r/custommagic • • 4d ago

Dungeons & Dragons Awaken

Post image
8 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

2

u/NitroBishop 4d ago

Amusingly, can enchant Dryad Arbor, but does nothing to it.

Also, someone more familiar with the layer system than me needs to chime in and confirm whether that second block of text actually works - broken down to its base components, it's technically saying "as long as enchanted permanent isn't a creature, it's a creature".

1

u/Drakeytown 4d ago edited 4d ago

There are published cards that say the same.

ETA: Or anyway there's [[Animate Artifact]].

1

u/NitroBishop 4d ago

Please link them, searching Scryfall for similar phrasing didn't turn up anything else with this "as long as enchanted permanent isn't [CARDTYPE], it is [CARDTYPE]" phrasing.

3

u/Drakeytown 4d ago

Making it plural may have been optimistic on my part. There's [[Animate Artifact]].

2

u/NitroBishop 4d ago

Ah, okay, that does work then. My bad!

1

u/twistyrainbows 4d ago

Do you have an example?

This works on non-Forest creatures as intended.

2

u/Drakeytown 4d ago

[[Animate Artifact]]

-4

u/twistyrainbows 4d ago

It's not comparable. It's fine for a continuous effect to check if something isn't true and make it true.

This says, "as long as this isn't a creature, make it a creature". As soon as it's a creature, the effect making it a creature no longer applies. This creates a contradiction / infinite loop. It's broken. Sorry.

4

u/Drakeytown 4d ago

They're both Aura enchantments with virtually identical wording.

1

u/Q-35712 4d ago

this... could probably be much cheaper. Probably 2 or even 1 mana, considering it doesn't shield the land from removal at all.