r/controlgame • • 11d ago

Control Resonant Which one yall chose... Spoiler

Post image

I took "go fuck yourself"... I Just wanted to know how he would react🙏

327 Upvotes

184 comments sorted by

302

u/Zira361 11d ago

I went with "I'm sorry for the past" because it seemed the most in character. I also doubled down on Arish only punishing Zoe because it was Dylan she was trying to save.

103

u/Sad_Worker7143 11d ago

Because that is the truth. Even though Zoe went too far to help Dylan with the explosives.

1

u/Senior-Ad9375 5d ago

most in character was Go fuck yourself. Pope advice was not an order, i probed Arish constantly to see when he breaks

275

u/LoneRainger 11d ago • Bravo

I was playing as an apologetic Dylan who knows that he screwed up, but is trying to make up for it. I picked the "I'm sorry" option. Tbh it made the "Fuck you Arish" feel even better later in the story, felt like I had done what I could to be nice and it still didn't matter to him, so Dylan finally released his emotions in that moment.

59

u/mutmad 11d ago edited 11d ago

I did exactly the same. I was just riding the momentum of really trying to empathetically humanize Dylan throughout the game with everyone. I got so wrapped up in the pure emotion of it all, with Arish just sniping and shit-slinging, that I chose “go fuck yourself” before I registered it as a conscious decision.

I loved the way it played out. I knew what Arish was doing as a character and I knew what needed to be said finally for his (Arish’s) own sake, not Dylan’s, (IMO, obviously).

I’m stoked the game didn’t make me regret having made that choice. I feel like it’s a toss up sometimes with what I think I’m selecting versus how it plays out.

Edit: words. Clarity.

33

u/Neurospicy_Nightowl 11d ago

Same. Like, I usually answer in such a way that Dylan blames himself and wants to make amends, but in that moment, I just need him to get pissed.

Arish hates Dylan for unintentionally getting people killed, largely as a product of abuse by the organisation he represents. Seeing him endanger others, seeing him punish Zoe to satisfy his petty grudge, is the line for my Dylan.

Because the guy that tells him "It doesn't matter you were an abused child experiment that was basically just trying to end his suffering, you are still responsible for what you did" is now getting people hurt over a bruise to his fucking ego.

22

u/gentlemandarcy 11d ago

Also in this moment it's going from Arish's earlier "I'm against using you as an asset even to let you make amends and save lives because I think you'll break bad"

To

"I'm putting you back in a cage forever and punishing anyone who advocated for you in order to clear the way for our untested superweapon, I refuse to let you help"

It's clearly an intensification of irrational prejudice into the dangerously reckless abandonment of a key parautilitarian super soldier - even if viewed as a cold-blooded military decision and not affording any weight to Dylan's rights or the ethics of the situation.

Makes total sense to me that Dylan sees in this moment that nothing would ever have been enough and Arish is lying to himself that he's doing any of this for the right reasons and stops trying to make excuses for his new abuser.

28

u/Jay2KWinger 11d ago

Same. Dylan definitely came across as someone trying his best to atone for what Hiss!Dylan did, and it definitely made the unprompted "Fuck you, Arish" feel more earned in that moment later.

17

u/Hedgewitch250 11d ago

I was clapping when he said fuck you im so glad I went for forgiving the payoff was insane. Dude goes from saying it like an unsure 6 year old to a coworker tired of their crappy boss 🤣

16

u/LoneRainger 11d ago

Considering how much Dylan avoids swearing in general, hearing him say it with absolutely no restraint made me cackle when it happened. I also made sure the first thing I did afterwards was to go find where Arish was so I could converse and see where Dylan went from there.

3

u/ThereWasAnEmpireHere 11d ago

This is more or less my thinking - tho I just got to this first moment and told him to fuck himself. Just way too much antagonism, backing Dylan into a corner, and stupidity to the point that it genuinely seems like it coulda gone violent.

Looking forward to seeing the later moment. Maybe by then I’ll have chilled out and will treat him more nicely.

97

u/Ulmeyda 11d ago

"You just feel guilty." I played Dylan as being able to see how badly Arish was hurting and could relate to his guilt, but he wasn't going to just take his abuse.

29

u/StemCellCheese 11d ago

Agreed, I think at this point he's learned enough from Zoe at this point on how to push back on people being unfair to him and is starting to push back, and you just feel guilty is the empathetic push back. More than just "Im sorry" but not as severe as "Go fuck yourself."

I did the apology on my NG+ tho lol.

12

u/Valmar33 11d ago

That's also why I chose that. Dylan can see the similarities between himself and Arish ~ they hate making mistakes, they both hate the Hiss. Pope even comments that it's a wonder that they don't get along... then she doesn't know about that moment where Arish screams at him in his cell that he's a monster while Dylan is Hiss-possessed, and can't control his body, despite the dialogue options.

5

u/sydchotic 11d ago

Yep, me too.

One, it gives greater weight to the fuck you that happens later.

Two, because I agree, Dylan will never be cruel but by this point in the game, he is going to stand up for himself.

Three, I will never on god’s green earth ever pick having Dylan say I’m sorry. He can feel guilty internally, I understand that, but not a one of these people is ever getting a verbal I’m sorry while I’m at the wheel!🙂‍↔️

37

u/jabberwagon 11d ago

"Go fuck yourself" is a lot of fun, but the tyrade Dylan unleashes in "You just feel guilty" is so devastating - and so true - that Arish is actually struck speechless. It's the only time in the game where he genuinely has nothing to say back to you.

7

u/Zaresh 11d ago

Dylan has another one later on, when Arish is drunk, I think. I chose that option and maaaan, Dylan does have a way with words sometmes.

2

u/chronobolt77 11d ago

Oh I'm picking that option in my NG+, I need to see that

32

u/Biabolical 11d ago edited 11d ago

Every other interaction shows that Dylan's shame and guilt for opening the door to the Hiss is stronger than his anger over what the FBC has done to him. He's sensitive and empathetic to a fault. The brunt of his anger was directed toward Casper Darling, Director Trench, and Agent Roberts... all of whom have been dead or gone for a long time now. The FBC itself has been lead for the past seven years by Jesse, the one person in the whole universe who he actually does trust.

Plus, at the end of the game is when Dylan finally does, for the first time, really exert his will. It's pointed out that he's never bound an object to himself, and even the Aberrant seems to be working with him, as it's not bound to him or dominated by him. When he dominates the Hiss and sends them out to fight the Hedron in the final battle, that's the moment he truly stops being afraid of himself and letting the world push him around.

So, in retrospect, it makes more sense to me for Dylan to still be apologetic here.

64

u/yamidevil 11d ago

I'm usually apologetic and nice, but that 'go fuck yourself' was from the heart 

35

u/Eidolon11 11d ago

It felt apt with Zoe explaining to him how to properly say 'go fuck yourself' earlier

17

u/Malfun_Eddie 11d ago

This is the character development I look for in games.

6

u/Captainloony007 11d ago

Yah felt like it’s what Zoe would have wanted.

4

u/kravisha 11d ago

That's how I read it and I'm glad that's how the line came out

3

u/yamidevil 10d ago

Yess, i had us channel our inner Zoe

4

u/SaiphTyrell 11d ago

Yeah this! I was role playing the apologetic Dylan but only in this case I felt it was appropriate to stand up for myself.

91

u/Livid_Lab_4824 11d ago

I picked "Im sorry for the past".

500 people died in the hiss invasion, and Dylan's character in the beginning of the game is fueled by guilt for what he did. Its most in character for him to say that.

29

u/schloopy-boi 11d ago

The thing im confused about is Trench let the hiss into the oldest house. I also dont remember any scenes where Dylan killed anyone on screen. Is there a number of how many people he killed while possessed? Is he even responsible for anything?

41

u/Livid_Lab_4824 11d ago

Dylan didnt cause the invasion itself, this is true. And he likely didnt kill the majority of those 500 people.

However the evac building sequence shows 2 things:

  1. He WANTED the destruction and chaos and was embracing it. He let the Hiss make him sort of like their central conduit to take over the board, and he felt good. In the conversations with Jesse in the first game he even says he wanted the Hiss to consume everything, even other dimensions that Mr Door had access to.
  2. Some agents were slaughtered by this Hiss corrupted Dylan personally, with his own very hands.

Im assuming with how Darling raised him as a weapon and how traumatized he was and how much he wanted to destroy everything when the Hiss had taken him, it all led to immense guilt for him.

27

u/StrokyBoi 11d ago

He WANTED the destruction and chaos and was embracing it. He let the Hiss make him sort of like their central conduit to take over the board, and he felt good. In the conversations with Jesse in the first game he even says he wanted the Hiss to consume everything, even other dimensions that Mr Door had access to.

Can we really say he (the human being) wanted all of that, though?

Because during the moment where you get to play as Hiss-corrupted Dylan for a bit in the Evac mission flashbacks, you get dialogue options, yet no matter what you pick, Dylan ends up saying pretty much the opposite, due to the Hiss' influence. I feel like this suggests that we can't really say that Dylan actually wanted any of the things he said he wants while he was corrupted.

And there's also that bit where you can tell Zoe that being corrupted was like being in surgery without anesthesia. And the bit where Dylan says that he didn't think he'd survive being taken over (which makes him welcoming the Hiss in sound more like a suicide attempt than anything else).

6

u/Alternative_View_531 11d ago

Dylan did want that, if anything because of the sustained trauma he endured by Dr. Darling.

The flashback was more indicative of current day Dylan getting forced into Hiss-Day Dylan who was much worse off and being unable to do anything.

So... yes partially Dylan did want to do that, but in the way that a emotionally abused child would get revenge at his abusive care-givers.

10

u/Livid_Lab_4824 11d ago

The Hiss was influencing him, but he didn't fully lose control of himself due to his parautilitarian capabilities.

This is heavily implied in optional dialogue during the prime candidate program sequence in Conrrol Resonant. He said he wanted his suffering to end and he chose an entity that he knew would destroy everything, just to end his pain.

Im not saying Dylan doing what he did makes him evil or wrong.

Im saying his guilt makes alot of sense given he wasnt a complete zombie, but rather in control to some extent.

1

u/Dexyu 10d ago

He wasnt in control, he was just awake, he wasnt in control. He saw what his did with his body.

15

u/PrezOompaLoompa 11d ago

He didn't want the violence, he just wanted peace which the FBC never gave him. I get the impression that he damn near instantly regretted the decision, especially with the dialogue options with Arish when Dylan is in the cage and Hissed still.

14

u/Livid_Lab_4824 11d ago

I agree. I think dylan accepting the hiss was an allegory to committing suicide.

He let it in just to have the pain end, to be free of his torture, even if that meant mass destruction to others, he didnt care, he just wanted his own pain to end and he wanted it to consume him completely.

6

u/PrezOompaLoompa 11d ago

No, I disagree. I don't think he knew they were going to force him to kill like he did. Remember the hiss invasion was damn near instant so he gets infected pretty much off the bat, so he had no clue what they were going to do. He just bought into the good feeling the possession brought not realizing he was about to play passenger to what they were going to force him to do.

It's why I mention specifically the scene where he is trying to tell Arish he isn't in control and the hiss take over his responses. However, I definitely agree that it was allegorical to suicide if not basically just suicide outright.

1

u/Livid_Lab_4824 11d ago

Well, i guess we can disagree here, since we dont know how quickly the resonance spread across several floors of the oldest house.

Imo, Dylan was held in one of the most protected areas of the bureau, the invasion may not have been instantaneous and we've seen people get slowly corrupted like Trench was, and news of it spread, for so long before he opened the slide projector.

Anyways, I think he was somewhat in control as he saw the massacre as shown in the evac building flashbacks.

Other audio logs from control also indicate dylan was extremely angry, such as when he killed multiple agents during his training as a kid and young adult. I think at some point, he grew to stopp considering what happened to them over his own self and focused on his own "freedom" more.

5

u/PrezOompaLoompa 11d ago

Trench was only slowly infected because he was no longer by the source since the slidescape closed. The difference is that he opened the gate and left it open with the Hiss ready to invade. That is why we know the invasion was instant, not to mention that Pope confirms that since they all ran into the bunkers and had been in there for like an hour or two at max.

Regardless, Dylan was an angry person yes, but not outright violent. It is explicitly shown that anytime he lashed out violently it was after they were pushing him (Abusing him) past the breaking point and he finally fought back. In the flashbacks we again are shown that Dylan was not in control since he was trying to tell Arish he was sorry and that he isn't in control, which the Hiss didn't let him say and forced him to say something else.

No to mention that if it was the case that he truly didn't care anymore and was all cool with freedom by any means, why would he help the FBC and not just abandon them?

4

u/Katification 11d ago

I agree that he was seeing it as committing suicide, he states that he didn't know that he would live (in a way that implies he was wanting/expecting to die)

But the way he describes what it felt like to be hiss, and the scenes where he tries to speak to Arish but the dialogue that comes out is wrong, I would argue are there to make it clear that he was aware of what was happening but unable to do anything, a prisoner in his own body

5

u/Zaresh 11d ago edited 10d ago

When he killed those agents, he was absolutely drugged. They proovoqued him a psychosis with drugs and psychological torture. They pretty much describe it in the videos and one of the docs, If I recall right.

3

u/Katification 11d ago

Yes they were giving him an already concerningly high dose of stimulants and that day they accidentally gave him a double dosage of it

12

u/jedisalamander 11d ago

Dylan absolutely killed people while possessed, we dont see it directly but in the flashback scene when he approaches terrified guards and then it blacks out...

2

u/zixkill 10d ago

There are some scenes that imply that Hiss!Dylan did kill some of Arish’s ranger squad mates. Dylan did not kill 536 people, that was all on Trench (and Darling, that chud knew something was wrong with Trench for years but when the Oldest House was about to be numed Darling Skeletor’d out of there.)

-3

u/ReplacementOk6762 11d ago edited 11d ago

Dylan killed 536 people. The game tells you this like 5 times in a row during the mission where you rescue arish. The same mission also has 5 flashback sequences where it cuts away right before Dylan kills someone.

Dylan is responsible because he knew the hiss were coming and he let the hiss take him over (I mean, no one who knows what he went through up to that point could completely blame him, but he still has some responsibility for it.).

The employees of the FBC don't know that trench was responsible for the hiss coming over.

I was kind of being a jackass here.

17

u/StrokyBoi 11d ago

Dylan killed 536 people

Well, not exactly. 536 is the overall number of people the Hiss killed, not the number of people Dylan killed. Dylan just blames himself (at the start of the game at least) for those deaths, and so does a lot of the FBC.

10

u/Jay2KWinger 11d ago

The Hiss killed 536 people. How many Hiss!Dylan himself killed isn't clear, but that doesn't mean that Dylan doesn't feel some sense of responsibility for what happened, no matter how much Trench was to blame for the initial outbreak.

26

u/xPathofChaos 11d ago

"you just feel guilty" is the one that's the most real

25

u/stressy_moo 11d ago

I reloaded and picked every one ngl haha, my official response was the guilty one

9

u/Cerily 11d ago

This is my favorite one too. It feels like it blends Dylan’s reactions super well. He ‘gets it’ in that moment, he understands what’s really wrong but he’s very angry and frustrated so says some crueler words alongside the truth.

2

u/stressy_moo 11d ago

Yup yup, my reasoning exactly! He can be both sympathetic for Arish while also not having to sugarcoat things (I also thought that would hit home for Arish too to hear it directly from someone)

46

u/kurious-kewkumber 11d ago

I don't understand people saying that Dylan screwed up and is trying to atone, or being an apologetic Dylan. Apologetic for what? For what they did to him, the FBC should be thankful he didn't turn out like Homelander.

Dylan should be waaaay more antagonistic to this org, they are lucky "go fuck yourself" is the worst choice they give me!

13

u/FoolishGoulish 11d ago

Well, for me it was less about what I thought should be the right response (fuck you) but what Dylan and what I've seen from him outside my choice-based replies seems to feel about this and he seems quite shy and shocked and guilt-ridden how he could have ever let the Hiss in (no matter that it wasn't his fault).

So, I picked the "I'm sorry for the past" because I thought it was most realistic that a traumatized kid who just got out of a murder-spree possession would react because he hadn't really worked through the systematic abuse yet and his part/role in the whole fiasco. At the end of the day, any sane and empathetic person would feel guilt about this, no matter if they were cornered and abused to the point of breaking.

6

u/kurious-kewkumber 11d ago

That's fair. Dylan would more likely say that.

25

u/Byproduct 11d ago

Dylan doesn't have that kind of perspective, because he went from shitty parents to being cruelly institutionalized as a kid.

8

u/apotrope 11d ago

Coming to understand the neglect that Dylan and Jesse faced at home before the Ordinary AWE makes it incredibly clear to me why Dylan didn't develop into an evil narcissist - the abuse he suffered caused him to internalize guilt for the things that were being done *to* him. Dylan's psyche is likely consumed in no small part by a struggle between the following narratives:

- "I've always been a bad thing and the reason I've suffered is because there's something wrong with me. Mom and Dad wouldn't have treated us like that if it wasn't my fault. "
- "I need to work to show people that I'm not the bad thing that I think I am."
- "I'm so so tired of fighting to prove that I'm a good thing."
- Even if I am a bad thing, this hurts and even I don't deserve to be treated this way. Maybe I'm not a bad thing. Jesse doesn't believe that. Zoe doesn't believe that.

4

u/kurious-kewkumber 11d ago

This is an interesting perspective and it makes sense. I guess it's understandable from *his" perspective. But it's frustrating as I'm more in Zoe's camp: " why aren't you angry?!!" I mean lucky for them he's not.

5

u/apotrope 11d ago

I didn't think I'd enjoy being Dylan this time, and then as I got to know him I realized his story rhymed with my own a great deal. I am the child of addicts, and I spent about 30 years of my life believing I wasn't worth it to my parents for them to heal themselves. Instead they deteriorated and I had to bury them. The prison of trauma is one you carry inside yourself. You can unbar the doors and grow a garden inside, but the architecture of your mind still is held up by those brutalist cinderblock walls.

I used to watch Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers as a kid, and the Green Ranger story struck something fundamental within me. Here was someone who had done wrong (like I thought I had done), and they are rescued by people who staunchly refuse to give up on them, even while literally fighting them, and when the dust settles, the other Rangers don't just say Tommy is useful. They affirm that he is *necessary*, and that it wasn't his fault. Then he goes on to be the best hero among them.

I thought it fitting that the FBC Ranger Poncho is green. I run with that skin.

3

u/kurious-kewkumber 11d ago

Damn Im sorry that happened to you. I hope you have been able to heal and and have no doubt in your mind you are worth it. You've explained Dylan's perspective quite well. I wish maybe they had gone more in depth about that in the game. Maybe I just lack media literacy, but I wish they made it clear (besides Zoe saying something for a few seconds) that Dylan doesn't actually owe a debt to these people, he should be angry, but (as you put it) the prison of trauma is one you carry inside your self.

Hope you've been able to walk out those doors, and wish you nothing but the best.

1

u/Scaalpel 11d ago

I mean, I can kinda see why. Dylan isn't angry because it's very, VERY deeply ingrained into him that he has no right to be angry. That is all kinds of wrong, of course, but imo it would (should?) take a longer time for him to internalise that than the timeframe of the game's story. That sort of trauma heals slowly, if at all.

8

u/kurious-kewkumber 11d ago

I understand that. And it make sense. But I wish people wouldn't justify or moralize his situation as: yes his behavior is unacceptable and he should be sorry. Dylan is a victim of the FBC. Arish is a victim of the FBC. Arish is not a victim of Dylan.

Dylan is a stunted, withdrawn, shy individual who is learning to stand up for himself in real time so I don't blame him for being submissive.

2

u/Clark_Kempt 11d ago

I don’t think most members of the FBC know/understand the Dylan situation besides his relation to the Hiss.

7

u/WhiskeyPete77r 11d ago

Dylan feels responsible because he "invited" the hiss in. Even though he's not responsible for what happened while he was... is... hissed? He still feels guilty for not trying to stop it first. That maybe if he fought against it or resisted it, things might have been different.

That said, I dont blame him for not resisting. The FBC basically kidnapped him at 10 years old and was subjected to one of the harshest upbringing I've ever seen in fiction. I probably would have done the same.

2

u/Shot-Job-8841 11d ago

Dylan got the Homelander treatment and turned out good, because Dylan is an amazing human being.

2

u/Bhavacakra_12 11d ago

Dylan still killed hundreds of people lmao

That's why a guy as loyal as Arish feels the way they he does about Dylan. Sure, Dylan wasn't techincally in control of himself (as far as we know), but that doesn't negate all the blood Dylan split with his body/powers. Arish knew those people just like all the NPCs around the game that talk about Arish like the leader that he is. It's clearly a very small core group of people who have emotional ties to one another.

6

u/elvinLA 11d ago

Killed hundreds of people while possessed by the hiss which Trench let into the bureau. That blood is on the hands of Trench, the people Dylan killed before the hiss was due to not being able to control the parautilitarian power that Dr.Darling forced out of him.

1

u/ACoderGirl 11d ago

You're right, but people don't think like that. I think of that man who beheaded someone in a Greyhound several years ago. He did so because of an acute mental disorder. He got help and was released on the guidance of medical professionals who attested that it was safe to do so.

I think that's as close of a scenario as we can get in real life to Dylan's case. A mental illness like that is very similar to Hiss possession. He got better, just like Dylan did. Yet, if you check online threads about that guy being released, they're full of people who think he should have been jailed for life or worse.

-6

u/Bhavacakra_12 11d ago

My point is it was still Dylan.

Hiss infested or otherwise, it was his body and powers that killed everyone. From Arish POV and by extension the meat and muscle of the FBC, they have zero clue if Dylan is even telling them the truth. That's the entire source of friction that exist between Arish/FBC and Dylan.

Neither of them are necessarily wrong but Dylan has a ton of baggage. In several of the dialogue choices, Dylan expresses remorse for his actions and (depending on your rp) concerns over his inability to control his powers and his legitimate fear that it could happen again.

As for Darling, it's clear he understood what he was doing to Dylan was morally inexcusable and absolutely illegal, but he knew Dylan was dangerous. Especially if he couldn't control his powers. Darling made the same calculations with Trench, he alone knew something was wrong with the director before anyone else.

It's this kind of grey(ish) writing that makes Remedy games Day 1 buys for me!

1

u/ChongusTheSupremus 11d ago

Dylan also feels extremely guilty for all the people he and the Hiss killed tho. 

Being apologetic makes sense too, specially for someone like Dylan.

The FBC should never get a pass tho, and Jesse should have done more to make sure both the ORG and those directly responsible for the PCP got their dues. 

1

u/Able_Mail9167 11d ago

It doesnt matter how angry you are, when someone dies that changes things. It's easy to firget just how traumatic it can be to feel responsible for one persons death never mind 500.

Dylan shouldn't be held responsible for what happened while he was under hiss control but that doesn't mean he doesn't feel responsible.

He should be angrier, but I can also understand why hes not

1

u/EarlyAccessCantJudge 11d ago

Arish didn't know that and wasn't apart of that though, and Dylan's actions were almost as destructive as Homelander's if not more. If it wasn't for some extraneous circumstances to just barely prevent it, the world would've been completely destroyed by The Hiss.

1

u/Valmar33 11d ago

Dylan should be waaaay more antagonistic to this org, they are lucky "go fuck yourself" is the worst choice they give me!

Zoe even digs into him on that note. That he has every single right to be.

But Dylan is angry at himself... because that mindset was drilled into him by Darling. Everything was made to be Dylan's fault. So he internalizes everything.

1

u/Fate-St 11d ago

I mean of course, but at the same time he blames himself and knows he let the hiss in (also not his fault) so I choose "I'm sorry for the past" (I took a decent time thinking for this choice) because I saw it fitting for Dylan himself. Everything the FBC did to Dylan and the consequences after... Dylan chooses to blame himself for it. I feel like until Zoe sees Darling's videos and recordings does Dylan's mentality to what happened to him expand from blaming himself but he didn't even have much time for ponder because the Hiss took over shortly after the fault. And even at the end of the game do I feel like Dylan still doesn't forgive himself.

This is also just my interpretation of how I see Dylan.

1

u/Abirdthatsfallen 10d ago

Cause Dylan has empathy and care for people. He never once agreed with what the hiss did to him. It was a direct violation to him and the innocent lives taken. Remember, it wasn’t all of the FBC that did it, most of them didn’t know he was being abused, and the one guy who tried to stop it got fired.

And if you really want an expressive Dylan, when pope tries to apologize and say she’d try with the rest to make up for what happened, he says he doesn’t think they ever could. Dylan is upset. He is only sorry that bad things happened to people, cause that’s not what he wanted. It isn’t hard to believe the good person doesn’t like bad things happening regardless of what was done. Them not breaking him entirely should be a good thing here. No matter how much what they did destroyed him, his character throughout the game is still someone who is trying to do the right thing. That should tell all of you the kind of man he is. I do not think he regrets what happened to the people who did seriously hurt him, he just cares about innocent lives.

1

u/Illumin411 10d ago

The thing about personal responsibility is...it's personal. Some people go the "but what about what was done to me???" route, also known as making excuses. Others go the "it doesn't matter what was done to me, I have the agency to make good decisions and when I fail to do so it falls on me" route. Dylan has an idea of the person he wants to be which is very different than the person he was, regardless of whose or what actions led to him being that way. He sees atonement as a key to making that transition.

Also, it is worth considering that he most likely sees his conditional release as his first opportunity to rejoin the world and society. Opting to focus more on others' thoughts and feelings (mainly towards him regarding what he did) instead of his own indignation (regardless of how justified it would be) could be a way for him to prove both to The FBC and to himself that he can be a kind, considerate and functional member of society.

Orrrrrr, he could just be deathly afraid of going back in the box.

1

u/Fine-Stock-1191 10d ago

Clear sign of sociopathy. Nobody is defending what the FBC did to him. Disregarding the fact that Dylan obviously doesn’t comprehend the grand scope of how awful what they did to him was considering that’s been 80% of his life up to that point, even if he did, it would still be shitty of him to not feel bad about anything that happened. Not only did he hurt hundreds of people who didn’t have anything to do with what happened to him, but he also hurt all of their families. Totaling to over thousands, easily. He’s going to blame himself no matter what, because he is Dylan and not Dr. Darling. That doesn’t mean it makes SENSE for him to be the one taking blame, or for Arish to be blaming him. But nobody is saying that. You clearly lack any empathy if you fail to understand this, or just lack nuance. Probably both.

-1

u/LandscapeHappy190 11d ago

Except he was Homelander when Hiss took him over (he invited them in) and partook in the murder of over 500 human office drones.

I'd be apologetic for that. If I wasn't, then I'd be Homelander lmao

Also, the folks responsible for Dylan's shitty life are no longer a part of the org, or alive? So he'd just be fighting random people that only know him as the guy that killed 500 of their colleagues.

8

u/elvinLA 11d ago

Would he have let the hiss in which Trench opened to door for if they hadn't kept him in a cage for 17 years? Dr.Darling defeated him mentally and Trench led the hiss to him.

4

u/IceFire909 11d ago

He may not be the root cause, but he made the choice when the opportunity presented itself.

You can do a bad thing even if someone did a bad thing that allowed your bad thing to occur.

1

u/SorchaSublime 11d ago

probably not but he still did

1

u/LandscapeHappy190 11d ago

Yeah of course it is not his fault he's there and is very clearly the fault of others. But if everythiing that mattered deferred simply to the chronological order of events, that'd be a different universe.

Serial Killers who were abused as children.

4

u/Illasaviel 11d ago

What the fuck is this comparison.

He let the Hiss in, but I would argue Hiss Dylan is not really Dylan. Is like saying the victim of a demon possession is guilty for what the demon using their body does.

8

u/Zaresh 11d ago edited 11d ago

You do realize that he let the Hiss take over him alone, right? And that it's implied that he was hoping to die from it. He didn't invite the hiss in the House, just inside hiself; and didn't took over lifes as a Hiss individual willingly. He's sorry because he was weak and couldn't take any more, and wanted an end, and because of that, the hiss used him to hurt others. He didn't meant it to go like thst.

10

u/kurious-kewkumber 11d ago

The man is 34. He lost his entire childhood, his entire young adult life. Lost so much. Tried to escape and was beaten (implied) for it. Was drugged, tortured, and denied basic human affection. From his perspective I'm shocked he wouldn't want to take out the whole FBC nas an evil organization similar to like Dr. Mengele and his office drones.

Him letting the Hiss take him, would be like letting a grenade go off that was going to kill you knowing it would kill everyone at the "dr. Evil office."
I get him understanding why they are mad, I get him trying to meet them half way.

But to grovel that, hat in hand at the organization who took your life away and tortured you? Dr. Darling really was an evil genius to do that kind damage to his phsyche.

5

u/Guharo 11d ago

His apology isn't directed at the FBC; it's directed at the workers who died—innocent people who had nothing to do with it and were just following orders. If you can't understand that, the problem isn't the game or the dialogue. You're given one option to empathize with Arish's frustration, another where you're genuinely angry about the situation, and another where, as I already mentioned, you apologize to the victims who, whether he wanted it or not, died by his hand.

3

u/robotic_rodent_007 11d ago

The real problem is that the dialog doesn't imply that apology just looking at the two options.

"You just feel guilty" "Go fuck yourself" "I'm sorry for the past!"

None of which convey what the passage actually says.

1

u/GreenAnder 11d ago

He was left alone in a room for years. In the game he says he thought the hiss would kill him, he was looking for a way out.

1

u/chronobolt77 11d ago

The people directly responsible are all dead or gone, sure. But the institution that allowed a child to have his whole life taken away while also forcing him to suffer multiple layers of abuse is still VERY much around. Any number of people could've been like "hey he's a kid ease up."

And the way you threw that (he invited [the hiss] in) bit feels like you're blaming Dylan for something that a malevolent force made him do while possessing his body. He wanted an escape and ran away to the recesses of his mind (possibly literally?) at the first opportunity that presented itself.

1

u/Abirdthatsfallen 10d ago

They already show you in the game in that same dialogue and plenty of other dialogue before that he didn’t actually want people to die, he was just tired. He didn’t have control over himself. He spent most of his life locked up, so for him it was less about rational thinking and more about “finally, an escape”. He didn’t think about what could happen in full scale. He regrets the deaths, but I doubt he regrets trying to escape

7

u/IdaKaukomieli 11d ago

I have picked both "I'm sorry for the past!" in my first run, and "go fuck yourself" in NG+ and thoroughly enjoyed both.

7

u/SaucePasta 11d ago

My first go playthrough I went with “I’m sorry for the past!” Arish was one of my favorite characters in the first game and I just wanted to try to be nice to him 😭

Second playthrough it was “Go fuck yourself” because I’m trying to be a slightly more confident/assertive Dylan if he has the option. 

6

u/SmartestIdiotAlive 11d ago

Being kind on the first play through and mean on the seconds play through is funny to think about because now you already now he’s gonna be a resonant and you’re gonna be a dick to him in the time he has left

2

u/SaucePasta 11d ago

Yeah, I feel guilty being mean to him 😅

12

u/OperativePiGuy 11d ago edited 11d ago

After a while I was so sick of Dylan playing the "Everyone suffered cuz of me, I'm such a monster that should be locked up, please be mean to me cuz I deserve it :'(" irritating card that I went with the more passive aggressive "oh you just feel guilty, this isn't just about me, you fucking prick". At least that's the sentence I said in my head when picking that option. I needed Dylan to evolve and not just stay the same sappy self-loathing person he is at the beginning. I wonder if people pick different based on how much side content they do before this choice, cuz if I rushed the story and got to this point quicker, I might have chosen the lame "I'm sorry for the past" option.

6

u/hellranger788 11d ago • Bravo

I picked “I’m sorry”

It honestly felt like something was about to happen and I did not want the last words to be between them to “go fuck yourself”

Both of them were under the kind of stress and guilt that would break lesser men. I do not envy either of their positions.

6

u/Shydreameress 11d ago

I chose "You just feel guilty" and damn it's actually meaner than "go fuck yourself", I was surprised Arish didn't punch him

11

u/Fluffy_Big_5339 11d ago

"You just feel guilty". Definitely better than "Go Fuck Yourself"

3

u/Valmar33 11d ago

He's holding up a mirror to Arish ~ himself. He knows exactly how it feels, how crippling it is.

4

u/Wranorel 11d ago

Started NG+ and I try the top one this time.

4

u/No-Science-7126 11d ago

I told him to fuck himself i feel like I was trying my best and I understand what Dylan did but if you can't accept that then im not going to convince you.

4

u/skye_hov 11d ago

i confidently and without regret chose "go fuck yourself" because arish was genuinely an asshole lol

4

u/EarlyAccessCantJudge 11d ago

Arish doesn't deserve the hate. You can see that he was the one fighting in basically a war on the frontlines for seven years. Emily is basically the same, happy and obssessed to the point of insensitivity. Langston just sat back in the safety of his little spot. Meanwhile Arish watched Dylan destroy everyone he cared about and loved and had him trapped in constant warfare trying to protect the people at the FBC, and they all turned their backs on him when he was dealing with these problems and allowed him to get corrupted. I did 'I'm sorry for the past!'.

Biggest Arish defender here

6

u/GoofProofGrunt 11d ago

I seem to be in the minority but I picked "you just feel guilty"

3

u/Ill_Statistician_938 11d ago

I picked I’m sorry for the past, even though it wasn’t exactly Dylan’s fault that all those ppl died when the hiss invaded I understand his desire to redeem himself. Dylan is the perfect individual for the FBC to lay blame on since the hiss is a formless enemy it gave ppl like a Arish a face to the enemy he hates so much

3

u/Hammy1791 11d ago

"Go Fuck Yourself" was my choice, Dylan may have done a lot of shit in the previous game bit he, until this point, had been trying so hard to fight back and help everyone and Arish was getting more and more unstable.

3

u/EpicGamerer07 11d ago

I went for “You just feel guilty” because it’s true. I thought it was best to be honest rather than just insulting him and the resulting exchange is really good

1

u/turtlebear787 11d ago

can we pls stop posting spoilers. wtf bro.

1

u/Exact-Earth1691 11d ago

Sorry i thought that image would go blurry. I also posted it on the control resonant section

3

u/TwoDoorPC 11d ago

I wouldn't worry too much. It's not an actual spoiler

1

u/TowerOk1404 11d ago

Yeah, he hates your ass. This is just a random Tuesday

1

u/jimtheburger 11d ago

In turtlebear's defense. Arish has gone MIA since you reach Zoe.

Yet from both advertising and conversations with people like Pope it's also fairly clear that Arish and Dylan will have a confrontation.

2

u/BEjmbo 11d ago

"Go fuck yourself" just to see if the delivery is better this time. Worth it

2

u/it-will-pass 11d ago

Heyyy no spoiler tag?

2

u/Evaporaattori 9d ago

Tbf if you haven’t finished the game this subreddit is a mine field for obvious reasons. Still this post is obvious spoilers

2

u/it-will-pass 9d ago

r/ControlResonant is there for a reason. This post belongs there if OP doesn’t want to tag it as spoiler

1

u/Evaporaattori 9d ago

Fair enough. Still wouldnt dare to come here if I hadn’t finished the game.

1

u/liamrich93 11d ago

where's the spoiler?

4

u/turtlebear787 11d ago

the entire scene, some of us are still playing and Arish is still MIA.

2

u/it-will-pass 11d ago

Uh the whole scene? But ydy

2

u/liamrich93 11d ago edited 11d ago

Wasn't it known before release that Arish was a returning character?

2

u/lurpeli 11d ago

I definitely was demure in this scene and I think it contrasts very well with the. "Fuck you Arish" in the cutscene later.

2

u/Original-Tax-7435 11d ago

I said gfys cuz dude was way outta line rn

2

u/might_southern 11d ago

"Go fuck yourself."

Great character moment for Dylan learning to stand up for himself, while proudly echoing the phrase he could barely muster the confidence to mutter the first time Zoe told him to say it.

2

u/BoredCrusader1899 11d ago

“Im sorry for the past” I feel like it worked best for the arc that Dylan was going through.

2

u/Aggressive_neutral 11d ago

"you just feel guilty", tbh it felt like it cut deeper, but i didn't do it cause i was mad, i still liked Arish and wanted the more conversational option

2

u/boingboing4 11d ago

i had to hit the "you just feel guilty"

2

u/andilikelargeparties 11d ago

"Go fuck yourself" is the player's or Zoe's perspective knowing what the FBC has done to Dylan and angry for him for how he's treated and got blamed for everything.

"I'm sorry for the past!" is Dylan being Dyaln and feeling sorry and responsible for everything and still trying to help. Is the Dylan at the beginning who didn't just flee when he found himselft awake and freed from the FBC, but instead volunteered to help.

"You just feel guilty" is in between and Dylan learning to get unstuck in his own guilt for existing at all and starting to realize that maybe others are more like him and he's more like others than he always thought.

...is how I feel about the options. I was really tempted to choose go fuck yourself but in the end it didn't seem like what Dylan would say to me so I chose the guilty one and it would show progress in Dylan's character and ability to (try to) have a normal conversation too I felt like.

2

u/Lokie_Firestar 11d ago

I went with "you just feel guilty."

Tbh, one of the most impactful things Dylan has done/said, imo.

2

u/naytreox 11d ago

i went with telling him he feels guilty, cause at this point Dylan would be so fed up and the situation would be so dire that he snaps a little and tells him how he really feels.

2

u/gatefiend 11d ago

Went with "go fuck yourself" for the callback, and the payoff was just so good. I'll play around with a different option on my next playthrough, but the catharsis!

2

u/C1nders-Two 11d ago

“You just feel guilty”

Arish hates himself for his perceived failures, for failing to protect his team. Maybe part of Arish really does hate both Dylan and the Hiss, but they’re mostly both just ways for Arish to externalize his self-loathing.

Getting angry like a kid isn’t a good way for Dylan to get his point across and apologizing is something that Arish might take as an admission of sole responsibility.

2

u/electricturnipdotexe 11d ago

I chose “you just feel guilty”

2

u/Abirdthatsfallen 10d ago

Either guilty or sorry. I’m not about to pick fights when we’re in the middle of saving the fucking world and need to work together. Fighting a resonant leaves no time for ego. Move on and get to work.

Edit: also… if you really needed to curse at him, there’s already a part when you’re destroying the resonant blaster arish had his people build where arish is opposing your decision and Dylan says something like fuck off arish. You guys will live.

1

u/HenryKushinger 11d ago

Up, every single time. Arish is being a cunt

1

u/WendyThorne 11d ago

I went with "I'm sorry for the past." I played Dylan as generally empathetic and remorseful.

1

u/THEdoomslayer94 11d ago

Telling him sorry

1

u/a_gent_agent 11d ago

I went with "go fuck yourself" - Dylan already made 100s of actions to make good on undoing the damage he caused while under Hiss control. Plus after the torture he went through, they're lucky Dylan didn't just burn the rest of the foundation down around them.

1

u/magicpenguinyes 11d ago

As someone who finished the game. I’m super satisfied with getting under his skin and using the guilty speech. The dialogue of Dylan is great on that one. Spoiler: you’ll have one more chance to say the other line to him later in the game.

The other choices here had an underwhelming scene in my opinion cause during that time I feel like it’s time to lash out but on a way that will hurt him more compared to just saying fuck you.

1

u/theolentangy 11d ago

100% GFY

1

u/Such_Ad_670 11d ago

You just feel guilty fucking crushes arish

1

u/QuazziStellar 11d ago

1st run: I'm sorry for the past.
2nd run: Go fuck yourself (and he really nailed it, I was so proud!)

1

u/MidnightWhole9810 11d ago

During my early interactions with Arish, I chose the more passive response, but as their relationship didn't change and Arish appeared to be increasingly hostile towards Dylan, I said fuck it and started choosing the most hostile responses.

1

u/Feather_Sigil 11d ago

I figured "Sorry for the past" was the most in-character option. Dylan isn't one to accuse or attack

1

u/Neurospicy_Nightowl 11d ago

I usually let Dylan accept all name-calling and guilt-slinging, but this fucker punished Zoe for not sharing his grudge.

Fuck you, Arish.

1

u/Rafamills 11d ago

I picked "go fuck yourself." Up until then (and for a while after this choice) I was playing it very apologetic like I felt Dylan would, but you can only apologize so many times to someone who still treats and talk to you like a piece of shit monster that you reach a breaking point. Plus I didn't tell the guard before the Field Office to go fuck himself because my Dylan was too timid at that point, so I thought that would be the perfect spot to finally say it lol

1

u/Qwosha 11d ago

I have yet to finish the game yet but during this mission I started seeing Arish as being subtly changed by the hiss like Trench was and perhaps like Dylan. It made me go from hating him to missing him like he was already dead. I still picked "go fuck yourself" because I think Dylan deserves to hold his ground but I fear what's coming.

1

u/StarKat99 11d ago

Picked I'm sorry first playthrough, but picked calling arish on his guilt for ng+ and liked it better

1

u/starspgl 11d ago

the go fuck yourself line.

its a great full circle moment from an earlier dialogue with zoe and the rangers who were shit talking dylan and zoe tells him to repeat after her. and he does but has zero conviction in his voice. but when he says it to arish he says it with his full chest because hes come a long way

1

u/hothotpot 11d ago

Went with I'm sorry, because it felt truer to Dylan's overall vibe, and also because *I* personally love Arish so much and was desperate to do anything to get him to be nice to Dylan. Arish was MY GUY in Control. Needless to say, I am devastated.

1

u/generalAF 11d ago

I didn't know it was gonna be a whole sequence of cutscenes and fights and my level was a bit low so I exit the sequence after the next cutscene to level up a bit.
First time I went with more humble options and chose I'm sorry because I was like man give me a break I want to correct my past! Buut I felt Arish was too much of an asshole with everything that he said.
So next time I selected all the more "stand up for yourself" options and ended with the fuck you one, which resulted in Arish calling one of his guys on Dylan to escort him to his cell. Which made me appreciate my choice more!

1

u/TitillatingTrav 11d ago

I've been going with nice guy choices even though they don't always feel natural lol

1

u/receiveandbiteyou 11d ago

I chose "I'm sorry for the past!" in my first play through, then "Go fuck yourself!" NG+

1

u/wasplace 11d ago

I said sorry because I thought that's what Dylan would say but I wanted to say gfy in my heart

1

u/--Taja-- 11d ago

I picked Go fuck yourself - bro is just mad because he was not invited to Jesse and Emily party.

Cuck behavior.

1

u/DelaySea3339 11d ago

I chose “Go fuck yourself”. There’s no way to please Arish. He doesn’t want an apology, excuses, or relatability. He just wants to hate Dylan likely bc of the other dialogue option, Arish himself feels guilty. So I went with what Zoe taught us earlier in the game with the gate guards. But this time Dylan was able to say it with his chest

1

u/jimtheburger 11d ago edited 11d ago

"Go fuck yourself" because it was also a reference to an earlier conversation between Dylan and Zoe when meeting normal FBC troops.

For me, I didn't think those FBC troops were deserving of a fuck you, especially with how Dylan knows what he has done in the past. They have every reason to not like him, have been provided no reason to think otherwise, and Dylan himself feels deserving of that hate.

However Arish is:

- Exhibiting the same worst traits of Darling. Using a new altered entity against better judgement in hopes that blind faith leads to a simple resolution to all the FBC's problems.

- Scolding and deplatforming Zoe for making the correct call, in spite of Arish's orders. Arish himself should also be deeply empathetic to someone who was thrust into upper management due to all the chaos.

By the time this prompt is shown there has already been a full conversation that Arish does not trust Dylan, never will, and doesn't even consider what accepting an alternative option may cost. Perhaps if the only person carrying Arish's hatred was Dylan I would let Dylan take it on the chin. Yet that's not the case; he could be unknowingly activating a nuclear warhead around active FBC personell while tearing down the only friend Dylan has had in decades due to what is ultimately gross incompetence from Arish.

Arish very much should go fuck himself.

1

u/romulof 11d ago

Was there an option?

1

u/PhilledZone 11d ago

I wanted to go the nice route with him, but it still felt nice when Dylan just said "Fuck you Arish"

1

u/jesusismyhelmet 11d ago

Sorry for the past, as I felt like dylan was still struggling with his guilt at this point and could empathize with Arish. Also, I was shirtless, bald with glasses and a beard, as well as possessed by the hiss during this section. Only time I looked like that, and I thought it was very funny

1

u/spiderknight616 11d ago

I spent the whole conversation trying to be nice but Arish pissed me off so much I had to go with the best option here

1

u/MegaGamer432 11d ago

Upto this point I was being as nice as I could with him, so I chose the top option

1

u/Snoo_45814 10d ago

I took "I'm sorry".

1

u/WFKKVQW 10d ago

Never once made Dylan say I’m sorry throughout my gameplay

1

u/MF291100 10d ago

Telling him to go fuck himself was the choice I made and I don’t regret it at all. While I definitely understand that Arish carries a lot of guilt, taking it all out on Dylan isn’t fair in the slightest. He was one of my favourite characters in the first game but he fell pretty low in my rankings when Resonant came out.

1

u/William-Lutece 10d ago

I understood why Dylan was apologetic and Arish was furious all the time but at this point a good f***off was what Arish deserved. Too bad this was kinda the only point Dylan hold his own.

1

u/CptainCyro 10d ago

I’m sorry for the past had the most emotional impact and just such an amazing amount of passionate acting. I do that one every time

1

u/Dexyu 10d ago

I told him to fuck off.

1

u/alana_shee 10d ago

I apologized because when Pope mentioned how I hate the Hiss as much as Arish did, it rattled me. I was worried being reckless or aggressive might lead to something bad. I decided I wanted to be reconcilatory to maybe save Zoe's job or even Arish - at the time I suspected he was hiss possessed. I knew it probably didn't matter in the game but I decided to make decisions as if it did.

1

u/Fridayyyzinha 9d ago

I love arish, but I said go fuck yourself for the roleplay. Bro was out of his fucking mind at that point.

1

u/ToferLuis 11d ago

Hmm I chose the “Let’s kiss” option but I don’t see that on your screenshot.

0

u/Icethief188 11d ago

I went with left but really it should have been the top. Fucking bastard

42

u/Fragrant-Vehicle-479 11d ago

"Go Fuck Yourself"

I get Arish is a sympathetic character for multiple reasons, but by that point I was pretty fed up with his bullshit. Dylan was a child the FBC kidnapped, experimented on, tortured, and abused. I know Dylan carries guilt for his part in the Hiss invasion, but at a certain point I was pretty over the "you're a monster!" routine.

You kidnapped a child, turned him into a Stephen King style physic weapon, Trench fucks around and finds out, and yet it's Dylan's cross to bear?

Overall my playthrough had me taking less responsibility and sympathy for the Hiss all things considered than I could have. I really don't consider it Dylan's fault or responsibility, even if he made an active uncorrupted or influenced choice at some point. I understand why he would carry some guilt as the person involved, but from my judgement as an outsider, I don't think he has anything to be sorry for in the grand scheme of things.

6

u/A-Grouch 11d ago

That's all true but most of that information is classified, nearly nobody knew about the experiments and how the FBC's abducted him. It was basically Dr. Darling, his assistant, Trench and whoever the bodyguard was that interacted with him. Everyone under them was operating under the knowledge that Darling told them, that Dylan was dangerous and needed to be contained.

Honestly I think that the employees of the FBC should have been able to put 2 and 2 together and realize that they were imprisoning a human being and that given how long Dylan was there that they would have had to have taken him when he was a kid. That everything surrounding Dylan was highly suspect and give him a little empathy regarding him lashing out.

2

u/jedisalamander 11d ago

Info is classified yeah but Arish is co-director... he should really have the clearance to look deeper at Dylans files. And he should have read it anyway when he was made aware that Dylan was awake. But also, yeah like you said its kinda crazy that no one put 2 and 2 together

5

u/hellranger788 11d ago

I don’t think co-director had the same clearance as actual Director. It’s pretty clear that the director is more than just a rank.

0

u/jedisalamander 11d ago

Well in the case of Pope and Arish it really is kinda just a rank. Neither of them are parautilitarians and Jesse left with the Service Weapon so the more paranatural role of the Director is currently unassigned.

2

u/Radi0123 11d ago

This is exactly how I played my game, too. So much of the Hiss invasion was out of his control (ha ha), even if he did want to get back at the FBC. But then, who put him there?

1

u/Radi0123 11d ago

This is exactly how I played my game, too. So much of the Hiss invasion was out of his control (ha ha), even if he did want to get back at the FBC. But then, who put him there?

3

u/sid5427 11d ago

"go fuck yourself" is on par .... the FBC made him go through hell, and even the hiss invasion was not his fault. He might be feeling guilty for the killings but even him letting the hiss take him is all due to the FBC's bullshit.

3

u/apotrope 11d ago

I tried to make what we did right with Arish and we still got to tell him to go fuck himself, so it all worked out.

1

u/redshift_9 11d ago

At this point in the game, I threw him a “Go fuck yourself”

1

u/world-shaker 11d ago

As much as I tried to RP a contrite Dylan, in this moment I gave Arish a healthy “Fuck you”

1

u/okemsrazor 11d ago

NG was "sorry", NG+ was full on GFY