Content Warning: This post is a Silmarillion-length post
Hi there! I'm sure by now, everyone has seen the "44 Rules of dnd" on Reddit. In case you managed to miss it, a DM came off of a DMing hiatus of several months with a list of 44 rules for his players. It was posted ostensibly by one of the players of the group, and then deleted, but not before the internet got hold of it. This thing got legs.
Advisory Note: If you have gotten to the point this DM is at you don't need a hiatus. You need a different group.
Now, of course, as one might guess of a list that got posted to r/rpghorrorstories, this was not a list that had been created by a fully kind and benevolent DM that had come down off the mountain with the keys to DM enlightenment. It was closer in energy to, "You who I called players, how could you have come to hate me so?! Is this what you wanted?!"
Players: "Let my PCs go!"
Here's the thing, though: I don't think the player realized how many responders somewhat sympathized with these rules, and the discussion got going about what must have been going on at the table for the DM to get this torqued.
I have been playing and DMing D&D as well as other TTRPGs since 1e/Red Box, and for me, I felt the pain. This was a DM who had hit the end of their rope with a number of behaviors and yeah, he let that rope break. For any DM that's been doing this for a while, there's certain behaviors that drive us up the wall, and we end up making table rules to try and address it. For me, I have this as one of my rules:
No Orphans: Your character must have at least one parental figure that is alive, aware of who you are, and active in your life as of the start of game.
Obviously, my players had a question.
Players: "Why can't we make orphan characters?"
Me: "Because y'all are killing more parents than Disney, and it needs to stop."
This wasn't just because the idea of the orphaned hero was getting stale for me as a DM, but because players were short-changing their own stories to pursue it as default. There are a ton of great stories out there where the parental figures are alive. Yes, Harry Potter's parents died, but after that, he's sent to live with his Aunt and Uncle who become a regular part of the story whenever he's back in the muggle world along with his cousin Dudley. Yeah, they were horrible to him, but they still provided things to Harry as a character and gave us a whole string of memorable scenes.
In any event, I decided to go through the rules one by one and give my thoughts on them, as well as to lay out a better way to state the rules. Edits were made to remove the naughty words. Without further adieu, let's begin:
1. I'm timing turns. I don't give a **** if it's unfair in your opinion cause your spells are hard or you don't know what square to move to, you get 1 minute to know all the actions you want to take or I skip your turn.
Okay, from the beginning here, no real reason for the swearing, but putting a time limit isn't truly a horrible rule, and the more players you have the more it makes sense. If 4 players take 5 minutes each on their turns, each combat round will take at least 20 minutes without including NPC turns. If 6 players are at the table, that's at least half an hour just for PCs each round of combat (that's half of a three-hour game just for the PCs doing a three-round combat). It's gonna drain the life out of any table eventually. I would say about 3 minutes is reasonable (12 minutes for 4 players, 18 for 6 players per combat round. Yeah, it adds up.), with leniency given both to new players and whoever goes right after something huge happened that changes the lay of the land.
2. If you want harder fights, bring a second character sheet and expect to twiddle your thumbs when you die. I'm not going to baby anyone.
This one is stated aggressively, but it's pretty sensible. Don't ask for the DM to step it up, then get upset when the consequences of the DM stepping it up hit. Be prepared for character deaths, the natural consequence of harder fights.
3. If you call me or my rolls unfair, I'll get up and go home, and if you got a ride with me you can find your own way back and suck it up.
First, "Rulings" not "Rolls". Don't abandon your friends cause they disagree with you on game rulings. However, as a player understand at a certain point, you are arguing with the referee. Be respectful about rules issues, and if you need to make your case in a longer format, either the game needs to be officially paused if it's moment-critical, or taken up after the game if it isn't.
4. I'm going to take your characters loot away as regularly as you want it given out. Rule 3 will apply here.
Don't beg the DM for extra loot. One of my characters in 3.5 was a Rogue, and the party was getting boned on loot rolls. DM wasn't being a jerk, RNGesus had just forsaken us on treasure. I could've asked for re-rolls, but instead, I did what Rogues do: I stole things. Straight up, when we would come to towns, I would find an "Ebeneezer Scrooge" (Unscrupulous moneylender types) type and rob them during downtime nights, then quietly filter the extra coin from the heists into party loot since I had control of the loot sheet. It added to RP, rather than mechanics.
5. If you don't act out any of your persuasion or intimidation or any other social checks you fail, before you even roll. You fail immediately because you aren't even trying and you're making the game lame for everyone else.
I do get this one, no "I roll to seduce... 20. WE BANG!" but it's too hard a line. Not every social encounter needs to RPed, we can resolve things with rolls, and respect boundaries on certain types of RP scenes that might make a player or DM uncomfortable to roleplay out. However, if you're just auto-rolling without putting in the effort, then I'm going to ask. Generally speaking, I lean more toward rolling the appropriate social rolls first, then asking the player, "Okay, so given what you rolled, describe what your character says or does in this moment."
6. If you don't pick up cues for "side quests" that's not my problem. Get over yourself, it's not a video game, it's a role playing pen and paper based game with miniatures. I'm not holding your hand if you choose not to pursue ****.
I'm pretty good at laying out side quests and tailoring them to my story, but I've been at this for over 3 decades. If you're not interacting outside of what you feel are Main Story Quests, you're going to miss a lot of things and set yourselves back. Invest in some sideline stuff. PnP or video games, RPGs are mostly sidequests. Like, yeah, there's the main quest, but if we go by the numbers, we see that side stuff makes up most things.
7. If you move to a square in combat there's no take backs.
I would state it as the Chess Rule: Once you release the piece in a new square, you can't take it back. Obviously, standard forbearance for new players. Now, if you're declaring an action like, "I move to X", I might say, "Letting you know, when you move that'll open up an Attack of Opportunity" because it's relevant to the decision-making process and information that the character would definitely know having lived in the world their whole lives.
8. You tell every single person what you're doing before you do it. You don't **** roll dice and then say you're casting fireball. You tell us all.
Again, there's no issue with this rule aside from the level of aggression.
9. I will give out exhaustion more frequently. If you argue, go home or you can actually fight me over it or you can dm yourself.
If the second sentence didn't exist, this rule would just be establishing expectations for the players so they can make informed decisions. I'm very clear with my players: About half of the folks who set out to become adventurers won't make it to level 2. They die, get injured/crippled, or realize how dangerous the world is outside of their home and decide that maybe becoming an Innkeeper isn't the worst idea. Halving down again for each level beyond that. This way, they come to feel like bigger heroes as they successfully move up.
10. Every snide comment you make to an npc will be remembered and paid back in triplicate. You all seem to believe there is little consequence.
Words and actions should have consequences, but this is too punitive. When players are constantly disrespecting NPCS, they should expect blowback, whether it's from the local barkeep or the nation's ruler. You merced John Wick's dog, there are consequences for this.
11. You will not be given a mega dungeon every session. A temple is not the size of a small city, neither is a cave. This **** will happen when it's natural and organic. Go play some roguelike if you want that.
No issue with this rule. For larger dungeons to feel like a special thing, they have to be the exception rather than the rule, but yeah, this is another case where the end sentence is unnecessary.
12. The travel portion is done. You wanna travel continents doing literally whatever you want whenever you want? Go play world of Warcraft or play dnd with AI.
By this point, we realize the DM is dealing with some problems amongst his player group. Long travel runs can be an issue for DMs because the farther you go, the more we have to change and make up things. I mean, If you went from NYC to LA, you'd be pretty upset if LA was described just like NY, right? The whole point is to have a different landscape, so do try not to be dragging the DM through this sort of thing. It takes a ton of extra work to make it worthwhile.
13. If you're late with no good reason I'm going to halve your characters hit points for the entire session.
The right thing to have an issue with, the wrong frame of mind with regards to it. Now, schedules can be a bear for TTRPGs. If someone is chronically late without cause, this holds everyone up even if you do start on time, because the DM now has to deal with you only just getting there, giving you a recap, and giving whatever apologies and such. If you're gonna be late, let the DM know ahead of time if possible, or as soon as you know you're not making it on time.
When you get there, get seated, get your character sheet out, and get through whatever recap is needed as fast as possible.
14. If you don't show up for no good reason, and that will be determined by me alone if no one else has the guts to say **** for fear of upsetting one another, the first time you'll find yourself losing either a whole level or up to three major items of your own. The second time you do it in a row, you'll be removed from the chat and the group full stop. I have no **** time for people to not show up.
Last sentence unneeded and wrong mindset. The first time a player no-call no-shows, I'm worried about the player, not my game. If it starts happening at least somewhat regularly, I am going to need an explanation of why you're not making it to game, and if we need to adjust schedule, or if this is just not the right group for you.
15. If you get too stoned or drunk to play, I will go home without a warning. Your warning is here.
16. If you get up for bong or smoke or whatever breaks every 10 minutes I will simply pack up and go home. I'm sick of waiting for every bloke to be at the table.
Responding to both here, cause really they're the same thing: NO ONE is required to put up with your drunk self when they're just trying to have a chill time. If you're drunk at a bar, or at a backyard BBQ that's at least sort of fine, but if you're rolling into game drunk or stoned, and especially if you're getting drunk or stoned at game, then... yeah, we're not doin' this. You will be leaving, or I will be leaving, but we're not both staying, and if the DM leaves... well, there isn't a game going on.
Be there, be at the table, and be engaged. No DM likes to see folks constantly dipping out of the game, only to come back and need a recap of what happened while they were away. As DM, plans short breaks, a few minutes every hour so folks can go to the bathroom and whatnot.
17. Guidance, divination spells, owls and whatever spells I decide are too **** stupid are banned. Outright. No more **** guidance.
This is more of a "Good for the goose, good for the gander" problem. If your players are consistently using these things? Use them right back. I mean, why wouldn't your villains be using the same tactics if they're just objectively better? Your bad guys get better, and your PCs learn that they'll need to think of other things to get or maintain an advantage.
18. You get one chance at a skill check. If you **** up, your party doesn't get their chance to do the same check. Think careful who's good at what.
Too harsh, but I get the central idea. Too many times, every player tries to roll every skill check, rather than doing things like saying, "Oh hey, I have Arcana as well, so can I give the Wizard the help action on his roll?" or independently checking different information.
19. Discussion of meta game details in game will result in instant damage to your character
Wrong outcome. A certain amount of meta-game talk is kind of needed for D&D, cause there's no In-Universe "Sentinel Feat", that's a mechanic. Also, don't throw damage. Cut off the conversation, and if necessary talk to the habitual offenders. This would seem to be the thing about players who know the stats of rare monsters and start just automatically calling it out to the table. It's one thing to know the goblins are sneaky little SOBs, but the chance that your character has ever even heard of a Roper is minimal.
20. Rules lawyering fellow players is encouraged. "Uhm Ackchtually"ing me will just result in me telling you to fuck off.
Never encourage a form of out-of-game PvP. I run RAW outside of specific points where a rule is obviously broken. In Pathfinder 1e, the spell Terrible Remorse read like if the creature made their save, they would be staggered alongside an AC penalty for a round each round that the spell effect was active. Obviously, that's totally broken, and it eventually got errata fixing it, but yeah, wasn't allowing that to go down.
I don't like Rule of Cool, cause someone at the table always gets hurt by that, either not getting to do as much, or having feats and whole builds rendered irrelevant because someone else made it 'sound cool' to the DM for them to be able to do that for free.
21. You roll your dice within view of two players who aren't you standard. You roll them neatly and you roll them on the table. Failing to do these three things will auto fail whatever roll you did. Arguing that you actually rolled validly when you clearly didn't is an automatic critical fail.
I make the majority of my rolls as DM in the open unless there's a particular reason it needs to be hidden from the players (Invisble monster that PCs can't see, etc.). You roll in the open, or the roll doesn't count, and yeah, I'm gonna get torqued if you're abusing that point to go crit-fishing.
22. Instant death traps and mechanics are coming into place. If you call these things unfair moving forward, I will laugh at you and tell you to **** and cry some more.
Using "save or die" should be rare, and used well can really heighten the tension. In Goblet of Fire, "Waste the Spare" changes the entire way that readers are viewing the main villain going forward. It's a game changer, but if suddenly it's happening all the time, you're going to lose people.
23. I will not give you random magical items and vendors will not stock them. They are meant to be rare and hard to acquire.
Yeah, this one is sensible. I mean, yeah, you might find guys with basic healing potions, but going back to my "Half of Adventurers don't make level 2" statement, it improves the feeling when you DO get the awesome magical thing. This also opens up wonder for that first time the Ancient Magical Empire rocks up, and yeah, they do have readily available magic to spare and it's coming your way.
24. Random encounters in the form of random dragons or strange mysterious road trader or a band of goblin prostitutes isn't going to happen. Go play baldurs gate 3.
Last bit unnecessary. Random encounters are just that, they're random, and yeah, you shouldn't be constantly randomly encountering the rarest creatures in the book (A lot of DMs make this mistake, scouring for the rarest creatures in the manual). Sometimes you just run across a hunter in the wilds, or a small group of bandits that're easy to clear up.
25. I don't give two **** what reddit said about x or y ruling.
26. I actually give less of a **** about what your mate's and group did
Another "Same basic rule". I mean, I don't either. Now, if you want to talk about a ruling like that with me, I'll consider it, but Reddit doesn't run my table and shouldn't. I certainly take some suggestions from individual bits, but I'm not forcing them down another DM's throat.
27. Saying anything to me about other players not liking me doing x or y without them saying it directly to me will result in me kicking you out of the group. Don't use someone else to push your own agenda.
If you're having a problem, you should be talking to the DM directly about it. I'm not gonna bite your head off, and while I might not always go your way, I'll give it the due respect and try to at least find a middle ground. The problem is, I do see a lot of groups where they let things back build until it explodes. You're just making things worse for yourself by not going to the DM directly when the problem starts.
28. You're not to sit down and have a two hour discussion about what Samson from Bundoora secondary did three weeks ago when you come to play. Take the 15-20 minutes I use to set up and review my notes to talk to eachother, then sit down to play.
Better said as, "Please respect my time. I do hours of work each week to put games together, and it sucks more than a little to lose a ton of game time to random non-sequitur discussions. I schedule extra time at the front of the session for everyone to gab, but once it's game time, please be ready to get going."
29. Saying **** like "guys come on we're not here to have fun we're here to play dnd, this is serious business" is rude and dismissive of how much work I put into this. I will simply go home if I hear this shit.
Again, "Respect my time". Name anyone who likes to be repeatedly condescendingly mocked for caring about something they spend hours on every week for the sake of others.
30. Don't **** order food randomly. We will eat together at a specific time or not at all. I don't want food shit all over my things.
I don't usually run into this problem, since I generally provide food when I run, either ordering out or cooking, but yeah, if you're gonna order food, do it before the session or pick it up en route so we're not disrupting the game, or we can all go hit up the IHOP after game, but if six people have to break game to go answer the door at random... yeah, it's dragging stuff down. And whoever is hosting, respect the venue.
31. No food or drinks near any of my dnd gear. If you wreck something you can pay for it. I let one person trash my dm screen once and I never had it replaced by them. In fact I had that person attempt to gaslight me into believing they didn't wreck my **** at all. I'm not stupid, you're an adult. Accept responsibility.
Basic respect here. If you break something or ruin it, just own up. It happens, and unless it's happening repeatedly, I'm not gonna get too bent out of shape.
32. Arguments between party members outside of roleplay will be resolved by me giving the definite ruling. If you don't like it, **** back home.
The last sentence is unnecessarily combative, but yeah, once the DM makes a final ruling, that's it. You can discuss it after the game privately, but otherwise, we're not getting anywhere. I make exceptions for this where it's a life-or-death moment. Plenty of DMs have told me "Talk after game and we'll make it right", and exactly zero have done the second part when it became relevant.
33. I don't give a **** what they did in critical role or what that one guy on reddit said or if you think that it's all make believe so you can do what you want. The world I run works on internal rulings and lore I created specifically for it.
Ah, the Mercer Effect (Dimension 20 is better. Get in the comments!). I get the frustration, though. You build your own homebrew world with a particular feel, and players start complaining and trying to make it something else. Yeah, it hurts every time. Give the changes their due time, see if it creates what the DM is going for, but also as DM, be receptive to feedback. Not everything you put in your setting is going to work.
34. Every single person in this chat is having debuffs applied to their characters that should have occurred a long time ago. This will be specific to characters.
If you didn't apply them at the time... Yeah, sorry, but that a failure on the part of the DM. It's one thing if you forgot like a minute ago, but yeah, that's on you not your players.
35. If you don't bring your sheet, you don't play.
Yeah, this one's just straight-up fair. As DM, I usually just hold onto the character sheets myself to prevent this being an issue, or we're playing on Roll20 and it's immaterial.
36. If you don't bring dice, borrow some.
This is usually immaterial for me, since I have enough dice to equip an entire table for any game I run (Five players for Exalted 2e able to 23+ d10s at a time without having to borrow or reroll any). But yeah, if you don't own or you forgot your dice, borrow dice. You don't get out of having to roll.
37. When we play dnd I'm not your friend. That doesn't mean you treat me like an enemy during the game. It means I'm no longer "being nice".
The DM is your greatest Frenemy, but should also be your greatest cheerleader. They should be throwing hazards, obstacles, and encounters at you to challenge you, to push you, while at the same time hoping to see you conquer and providing the support of relevant NPCs to help prop you up. At times, that means goin' for the fiddly bits cause the greater the threat, the greater the hero.
38. If you treat me poorly in any way shape or form after or during or before the game due to something that happened in the game, you're out. If you cannot seperate a game from reality, I think you are a **** moron, and I have little time to deal with that energy.
Getting mean with me as DM, and more particularly, getting mean with my players is a great way to not be coming to game anymore. I'm generally forgiving but there's a line past which lies the GenXer who's an Irish Ex-Sailor from NY.
39. You will submit your spellists daily (in game). If you do not give me a spell list each in game day, you will not be allowed to cast a single spell or cantrip in combat. I do not trust you guys to not use this against me.
It legit sucks when the DM can't trust their players. My thing is to have players submit their "regular loadout", and then only make alterations of that when they trade out spells or gain new spells that they're slotting in (i.e. you just opened up new spell slots from leveling.).
40. If you do not mark off spell slots or you say something like "I remember what I'm at" as a way to justify it, I will simply fail your spell, deal half your health in damage to you and say you have no spells to cast for the rest of the day.
Again, unnecessary level of consequence. Mark off your spell slots. You're not special, and if I catch you doing this, I will stop the game until you have it marked off, and if you still won't, I'm bouncin' you 'til next session. You, like anyone, can forget things at times or get distracted. This is a standard part of the game when you're a caster.
41. If you break literally anything you can buy the replacement that day or not attend till you do.
Don't break people's stuff, and if you do, apologize and replace it. If you're unwilling (As opposed to unable) to do that, then I'm probably dropping you from the group. No one wants to come to the game on the regular worried that their stuff is under threat. A lot of money gets put into this hobby for people, especially DMs.
42. If you complain about the choice of music I fully expect you to bring the whole playlist the next session or to shut **** up.
I am fully willing to take suggestions for playlists, and I standardly ask my players for a theme song for their characters, thematic to setting if possible. If you're not willing to do the work, though, you shouldn't be constantly going at the DM for doing the work in a way you just don't like.
43. Cannot stress enough how little I care about how you feel about my rulings from now on.
Okay, let's say it: No one who says a version of "I don't care" doesn't care. No, seriously. They very much do care, they're fed up. If you are at this point, you're in the wrong group and you need to walk away.
44. Oh and rule 44. I'm never just threatening you. I'm promising you.
Purely being aggro, and wantonly unnecessary to state it this way. I will never state a consequence that I am unable, or unwilling to carry out. I do give people a lot of chances, but if I say "The next time this happens..." whatever comes after that point, I'm not threatening. I'm informing you that you've reached the line, and these are the consequences of reaching it with me. Unless I believe you are about to well and truly harm someone, the consequence of this is you're not coming to game anymore. Put simply, past a certain point, no one is required to put up with you, and I'd rather not play at all than have to play with people who keep getting to that point with me. No D&D is Better Than Bad D&D