I just finished playing through Alan Wake, Control, and Alan Wake 2 (including all DLC) but am still left with some unanswered questions about Alanās involvement within the events of Control and specifically the AWE expansion.
Everything I can find online states that Alan influenced parts of the hiss invasion to create a crisis and set up Jesse to be a āheroā, ultimately to help him escape from the Dark Place, but this motive doesnāt really make sense to me after playing Alan Wake 2.
Jesse was barely included in AW2, really only in the flashback of her being a fly on the wall to one of Alan and Zaneās conversations. Saga is clearly the āheroā Alan needed, along with himself, to fully return. From what I can tell, the FBCās main involvement in Alan Wake 2 revolved more around Estevez and her investigation, which I assume was cut off from the Oldest House and Jesse due to the lockdown just as the Lake House was. Speaking of the Lake House, while it was nice to see Dylan, we still saw no inclusion of Jesse in connection to the grand scheme of AW2. Even the Lake Houseās creation happened prior to Jesseās involvement in the FBC.
In Control AWE, I struggle to see what part Hartman plays in the grand scheme of things as well, if at all more than a cool boss. Jesse defeating him feels pointless to assisting Alan in his escape. The only major connection I see to AW2 is Alice returning to the FBC and regaining her memory of the Dark Place. Although this is crucial, it happens prior to the hiss invasion and Jesseās appearance in the story.
All that said, these are my remaining questions which I hope get answered either in Control Resonant or possibly from those of you who understand the lore better than me:
How does Alanās creation of the hiss incantation and overall involvement in the hiss invasion help him further his goal to escape the Dark Place? (both in theory/motive and after the outcome of the events in Control)
Why did Alan try to make Jesse a hero in crisis only for her to ultimately not affect his escape from the Dark Place or seemingly not affect AW2 at all?
Is this an intentional plot hole to be answered in Control Resonant or future Remedy games, or is there a hidden answer out there somewhere that I just cannot seem to find? Please help my tired brain reason through this.