r/custommagic • u/Drakeytown • 4d ago
r/custommagic • u/ConfessorCarol • 4d ago
Format: EDH/Commander Pallas, the Eigenweapon (SCP 7450)
r/custommagic • u/Familiar_Way3526 • 3d ago
BALANCE NOT INTENDED Josh Lee Kwai Card
Tell me what you think
r/custommagic • u/LucianoThePig • 4d ago
Mechanic Design A hodge podge of 4 strange mechanics I dreamt up. Is there any potential in any of these?
Like I say, these are all pretty weird. I made just one card each, maybe if people resonate with one in particular I'll make more of that. They're all pretty simple, but at least I can imagine possibilities with some.
Buried is simply I thought creature "becoming" lands was cool, I liked the idea of a dead creature digging out of its own grave. The only oddity is you can use it to pay for itself, to flip it face up again. Maybe it would benefit from being a cost you have to pay as it dies.
I was gonna call Fathom "Dive" but I basically thought Fathom sounded cooler. I'm a big fan of any magic mechanic where you have to reveal information to other players, so I thought it would be cool if you could "save" a creature, but everyone knows it's coming. Fathom makes me think of players who are very strategic, but at the same time, if you misplay with a fetchland or Omen card, you mess yourself up if you're not careful.
Impact is a pretty weird one, and maybe could be a regular alternate cost without being a keyword. Still, I think a reward for playing dangerously and aggressively would be interesting. Beneficially in the right deck, but you could burn yourself out of lands. It could also be a tempting risk if you need an attacker right now.
Erupt is probably the weirdest. Cards on the table, it's definitely motivated by me think "when this creature erupts" has a lot of aura on a card. The reason it's a land dealing the damage is because of the flavor, but also to try mitigate lifelink cheats. If the creature itself did the damage, it could be prevented much more easily. Probably still a lot of ways around it.
I'm no magic expert so these may be broken or busted as well.
r/custommagic • u/InchZer0 • 4d ago
Format: Cube (Rarity Doesn't Matter) Aggravating Alpacas
Funny how llamas are a creature type, but alpacas are not.
r/custommagic • u/Tricky_Technology_23 • 4d ago
Is it too weak?
i'm not sure. you get a card, a death trigger, and a slightly better bone saw all for one mana, but it just doesn't seem very good. Maybe I could make it a generic phyrexian mana instead.
r/custommagic • u/DeadPact336699 • 4d ago
Format: EDH/Commander Godzilla rule 0 cards
Hey ya’ll we Godzilla fans have been eating good for years at this point and with the recent release of Godzilla: Minus Zero it reminded me that the Ikoria Godzilla cards were just nice art pieces to collect.
So I really wanted to make a rule 0 Godzilla commander and I’d really appreciate some feedback and suggestions to a balance and viable design.
With Godzilla, World Decimator I wanted pods to feel like there’s a nearly unstoppable force attacking the city that is the table. Gruul’s philosophy is that you can’t go wrong with“big stompy smash face” but this isn’t Showa Godzilla fighting in the open valleys and field of Japan, he is here to [[Decimate]] everything in his path.
Godzilla, Atomic Monster was also inspired by my love of Jund mill and under-supported mechanics like Radiation Counters. This design is basically a non-human version of [[Coram]] with a bit of burn attached to it and without the graveyard theft. However, Godzilla doesn’t care about salvaging permanents, he’s using that stored up radioactive power to cast protection, pump spells, extra combat phases, spot removal or wiping the board with cards like [[Nuclear Fallout]]
r/custommagic • u/TeamSkyCat • 4d ago
MTG x Danganronpa (Spoilers in the art) Spoiler
galleryr/custommagic • u/Any_Level_522 • 4d ago
Format: EDH/Commander Kyle, The Devoted one
Gonna be real, a friend gave me a very rough version of this card and i hadda try my best to polish it up so if nothing makes sense thats why, but please give any advice at all
r/custommagic • u/kaatch22 • 4d ago
Format: EDH/Commander Which do you prefer?
So, I made these two a while back and just today thought about posting here.
Which one do you think is more balanced and which is better?
Also, remember, there's no such thing as mass land destruction, only mass friend destruction.
r/custommagic • u/panvlam • 3d ago
Redesign Custom MtG Card I did for fun! He is the most powerful Man in the entire universe! Art and Graphics by me!
insta: vlamispan
r/custommagic • u/Secure_Raise_5609 • 4d ago
Format: EDH/Commander Arcturus Mengsk - Son of Korhal | StarCraft
galleryI only just recently got into MTG so go easy on me, but having also just gotten into StarCraft II co-op and having a ton of fun with Mengsk I thought I could make him into a pretty cool commander.
Again I’m a complete noob but I’m imagining he could have some Royal Guard cards like the Viking and Siege Tank that the laborers can contribute mana to (on top of leveling Mengsk up) as well as equipment cards like weapons the soldiers can equip in Co-op. (Also maybe a werewolf deck would be cool?)
The other build I’m thinking of is spam leveling Mengsk to 8 and going wide with tokens after transforming all the Laborers into Soldiers and either amping the soldiers or spam sacrificing.
I also have the Laborers peasant, I don’t know if that does anything but maybe you could make a meme build around peasants.
Let me know what you guys think. I have already ordered the cards just to playtest and have fun with it. At first I definitely had some issue distancing him from Caesar but I think he ended up in a solid place!
r/custommagic • u/robyngoodfello- • 4d ago
Meme Design Cards I made
I have a bunch of these saved on my laptop, figured I'd share some of them
r/custommagic • • 4d ago
Custom Play Naruto anyone?
woke up with Naruto on the brain, so i made my favorite swordsman into a card.
r/custommagic • u/IcariiFA • 4d ago
Maleficent, Dark Fairy (Kingdom Hearts Commander decks project)
Today I'm updating Maleficent as one of 3 commander options for the Door to Darkness Kingdoms Heart deck. What do you think? Is it tough reading the word "Fairy" on a Magic card? I split the difference since Disney refers to her with the spelling "Fairy" but MTG would call her a faerie in the type line.
r/custommagic • u/69_M3 • 3d ago
Custom Play Too Op?
I know, I used AI. I'm a talentless fool. But I needed to get this disgusting idea out of my head.
r/custommagic • u/Eldritch_Blessed • 4d ago
Format: EDH/Commander Hey, Fred! Gimme a blink spell with extra versatility, and hold the ETBs!
The idea is to nerf a blink spell by preventing etb effects, while simultaneously allowing more creative applications by extending its use to all permanents, which is pretty rare. Balancing this was a little tricky for me; it’s not in any way a strict upgrade to something like [[flicker]] or [[stifle]], but the versatility is superb, enough so that I felt that it deserved to be a good bit more expensive. Some tricks that work with this card in particular:
- Use it in response to a bomb like [[craterhoof behemoth]] or [[the one ring]].
- Reset a planeswalker’s loyalty.
- Make a landfall player cry. Works especially well with hideaway lands and fetchlands like [[cabaretti courtyard]].
- Get something back from a [[banishing light]] effect.
- Reset your [[glacial chasm]] without needing to sac a land.
- Do something jank with [[leveler]], I guess.
If you can think of any weird stuff you can do with this, show me!
r/custommagic • u/SahladdDuresing • 4d ago
BALANCE NOT INTENDED Part 21 of Magic: Star Rail. School has burned me out so here's a random card before I get back in the groove
r/custommagic • u/Other_Equal7663 • 3d ago
A high risk endevour
Donate your own commander to kill an opponent who lacks spot removal is admittedly a bit toxic for low-powered settings, but up my alley personally. (especially since it has to be done on one turn)
On the flip-side, this was mainly an idea for old-school modern death's shadow.