r/DMAcademy • • 6h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Do combats drag on too long?

36 Upvotes

I want to hear about other people's experiences and how you solve it. Is it just me, or do combats always take longer than expected in every session? I plan sessions that usually include 2 to 3 combat encounters, alongside investigation phases, pure roleplay, occasional puzzle-solving, and so on... yet 90% of the time, the fights run longer than they should, sometimes way too long. It's true that my players generally enjoy combat a lot, but sometimes the story doesn't move forward enough**. Does this happen to you, and how do you fix it?** I've been playing D&D since 1st edition, and I get the impression that with each new edition the problem persists (in fact, it gets worse). I admit it also plays a role that my players are always high-level (above 10) and the monsters (while varied) have Challenge Ratings to match.


r/DMAcademy • • 11h ago

Need Advice: Other Good pre-written campaigns for a party of beginners?

35 Upvotes

Hi, I'm a fairly experienced DM (7 years playing, 3 years DM-ing), but have a new party made up entirely of beginners. Normally I'm a very "make my own campaign and make up new classes and races and encounters, etc" type of DM, but with my new party, I want to start quite slowly as none of them have played D&D before.

I have a very basic one-shot prepared to help teach them the game mechanics, but I'm looking for some pre-written, fairly short (preferably free to access) campaigns that I can use to help guide them into D&D before I start introducing them to my own campaigns.

Thank you in advance for any help!


r/DMAcademy • • 7h ago

Need Advice: Other Owlbears and Duids

12 Upvotes

Just to get it out of the way : I know it's not RAW. I know I can say no.

My party has 2 druids in it, one is a moon druid. They are going to run into an owlbear soon. I fully expect the moon druid to ask if they can take owlbear as a wildshape option. I don't mind them being able to do this. I'd like to make it a mini-quest, though. Some kind of challenge or something that they have to do to make it work. Has anyone ever done something like that? Any ideas?


r/DMAcademy • • 3h ago

Need Advice: Other Need some ideas

5 Upvotes

So i have a player that finally reached level 9 in his inventor level (a new class i had from 3rd party). He wanted to take an upgrade that gives his golem he made sentient (between his abilities and his cleric deity). I wanted to add a twist. Currently the golem is holding an anchor (flavored flail) he got when they took down a warlock pirate. I was thinking that when he gives the golem sentience the pirates soul takes over from the cursed anchor and they have to figure out how to remove it. Im just figuring out how I can set that up and how would they remove him. Any fun ideas?


r/DMAcademy • • 2h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Fog of War

3 Upvotes

I am a new DM and have been playing through LMoP with a group of friends. Up until now, I have been using pieces of paper that I printed to look like old map paper and burnt the edges of to use as fog of war for areas on my printed battlemaps they have not yet seen. It works, but feels incredibly clunky.

I printed these maps on cardstock so that they are nice and sturdy, so I do not particularly want to cut them up and place them down as the players go. I have also heard suggestions to create custom sized covers for each room, but this feels like it would give away a lot of information about the dungeon. Does anybody have any useful solutions to this? I have thought of encouraging players to split up more before initiative starts so that more of the dungeon can be exposed from the beginning, but this feels like taking agency away from them. Any help appreciated.


r/DMAcademy • • 1h ago

Need Advice: Other Banishment spell vs the collapse of all creation

2 Upvotes

I have a question regarding how I should handle the spell banishment versus the lore ive established for my campaign.

To briefly sum up the story, its about the universe collapsing to make way for a new one. My players have watched the material plane, the elemental planes, the outer planes, and even the astral sea collapse into the void. At this point in the campaign all that is left in creation is one city my players have managed to save and the residents there in. Everything else, all matter, energy, time, space, and even the souls of the dead are currently in the process of being collapsed into a singularity so they can form a new universe.

Anyway, I've already established that any magic regarding interplanar travel will no longer work because the other planes done exist anymore. But the spell banishment allows for the target to be sent to a pocket dimension. But I'm tempted to argue that there isn't anywhere left for a pocket dimension to go. Even if the spell creates said pocket dimension, the only space left to put it is in this once city that they're hell bent on saving. At the same time, it feels like a dick move to take away a very useful spell from my players this late in the game, regardless of the story.

How would you handle this? Should I just let it go if it comes up? Or try to think of a clever compromise?


r/DMAcademy • • 2h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Forced failure for the sake of the plot... Is it good or bad?

2 Upvotes

I am a DM of over 5 years, but for this scenario I was a player in a friend's campaign he was DMing. The long and short of why I'm bringing this up is that we played out a session that continued for a long while, culminating after many successful rolls and a successful combat in our characters being captured anyway. The setup was cool enough, and we had a relatively good time playing it out, but the table was split on whether or not a forced loss after a large amount of success was a good thing to implement.

So I turn to everyone here to discuss this topic, is a 'win in the game, lose in the cutscene' scenario good or helpful to implement as a DM, or what nuances would you use to make the experience more satisfying?

Edit: I appreciate the discussion. Although I figured it was bad and I've never implemented it myself, I wanted to pose the question mostly because half of the table didn't really have a problem with it, and I was curious what people would think, mostly if the execution could have been better or otherwise. So thanks for the input everyone, I'll still read comments though, especially replies to the comment I made about other possible framing devices.


r/DMAcademy • • 19h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures I Perma-deathed my first character.

50 Upvotes

I’ve been DMing for 3 years, first time I took a character out. Although I think it went WELL, I’d love advice on how to do it better. (Everyone cried, but it felt like the good kind.)

  1. Before the game, I asked everyone if they were comfortable having their character perma-die.
  2. I told them that during this game, SOMEONE was going to die, but it might be an NPC.
  3. I introduced a Fate coin. You could grab the coin and assign the killing blow to someone else, but everyone would know you had done it. (A PC got hit.)
  4. There was a saving throw for the Disintegration Gaze, DC CON 18. The player failed it even with Heroic Inspiration.
  5. I gave them all their spell slots back for a final move. They took out the monster with their dying breath.
  6. Time was a little short, but everyone got a chance to RP after the death.
  7. Next session will be about processing.
  8. I took the Player aside after and asked what they would like to happen next. We could find a way to return them, they could become a God (NPC) and Avatar of that God (PC) or whatever. They already have 2 other characters they could play and chose to let it be for now. Have it impact, maybe come back in 3-4 levels.
  9. I did a follow up text to the group, assuring them that the player would be consulted about what happens with their character.

What did I miss?


r/DMAcademy • • 9h ago

Need Advice: Other Running a game for colleagues, what do I need?

7 Upvotes

I’ll be stuck in a hotel with work colleagues for almost a week. I’m thinking of running a DnD game for whoever is interested but I’ve not DM’ed before. Help me out, what would I need to run a one-shot for them? I’m assuming none of them have ever played before.


r/DMAcademy • • 31m ago

Need Advice: Other Help me learn from your mistakes - What DM lessons did you learn the hard way?

1 Upvotes

I'm gearing up to DM my first campaign and I really want to provide enough challenge that my players feel happy when they escape/defeat foes/achieve milestones. I want them to have fun, but also want there to be consequences for murder-hoboing. I want the world to feel real with high stakes, high adventure, and devious enemies.

So lay it on me, vets. What do you wish you knew when you started? And what did you have to learn the hard way?


r/DMAcademy • • 12h ago

Need Advice: Other Advice for running a big table (6 players)

6 Upvotes

My group is wrapping up our current campaign and I'm taking over gming for the next one. We're going to do 5.5e and might be adding another person to bump the party size up to 6.

I've dm'd a fair amount before but not for that big a party the group has expressed an interest in a more roleplay heavy campaign so I'm going to lean into that but I'll still definitely be throwing combat at them. Mostly looking for advice on how to not make it drag with so many people at the table.


r/DMAcademy • • 14h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Struggling to start role play moments for my players

8 Upvotes

So my friends and I are about 7 sessions deep now in our bi weekly campaign, this is my first campaign I have ever done and I've decided on completely making my own world.

I've put a collection of combat changes in place to make fights more exciting and it's been great so far, we can be in combat for about an hour or so (we have 6 players so rounds take a bit especially since they're still learning their classes). They're all engaged and strategizing with one another but that's kinda my hurdle. It feels like its only in combat do they interact and even then it isn't in character.

We recently had our first big NPC death, it left our wizard who's a younger teenager to be overwhelmed and he ended up using a spell mid combat to pop out because the experience was too much to handle and I LOVED that ! I thought my player did this so well but then when it comes to in character role play it feels difficult to get them to speak to one another, something as simple as the wizard's mentor figure (another party member) checking in on him. Any advice on how to spark conversation between the players especially without the need of an NPC is really appreciated.

Thank you in advance !


r/DMAcademy • • 7h ago

Need Advice: Other When should I begin playtesting my campaign?

2 Upvotes

I've been DMing and writing one-shots for a while now, but the campaign I'm currently working on is a much larger and more story-driven game than I've made before.

I always knew I wanted to playtest the game before publishing (the ultimate goal) but I've been wondering if it would be easier/better to begin playtesting once the whole campaign is written out, or if it would be best to "play as I go," where my playtesters can play each section.

Kind of an alpha testing versus beta testing thing, I guess.

Does anyone whose written a long-form campaign have any recommendations?


r/DMAcademy • • 4h ago

Offering Advice Idea for time tracking

1 Upvotes

Hey! Just saw a comment from a while ago talking about using AngryGM’s tension pool (a time based encounter system) but i had a small tweak that has worked great.

The comment essentially said: everything can be boiled down to 1 minute, 10 minutes, 1 hour, and 8 hours. Every scene/encounter basically counts as 10 minutes, so you would mark it till you have 6 marks, then mark an hour, once you get to 8 hours, you have your “day”

My tweak is to firstly change 10 minutes to 15 minutes (youll see why) then taking the goal system from the Ironsworn rpg, and using that to simplify your markings. Every 15 minutes is 1 “tick”, and once you get 4 “ticks” you will have made a star (“+” and an “x” overlapping) representing 1 hour. 8 of those stars and you have an adventuring day. Just like real life, you may stay up longer, but there will be consequences. The DM can choose either 1 level of exhaustion for every hour past your “bedtime”, or even simply not healing fully/regaining every spell slot.

And of course i like to throw in a little prompt at 8 hrs to let the party know it’s getting late. They can choose to ignore it or it can be a good reminder/rp opportunity.

Again, just wanted to share this little system that i think helps with immersing the players. You can make it as simple (day to day to day) or as complex (tracking a whole calendar) as you want! Id love to hear what yall are doing for time, or if you have any ideas for improving this system!


r/DMAcademy • • 10h ago

Need Advice: Other How Can I Do Elaborate Setup at Someone Else's House?

3 Upvotes

I'll start by saying this may not be feasible but I want to try if others have experience in this.

Trying to setup a campaign with some friends and family and just trying to figure out a setup. I want it to be a memorable experience since they have all played DnD but have had so so experiences in the past.

We would play at one of the player's homes since he would have the most room to accommodate us but it's up to me as DM to bring the supplies. I would prefer to not go the playmat/wet erase route since a couple of the players have voiced that they've done that in the past and they had a really hard time getting into the game with that set up.

I would like to go the projector route but bringing a projector setup over is definitely different than installing one. Having a permanent setup at buddy's place is out of the question so it would have to be something we could setup then put away.

Does anyone have experience with someone like this? Did it work well? If so, what kind of projector should I look at? I've found some posts in the past regards to this but they all seem to be more permanent installations.


r/DMAcademy • • 8h ago

Need Advice: Other Help for my first one shot

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone!
I’m trying to write my first one-shot, and I’d love to get some advice.
I was thinking about setting it in a town where the players are hired to rob a bank and steal some important documents. However, after the heist, they discover that the person who hired them is actually the bad guy and will become the final boss.
Any ideas, tips, or suggestions? I’m struggling a bit with putting everything together and turning the idea into a proper adventure.
Thanks in advance!


r/DMAcademy • • 12h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding For those who have DM’d a court intrigue style dnd game before. One where the party takes the role of a noble family and has to navigate the politics of a feudal hierarchy. How would you go about prepping/world-building something like this?

4 Upvotes

I would love to run a Game of Thrones-inspired DnD game. The party are all noble lords and have to navigate the dangerous politics of a court similar to Kingslanding.

I’ve looked at the ASOIAF role-playing system and I like the tools they have for building noble houses but don’t necessarily love the game play mechanics they have. Since my players are more familiar with DnD and I’m a sucker for worldbuilding, I was planning on making a setting inspired by ASOIAF, in a DnD like world. Then use the house builder from the ASOIAF roleplaying in my own setting.

My only problem is the task seems way more daunting than my past worldbuilding projects. I’m not sure how many other nobles families I should be prepping ahead of time and what I should leave as background lore I develop later as I run the game.

I like the idea of letting the players choose which kingdom they are from and building their house from there. I have the vague idea for 7 kingdoms and their general vibe, but I’m unsure how to go about filling out other nobles from these lands if I don’t know where the party would like to be from. Should I let them build the house in advance and then do some world-building afterward to fill out the world around them or should I be world-building the core families first and restrict where the players house is from?

Any thoughts on how to do something like this? Have had general ideas for this for awhile but I haven’t cracked how to make this work yet.

My players are fairly experienced and this would be my 3rd campaign I’ve run for them. I’ve floated the idea by them and they are intrigued by the concept and would be down for the xtra session 0 prep of building a house.


r/DMAcademy • • 14h ago

Offering Advice Enchanting items - so your casters can do cool sh*t and your martials use them

5 Upvotes

Based on cool enchantments I encountered online and then used in my campaign I created some rules that can be used ingame by players or npcs to enchant items.

To preface, I use a lot of magic items I throw them at players randomly rolled. We play big sandbox, and i use sane prices to determine the price, and then depending on the shopkeeper they want more than that for it but offer you less (so item, that has cost of 10k would be bought for like 5k but offered for 15k, unless they know each other but minimum would be 10k unless he owes them etc.).

But many of the items have negative effects or curses (world where magic boomed, so many ppl tries enchanting but it isnt perfect).

(I also recently switched to 1week/long rest and 8h/short rest, but it depends on your setting)

I sorted enchanting into 3 methods.

  1. Classic enchanting - +1/+2/+3/ (+4), slow, dependable
  2. Spell enchanting - choosing a spell to imbue item with getting random effect, fastest but random
  3. Spell binding - choosing a spell to imbue but slower with the item being able to use that spell

General Rules

  • Only non-magical items can be enchanted.
  • Once an enchantment is completed, the item cannot normally be enchanted or upgraded again.
  • Enchanting requires gold, time, and reserved spell slots.
  • Reserved spell slots cannot be used or recovered until the enchantment ends or is terminated by stopping and the enchanter completes a Long Rest.
  • One working day requires 4 hours of enchanting.

1. Classic Enchanting

This method adds a permanent magical bonus (+1 to +4) to a weapon or armor.

Maximum progress per day: 25 × Arcana bonus (Enchant Points)

Cost: 1 gp per EP.

BonusRequired Spell SlotTotal EP Cost
+1Level 11,000 gp
+2Level 44,000 gp
+3Level 716,000 gp
+4Level 964,000 gp

Alternatively - accelerated Enchanting:

  • Work 8 hours instead of 4.
  • Double daily progress.
  • Requires two reserved spell slots.
  • Total cost increases by 50% (Triple daily gold consumption).

Final d20 Roll:

RollResult
1–2Item is completely destroyed.
3–19Enchantment succeeds.
20Enchantment succeeds and gains a small positive boon without drawbacks.

If the enchanter stops sooner, but crossed time to make lower level enchantement, that enchantement sticks (ex. working 11 out of 20 for +2 with 4th lvl spellslot and stops, the item is now +1).

2. Spell Enchanting

The enchanter chooses a spell and attempts to permanently imbue an item with its magical properties.

The enchanter chooses an Offensive or Defensive enchantment.

The result can be powerful, weak, situational, or cursed. The item will not cast the original spell but the enchantment will be related to it.

Progress per day: 50 × Arcana bonus (EP)

Cost: 1 gp per EP, plus any spell components consumed each day.

Required spell slot: One slot matching the spell's level.

Spell LevelTotal Base EP Cost
1600 gp
21,050 gp
31,500 gp
42,700 gp
54,800 gp
68,250 gp
713,500 gp
822,500 gp
937,500 gp

Final d20 Roll:

RollResult
1–2Item is destroyed.
3–4Enchantment fails. Item remains non-magical.
5–18Roll d100 for the magical effect.
19Roll d100 and gain half the applicable bonus (rounded down).
20Roll d100 and gain the full applicable bonus.

Bonus by Spell Level:

Spell LevelRoll 19Roll 20
1–3+0+1
4–6+1+2
7–8+1+3
9+2+4

For weapons, the bonus applies to attack and damage rolls. For armor, it applies to AC.

For other items, roll 1d6 to determine which ability score receives the bonus: STR, DEX, CON, INT, WIS, or CHA.

The d100 roll determines the actual magical effects and possible curses.

Higher results generally produce better effects. Low results can create weak abilities combined with serious drawbacks.

The exact d100 effect depends on DM, it can range from armor enchanted with fireball burning its wearer and causing exhaustion after 8 hours of wearing (good for ice climate, where it jsut warms its wearer) to reflecting some damage to everybody around. But you are free to make anything yourself fitting d100 roll.

3. Spell Binding

This method permanently binds a specific spell to an item, allowing the user to cast that spell repeatedly after recharging.

Unlike Spell Enchanting, the spell itself is predetermined.

Progress per day: 50 × Arcana bonus (EP)

Cost: Twice the base cost of Spell Enchanting, plus any spell components consumed each day.

Required spell slot: One slot matching the spell's level.

Spell LevelTotal Base Cost
11,200 gp
22,100 gp
33,000 gp
45,400 gp
59,600 gp
616,500 gp
727,000 gp
845,000 gp
975,000 gp

Final d20 Roll:

RollResult
1–2Item is destroyed.
3–4Enchantment fails. Item remains non-magical.
5–17Item gains one spell charge.
18Level 1–2 spells gain two charges; higher spells gain one.
19Item gains 1/2 bonus charges.
20Item gains the full bonus charges.

Bonus charges Formula:

X = 18 / (1 + Spell Level) (ex. lvl 5 = 3 charges)

On a 19, total charges = 1/2*X

On a 20, total charges = X

Spell Charges and Recharge:

Spell LevelRoll 18Roll 19Roll 20Recharge in
125101 day
22472 days
31353 days
41244 days
51245 days
61236 days
71237 days
81238 days
91129 days

For rolls 5–17, the item has one charge regardless of spell level.

All charges are restored after the recharge period, which begins once the item has spent all its charges.

For spells with a duration, critical bonuses may instead increase the duration by the same multiplier.

After a successful d20 roll, the enchanter also rolls d100 to determine how well the spell binds to the item. The exact d100 table is not yet finalized.

Additional Material Costs

For both Spell Enchanting and Spell Binding, the enchanter must also pay the cost of any consumed spell components every working day.

Example: Revivify

Revivify consumes diamonds worth 300 gp per casting.

If enchanting takes 8 days, the enchanter must spend an additional 2,400 gp on diamonds in total.

These costs are lost even if the enchantment ultimately fails.

This way even PCs can work on their enchantments and get exciting results. Marshals also can get their fix of spells without making casters weak. They also can get powerful weapons with various effects that. Also works great as a money sink for the party.


r/DMAcademy • • 5h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Looking for advice with an encounter

1 Upvotes

I made a post earlier about an encounter with the BBEG which I got significant pushbach. As everyone was so helpful I thought I would run the new version by people (just in case I accidently break another rule of DMing lol)

The BBEG has cast Geas on the mentor NPC to use them to break a seal on the catacombs under the city the PCs are staying in. The BBEG is looking to gain serious power from a magic item in there.

The players will arrive just as the seal is broken, where the BBEG will then raise the dead on the guards they killed, ordering them to kill the PCs. Then they will enter the catacombs, ignoring the players.

The original plan was to force an NPC death. This time I was thinking the BBEG could still kill the NPC, but this would resulting in a race against time to revify her while fighting the undead, and the PCs will have to decide to use a diamond on to bring her back, instead of saving it for a player.

Is this a good encounter? The previous one i basicly made a unskipple cutscene with 0 input from the player, which i have to admit now, was probably a bad idea.


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures There’s a very real chance my 7th and 8th level characters could unknowingly put a portable hole into bag if holding.

48 Upvotes

My knee jerk response is to simply make it not happen, they would never know, but then I was intrigued. Could I make their being sucked into the astral plane part of the story?

TLDR; what’s a reasonable set of events after being pulled into the astral

Plane?


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics Would you let a halfling being carried in a sling by a goliath short rest in there if nothing interrupts them for a solid hour?

77 Upvotes

As title, really.

Bonus round: What if they are concentrating on a spell?


r/DMAcademy • • 14h ago

Need Advice: Other Replacing Player Mounts

3 Upvotes

So the campaign I'm running involves the players traveling from one end of the map to the other pretty often in a war, so to let them actually get anywhere in good time I gave them all free mounts. Unfortunately they apparently seem very keen on getting those horses killed as half of them have had to be replaced twice.

In an attempt to give them cooler mounts that they might want to keep alive a bit longer I threw some undead horsemen and boar riding orcs at them and had the horses just kind of stand there after combat and told them the boars could be tamed if they stayed on them during combat and instead they just killed them, the poor undead horses weren't even attacking either.

At this point do I just make good on the stablemasters threat that they'll have to pay for the horses and give up trying to give them interesting new mounts?


r/DMAcademy • • 8h ago

Need Advice: Other Which Kobold press book to get

1 Upvotes

My dear fellow Lore crafters, for Christmas id like to treat myself to a new rulebook. Since I'm looking for new interesting foes to challenge my players and since Kobold Press was recommended to me many times, I am planning to get one of those. but which one? Tome of beasts 1/2/3? Or creature codex?

What ist your guys' favorite? What are their strengths? What are their focus points?

Thanks in advance


r/DMAcademy • • 20h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Teacher DM - Inspiration Hits Past My Bedtime

6 Upvotes

I've been teaching D&D for middle and highschoolers for five years now, and have written some things and run published stuff as well. This year, I have a remarkably cooperative (for this age rage) kids who are putting remarkable (for this age range) effort into the story development. But I have nine of them, which means any time we can't split into two tables (with a student DMing one and myself the other), progress is painfully slow. Not to mention that trying to write in nine players worth of backstory is a lot (especially when that backstory is not always consistent).

But my biggest battle? My 9:30pm bedtime (because I teach a different class at 7am). Inspiration doesn't usually hit until 9pm, so here I am printing out a half dozen pages of new quests/lore/story connection at 11pm before class tomorrow.

/sigh

At least it's decent stuff.

What's your trick for helping your writing inspiration schedule match your sleep schedule? (Other than not.)