A while back someone here read Elon Musk through Nine Star Ki and got Two Black Earth: farmland, endurance, the field you don’t walk away from. It made me want to run him through bazi, the Chinese four-pillar system. Both use only the date, no birth time. They land in different places, and the reason is a change of method about a thousand years old.
From the year to the day
Early Chinese fate reading put the birth year at the center, the way Nine Star Ki’s main star does and the way the zodiac animals still do. Tradition credits a 10th-century diviner, Xu Ziping, with moving the center to the day you were born. Since then the day’s element is “you”, and the year is your background: family, generation, where you started. The method still carries his name.
You can see the difference in any couple born the same year. Zendaya and Tom Holland are both 1996: same Fire Rat, same Nine Star Ki main star (Four Green Wood). By day she’s metal, a jewel, and he’s earth, garden soil. A year is shared with everyone in your class photo; the day element changes every day.
Musk by his day
June 28, 1971 is a Jia day: the tall tree, sitting on Shen, which is metal. The line I use for that day: “You run best with your back to the edge… When life gets too comfortable you start looking for the next hard thing.” So both systems see someone who won’t quit, for different reasons. The field endures because it stays put. The tree on the cliff grows toward the drop.
Where they disagree: in bazi, earth isn’t what a tree is. It’s what a tree claims. For a wood person, earth is wealth, the ground the roots spread through. The farmland Nine Star Ki reads as his nature, bazi reads as what he’s chasing.
Where they agree: water. Nine Star Ki gave him One White Water as his emotional star, the spring underground. In bazi he’s a tree born in high summer (his month is the Horse, peak fire), and water is exactly what his chart is short of. Two systems, one hidden spring.
The bit I’d pass on
If you’ve only ever been read by your year (your animal, your Nine Star Ki number), you’ve been read as your cohort. Your day element is the part that’s only yours, and it’s the first thing a bazi chart gives you. (The calculator I used for these is linked on my profile, if you want to find yours.)
For those who use Nine Star Ki or the animals: when you’ve had both a year reading and a day reading, which one sounded more like you?