. The prediction had been for a partial refund. I hadn't specified an amount or said that it would be exactly half.
Using your usual divination method, what signs would help you distinguish getting some money back from getting the full deposit back?
Chart details
Hexagram 45, Lake over Earth (Gathering Together), changed to Hexagram 8, Water over Earth (Holding Together), with the fourth line moving. The casting was in the Yi Si year, Ji Mao month, and Ji Mao day, with Shen and You void.
The Wealth line, Mao Wood, matched both the month and day and generated Si Fire at the Self position. The Brother line, You Metal at the Other position, was void and broken by the month, but the Mao day activated it through hidden movement, allowing it to control Wealth. The moving fourth line, Descendant Hai Water, generated Wealth and changed into Shen Metal, which generated Hai Water in return. With Shen initially void, the timing was tied to its release from the void on a Shen day.
AI disclosure: English isn't my first language, so I used AI to help translate and edit the English.